Skip to content

The DE Filter Replacement Decision

The Pool Guy Podcast Show

19m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode covers the decision-making process for replacing an aging diatomaceous earth pool filter, specifically focusing on whether to install another DE filter, a quad DE filter, a sand filter, or a large cartridge filter. The host argues that replacing a standard DE filter with a large 400 to 500 square foot cartridge filter is the best option because it eliminates the mess and health hazards of DE, increases water flow, and drastically reduces cleaning frequency. The discussion highlights practical challenges such as reverse plumbing requirements, equipment pad footprints, and environmental regulations regarding DE runoff.

  • Replace old DE filters with large cartridge filters to eliminate the mess and health hazards of diatomaceous earth. 2:19
  • Expect increased water flow when upgrading from a small 60 square foot DE filter to a large 520 square foot cartridge filter. 3:39
  • Be prepared to modify plumbing because inlet and outlet ports are reversed on cartridge filters compared to DE filters. 6:45
  • Avoid environmental fines by knowing local regulations that prohibit washing diatomaceous earth into street gutters and storm drains. 15:44

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Sponsorships and Intro

    Hosts introduce the episode and announce sponsors Hasa and Skimmer.

  2. 1:05
    Host Introduction and Topic Overview

    The host welcomes listeners and outlines the focus on DE filter replacement decisions.

  3. 2:06
    Choosing a Replacement for a 15-Year-Old DE Filter

    The host explains why a cartridge filter is preferable over a direct swap of DE filters.

  4. 3:26
    Benefits of Cartridge Filters Over DE Filters

    Cartridge filters offer larger surface area, easier maintenance, and reduced backwash needs.

  5. 7:03
    Comparing Cartridge, Sand, and Quad D Filters

    The host discusses alternatives, noting cartridge filters outperform sand and Quad D in efficiency and footprint.

  6. 8:45
    Coaching Program Promotion

    The host promotes the Pool Guy Coaching Program and UPA insurance partnership.

  7. 13:31
    Health Risks of Diatomaceous Earth

    DE is a carcinogen; the host warns about inhalation risks and the importance of avoiding it.

  8. 15:22
    Practical Maintenance Tips for Cartridge Filters

    Cartridge filters can be cleaned on grass or cement, avoiding street discharge and simplifying routine.

  9. 15:53
    Regulatory Issues with DE Filters

    The host highlights legal and environmental concerns about disposing DE waste in street drains.

  10. 18:34
    Closing Remarks and Final Sponsor Acknowledgment

    The episode concludes with thanks, website links, and final sponsor shout‑outs.

Highlights

  • 2:19

    Switch to Cartridge Filtersstrategy

    The host advises replacing worn-out DE filters with large cartridge filters rather than replacing them in-kind, citing ease of maintenance and elimination of messy DE residue.

  • 3:34

    Massive Filtration Area Increasedata

    Moving from a 60-square-foot DE filter to a 500-square-foot cartridge filter multiplies the filtration area by eight to ten times, boosting pool flow.

  • 4:39

    Extended Cleaning Intervalsinsight

    Large cartridge filters hold so much dirt that pressure does not drop for up to six months, eliminating frequent backwashing.

  • 6:45

    Plumbing Reversal Complicationstrategy

    Switching filter types requires cutting out the backwash valve and dealing with reversed inlet and outlet locations.

  • 7:31

    Footprint Comparison with Sandinsight

    While cartridge filters fit the same footprint as DE filters, sand filters take up a much larger and bulkier footprint on equipment pads.

  • 13:31

    Health Risks of Diatomaceous Earthinsight

    Diatomaceous earth contains silica and is a carcinogen when inhaled, making the elimination of DE a major safety benefit of cartridge filters.

  • 15:44

    Strict Environmental Runoff Finesstory

    Washing DE into the street or storm drains can result in sizable tickets from city workers or the fire department.

Quotes

  • “I think if you have a chance to get rid of the D filter, take that chance and replace it with a good cartridge filter.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:19
  • “You can go six months without cleaning that filter and the PSI or the pressure won't drop one bit.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:50
  • “DE is a carcinogen, so it's something that if you inhale a lot of the dust, you can get silica in your lungs, and this causes lung disease and possibly lung cancer.”
    Unnamed speaker · 13:31
  • “The cartridge filter will fit pretty much directly where the D filter was.”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:31
  • Hasa 0:00–0:18
  • Skimmer 0:27–0:49
  • Pool Guy Coaching Program 1:23–1:39
  • UPA 8:45–9:03
  • Hasa 18:41–19:00

About this episode

That old DE filter on the pad is doing more than collecting dirt, it is quietly adding hours to your workload and choking your pool’s circulation every time the PSI creeps up. We break down what really happens when a DE grid filter ages out, why the “quickest” replacement can be the most expensive choice over time, and what upgrades actually make a difference for water clarity, flow, and weekly maintenance. We use a familiar setup like a Pentair FNS Plus as the reference point and compare re...

Transcript

0:00
19:03

3,532 words · 3 speakers

Topics

  • D filter
  • cartridge filter
  • Quad D Filter
  • sand filter
  • Pentair
  • Pentair FNS Plus
  • DE filter
  • Aqua
  • Pentair 520-square-foot cartridge filter
  • Swimmingprolearning.com

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated