458: Baby Survives Being Buried Alive, Obsessed Stepdad’s Shrine of Underwear & Incest Dad Walks Free
Hosted by Annie Elise
- 1h 4m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In this episode of Serialously, host Annie Elise is joined by Amy Collette to break down disturbing true crime headlines from across the country. The discussion covers the controversial early release of Steven Chavez, a California father who pled guilty to felony incest and serving alcohol to a minor before his daughter Michaela tragically took her own life. The hosts also cover the tragic murder of runner Katie Suarez in Brooklyn by a former NYPD officer, the brutal killing of Melissa Pelk in upstate New York by an ex-husband who built a disturbing shrine of her daughter's belongings before dying by self-harm, the miraculous rescue of 11-month-old Koa Sharp after being buried alive in a dog crate by his father, and the horrific abuse and murder of 10-year-old foster child Malaysia Alfred in Philadelphia by her foster mother.
Throughout the episode, the host and guest express shared outrage over systemic failures, lenient sentences, and the inadequacies of protective orders and child welfare monitoring. They emphasize the devastating impact of these crimes on the victims' families, who frequently followed all recommended safety precautions yet still faced unimaginable tragedies. The episode serves as both a detailed headline breakdown and an impassioned critique of justice system shortcomings.
- File a petition for legislative reform or support survivor-led campaigns, as demonstrated by Michaela's mother launching a change.org petition to demand stricter sentencing laws surrounding sexual assault. 15:58
- Never ignore red flags in personal relationships or dangerous domestic incidents, as ignored threats and stalking often escalate to fatal outcomes. 47:23
- Always document violations of personal protection orders and press legal authorities for immediate action when harassment or stalking occurs. 37:41
- Support organ donation programs, which can provide a lasting legacy of saving lives even in the wake of unimaginable tragedy. 26:16
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro & Sponsored Ads
The episode opens with a series of promotional segments for insurance, Dell, Lowe’s, and other sponsors before the host introduces the show.
- 2:48Host Introduces Serial Ashley and Weekly Highlights
Annie Elise welcomes listeners, explains the Headline Highlights format, and previews the week’s true‑crime stories.
- 8:13Steven Chavez: Incest, Release, and Public Outrage
The host discusses the case of Steven Chavez, his brief incarceration, and the anger over his early release and the lack of accountability for his crimes.
- 19:31Katie Suarez: Random Trail Murder and Police Breakthrough
The episode covers Katie Suarez’s stabbing on a Brooklyn trail, the investigation’s challenges, and the arrest of suspect Syed Mohaseeb.
- 33:47Melissa Pelklor: Shrines, Sexual Assault, and a Mother’s Murder
The host details Allison Pelklor’s allegations of her stepfather’s sexual abuse, the shrine of underwear, and the subsequent murder of Melissa Pelklor.
- 42:40Andrea Cantorini: Domestic Violence, 14‑Minute Phone Call, and Tragic End
The story of Andrea Cantorini’s death, her boyfriend’s gun‑point threat, and her father’s harrowing 14‑minute phone call is recounted.
- 47:05Closing Reflections and Listener Takeaways
The host wraps up the episode, reflecting on the emotional impact of the cases and urging listeners to stay vigilant and informed.
- 50:06Breaking Baby‑Burial Case Introduction
The hosts introduce the shocking case of an 11‑month‑old baby buried alive in a dog crate, outlining the initial discovery and the baby's miraculous survival.
- 56:00Background on the Family and Motive Speculation
The hosts explore the family dynamics, prior legal issues of the father, and possible motives behind the burial, noting the lack of formal charges yet.
- 1:00:30Malaysia Alford Foster‑Care Murder Case
The hosts shift to the case of 10‑year‑old Malaysia Alford, detailing her disappearance, the discovery of her body, and the arrest of her foster mother.
- 1:05:50Investigation Details and Foster‑Parent Abuse
An in‑depth look at the evidence against Caprice Williams, including surveillance footage, abuse allegations, and the legal implications of her prior record.
- 1:08:31Discussion on Foster‑Care System Failures
The hosts critique the foster‑care system, citing examples of abuse, financial motivations, and systemic failures that allowed the tragedy.
Highlights
- 11:50
Steven Chavez Released Earlydata
Steven Chavez, who pled guilty to felony incest and serving alcohol to his teenage daughter Michaela, has been released from jail after serving only five months of his one-year sentence.
- 15:58
Petition for Legal Reformstrategy
Following her daughter's tragic suicide and the minimal sentence given to Steven Chavez, Michaela's mother launched a petition demanding stricter sentencing laws for sexual assault perpetrators.
- 22:54
Arrest in Brooklyn Jogger Murderstory
Police arrested 27-year-old Syed Mohaseeb for the random stabbing death of runner Katie Suarez in Brooklyn, uncovering surveillance footage and evidence that he attempted to destroy bloody clothing.
- 26:16
Organ Donation After Tragedystory
Despite the devastating loss of Katie Suarez, her family found solace in knowing she was a registered organ donor whose organs saved four people.
- 37:14
Creepy Shrine Discoveryinsight
Following the murder of Melissa Pelk, her daughter Allison revealed that her former stepdad Norman had created a disturbing shrine of her personal belongings and underwear inside a storage closet.
- 43:52
Fourteen-Minute Phone Callstory
Retired NYPD officer Rudy Cantorini described spending fourteen terrifying minutes on the phone pleading with his daughter's boyfriend before hearing the gunshot that killed her.
- 50:22
Baby Buried Alive in Cratestory
Eleven-month-old Koa Sharp was miraculously found alive after being buried in a shallow grave inside a dog crate for nearly 24 hours in South Carolina.
- 1:02:20
Foster Mother Charged With Murderdata
Caprice Williams was arrested and charged with the murder of 10-year-old foster child Malaysia Alfred after investigators discovered repeated physical abuse and a cover-up attempt.
Quotes
“Because Michaela was no longer alive, she couldn't testify against her father.”
Annie Elise · 10:28 “I have to live with this the rest of my life.”
Unnamed speaker · 47:02 “He was sentenced to only one year in Ventura County Jail, followed by three years probation.”
Annie Elise · 10:12 “He was arrested in April of 2025 for violating the protection order.”
Annie Elise · 38:32 “The shrine really freaked her out and that she and Melissa actually went to the sheriff's office to report what was happening.”
Annie Elise · 37:56 “But an 11-month-old baby was buried alive. Not only buried alive, as if that's not bad enough, but buried in a dog crate in the woods.”
Annie Elise · 50:22 “The sheriff said, quote, 'He was screaming at the top of his lungs,' which is a good thing in the baby world, I would guess.”
Annie Elise · 54:18 “Caprice allegedly used her young 10-year-old foster daughter's phone to send herself text messages, making it look like she had gone off with her biological family.”
Annie Elise · 1:04:17 “I am beside myself with this case. It is horrible.”
Annie Elise · 1:00:15
Sponsored segments
- Progressive 0:10–0:28
- Dell 0:28–1:04
- Lowe's 1:04–1:38
- Patreon 5:32–6:08
- Kachava 29:20–30:51
- Mint Mobile 30:59–32:12
- Quince 32:27–33:43
- Rakuten 48:10–49:03
- Tax Relief Advocates 49:06–50:05
- Lucky Land Casino 1:12:22–1:13:16
About this episode
Join Annie as she breaks down what’s happening in true crime this week.
Transcript
13,689 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- NYPD
- Monday Note Taker
- Monday.com
- IRS
- Lexington County
- South Carolina
- Lindenwald
- New Jersey
- Inland Empire
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated