Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg About this episode Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about a litany of issues, including the Cambridge Analytica scandal and why Infowars and other conspiracy theorists, like Holocaust deniers, don't get kicked off Facebook. He says he believes over-regulating tech companies is dangerous because it could advantage Chinese firms that don’t share Americans’ commitment to freedom of expression. Zuckerberg also talks about how he thinks VR and AR will change the future of work, explains why his 2017 tour of the U. S. was not a political campaign and says that if anyone should be fired for Facebook's recent privacy stumbles, "It should be me." However, he declines to fire himself, instead committing to an audit of all the other companies like Cambridge Analytica that had access to the most user data.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 15,506 words · 5 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Thanks to ZipRecruiter, which is the presenting sponsor of Recode Decode and the smartest way to hire. Let's face it, hiring isn't always fun. It can be exhausting. But that's no excuse for not taking the time to make sure to find the right hire. How can you make finding great candidates faster and simpler with ZipRecruiter? Their powerful matching technology scans millions of resumes across its network to actively find people with the right experience and invites them to apply, so you get qualified candidates fast. If you're hiring, it's time to get smart. Try ZipRecruiter for free right now at ziprecruiter.com/decode. That's ziprecruiter.com/decode.
0:40 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, the editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as the only person who can make Mark Zuckerberg sweat, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we have a really special interview for you. I sat down with Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg at the company's Menlo Park headquarters. Everything was on the table, and for Facebook, after this year, it was a very huge table. Let's take a listen.
1:09 Speaker 00 So, Mark, thank you so much for talking to me. This is our first interview in years, right?
1:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:13 Speaker 00 We've seen each other. No problem. So, I'm going to start off with the news of the day. You saw the Putin-Trump press conference, essentially.
1:20 Speaker 01 I saw the news about it.
1:20 Speaker 00 You saw the news about it. Tell me what you think about his idea that there is no evidence that the Russians used social media and did different things during the election.
1:31 Speaker 01 Well, the evidence that we've seen is quite clear that the Russians did try to interfere with the election. What we saw...
1:39 Speaker 00 This is on Facebook?
1:40 Speaker 01 Yes. I mean, all of what we saw was on Facebook. And then, you know, we've tried to cooperate with the government and the different investigations that are going on. And they, obviously, have much more context in this. But... We saw before the election was this Russian hacking group, part of Russian military intelligence that I guess our government calls APT 28.
2:03 Speaker 00 Right.
2:04 Speaker 01 And they were trying to do more traditional methods of hacking, phishing people's accounts, just getting access to people's accounts that way.
2:15 Speaker 00 Right.
2:15 Speaker 01 And we identified this actually in the middle of 2015 and notified the FBI. And when we saw similar activity through the campaign in 2016, that they were trying to fish people's accounts in both the DNC and RNC. We notified some of the people over there as well who we thought were at risk. And then later, we also identified that they had set up a fake account and fake pages under the banner of connected to this thing, DC Leaks, in order to seed stolen information that they'd gotten to journalists. So we, around the time of the election, had given this context to the FBI.
3:00 Speaker 01 They've clearly gone much further now at this point in terms of putting the whole story together. And you could see that in the indictments that Mueller just issued over the last week or so. So that's the part that I actually think we got and we're on top of. Now, there's a whole other area of election interference that we were slower to identify, right? And that's around the coordinated information operations that they were trying to run. And that was a different group. Instead of APT 28, that was this group, IRA, the Internet Research Agency, which basically was just setting up a network of fake accounts in order to spread divisive information, misinformation.
3:43 Speaker 00 Advertising content in a variety of ways.
3:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, both advertising and organic. So setting up pages and using the free product. So. You know, once we became aware of this, which, you know, we think we were too slow to being on top of that. But once we became aware of this, we developed this whole roadmap instead of techniques to go and handle that type of security threat in addition to the type of phishing and more traditional cyber attacks that we'd seen before. So that takes us through all the elections that we've seen since then. So there's the French presidential election, the German election, the Alabama special election, the Mexican election recently, and there are elections all around the world. And now, you know, the playbook is, you know, we build AI tools to go find these fake accounts,
4:30 Speaker 01 find coordinated networks of inauthentic activity and take them down. We make it much harder for anyone to advertise in ways that they shouldn't be, right? So a lot of tools are on ad transparency to make it so that anyone who's advertising, especially around political issue ads, will have a lot of the information, a very high standard of transparency, higher than what you have in TV or print or other kinds of ads there. And in the US, we're also even going so far as verifying the identity and location of every single advertiser who wants to run a political or issue ad, which, for a lot of folks, legitimate folks, has slowed down the process of buying ads,
5:11 Speaker 01 which I think can have its own costs for discourse, but we just think is the right precaution to be taking on this. So anyhow, that's probably a longer answer to what you were going for.
5:21 Speaker 00 So you believe it's the Russian government from where you're sitting was using or misusing Facebook? You believe it was the Russian, unlike Trump, you believe it was the Russian government?
5:34 Speaker 01 So the information that we have on who these groups are largely comes from the US government and US intelligence.
5:40 Speaker 00 So you believe US intelligence?
5:43 Speaker 01 We have no reason not to. And certainly, we've seen the activity from APT28. That name, I think, comes from US intelligence, Advanced Persistent Threat 28 from Russia.
5:56 Speaker 01 And the IRA, I mean, these are real things. I mean, this is not, these aren't things that someone made up. And we saw this activity. We went out. We've traced IRA activity, not only through what they've tried to do in the US, but we've traced that activity back to trying to manipulate culture and news in Russia itself, including taking down their pages that are connected to sanctioned Russian news organizations. The government, Roscom, has set a real news organizations there. But what we've detected through our systems are actually essentially the same thing as the IRA. All the people who are running them are the same. So, yeah, so these things are real.
6:39 Speaker 01 And we have been aggressively pursuing them for the last couple of years. And this is now just part of the ongoing playbook that we have for preventing this kind of, these kind of disinformation campaigns.
6:50 Speaker 00 So what took you so long? I mean, I think many people, as you know, feel disappointed with Facebook's behavior and the slowness, just given the power you have or the power over the market you have. I don't want to say what's your excuse, but that's kind of the question. What was the problem?
7:05 Speaker 01 I mean, I think we just weren't looking for these kind of information operations. You know, we have a big security operation. We were focused on traditional types of hacking. We found that and notified both the government and the people who were at risk. But we were, there's no doubt, I mean, we were too slow to identify this new kind of attack, which was a coordinated online information operation. And you can bet that that's now a big focus of the security effort that we have here. And we're very focused on making sure that we get this right, not just broadly, but in all the elections that are coming up. 2018 is an incredibly important election year, not just with the important midterms here in the US, but you just have the Mexican elections, you have Brazil, you have India coming up at the beginning of next year. There's an assortment of elections around the EU.
7:50 Speaker 01 We're very serious about this. We need to, we know that we need to get this right. And we take that responsibility very seriously.
7:56 Speaker 00 I know you say that, but I do want to get out, do you reflect on what it was within? Because you're the leader here, you're the head of this, that you didn't see it? That you don't see that side of humanity or that you don't understand your responsibility?
8:09 Speaker 01 I'm not sure. I think. In retrospect, I do think it's fair to say that we were overly idealistic and focused on more of the good parts of what connecting people and giving people a voice can bring. And I think now we understand that, given where we are, right, both the centrality of Facebook, but also frankly, we're a profitable enough company to have 20,000 people go work on reviewing content. So I think that that means that we have a responsibility to go do that. And that's a different position than we were in five or six years ago, even when we went public and were a meaningfully smaller company at that point. So I do think it's fair to say that we were probably, we were too focused on just the positives
8:53 Speaker 01 and not focused enough on some of the negatives. That said, I don't want to leave the impression that we didn't care about security or didn't have thousands of people working on it before that. So it's not like, I think that these are different kinds of threats that people widely didn't anticipate. And that isn't an excuse. I think it's our job to anticipate this stuff on our platform and to make sure that it's, that people can't use it for negative. And this was a new thing. And I think we understand that we were slow to it and need to do a better job, both on this specific type of threat, defending against nation states, which is not really a top line thing that we'd, that was a major focus before, even though there were some parts of the program that were doing that. But I also think that we know that there are going to be new threats in the future that we haven't
9:38 Speaker 01 seen yet, and that security is an arms race, and it's our responsibility to be as ahead of that as possible.
9:42 Speaker 00 Some people feel you are a nation state in a lot of ways.
9:45 Speaker 01 We're not. We're a company.
9:46 Speaker 00 Okay. You know that. You know, people think of you in a much more powerful manner, I guess.
9:54 Speaker 01 I think we have a lot of responsibility. I mean, the community, more than 2 billion people use our products. And I think we, we get that with that. A lot of people are using that for a lot of good, but we also have a responsibility to mitigate the darker things that people are going to try to do.
10:08 Speaker 00 What does that, what does that responsibility feel like? Do you think you have understood it? Because there's a lot of ways, someone was saying to me, you can't just pass power along. You have an enormous amount of power. Do you understand that? Or do you, do you think about that? Or you don't think you have?
10:25 Speaker 01 No, I think we have a big responsibility, but I'm not sure what you mean by pass power along, but I actually think one of the things that we should be trying to do is figure out how to empower and build other institutions around us that are important and can help figure out these new issues on the internet.
10:47 Speaker 00 Like what?
10:49 Speaker 01 So in one example recently is probably fact checking. Right? You know, I don't think that we should be in the business of having people at Facebook who are deciding what is true and what isn't.
11:00 Speaker 00 All right, we're gonna get into that in a second.
11:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, but I think that, but someone has to have the job of doing that. Right? Society needs people who can be trusted, who can say, to vet things fairly and say, this is provably false. So I think that there's a role there to help build an ecosystem and support that ecosystem. News, I think, is another topic that I'm sure we'll get into.
11:26 Speaker 00 Yeah, we're gonna get into it in just a second. Before we get to that, but we are gonna, the idea of other institutions, that's a really interesting idea. So when you first met, if you remember, do you remember when we first met?
11:35 Speaker 01 I remember we went on a walk. But I don't know if that was the first time.
11:38 Speaker 00 I think it was. Owen Vanata introduced us. And two things you did is you said, I hear you think I'm an asshole, because I had just joked to Owen about it. And I said, I don't know you well enough to know if you're an asshole or not yet, but I will soon. But one of the things you did tell me that was really striking was you called Facebook a utility. Do you remember that?
11:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I called it that for a while.
12:01 Speaker 00 For a while?
12:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:02 Speaker 00 And at the time you met, it was a useful system. It was in contrast to other internet companies at the time, they're much more entertaining or various things like that, that were in ascendance at the time. What do you call Facebook now?
12:14 Speaker 01 I mean, I think that that is still a good description. I mean, in general, we're a social network. I prefer that because I think it is focused on the people part of it as opposed to, some people call it social media, which I think focuses more on the content. For me, it's always been about the people. And the reason why I called it a utility was because a lot of people used to think it was a fad. And what I was trying to communicate was, no.
12:39 Speaker 01 Building a network and building relationships is one of the most core things that people do. And that is an enduring utility that people need. Right. That is not a fad. The company shouldn't be run to try to build something that is cool. It should be trying to, it should be run to build something that is, that is useful and enduring. And I still believe that. Right. But I think that there's this notion today that a lot of the main uses of, of social networks are for sharing content. And, and that obviously has a, has a big impact on, you know, giving people a voice and their safety and security implications. There are media implications of that.
13:19 Speaker 01 But when I think about what social networking should be, it's, okay, now you've mapped out all of the people who, who a person cares about. What are all the useful things that you can do for people on top of that? So I think about things like Marketplace that, that we're doing, that now, you know, people can have trust through their network and can basically go and buy and sell things more easily than they would be able to on other services. You know, your choices are basically, you know, you can use Amazon, which is a central service. You can use eBay, which is a community because they have their, their broad reputation system. Or you can trust people through the network.
13:58 Speaker 01 And a lot of people choose to do that because they know people in common and, and, and that feels better and is a better experience for them. So I think that that is a really important example. Other examples are things like Safety Check. I mean, there are disasters that happen. Hurricane Harvey came up and you had people self-organizing through the community and getting in boats and driving around rescuing people coordinated ad hoc through this network. Well, that's not, that's not a media function. That's a, a social network of people coming together ad hoc to provide safety infrastructure that the world needs. So that's kind of more what I, how I think about what we're doing. And my hope would be- You're talking about a city then?
14:43 Speaker 01 Um, I'm not sure if it's a, if it's a city. I think it's, it's social infrastructure to be sure. But my hope is that if you fast forward five or 10 years, more of what people think about social networking will not only be the aspects around people sharing content, but also people coming together in these different ways.
15:04 Speaker 00 So let's talk about news. Let's talk about news.
15:06 Speaker 01 Sure.
15:07 Speaker 00 This has been one of, every day seems to be a new thing of people asking you to make determinations about what news is. The power you have over distribution is very clear to publishers, to citizens and everyone else. How do you look at your role? Because you're kind of an accidental publisher in a lot of ways. Content, there was all kinds of content, but right now you're being asked, right now as we're doing this interview, there's a congressional hearing going on. In that case, conservatives think that you're not, you don't give enough voice to conservatives. Yesterday I wrote a story, which I think you read about, other publications think you give too much voice to those. You shouldn't have Infowars on here. Let's talk about Infowars. Let's use them as the example.
15:49 Speaker 01 Sure.
15:50 Speaker 00 Make the case for keeping them and make the case for not keeping, not allowing them to be distributed by you.
15:58 Speaker 01 So there are really two core principles at play here, right? There's giving people a voice so that people can express their opinions. And then there's keeping the community safe, which I think is just really important. And we're not going to let people plan violence or attack each other or do bad things.
16:17 Speaker 00 Right.
16:19 Speaker 01 So within this, those principles have real trade-offs and real tug on each other. In this case, we feel like our responsibility is to prevent hoaxes from going viral and being widely distributed.
16:35 Speaker 00 Okay.
16:35 Speaker 01 So the approach that we've taken to false news is not that, not to say you can't say something wrong on the internet, right? I think that that would be too extreme. Everyone gets things wrong, right? And if we were taking down people's accounts when they got a few things wrong, then that would be a hard world for giving people a voice and saying that you care about that. But at the same time, I think that we have a responsibility to, when you look at, if you look at the top 100 things that are going viral or getting distribution on Facebook within any given day, I do think we have a responsibility to make sure that those aren't hoaxes and blatant misinformation. So that's the approach that we have taken is we look at the things that are getting the most distribution. If people flag them
17:17 Speaker 01 as potential hoaxes, we send those to fact checkers who are all well reputable and have followed standard principles for fact checking. And if those fact checkers say that it is provably false, then we will significantly reduce the distribution of that content.
17:36 Speaker 00 Right.
17:36 Speaker 01 And if someone-
17:36 Speaker 00 So you move them down the line rather than get rid of them?
17:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, in newsfeed.
17:40 Speaker 00 Why don't you want to just say, "Get off our platform"?
17:43 Speaker 01 Well, look, as abhorrent as some of this content can be, I do think that it gets down to this principle of giving people a voice.
17:49 Speaker 00 Even if it's a hoax?
17:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. I mean, at some level, it's hard to always have a clear line between, no, I'm not defending any specific content here. And I think a lot of the content that's at play is terrible. And I think when you get into discussions around free speech, you're often talking at the margins of content that is terrible and what should, but defending people's right to say things, even if they can be bad. But, sorry, I lost my train of thought here.
18:20 Speaker 00 There's a difference between offensive and hoaxes.
18:23 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
18:24 Speaker 00 Infowars. I want you to make the case for taking Infowars off if you were on the other side of it.
18:30 Speaker 01 I mean, I think if you were trying to argue on the side of basically that the core principle of keeping the community safe, I think you would try to argue that the content is somehow attacking people or is creating an unsafe environment. Now, let me give you an example of where- We would take it down. So in Myanmar or Sri Lanka, where there's a history of sectarian violence,
18:58 Speaker 00 Right.
18:59 Speaker 01 You know, similar to the tradition in the US where you can't go into a movie theater and yell "fire" because that creates an imminent harm.
19:08 Speaker 01 You know, there are definite examples of people sharing images that are taken out of context, that are false, that are specifically used to induce people to violence in those areas where there's ongoing-
19:18 Speaker 00 And violence has resulted.
19:19 Speaker 01 Yes. So, you know, we are moving towards the policy of misinformation that is aimed at or going to induce violence, we are going to take down. Because that's basically, the principles that we have on what we remove from the service are, if it's going to result in real harm, real physical harm, or if you're attacking individuals, then that content shouldn't be on the platform, right? And there's a lot of categories of that that we can get into. But then there's broad debate and-
19:49 Speaker 00 Okay, Sandy Hook didn't happen is not a debate. It is false. You can't just take that down.
19:57 Speaker 01 I agree that it is false. And I also think that going to someone who is a victim of Sandy Hook and telling them, "Hey, no, you're a liar," that is harassment and we actually will take that down. But overall, you know, I mean, let's take this a little closer to home, right? So I'm Jewish, and there's a set of people who deny that the Holocaust happened, right?
20:19 Speaker 00 Yes, there's a lot.
20:19 Speaker 01 I find that deeply offensive. But at the end of the day, I don't believe that our platform should take that down because I think that there are things that different people get wrong. Either, I don't think that they're intentionally getting it wrong, but I think that they-
20:36 Speaker 00 In the case of the Holocaust deniers, they might be, but go ahead.
20:39 Speaker 01 It's hard to impugn intent and to understand the intent. But I just think for as important as some of those examples are, I think the reality is also that- I get things wrong when I speak publicly. I'm sure you do. I'm sure a lot of leaders and public figures we respect do too. And I just don't think that it is the right thing to say we are going to take someone off the platform if they get things wrong even multiple times. So what we will do is we'll say, okay, you have your page. And if you're not trying to organize harm against someone or attacking someone, then you can put up that content on your page, even if people might disagree with it
21:23 Speaker 01 or find it offensive. But that doesn't mean that we have a responsibility to make it widely distributed in newsfeed. I think we actually, to the contrary-
21:30 Speaker 00 So you just say, "Move them down" versus in Myanmar where you remove it?
21:35 Speaker 01 Yes.
21:36 Speaker 00 Can I ask you that specifically about Myanmar? How did you feel about those killings and the blame that some people put on Facebook? Do you feel responsible for those deaths?
21:44 Speaker 01 I think that we have a responsibility to be doing more there.
21:49 Speaker 00 But I wonder how you felt?
21:50 Speaker 01 Yes, I think that there's a terrible situation where there's underlying sectarian violence and tension. And it is clearly the responsibility of all of the players who are involved there. So the government, civil society, the different folks who are involved. And I think that we have an important role, given the platform that we play. So we need to make sure that we do what we need to. And we've significantly ramped up the investment in people who speak Burmese. It's often hard, from where we sit, to identify who are the figures who are promoting hate and which is the content that is going to incite violence. So it's important that we build relationships with civil society and folks there who can
22:35 Speaker 01 help us identify that. But it's not just Myanmar, right? It's also Sri Lanka. So we have a whole effort that is a product and business initiative that is focused on these countries that have these crises that are on an ongoing basis.
22:52 Speaker 00 Again, I wonder how you feel. How did you feel when that started to happen and the blame was shifted a little bit to Facebook and how Facebook was used as a tool by these people?
23:01 Speaker 01 Look, I want to make sure that our products are used for good. At the end of the day, I mean, other people blaming us or not is actually not the thing that matters to me. What matters to me is how are people using our services and are we acting as the force for good that I know we can and have a responsibility to? And it's not that every single thing that happens on Facebook is going to be good. I mean, this is humanity, right? People use tools for good and bad, but I think that we have a clear responsibility to make sure that the good is amplified and to do everything we can to mitigate the bad. And when you hear that new bad things are happening...
23:37 Speaker 00 What kind of responsibility do you feel? I'm just really curious. I mean, I'd feel sick to my stomach, I'll tell you. That would be my first thing. I feel sick. People die, possibly because of something I invented. And you know, you could do the sort of the old Facebook doesn't kill people, people kill people kind of argument, but what does that make you feel like? What do you do when you see that? What do you do yourself? Or what are you? What's your emotion?
24:00 Speaker 01 I mean, my emotion is feeling a deep sense of responsibility to try to fix the problem. I mean, that's, I don't know that that's, I think that's the most productive
24:11 Speaker 00 To do something.
24:12 Speaker 01 So, I mean, look, you can either look at this and say, we should have predicted all of these issues ahead of time. And some people think that. I tend to think that it is very difficult to predict every single thing. Now, some of these things I think we could have done better on, but I think you're building something from scratch. There are going to be, there are going to be challenges that come up that are things that we did not foresee. And if we foresaw this, I think we might have missed something else. Now, that doesn't make it okay, but what I think it means is that our primary responsibility, I don't believe, is to foresee every problem before it happens as much as it is to, one, we become aware of something, to do everything we can to address it. So, let me give you
24:55 Speaker 01 another example. When Live came up, you know, one of the...
25:01 Speaker 01 One of the terrible use cases where people were using, there were a small number of uses of this, but people were using it to show themselves self-harm, or there were even a few cases of suicide. And we looked at this and we're like, this is terrible. I mean, this is not what we want the product to be. This is terrible, right? And if this is happening and we can help prevent it, then we have a responsibility to. So what did we do? We took the time to build AI tools and to hire a team of 3,000 people to be able to respond to those live videos within 10 minutes, right? So most content on Facebook, we try to get to within hours or within a day if it comes up. But obviously, if someone's going to harm themselves, they don't have a day or hours. You have to get to that quickly.
25:46 Speaker 01 So with all the millions of videos that are posted, we had to build this combination of an AI system that could flag the content that our reviewers should look at, and then hire a specific team trained and dedicated to that. So that way, they could review all the things very quickly and have a very, very low latency. In the last six months, we've been able to help first responders get to more than 1,000 people who needed help quickly because of that effort.
26:13 Speaker 00 So not anticipating it before? Did you not see that that would be a thing? I got into a lively debate with your product managers about it before it was, because you all showed the press before it. And they seemed genuinely surprised when I said, what about murder? What about bullying? What about suicide? What about self-harm? What about this? And they seemed less oriented that than towards the positivity of what could happen on the platform.
26:35 Speaker 01 Well, I think some of the cases we were ready for and some we weren't. I mean, bullying, I think, is something that we've worked on for a while and have ongoing good collaborations with law enforcement and community groups around the world. There's always more to do there, but that's an area where I'm generally proud of the work that we've done. And yeah, I mean, look, I think on any of these given things, Someone will have thought of it in advance. But I think that we should be judged by when we become aware of an issue.
27:07 Speaker 00 How quickly you.
27:08 Speaker 01 How do we respond and do we get it right? And is it a repeat thing? The thing that I, in running a company, if you want to be innovative and advance things forward, I think you have to be willing to get some things wrong. But I don't think it is acceptable to get things, to get the same things wrong over and over again.
27:26 Speaker 00 Absolutely. But I mean, but you're coming from a different case. When you get things wrong, I don't want to say people die, but people suffer. People can suffer in a different way than if I get something wrong or other people do. I mean, the vast amount of responsibility that you have is, I think.
27:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would just, I would just say that on the flip side, that if we don't move forward, a lot of good that should happen, won't happen either. And it's hard to know what the moral equivalence of those things is, because a lot of the good is diffuse and not things that get in the news. But I can't tell you how many times I walked on the street in some city and people come up and say that they got married because of Facebook. They point to their kids and they're like, I have this kid because of Facebook. People have stories about how the communities that they form on Facebook are the most meaningful thing in their life that got them out of bad situations that they were in. And I think if you don't move forward, you lose all that stuff, too. So there's, I mean, these are hard trade offs.
28:24 Speaker 01 And certainly, I don't think that, you know, we retired, move fast and break things many years ago. We didn't think that that was serving the community as well as it had originally. But I do think that there is a benefit and virtue to continue making progress. And I think with progress means that you get some things wrong. And I think that what our responsibility to do is accept when we get things wrong and not be in denial about it, which sometimes we can be too slow on. But in general, I think. If we mess something up, we better damn well make sure we don't make that same mistake again if it's a serious thing. So across elections and all this different stuff, it's, yeah, we need to make sure that we're on top of these issues.
29:05 Speaker 00 Do you regret the move fast and break things? Because a lot of, I mean, I make the joke, you broke enough things, now fix them, kind of idea. Do you regret that motto?
29:12 Speaker 01 I mean, I think it is certainly used today as a symbol. It's used in a way that isn't what I meant. Right? So the notion upfront was that was not about social impact. It was about writing code in the service. And the idea is that by moving faster, we can serve more people with something that a lot of people really wanted. And actually, so it's CZI, Chan Zuckerberg Initiative. We've kind of adapted that value. Instead of move fast, we call it learn fast.
29:46 Speaker 00 Okay.
29:47 Speaker 01 And that's really the spirit of it more, I think, is that the idea is you can either try to get everything right upfront, which I think has a high cost to making progress and serving people. Or you can believe that we're not going to get everything right upfront, but by moving forward, we will learn more. And that will make it that the second and third version of what we do is better. And I really believe that that is the right way to run a company. I think companies need to be learning organisms more than any specific product strategy that we have. Our strategy as a company is to learn as quickly as we can how to serve our community. And I think you only do that by being out in the world, by talking to people, by running experiments, and by trying out things that you're not
30:30 Speaker 01 sure are going to be good, to see how people use them. I think that that is our responsibility is to learn as quickly as we can as an organization.
30:37 Speaker 00 So if it's learn fast, what's the second thing? What do you do with things?
30:40 Speaker 01 What do you mean?
30:42 Speaker 00 Learn fast rather than move fast. What's, what happens to break things?
30:45 Speaker 01 Well, the value is always move fast. It was not, it wasn't-
30:47 Speaker 00 What happens to the break part?
30:49 Speaker 01 Well, the point there was I think values are only worth what you're willing to give up for them. And-
30:57 Speaker 01 You know, so a lot of companies have values that are like, be nice. It's like, okay, well, that's fine, be nice, but that's good, you should. But the real question is like, what are you willing to give up? So I don't think you can just tell a company, move fast. The question is, what are you willing to tolerate? And what we were willing to tolerate early on was more bugs in the product. Right? Not having the product do something completely different. But like, if there were a few errors in the code and it wasn't fully polished, we generally thought that learning quicker and serving people who wanted the product was more important than having it be completely bug free. Now, what we realized was we were getting to a point that we were accumulating so many bugs
31:43 Speaker 01 that having to go back and fix all the bugs after the fact of having launched them was actually net slowing us down and making it so it actually became not an effective way to move forward. So we changed the motto to what is now the much less sexy version of move fast with stable infrastructure, where the current strategy for moving fast is to invest disproportionately in infrastructure and abstractions so that any given engineer could either go work at their, at a startup or their own company, or they can come here and I think be much more productive because they're building on top of all this, these great systems that have been built. But either way, you know, I don't think you can just say move fast. The question is, what are you willing to give up? And in our case now, what we're willing to give up is a meaningful portion of our engineering
32:24 Speaker 01 team working on great infrastructure and abstractions to help everyone else move forward, when those people could otherwise be working on serving people directly. I still think that that's the right strategy because I think learning fast is the core of what we need to be doing.
32:37 Speaker 00 We're going to take a quick break now. We'll be back in a minute with Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg. Today's show is brought to you by ExpressVPN. With the recent news about online security breaches, it's hard not to worry about where my data goes. Making an online purchase or simply accessing your email could put your private information at risk. You're being tracked online by social media sites, marketing companies, and your mobile or internet provider. Not only can they record your browsing history, but they often sell it to other corporations who want to profit from your information. That's why I decided to take my privacy back by using ExpressVPN. ExpressVPN secures and anonymizes your internet browsing by encrypting your data and hiding your public IP address.
33:18 Speaker 00 Protecting yourself with ExpressVPN costs less than $7 per month. So if you ever use public Wi-Fi and want to keep hackers and spies from seeing your data, ExpressVPN is the solution. Protect your online activity today and find out how you can get three free months at expressvpn.com/decode. That's E-X-P-R-E-S-S-V-P-N dot com slash decode for three months free with a one-year package. Visit expressvpn.com/decode to learn more.
33:50 Speaker 00 Hey, Recode Decode fans. Here's something cool. This show has been nominated for the People's Choice Podcast Awards. You can vote for our show by going to podcastawards.com and we'll also put a link to that in the show notes. Listener nominations are open until Tuesday, July 31st, so don't wait. Go to podcastawards.com to cast your vote for Recode Decode, hosted by Kara Swisher. That's me. Thanks. So I want to finish up on news by talking about sort of what's going on today with conservatives versus liberals. How do you feel with the allegations from conservatives that there's not enough conservative that conservative voices are shadowed? I hear it all the time from conservatives. They get they get shadowed either on Twitter or on Facebook or they're that you that you're
34:34 Speaker 00 out to not allow conservative voices to speak up. And on the other side, others think that you do that, you're bending over backwards to to serve a conservative constituency. I don't think you can win anyway, but.
34:47 Speaker 01 Well, I think it gets back to the core principles here. So it's actually the same core principles we discussed before, giving people a voice on the one hand and keeping the community and people safe on the other hand. And our bias tends to be to want to give people a voice and and let people express a wide range of opinions. I don't think that's a liberal or conservative thing. Those are the words in the US.
35:13 Speaker 00 Silicon Valley-ish.
35:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, but I mean, that's we think that that is a is a virtue. Interestingly, I think for most of the history of the company, I think a lot of people agreed that that was a virtue. I think recently, a lot of people may be just more focused on some of the negatives that can come with people widely having a voice. But I think that's become a more unpopular belief in the last few years, that giving people a voice is good. But we still believe it. I think that you see a lot of good around the world come from that. And I think that we will eventually come around to that as well in the US broadly.
35:54 Speaker 00 What is your political leanings? Do you have them?
35:58 Speaker 01 I care about specific issues very deeply, and I'm not sure that aligns with any kind of specific thing. So I mean, I'm very outspoken on immigration reform. In 2013, I helped start with a number of entrepreneurs here at Forward.Dot us, which is a group working on immigration reform that I think recognizes that we need to secure the border and enforce laws, but that also understands that the benefits of immigration, both to the country and the economy, and as a humane civil rights issue for the 11 million people who are undocumented here, is incredibly important.
36:43 Speaker 00 How did you feel about the border separations?
36:47 Speaker 01 It's terrible. Terrible.
36:50 Speaker 00 What did you do? Did you do anything besides donate money or stuff like that?
36:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, I mean, the good news here is because we've been working on Forward for so long, it has established a lot of the infrastructure that now, when you get a crisis comes up, you can't just spin the stuff up immediately. So they're in there and are able to help out. But I mean,
37:12 Speaker 01 Talking about social utility, I mean, one of the really proud moments recently of working at this company was the fact that a couple of people could-
37:22 Speaker 00 The willers, I have them on the podcast. Yeah, they're great.
37:24 Speaker 01 They'd start a fundraiser to raise $1,500, enough to bail one person out. And they ended up raising more than $20 million. And this thing just went viral. And I think it's a great example of when you give people a voice, what positive things can happen. And both substantively in terms of the fundraiser and just the widespread show of support, I think, is also really meaningful. And I think a combination of that and a number of other things like that may have been what led the administration to backtrack on the policy there.
38:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, possibly, possibly. So let's get into the idea of privacy and data. How do you assess your performance in front of Congress? It was a low bar mark. They didn't do a very good job. That's my opinion.
38:14 Speaker 01 You thought I didn't do a very good job?
38:15 Speaker 00 I thought you did, but I only thought it's because they did such a bad job.
38:18 Speaker 01 Well, look, I think a lot of people think about this from a gamesmanship perspective of like, someone's winning and someone's losing.
38:25 Speaker 00 Right.
38:26 Speaker 01 I tried not to-
38:27 Speaker 00 It's politics.
38:28 Speaker 01 I tried not to, yeah, okay. And maybe, maybe I'm too idealistic still. But I tend to come at this from the perspective of, we have a duty to the country to provide as much context as we can about the set of issues that we see. And in general, I was impressed at how many of the people there, both, I think, had a handle on a lot of the issues. And I think genuinely, we're trying to understand them.
38:56 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
38:57 Speaker 01 And some of the questions I thought were really, were really hard and pointed.
39:02 Speaker 00 Which one? Which one?
39:03 Speaker 01 Um, I thought on the second day, I thought Congressman Kennedy's questions-
39:09 Speaker 00 Second day was better, yeah.
39:10 Speaker 01 Around- You know, I mean, it's, I mean, he asked them respectfully, but they were very hard questions around, around who owns the data and how is it going to be used? And, and to me, that just got to the heart of why processes like that are important. And so my, I didn't feel like my responsibility there was to show up and, and win. I was trying to.
39:34 Speaker 00 Oh, I wasn't thinking it was a winning thing. I thought the questions were not very illuminating. That's all.
39:38 Speaker 01 I'm there as a witness who hopefully understands some relevant context on an issue of importance to the nation. And I view my responsibility as making sure that they can get as much information as they need to in order to inform what they need to go do. Because you know, now, you know, whether it's, you know, the cooperation that we have with the Mueller investigation, or areas like this where there's hearings about election interference, or, or the data privacy issues, these are broader issues. And we're a player in them, but there's a much bigger picture here as well. And we don't have the full context of that. So I think to the extent that we, our responsibility is to do everything we can to prevent these
40:20 Speaker 01 issues on our surface, and to make sure that the people who, whose job it is, is to have the full context across everything, have whatever information we, we can provide. You know, like you saw with the, the Mueller indictments recently, it's, you know, I think some of that context probably initially came from us, but then they had to go build on that for years in terms of putting together the whole, the whole story and do very significant work on top of that. But if we can help out in ways like that, then I, then I feel good about our contribution.
40:49 Speaker 00 But have you given them full activity of the Russians on your platform? Have you given the investigation full access to that data?
40:58 Speaker 01 Um, I'm not sure what that means. I mean, in general, I think the way this works is they, they ask a set of questions and we go and do investigations and turn up whatever we find.
41:08 Speaker 00 Okay. In the, back to the hearings, one of the things I think, I'm not saying it's a, it's a win lose thing. I think they were, they did not press you very hard on certain issues. One of them that you kept saying, two, two areas. One is what you guys do with the data. One was the part related to Cambridge Analytica, which is what happened there, which I think is still, you're still investigating, it's still being investigated by authorities and how it happened. And your, in that case, your defense was, we didn't see it, but once we saw it.
41:40 Speaker 00 We did something about it. What I would have asked is, why didn't you see it? What's the problem with this data that you did not see it being misused? Because I was at your 2009 or 2008, I remember when you were talking about this idea.
41:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, so the principles at play here are, on the one hand, you want people to have control over their information and to be able to bring it out of Facebook, right? To other different apps. Because we're not going to build all of the social experiences and it should be easy for people to use their data anywhere. But on the other hand, if they had that information in Facebook and the developer has some relationship with us, then we also have a responsibility to protect people and keep people safe. And what happened here was a developer built a quiz app and then they turned around and sold the data that people gave them to someone else. And that is clearly against all of the policies that we have. I mean, that's terrible. We don't sell data, we don't allow anyone to sell data.
42:42 Speaker 01 Because it was on their servers, we don't necessarily see that transaction or whatever they're doing.
42:50 Speaker 00 But you have in the past caught people doing this and been much more rigorous in that.
42:54 Speaker 01 So we do a number of things. One is, we do ongoing audits and we have built technical systems to see if a developer is requesting information in weird ways. We do spot checks where we can audit developer's servers. But a lot of the stuff comes from flags that either people in the community or law enforcement or different folks sent us. And that was actually similar here, too. I think it was The Guardian who initially pointed out to us, hey, we think that this developer, Alexander Kogan, has sold information. And when we learned about that, we immediately shut down the app, took away his profile, and demanded certification that the data was deleted.
43:38 Speaker 01 Now, the thing that I think in retrospect that we really messed up here is that we believed the certification. Now, normally, I don't know about you, but when someone writes a legal certification, my inclination is to believe that. But in retrospect, I think it's very clear. You don't?
43:53 Speaker 00 No, I don't believe anybody.
43:54 Speaker 01 All right, well, that's...
43:56 Speaker 00 There's an expression in journalism, if your mother says she loves you, check it. But go ahead.
44:00 Speaker 01 All right, that's fair. I tend to have more faith in the rule of law.
44:03 Speaker 00 And I think the links between Peter on your board and the Bannon and it was, it creates a really bad situation for you all. Or suspect, at least, leads to people wondering what was happening there.
44:15 Speaker 01 All right, well, I don't think there's any suggestion that that stuff was.
44:18 Speaker 00 No, but I'm just saying, it just creates a what the heck was going on here.
44:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think in retrospect, you know, we didn't know what Cambridge Analytica was there. It didn't strike us as a sketchy thing. They, we just had no history with them. Knowing what I know now, we obviously would not have just taken their certification at its word and would have gone in and done an audit then.
44:40 Speaker 00 All right.
44:41 Speaker 01 And now, so now we're basically doing this. Now our policy is we are not just going to take developers at their word when they say that they aren't misusing information. We're going to go and audit every single developer who had a large amount of access to people's information before we significantly locked down the amount of access that developers could get, starting back in 2014.
45:00 Speaker 00 Should someone have been fired for this?
45:03 Speaker 01 You know.
45:03 Speaker 00 I asked Cheryl this, I'm just curious if you, what you think.
45:06 Speaker 01 Well, I think it's a big issue, but look, I designed the platform. So if someone's going to get fired for this, it should be me. And I think that the important thing going forward is to make sure that we get this right. In this case, the most important steps in terms of to prevent this from happening again, we'd already taken in 2014 when we had changed dramatically the way that the platform worked.
45:34 Speaker 01 But yeah, I mean, overall, I mean, this is, this is an important situation. And I think, again, it's, this to me is an example of you get judged by how you deal with an issue when it comes up. And I think on this one, we've done the right things and many of them, I think we'd actually done years ago to prevent this kind of situation from happening again.
45:57 Speaker 00 But to be clear, you're not going to fire yourself right now, is that right?
45:59 Speaker 01 Not on this podcast.
46:00 Speaker 00 Okay, all right, that would be fantastic. I mean, I think you'll do okay. So let's get to the privacy and data part of it. One of the things you kept saying in Congress, which really drove me crazy because you said it like I counted.
46:12 Speaker 01 Do you really want me to fire myself right now?
46:14 Speaker 00 Sure, it's fine.
46:15 Speaker 01 Just for the news?
46:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, why not?
46:19 Speaker 00 Whatever, Mark, whatever works for you. No.
46:22 Speaker 01 I think we should do what's going to be right for the community.
46:25 Speaker 00 All right, okay, all right. Well, I'll get to whether a regulation in a second, but two more sections and then you'll be out of here. One is, you kept saying, Senator, we don't sell your data. Senator, we don't sell your data. You kind of sell people's data in a different way by marrying it with other data. You sell insights into that data. You sell, your whole business is predicated on using data to make money. Why did you keep saying that? I mean, technically, you're correct, but...
46:58 Speaker 01 Well, I think facts do matter.
46:59 Speaker 00 Yes, I know, but you don't technically sell their data, but you use their data to sell advertising. So you are in a, in essence, what are you doing with people's data? How would you describe it?
47:09 Speaker 01 It bothers me when reputable news outlets make claims like saying that we sell data
47:17 Speaker 00 Like to propter and gamble.
47:18 Speaker 01 Because it's just not true.
47:19 Speaker 00 Right, okay.
47:20 Speaker 01 We don't sell data. Now, I understand what you're saying. There's, the business model works in, basically in two ways. One is, people have attention from, from being on the service, which is no different from the ads you'll run during this podcast, or traditional TV ads for the last 50 years. But there is an element of targeting, which is that because we understand what you're interested in, we can show you more relevant ads to you. And people overall, people want to know that their information is secure, and that if they give it to you, they want you to use it to make their experience good, but they don't want you to give it to other people. So while it may seem like a small
48:02 Speaker 01 difference to you, this distinction on, on selling data, I actually think to people, it's like the whole game, right? So we don't sell data. We don't give the data to anyone else. But overwhelmingly, people do tell us that if they're going to see ads on Facebook, they want the ads to be relevant. They don't want bad ads. So they want us to use what they're browsing on Facebook and what they've clicked on, what they've told us that they like, in order to show them more relevant ads.
48:29 Speaker 00 Do they still know enough about what they're opting into? Someone recently called you to me a greedy information hoarder, essentially, that you hoard this information
48:38 Speaker 01 Well, let me give you, let me give you one example that I think is interesting. During the GDPR flows and rolling that out, one of the specific things that we needed to do is get specific opt-in permission from people to use information from the websites that they used and apps in order to help target ads. And the vast, vast majority of people chose explicitly to opt into that, which goes in line with everything that I've seen on the research from what people want, which is that when faced with the decision of, do you want more relevant ads or less relevant ads if you're going to see ads, people want better ads.
49:21 Speaker 01 Not everyone, I mean, some percent of people said no, but the overwhelming majority of people say yes. And I think that's just an important thing to.
49:30 Speaker 00 Right. Do you think people understand how much information you have on them? It's a different factor than ever before in history, how much information you know about people.
49:39 Speaker 01 Maybe, although I think most people actually on a service like Facebook or Instagram probably have a greater awareness of the information that's there than on a lot of other services, because in our case, you actually put it there. Right? I mean, you told us that you liked that thing, or you posted that photo, or said that. So I actually think people generally have an awareness and feel like, wow, these networks have a lot of information. The areas that I would actually worry about more for consumers are places where they don't realize that services are collecting a lot of information about them, but actually are.
50:18 Speaker 01 So that's a whole different thing.
50:19 Speaker 00 Like who?
50:20 Speaker 01 Well, a lot of other folks online.
50:22 Speaker 00 Such as?
50:23 Speaker 01 I mean, there's the whole industry of data brokers, for example, who we've recently made the decision that we don't want to be in business there.
50:33 Speaker 00 Right.
50:34 Speaker 01 I mean, we never were a data broker, but we used to let advertisers use data brokers. And we decided, no, we think that this is not a good thing.
50:43 Speaker 00 Why did that happen? Why did you suddenly come to that realization?
50:47 Speaker 01 Well, I think.
50:50 Speaker 01 Around the time of the Cambridge Analytica issue, we realized that we needed to do a full audit, not just of that specific issue, but across all the platform, like everything that was going on. Where was data coming into the system? Where might people's data be going out? And every case of that, do people understand what is going on? And we just made a series of decisions that were like, no, we think that given where, how we view our responsibility and where the world is, this is no longer the right thing. We should not do this. We should not do this. This we should change or communicate differently. And we did a series of actions around that, and this was one of them.
51:31 Speaker 00 Okay, so let me finish up about you, but I do want to ask one more thing in this area. Regulation, how much do you think is coming from if the Democrats get back in power? They've gotten rather hostile towards you and Google, it seems.
51:44 Speaker 01 Well, I think you're too focused on the US.
51:47 Speaker 00 Okay, across the world. Do you see regulation being, obviously, Europe is a place where there's much more regulation happening and more activity.
51:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, so there's lots of different areas for this. The area that I think is most likely is content. Right, so the US has a very rich tradition of free speech. It's written into the Constitution, free speech. So here, we have a very strong allergic reaction to trying to regulate that. But in almost every other country in the world, while people generally want as much expression as possible, there's some notion that something else might be more important than speech, so preventing hate or terrorism or just different things. So you're already starting to see this. I mean, there was the hate speech law in Germany.
52:34 Speaker 01 I think that there will be additional laws creating responsibility for for social networking and social companies and internet companies overall to be more proactive in policing terrorism or bullying or hate speech or different kinds of content. And overall, I think that there are good and bad ways to do that. But my general take is that a lot of that stuff can be pretty reasonable. I mean, I think we're not, we're not kids in a dorm room anymore, right?
53:04 Speaker 00 No, that's a long ago.
53:06 Speaker 01 So when we were, no, I mean, but when, back then. If someone had said, you need to make sure that you're going to give people a voice, but you need to make sure that it's not used to spread hate speech. The best you could do is get the community to flag things for you and hope to review them yourself. But now, you know, we're a big company. AI technology has advanced significantly. We're at a point now where we've built AI tools to detect when terrorists are trying to spread content. And 99% of the terrorist content that we take down, our systems flag before any human sees them or flags them for us. And we can afford at this point to have 20,000 people reviewing the content. So I think at the point where you have that kind of AI technology and you have the resources
53:51 Speaker 01 to be able to employ people to do that kind of content review, I kind of think you have a responsibility to do it.
53:58 Speaker 00 Okay. So you can handle regulation. What about the call? There's been some calls to break up companies like Facebook or Amazon that have become too big. Are you in fear of that in any way?
54:08 Speaker 01 No, I think that there's, it's a very interesting debate overall. You know, if you actually get down to why we're big, it's not, in the traditional sense, we're not big because we're so big in the United States. Although, although we are, and a lot of people use our products here. If we weren't an international company, if you just, if you said, okay, you have to shut down all of your services outside of the US, we actually would not be very profitable at all. We actually would probably be unprofitable. So the reason why we are a successful and large company is because we have built something
54:49 Speaker 01 here that can now serve billions of people around the world as well, which is actually where all the margin comes from. In terms of, I mean, we have the cost structure that we have, and then you're, and then that's, that's where the business comes from. And don't get me wrong, there's a lot of revenue in the United States as well, but, but that would barely cover the cost of the company. So I think you have this question from a policy perspective, which is, do we want American companies to be exporting across the world? And it's, you know, we grew up here. I think we share a lot of, a lot of values that, that I think people hold very dear here. And I think it's generally very good for
55:33 Speaker 01 Very good that that we're doing this, both for security reasons and from a values perspective. Because I think that the alternative, frankly, is is going to be the Chinese companies.
55:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
55:45 Speaker 01 Right? So if we adopt a stance which is that, OK, we're gonna, as a country, decide that we want to clip the wings of these companies and make it so that it's harder for them to operate in different places, or they have to be they have to be smaller, then there are plenty of other companies out there that are willing and and able to to take the place of the work that we're doing.
56:08 Speaker 00 Specifically, the Chinese companies.
56:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, and they do not share the values that we have. And and I think you can bet that, you know, if the government here is worried about whether it's election interference or terrorism, I don't think Chinese companies are going to want to cooperate as much and try to aid the the national interest there.
56:28 Speaker 00 What is your situation in China now?
56:30 Speaker 01 I mean, we're we're blocked.
56:32 Speaker 00 And are you are you working on moving Facebook products in there?
56:36 Speaker 01 Over the long term, I think it's hard to have a mission of wanting to bring the whole world closer together and leave out the biggest country.
56:42 Speaker 00 And what will that take?
56:44 Speaker 01 I don't know. I mean, I think that that's.
56:46 Speaker 00 You went, you jogged in Tiananmen Square. What what else could you do?
56:50 Speaker 01 I actually, I thought that that was interesting, that that got so much pickup. That you're right.
56:54 Speaker 00 I'm right on that one.
56:55 Speaker 01 That you're right.
56:55 Speaker 00 You can't jog in Tiananmen Square, Mark. You can't. It looks it looks like you're cooperating with the Chinese government. We're going to argue about that forever.
57:02 Speaker 01 Fine. Well, I mean, that year I posted photos of me running everywhere, including Delhi, which has worse air quality.
57:09 Speaker 00 I know you were 12, but there was a guy with a tank and a briefcase in that square when you were 12, and it was problematic.
57:15 Speaker 01 OK, well, I'm not gonna I'm not gonna defend that. But.
57:19 Speaker 00 Where are you with China?
57:21 Speaker 01 I mean, we're, I think, a long time away from from doing anything. I mean, it's it's some point, I think, that we we need to figure it out. But we need to figure out a solution that is in line with our principles of what we want to do and in line with the laws there, or else it's not going to happen. And right now, there isn't an intersection.
57:42 Speaker 00 We're going to take another break now. We'll be back after this with Mark Zuckerberg, the CEO of Facebook. Today's show is brought to you by TransferWise. Do you ever need to send money internationally? Sure, your bank or PayPal can get your money from A to B, but that transfer will cost you more than it should, a lot more. That's the old way of doing things. Let me tell you about the new, smarter, and cheaper way to send money internationally: TransferWise. TransferWise was founded by two friends, Tavet and Cristo, who were frustrated by their bank's bad exchange rates and high fees. They wondered, what if we could bypass the banks entirely? So they built TransferWise. That was seven years ago. Today, more than 2 million people use TransferWise. People sending money home, businesses paying suppliers, freelancers getting paid, the
58:27 Speaker 00 list goes on. TransferWise's clever new technology gives you a great exchange rate and a low fee. So it'll put some extra money in your pocket for more important things. No one has ever said, "It's important that my bank gets some extra money." Test it out for free at transferwise.com/podcast or download the app. Once again, that's transferwise.com/podcast. It's the wise way to send money.
58:53 Speaker 00 I'd also like to tell you about my other podcast, Too Embarrassed to Ask. Every week, we answer your questions about consumer tech and the week's news. This week, I talked to Cristo Wilson and David Chofness from Northeastern University. Cristo and Dave, what did we talk about?
59:05 Speaker 02 Well, we discussed that most apps aren't watching you, but there's a couple that are actually just recording everything and sending it to third parties.
59:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, the fear that your app is listening to you all the time, or that it's watching you via the camera. We can't say that's true for most apps, but we did find some other behavior in terms of them watching what you do on the screen that in some sense might be even more dangerous.
59:27 Speaker 00 Yes, these are two professors who largely debunk the conspiracy theory online that your phone is always listening to you for ad purposes. Anyway, you can find Too Embarrassed to Ask on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. That's Too Embarrassed to Ask. See you there. All right, I want to finish up just talking about you. We just have a few more minutes. This is an issue I've talked about a lot is Silicon Valley responsibility and taking responsibility and taking responsibility for dark things and not being quite as optimistic. And a lot of people here have a problem with looking at that. How do you look at your responsibility as a leader of a massive company with enormous power? Do you think you grok that at this point? Sometimes I don't think you do. I really don't.
1:00:09 Speaker 01 Well, I think we have a responsibility to build the things that give people a voice and help people connect and help people build community, which ultimately is the unique thing that we do in the world. So that, I think, is one important piece of it. But then, on the other hand, I think we also have a responsibility to recognize that the tools won't always be used for good things and we need to be there and be ready to mitigate all the negative uses. So whether that's terrorism or people thinking about self-harm or suicide, who we need to go make sure that they get help quickly, or bullying, or election interference, or fake news, and the list goes on, and there's a lot of these things. And there are very specific pieces of work that we have to do on each.
1:00:53 Speaker 01 So I mean, just take terrorism, for example. We have a team of more than 200 people working on counterterrorism. I mean, that's pretty intense, right? That's not like what people think about what Facebook is.
1:01:04 Speaker 00 No, I'm sure when you were an engineer, you weren't thinking this was your...
1:01:06 Speaker 01 So, look, I do think that there will be things that we get wrong in the future too. But I think to say that we don't care about what's going on or mitigating any of the downsides of what people do, I don't think is right. And I think to say that that is the only thing that we should be focused on, I think also is not quite right, because I think that what most people out there want is the ability to stay connected with the people that they love and to be able to join communities, because that's an important part of people's lives. And if we're not making progress on that and advancing the ball forward there too, then I also don't think we're doing our job.
1:01:50 Speaker 00 What about the image of Facebook? It's not great right now. Would you agree with that? Sort of not-
1:01:56 Speaker 01 It's not as good as it's been.
1:01:57 Speaker 00 Yeah. How does that feel personally?
1:01:59 Speaker 01 I mean, personally, my take on this is that for the last 10 or 15 years, we have gotten mostly glowing and adoring attention from people. And if people want to focus on some real issues for a couple of years, I'm fine with it. And frankly, I think that the news industry is critically important because it points out things and surfaces truths that can often be uncomfortable. And I think that that's working. And the spotlight has been pointed on things that we have a responsibility to do better. And I accept that. And while it may not be the most fun period of running the company, I think we take the responsibility really seriously and get that in the grand scheme of things,
1:02:44 Speaker 01 like, I don't think people are being unfair to us. I think, you know, people have been very positive and have focused on all the good that come with the technology for a long period of time. And if it's, you know, to have a period where people focus on some of the negative uses, so to make sure that we fully understand that, I think is completely reasonable.
1:03:03 Speaker 00 What about you personally? How does that feel? Because it's a lot of us directed at you.
1:03:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I think that that is my personal take. I think it's-
1:03:12 Speaker 00 It's okay. Mark is okay. Like, is that what you... I don't... You accept the responsibility of the criticism, is what you're saying.
1:03:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, I also just think you need to put all this in perspective, right? It's... If you look at what people have said about Facebook and how much they love the brand and the products over a 10-year period, I mean, most of the coverage and what people say is super positive. If there's going to be a period of two years where we frankly didn't handle a bunch of things as well as we should have and need to get back on top of it, then, you know, I mean- You're not going to cry about that. You're going to do what you need to to make it good.
1:03:49 Speaker 00 So what do you do not cry about it?
1:03:51 Speaker 01 What do you mean?
1:03:52 Speaker 00 Well, if I got this much criticism, I think I'd feel a lot of pressure. I'd feel a lot of pressure.
1:03:56 Speaker 01 Well, having feeling pressure is different from being sad. I think that.
1:03:59 Speaker 00 Oh, I don't think you should be sad necessarily. I think you've got a pretty good life.
1:04:02 Speaker 01 I think so what we we sit down and say, all right, we have to go do this, right?
1:04:08 Speaker 00 And you might be more self reflective. Most people in Silicon Valley aren't self reflective. Like, you might go, what did I do? What have I done? And what should I do better in the future? I think most people, that's that would be an adult response.
1:04:19 Speaker 01 At a institutional level, I think making sure that we put appropriate focus on these things is is really important.
1:04:27 Speaker 00 So what's your goal this year? You have these goals. This is this year is fix Facebook. You did the you did the visit every cow in America tour last year. What is your personal goal this year away from fixing Facebook?
1:04:39 Speaker 01 I mean, that is, I think that the feeling this year is that, you know, I've done these personal challenges because I think running a company can be an all consuming thing. And I think in order to have a broader perspective, you want to do things outside of that, too. So whether that's running or learning Mandarin or visiting different places or coding an AI to run my home. I think those are all good things. This year, I just think we're so.
1:05:08 Speaker 00 Home, but okay, all right. I miss the AI running your home, but go ahead.
1:05:12 Speaker 01 What do you mean?
1:05:12 Speaker 00 I miss that.
1:05:14 Speaker 01 Jarvis.
1:05:14 Speaker 00 Oh, Jarvis. Yeah, that's right. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
1:05:17 Speaker 01 That was fun.
1:05:18 Speaker 00 Okay.
1:05:18 Speaker 01 That was fun. But, you know, this year, I think we have a number of issues that we need to deal with. And it didn't feel right to me to to focus on something else outside. I think this is, interesting enough,
1:05:33 Speaker 01 this is an important challenge that I think we need to dedicate every fiber of what we're doing to making sure that we get this right.
1:05:39 Speaker 00 How long does that last?
1:05:41 Speaker 01 What, this focus? You know, I think it'll take. About three years to fully retool everything at Facebook to be on top of all the content issues and security issues. But the good news is we're about a year and a half in. I do think that by the end of this year, we'll have significantly turned the corner on a lot of these issues. I don't think we're going to be as good as we would like to next year either, but I think it'll be close. And then my hope is that by the end of 2019, a lot of the systems will be much more operational and dialed in, which doesn't mean that there aren't going to be errors, right? There are going to be, there are always going to be errors that people say, hey, you enforced against this content
1:06:23 Speaker 01 incorrectly. But I think part of that means having mature systems, like building an appeal process. So that way, it's not just some representative somewhere around the world of Facebook who makes a decision on your content, but you can appeal that and maybe even appeal it independently over time to some other body. But by the end of 2019, I would hope to have all of that in place.
1:06:43 Speaker 00 And then have some other goal. Do you have any political goals? I know people thought when you did your grand tour of the United States, that was what you were doing with your team of videographers, etc. You had a lot of photographers, Mark. They were lovely photos. I went across the United States. I had no photographers with me.
1:07:01 Speaker 01 We have one photographer at Facebook.
1:07:05 Speaker 00 They were nice photos.
1:07:06 Speaker 01 Yes, it's okay. Anyhow.
1:07:08 Speaker 00 You might imagine why people would wonder if you did, doing that.
1:07:13 Speaker 01 I understand. I mean, I care about helping to address these problems of social cohesion and understanding what economic problems people think exist.
1:07:25 Speaker 00 Right.
1:07:26 Speaker 01 I tend to think that we all get support from three basic places: our friends and family, the communities we're a part of, and then ultimately, the government with its safety net. And I think as a society, we spend the vast majority of our time talking about what the government should do in the political debates. And I think we spend not enough time talking about how important community is. So you go around and you, you know, I saw... Sit down with ministers and places and they talk about not just the religious role that they play, right, as a religious organization, but as a community organization. So, you know, one minister told me that he knew that when a factory closed down in
1:08:09 Speaker 01 town, he was going to be seeing more couples for couples counseling a few weeks later because of the tension. All right, that, that's a real piece of social infrastructure that needs to exist. And, and if people aren't a part of those kind of organizations, then there's a core need that people have that is not being fulfilled. You know, you go to military bases and you meet the spouses of people who get deployed in different places. And they told me that the core part of their social infrastructure are these Facebook groups where every time they get deployed, they go, they go join the group of, of military families around that base and figure out what school they should send their kid to, what services locally they should use. And that is like how they got rooted and how they get, they get established in a community.
1:08:54 Speaker 01 And it's not just a group that's online, it spans online and offline, meeting real people. And I sat down with kids in Chicago at a school where a lot of kids were in gangs. And I mean, they told me the reason why people were in gangs is not because they wanted to be in a gang, they understood that it was dangerous, but because they needed a sense of community in a dangerous environment, they wanted to know that someone was looking after them. So my takeaway here is that there is a real issue, which is that people need community support. But if you look at the sociology and the history here, community membership has actually been on the decline and has been fragmenting for 40 or 50 years, well predating the internet.
1:09:36 Speaker 01 And since the seventies, there are now 25 or 30% of people who are no longer members of groups, whether religious organizations or local organizations or volunteer organizations that they once were. And that strikes me as a real crisis. And it's not just American, I think it's around the world. As well. So that's why we changed our mission last year to not just be about friends and family, which is always going to be a core part of the Facebook experience, but to now be about helping people connect and join those kind of meaningful communities like military spouses, or the group for you have a new kid and you join a group for new fathers or new mothers, that ends up being a really core part of your social support
1:10:18 Speaker 01 network. Or you, God forbid, come down to the rare disease and you need to have a support group of people who have that, but there are no other people around you who have that. There are about 200 million people on Facebook who are part of what they call these meaningful communities, for whom upon joining them, that becomes like the defining aspect of their Facebook and internet experience and one of the most important parts of their real world support structure.
1:10:46 Speaker 00 Okay. So, so some people might say the uses of the internet and mobile phones is the reason people are feeling this way, too.
1:10:54 Speaker 01 Well, hold on, hold on, because-
1:10:55 Speaker 00 So the solution to Facebook might not be more Facebook, but go ahead.
1:10:57 Speaker 01 Look, I think that this problem clearly predates the internet, let alone Facebook.
1:11:02 Speaker 00 Loneliness, yes, human condition.
1:11:03 Speaker 01 And the decline of community.
1:11:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:11:05 Speaker 01 So I think putting that all on the internet seems unlikely.
1:11:09 Speaker 00 I get that.
1:11:10 Speaker 01 I also, I think it's clear that not all the uses are going to be good. So I mean, so I'm not, I'm not trying to say that it's all good. But I think that it can largely be good.
1:11:19 Speaker 00 Let me hurry you up here. So, community is needed. Does that mean you don't want to run or do you want to be Oprah? Or what's, what is your goal?
1:11:25 Speaker 01 Oh, no, sorry. I didn't realize we were still on that.
1:11:26 Speaker 00 Yes, I'm still, you didn't answer it. Well done.
1:11:28 Speaker 01 No, no, look, I mean, we have a five-year goal of helping a billion people join communities that are meaningful like that.
1:11:35 Speaker 00 Okay.
1:11:35 Speaker 01 And if we, and if we do that, then I think that we will have played a role in reversing this many decades-long trend of people not being parts of communities.
1:11:46 Speaker 00 Right.
1:11:47 Speaker 01 I happen to think that we as a society do not spend enough time thinking about communities and the importance of them.
1:11:54 Speaker 00 Versus government.
1:11:55 Speaker 01 Versus what government, governments are extremely important. There are things that only governments can do. Safety net is extremely important.
1:11:59 Speaker 00 Right.
1:12:01 Speaker 01 But I mean, that's not me. I mean, I'm, that's not like the thing that I'm here to do. I can help build communities and connect people. I do think that that's an area where where I have unique insights and abilities that I can help people do. So that's what I care about. But I think that's really important.
1:12:18 Speaker 00 Two more quick questions before I know I have to go is, one is, who do you look up to? Do you look up to other internet people, Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos? Or is it just like an ultra male competition between and among you? Who is your mentor, would you say?
1:12:34 Speaker 01 Well, I think that there are a couple. Bill Gates has always been a mentor and inspiration for me, even before I knew him, just growing up. I admired how Microsoft was mission focused, right? It wasn't, it was a company that had a clear social goal, or that it wanted to put, they thought that computers were going to be valuable and having that become ubiquitous, it was kind of like an Apollo-like goal to me, that always struck me as really nice. And then, I think his second act of going and being one of the world's greatest philanthropists has absolutely influenced me, not only to try to follow in his footsteps and do something,
1:13:15 Speaker 01 hopefully one day that will be as impactful as what he has done, but his lesson there, that you have to start early to practice, right? Like anything that you want to get good at, you don't just show up one day and like can effectively and efficiently give money away. So the notion that if I want to be really good at this 10 or 15 years from now, then Priscilla and I really need to be starting to work on this now. So he has had, he and Melinda, and Melinda has increasingly really been a role model for us as well, just have really had a deeply influenced the way that I think about both work and philanthropy. But one of the things that I'd say that I'm really lucky is that
1:13:58 Speaker 01 A lot of the people who I look up to the most, I get to work with every day. And I think Cheryl is amazing, right? A lot of what I know about about business and building organizations and leadership come from working with her. A lot of the other folks who I get to work with every day, Chris Cox is just an amazing person, right? I always tell people that you should only hire people to be on your team if you would work for them. And it's not that I'm like looking to swap my role, but like, I think that-
1:14:27 Speaker 00 Well, you fired yourself earlier.
1:14:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, but in an alternate, yeah. But in an alternate universe, I would be honored to work for any of these people. And I think that that is, I don't know, that is a greater gift than having some external mentors who I get to talk to once a quarter.
1:14:44 Speaker 00 Right, right. Okay, my very last question, we didn't get to talk about products. What is your-
1:14:48 Speaker 01 We did, we talked about a little bit.
1:14:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, community, community.
1:14:50 Speaker 01 I got that in there.
1:14:51 Speaker 00 I know you did, but of the products, of the many products that, and we didn't get to talk about diversity, we didn't talk to tech addiction, there's all kinds of stuff we could talk about, but of the-
1:14:59 Speaker 01 You want to go longer?
1:14:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, sure, if you want, I'm good. Rachel says no. But very briefly, what do you think the most exciting product area is right now? Let's finish up on that.
1:15:09 Speaker 01 Well, I think the timeframe matters. I'm very excited about this social mission of helping a billion people-
1:15:16 Speaker 00 Join communities.
1:15:17 Speaker 01 Be a part of meaningful communities. I think that that is a very important social need. I think we're well set up to do it, and I'm very excited with the team that's doing that. Longer term, as a technologist, I mean, one of the things that just excites me is there are always different, there are always new computing platforms. And every 10 or 15 years, a new one comes along, and they're always more native, they capture your human experience more immersively, though you share more naturally what you're experiencing. And I just think that VR and AR are going to be a really big deal.
1:15:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:15:54 Speaker 01 You know, you can just see this trajectory. From early internet, when the technology and connections were slow, most of the internet was text. It's like, okay, text is great, but it's can be sometimes hard to capture what's going on. So then we all got phones with cameras on them and the internet got good enough to be primarily images. Now the networks are getting good enough that's primarily video. And at each step along the way, we're able to capture the human experience with greater fidelity and richness. And I think that that's great. So now I do think that we're going to move towards this world where eventually you'll be able to capture a whole experience that you're in and be able to send that to someone. And I think that that's just going to be an amazing technology for perspective-taking
1:16:38 Speaker 01 and putting yourself in other people's shoes, for being able to feel like you're really physically there with someone even when you're not. And one of the criticisms of technology today is you're sitting and looking at your phone and we could be sitting together.
1:16:51 Speaker 00 No, I agree with you on VR. I've just been doing some recent VR stuff that's really.
1:16:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I mean, it's not, there's a few technology leaps that still need to be made, but the initial use is amazing. And I just think that that's a really important technology.
1:17:05 Speaker 00 I'm not sure you can give people empathy, though. You can see people's, the world through people's eyes, but you can't understand their experience necessarily.
1:17:12 Speaker 01 Yes. Although I think there's also an economic, we've talked a lot about the social aspects of all of this, but I think one of the biggest issues economically today is that opportunity isn't evenly distributed. And so you get, all these people have to move to cities and then the cities get to be way too expensive. And if you have a technology like VR where you can be present anywhere, but live where you choose to, then I think that that can be really profound. I mean, it's, I mean, I look at. There are really only a few solutions to this. I mean, historically, cities have grown to be bigger by building better physical infrastructure. And there will be some amount to that.
1:17:57 Speaker 01 I mean, I think things like Hyperloops and things like that can extend the suburbs. I think could be quite interesting. But I have to believe that we're here in 2018. It's much cheaper and easier to move bits around than it is atoms. It strikes me that something like VR or AR or even video conferencing on the path to that has to be a more likely part of the solution than like just building a ton of of physical infrastructure. So it's not that we'll do both, but that ends up being just critically important. And we didn't touch on that so much today in this. But one of the areas that we're really focused on is economic empowerment. And one of the things that we're most proud of is that there are 80 million small businesses who use our tools.
1:18:39 Speaker 01 And when you poll them, the majority of them say that they're growing jobs, creating jobs and growing faster because of using our tools. And the vast majority of them aren't even paying, right? They're not. We have about 6 million advertisers and 80 million small businesses. So that's an area where that's really the foundation of the economy. And if we can help grow that, then that will also make communities stronger and will end up being just a really important part of how I think the country and the world holds together and moves forward over the next 10 or 15 or 20 years.
1:19:11 Speaker 00 All right, now you have one chance. What would you like to say to your giant nation state of Facebook right now? What is the one thing like?
1:19:17 Speaker 01 We've been talking for a while.
1:19:18 Speaker 00 I know, but what's the one thing they're getting wrong about you right now? I'm going to give you a nice out.
1:19:24 Speaker 01 You know, that's tough. It's always hard to say, what is the one thing? I don't know. I think that the main thing that I've tried to internalize this year is we get that there's a big responsibility and a lot of things that we need to do better than we are. And we are working on it. And I think a lot of them were doing better already. And for the rest, we're committed to getting to where we need to be for the community. And at the same time, we also feel a responsibility to keep on moving forward, on giving people tools to share their experience and connect and come together in new ways. Because ultimately, that's the unique thing
1:20:04 Speaker 01 that Facebook has put on this earth to do. And I think if we don't push forward on that, we will be missing our responsibility for advancing the ball there. So that's what I care about. And we're just very serious about making sure that we do both of those things.
1:20:20 Speaker 00 All right, Mark, I really appreciate you talking to a lot of things. We didn't get to everything, but I do appreciate it. And
1:20:25 Speaker 01 We'll save it. We'll do it again.
1:20:27 Speaker 00 We'll do it. Yeah, next time. Well, we got a lot of stuff. Thank you so much. And we will talk again soon. Thanks again to Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg for coming on the show. If you enjoyed this interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcasts for more. And if you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and tell other people about the show. That helps them discover great interviews just like this one. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other podcasts, Too Embarrassed to Ask and Recode Media with Peter Kafka. You can find those shows wherever you found this one. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. And thanks to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer
1:21:12 Speaker 00 Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Saturday. Tune in then.
1:21:20 Speaker 04 Hi, Recode Decode listeners. I want to tell you about a new podcast, The Arthur Brooks Show. That's me, Arthur Brooks. And I'm president of the American Enterprise Institute. I'm making a new podcast with Vox Media. Now, as president of AEI, that's a Washington think tank, I see bitter disagreement all the time. And it's terrible. We need some way to disagree, not less, but better. So this is a series that looks at the art of disagreement. The first episode is out July 12. Find it on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcasts. And most of all, subscribe right now.
Previous Recode Decode: How social media bots could tank your stock price Next Recode Decode: Alibaba exec Joe Tsai (Live at Code 2018) Page updated October 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated