Pool Products That Shouldn’t Have Died
- 19m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode examines discontinued pool products, analyzing why major manufacturers like Pentair stopped making certain cleaners, filters, and automation systems. The host discusses how the transition from single-speed to variable-speed pumps impacted suction-side cleaners like the Creepy Crawly, and reviews the design flaws and market pressures that led to the discontinuation of items such as the 4000 series filter and the TriVac pressure cleaners. By comparing Pentair's product eliminations with competitors who choose to redesign and revamp flawed items, the episode highlights the strategic importance of keeping reliable entry-level products in a manufacturer's lineup.
- Manufacturers should consider redesigning and updating flawed products rather than completely discontinuing them.
- Keep popular entry-level automatic pool cleaners in your lineup to serve as lead-in products for broader equipment sales. 14:54
- Retain field-tested mechanical designs like the Polaris 280 rather than over-engineering replacements that become too complex or costly. 13:11
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Sponsorships
Hosts introduce the episode and announce sponsors Hasa and Skimmer.
- 1:07Overview of Discontinued Pool Products
The host outlines the focus on products that have been discontinued and why.
- 1:47Pentair's Cleaner Discontinuations
Discussion of Pentair’s phased-out suction cleaners, including the Creepy Crawly and Great White.
- 2:30Reasons Behind Pentair's Cleaner Cuts
Pentair’s shift to variable‑speed pumps and sales cannibalization led to cleaner discontinuations.
- 4:32Pentair 4000 Series Filter Issues
The 4000 series filter’s rotor valve, lid cracks, and competition with Quad D filters caused its discontinuation.
- 8:24Polaris Pressure Cleaner Evolution
The host reviews Polaris pressure cleaners, their redesign attempts, and why they struggled in the market.
- 17:51Product Strategy Lessons for Manufacturers
The host critiques Pentair’s product strategy and urges revamping rather than discontinuing.
- 19:10Coaching Program and Additional Resources
Information about the Pool Guy Coaching Program and where to find more podcasts.
Highlights
- 1:47
Discontinuing Popular Suction Cleanersdata
Pentair discontinued major suction-side cleaners like the Creepy Crawly, Great White, and Sand Shark, leaving only a few models on the market.
- 2:45
Variable Speed Pump Impactinsight
Pentair claimed the Creepy Crawly required too much suction for modern variable-speed pumps, though field experience showed it still functioned well at medium speeds.
- 5:07
Flaws in the 4000 Series Filterstory
The 4000 series fiberglass filter was ultimately discontinued due to expensive, wearing rotor valves, heavy lids prone to cracking, and UV degradation.
- 8:46
The Failure of TriVac Cleanersinsight
Pentair's TriVac 500 and 700 pressure cleaners struggled because they were expensive, required booster pumps, and failed to back up as effectively as the Polaris 280.
- 11:55
The Endurance of Polaris 280insight
The Polaris 280 pressure cleaner has remained on the market for decades because its foundational design stood the test of time while more complex belt-driven alternatives failed.
- 14:29
Missing Out on Roboticsdebate
Pentair missed a major market shift by failing to develop its own robotic pool cleaners after dropping its Dolphin-sourced models, ceding market share to competitors.
- 18:05
Zodiac's Revamp Strategystrategy
Unlike competitors who abandon troubled products, Zodiac successfully updated the MX8 Elite into the Polaris Max and Atlas to solve debris-clogging issues.
Quotes
“The Creepy Crawly still worked fine at 2,600 RPMs or 2,800 RPMs, so it still worked fine at a medium to high, medium-high to medium-high speed, not necessarily the full 3450 RPMs.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:04 “The rotor valve would eventually wear out, it would really be expensive to replace.”
Unnamed speaker · 5:22 “If you ever had a 380, taking it apart, fixing it was just a true pain.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:49 “Pentair copied this design pretty much entirely with their Legend cleaners, which by the way, they discontinued all of those as well.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:55 “I think the biggest issue was that they were expensive and they really didn't work well.”
Unnamed speaker · 10:19 “Pentair got rid of their Intellatouch and Easy Touch, which I thought were decent controllers and people may like them still and a lot of pool guys still like those controllers and they're moving towards a more advanced controller.”
Unnamed speaker · 16:23
Sponsored segments
- Hasa 0:00–0:18
- Skimmer 0:27–0:49
- UPA 8:35–9:07
- Hasa 19:29–19:35
About this episode
They didn’t just discontinue a few random SKUs. They retired products that pool pros actually relied on, and that raises a bigger question: what makes a manufacturer walk away from a cleaner or filter that still works? We unpack the real-world reasons behind “dead” pool products, starting with Pentair’s decision to discontinue a long list of suction side pool cleaners, including the famous Creepy Crawly, and whether variable speed pumps are truly to blame or just a convenient narrative. From...
Transcript
3,530 words · 2 speakers
Topics
- Pentair
- Hayward
- Great White
- Little Rebel
- 4000 series filter
- Polaris 280
- Fluoridra
- Sand Shark
- Pentair Rebel
- FNS Plus filter
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated