457: Her Phone Went Silent Before He Left her Apt…Then He Wiped His Phone | Sandra Birchmore Trial
Hosted by Annie Elise
- 1h 0m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode covers the federal trial of Matthew Farwell, a former police officer in Massachusetts accused of murdering 23-year-old Sandra Birchmore in February 2021 to prevent her from exposing an abusive relationship that began when she was twelve years old and he was a mentor in a police youth program. The prosecution argued that Matthew Farwell strangled Sandra and staged her apartment to look like a suicide after she became pregnant and demanded he take responsibility. Meanwhile, the defense maintained that Sandra died by self-harm following the emotional collapse of their breakup. The trial featured extensive testimony regarding how multiple police officers exploited the youth program, alongside complex DNA and timeline evidence.
- Sandra joined the Stoughton Police Explorers Youth Program in 2010 at age twelve, where Matthew Farwell was a volunteer mentor. 8:05
- Federal prosecutors charged Matthew Farwell with killing a witness and causing the death of an unborn child. 23:24
- DNA testing eventually established that Jason Pickard, not Matthew Farwell, was the biological father of Sandra's unborn baby. 51:26
- Matthew Farwell's twin brother William testified under immunity that Matthew stated he had a problem and needed help. 54:50
Chapters
- 0:00Episode Introduction & Sponsor Ads
The host opens the episode, introduces the case, and intersperses several sponsor advertisements before diving into the story.
- 2:35Case Overview and Host’s Background
The host explains the Sandra Birchmore case, her long‑time coverage, and why the trial is significant in Massachusetts.
- 12:00Matthew’s Abuse Escalation and Pregnancy Threats
The narrative covers Matthew’s continued abuse, the discovery of his wife’s pregnancy, and Sandra’s attempts to force him into fatherhood.
- 19:35Sandra’s Disappearance and Police Investigation
The episode describes Sandra’s last days, the police wellness check, and the initial ruling of suicide that her family contested.
- 30:00Sandra’s Early Grooming and Relationship with Matthew
The host details how Sandra joined the Stoughton Police Explorers program, met Matthew, and the progression from mentorship to sexual abuse.
- 30:32Federal Trial Begins: Opening Statements
Both prosecution and defense present contrasting narratives—Matthew killed Sandra to silence her versus Sandra’s self‑inflicted death after a breakup.
- 36:00Key Witnesses and Revelations
The host summarizes testimony from the police chief, officers, Sandra’s friends, and others that expose the depth of abuse and cover‑up.
- 52:02DNA Evidence and Timeline Reconstruction
The prosecution presents forensic DNA findings and a timeline of Sandra’s phone activity to argue Matthew’s guilt.
- 53:16Twin Brother William’s Testimony on Sexual Relationships
William reveals his sexual history with Sandra and his brother’s involvement, highlighting potential motives and misconduct.
- 56:15Discussion of Sandra’s Pregnancy and Text Exchanges
Prosecutors present text messages showing Sandra’s pregnancy announcement and Matthew’s hostile reaction.
- 57:31Defense Witness William Kilroy Testifies About Sandra’s Background
William Kilroy shares Sandra’s troubled childhood, family abuse, and a disturbing allegation about her father.
- 59:05Defense’s Journal Entry and Emotional Struggles
William presents a journal entry to illustrate Sandra’s emotional state leading up to her death.
Highlights
- 8:05
Explorers Program Backgroundstory
Sandra joined the Stoughton Police Explorers Youth Program in 2010 when she was twelve years old, where she first met 24-year-old volunteer Matthew Farwell.
- 11:16
Pregnancy Threat and Demandsinsight
After discovering Matthew's wife was pregnant with their third child, Sandra demanded he sign the birth certificate or she would expose their long-term relationship.
- 16:57
While at the hospital for the birth of his third child shortly after visiting Sandra's apartment, Matthew texted a colleague asking if anything was happening at the department.
- 18:33
Officers performing a wellness check entered Sandra's apartment and found her seated on the floor with a duffel bag strap wrapped around her neck.
- 20:55
Internal Affairs Revelationsinsight
An internal affairs investigation revealed that not only Matthew, but his twin brother William and former deputy chief Robert Devine had inappropriate relationships with Sandra.
- 23:16
Federal Indictment Chargesdata
The FBI arrested Matthew Farwell, and a federal grand jury charged him with killing a witness and causing the death of a child in utero.
- 51:26
DNA testing revealed that army recruiter Jason Pickard was the biological father of Sandra's unborn child, while Matthew's DNA was primary on the duffel bag strap.
Quotes
“The whole reason we're even talking about the trial is because for the past four weeks, the federal trial of Matthew Farwell has been unfolding in Massachusetts.”
Annie Elise · 6:41 “Matthew killed Sandra because he was terrified of losing everything, his family, his career, and the life, the fake life, I should say, that he had built.”
Annie Elise · 30:42 “He absolutely, in my opinion, is preying on this young girl, first talking to her when she was 12 years old and getting to know her, then started communicating with her more personally a couple years later when she was 14, and then started a sexual relationship with her when she was 15 years old, while he's 27 years old.”
Annie Elise · 9:37 “I was afraid. I was a married man. I was a recruiter and she was a recruit. I knew what it would do to my marriage, my children, and my career.”
Annie Elise · 45:34 “Both Matthew and Jason's DNA profiles were identified on Sandra's underwear.”
Annie Elise · 52:35 “He also said that sometimes when they would have sex, he was on duty and they would have sex in the back of his police car, which it seems like that's kind of a reoccurring theme, right?”
Annie Elise · 53:41 “I have a problem and I need your help.”
Annie Elise · 55:07 “You are truly the worst person on the face of the earth.”
Annie Elise · 13:24 “The defense relied heavily on its final witness, Dr. Thomas Andrew, who testified that this was absolutely not a manual strangulation.”
Annie Elise · 1:04:48
Sponsored segments
- Progressive 0:13–0:27
- Dell 0:32–1:04
- Lucky Land Casino 1:08–1:35
- Kachava 25:44–27:14
- Mint Mobile 27:31–28:28
- Quince 28:58–29:59
- Atlantic Union Bank 49:11–49:39
- Wayfair 49:52–51:02
- Monday.com 51:05–51:19
- 102Life 1:08:08–1:08:18
- Your Gutters 1:08:47–1:09:15
- SimpliSafe 1:09:17–1:09:46
About this episode
For years, Sandra Birchmore’s death was ruled a suicide, despite the disturbing questions surrounding her relationship with a Stoughton police officer who had known her since she was just 12 years old. Now, Matthew Farwell is on trial for allegedly grooming Sandra as a teenager, killing her while she was pregnant, and staging the scene to cover it up. But now, 50 witnesses take the stand, thousands of messages are examined, and one shocking DNA revelation turns the case upside down.
Transcript
12,170 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- state crime lab
- Boston
- Apple Watch
- Google searches
- Brockton
- community college
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated