459: 4 Hour Assault By Her Own Father Results in Her Death | Makayla Settles
Hosted by Annie Elise
- 45m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode covers the tragic case of 18-year-old Michaela Settles, who moved from North Carolina to California in July 2025 to live with her biological father, Stephen Chavez, and attend college. Two days after her arrival, following heavy drinking, Chavez subjected her to a brutal four-hour sexual assault. Michaela called her mother, was taken to the hospital by her family, and a sane exam confirmed internal injuries and Chavez's DNA. Despite this, prosecutors did not charge Chavez with rape, citing Michaela's later death by suicide in December 2025 and the difficulty of proving non-consent without her testimony. Instead, Chavez was charged with felony incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor. In May 2026, he pleaded guilty under a judge's offer and was sentenced to one year in county jail with credit for time served, resulting in his release in November 2026 after serving under six months.
The host details the public and familial outrage surrounding the lenient sentence, the civil wrongful death lawsuit filed by Michaela's mother, Carolina Sandoval, and the widespread advocacy efforts led by the family to demand legal reform. The episode examines the stark gap between the family's pursuit of justice and the legal constraints that resulted in Chavez walking free as a registered sex offender with an unknown current location.
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Ad Read
The episode opens with a promotional ad for the Yellow Jackets series and a brief host introduction.
- 1:44Michaela’s Background and Move to California
The host explains Michaela’s upbringing, her decision to move across the country to live with her estranged father, and the promises made to her.
- 3:12Host Sets Tone for Harrowing Case
The host warns listeners about the disturbing nature of the upcoming true‑crime story and previews a deep dive into Michaela Settles’ case.
- 6:38Legal Charges and the Question of Rape
The discussion focuses on why Chavez was charged only with incest and alcohol offenses, not with sexual assault.
- 11:31The Assault and Immediate Aftermath
Details of the alleged sexual assault, the hospital examination, and the initial arrest of Stephen Chavez are recounted.
- 20:52Michaela’s Suicide and Family’s Response
The host describes Michaela’s suicide, the family's belief that the assault caused it, and the wrongful‑death lawsuit filed.
- 30:16Preliminary Hearing and Plea Deal
Chavez’s preliminary hearing, his guilty plea to incest and alcohol charges, and the judge’s offer of a plea deal are explained.
- 38:57Sentencing and Public Outrage
The sentencing details, including the one‑year jail term, probation, and the family’s reaction to the perceived leniency, are covered.
- 43:40Release and Ongoing Civil Case
Chavez’s early release, the conditions of his parole, and the upcoming civil trial are discussed.
- 46:03Family’s Advocacy and Call for Change
The host highlights the family's activism, petitions, and demands for sentencing reform to prevent similar injustices.
- 49:31Episode Introduction
The host sets the stage for the episode, introducing the case of Michaela Settle.
- 50:07Justice System’s Response and Outcome
Examination of the DA’s decision to charge only what could be proven and the implications after Michaela’s death.
Highlights
- 4:10
Moving to California for a Fresh Startstory
Michaela Settles moved across the country to California at age 18 to reconnect with her biological father, Stephen Chavez, and start college.
- 6:01
One-Year Jail Sentence Handed Downdata
Despite requests for the maximum state prison term, the judge sentenced Chavez to one year in county jail due to his lack of prior criminal history.
- 8:06
Ambitions and Dreams Cut Shortstory
Michaela had graduated high school in Raleigh, North Carolina, and held multiple ambitions, including becoming a stenographer, nail salon owner, and architect.
- 11:31
The Four-Hour Assault Aftermathstory
Two days after moving in, Michaela was allegedly subjected to a four-hour assault after drinking with her father, leaving her unable to walk and requiring hospital care.
- 14:49
Initial Charges Filed Without Rape Countsdata
Chavez was arrested in July 2025, but prosecutors charged him only with felony incest and giving alcohol to a minor, omitting sexual assault charges.
- 20:52
Tragic Death by Suicide Months Laterstory
Struggling with severe trauma and public disbelief after her father claimed the act was consensual, Michaela took her own life on December 22, 2025.
- 30:16
Guilty Plea Under a Judge's Offerinsight
Chavez advanced his court date and pleaded guilty to felony incest and misdemeanor furnishing of alcohol over the objections of prosecutors.
- 43:40
Release from Jail After Five Monthsdata
Due to statutory credits and 88 days of pre-trial credit, Chavez walked out of Ventura County Jail as a free man after serving less than six months.
Quotes
“He was not charged with rape. Instead, he was charged with felony incest and one misdemeanor count of giving alcohol to a minor.”
Annie Elise · 14:49 “The judge sentenced Stephen to one year in Ventura County Jail.”
Annie Elise · 38:57 “He got one year in county jail, served less than six months, and now he's out walking the streets.”
Annie Elise · 47:26 “Michaela's family is not sitting quietly. They're not gonna just sit by idly and watch this monster get to live his life and move on.”
Annie Elise · 45:11 “She said, "It hurts all over again. It's yet another date that we have to remember and it's painful."”
Annie Elise · 45:39 “If that's not sexual assault, what is?”
Annie Elise · 49:35 “She was the one who couldn't walk. She was the one who had to be carried into an ER and get a sane exam. She’s the one who vocally said it was an assault.”
Annie Elise · 49:53 “The responsibility, though, of course, is not on her. It never was on her. It's on this monster of a father who groomed and lured his daughter to him, to only two days later inflict a four-hour sexual assault on his daughter.”
Annie Elise · 51:11 “This poor girl, what she went through, only to then be called a liar by her own dad, saying, "No, it was consensual. She wanted to have sex with me, too. It was just really rough sex."”
Annie Elise · 51:45 “Consensual or not consensual, I don't even care. It's gross. Stop it.”
Annie Elise · 53:05
Sponsored segments
- Yellow Jackets 0:00–0:30
- Progressive 0:44–0:59
- Dell 1:06–1:35
- Kachava 15:13–17:05
- Atlantic Union Bank 34:48–35:12
- Mint Mobile 35:31–36:27
- James River Air 53:23–53:50
- HomeSense 53:52–54:05
About this episode
Makayla Settles moved across the country at 18 to finally build a relationship with her biological father. But just two days after arriving in California, he brutally assaulted her. Five months later, Makayla took her own life, and after pleading guilty to incest, her father was sentenced to just one year in county jail. Now, after serving less than six months, he’s walked free, leaving her family demanding answers about how this could possibly be justice.
Transcript
9,815 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Ventura County
- Moore Park
- Fox 11
- Los Angeles
- Moore Park College
- California Penal Code 285
- Change.org
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated