Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Alibaba exec Joe Tsai (Live at Code 2018) About this episode Joe Tsai, the executive vice chairman of Chinese commerce giant Alibaba, talks with Recode’s Jason Del Rey at the 2018 Code Conference. He says that Alibaba has not tried to do a big acquisition deal in the U. S., but is definitely looking to create strategic partnerships. Specifically, Tsai wants to encourage American companies to tap into the Chinese market, where there are hundreds of millions of internet consumers as potential customers. He also disputes some criticism lobbed by fellow Code Conference speaker Sen. Mark Warner, who had alleged that Chinese tech firms were too cozy with the country's communist government.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Thanks to ZipRecruiter, which is the presenting sponsor of Recode Decode and the smartest way to hire. Running a business is full of tough calls. One of the biggest, hiring. Finding the right people to keep your business moving and growing isn't easy, but ZipRecruiter has found a way to streamline the process. Their powerful matching technology scans thousands of resumes to actively find people with the right experience and invites them to apply to your job. So if you're hiring, it's time to get smart. Try ZipRecruiter for free right now at ziprecruiter.com/decode. That's ziprecruiter.com/decode.
0:35 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play an interview from the 2018 Code Conference, which I co-produced with Recode's executive editor, Peter Kafka. This is an interview Jason Del Rey did with Alibaba executive vice chairman, Joe Tsai. Let's take a listen.
0:59 Speaker 01 Hey, everyone. I know we are the only people standing between you and what's going to be a great dinner, which I'll tease a little more in a bit, but I'm super excited about this last interview of the day. Alibaba is obviously one of the most powerful companies in the world, one of the most innovative, and I'm thrilled that we have one of the company's leaders here today, Joseph Tsai, who's the executive vice chairman and one of the company's co-founders. Joe, please join me on stage.
1:36 Speaker 01 So Joe thought that a good way to avoid hard questions today would be by wearing a Yale lacrosse shirt and making me ask him about it. So, okay, Joe, why are you wearing a Yale lacrosse shirt?
1:49 Speaker 02 Because Yale just won the national championship in lacrosse on Monday.
1:54 Speaker 01 Okay, okay, okay.
1:55 Speaker 02 And by the way, I was wearing this shirt on Saturday during the semifinals, so I haven't washed it yet.
2:00 Speaker 01 Oh. So, okay, we're getting spicy. I thought you were gonna say something with the Under Armour logo and...
2:08 Speaker 02 Oh, no, maybe I should cover it.
2:09 Speaker 01 Okay.
2:10 Speaker 02 Do we have any IT people in the company?
2:12 Speaker 01 So, we're gonna start with the really fun stuff, which is policy. Obviously, there's a ton in the news with this current administration and trade relations with China. On-again, off-again trade war, most recent announcement around 25% tariffs proposed on $50 billion worth of goods coming out of China. You know, there's still a lot that hasn't been decided. But you're watching this, and I'm sure you're thinking, or I'm thinking, how does this affect, potentially affect, your business globally? Can you give us a little insight into that?
2:47 Speaker 02 Well, I think we already got a little bit of a preview when Trump was on the campaign trail. He talked about being unpredictable. So, we're seeing a lot of this on-again, off-again unpredictability. You know, a week ago, they came out after the summit meeting to say that the trade war is on hold. But now, there's tariffs on $15 billion of goods. I think we are, in a way, we kind of predicted the unpredictability. There's always gonna be volatility, but what we're focused on is in the long term. And one thing that Alibaba's business here, what we're trying to do in the United States,
3:31 Speaker 02 is to get small businesses and farmers to see how big of a market there is in China. China, right now, has over 300 million middle-class consumers. And we're in the process of upgrading the economy, so that the economy is going from export-driven to consumption-driven. Your average consumer now cares about buying better food, healthier products, and things like that. So, they're looking to, outside of China, to bring in more imports. And that's a great, huge opportunity for the producers all around the world, including farmers, including small businesses in the United States. And that's what we're focused on.
4:13 Speaker 01 So that's been the company's messaging since your IPO in New York.
4:17 Speaker 02 So we've been consistent.
4:19 Speaker 01 Yes, you could call it that. And I'm wondering how much of that is a business decision versus a recognition of perhaps the challenge to do business in the US in a big way if you were to try to do it, whether it be big M&A activity in the US. And I should have pointed out earlier, you run M&A globally for Alibaba. And there's a lot of that which we'll get to. But how much of it is decision on, well, we might not be able to get the deals we want to get done in the US, so this is our strategy?
4:55 Speaker 02 Well, the thing is, four years ago, when we went public, there was no trade war. There's not even a threat of trade war. And we talked about helping small business, helping American companies to sell into China. So that's been very, very consistent. That's very much driven by business. If you look at our mission, to make it easy to do business anywhere, implied in that mission is we want to help small businesses. That's how Alibaba was founded. We were founded as a marketplace for small businesses, actually for Chinese companies to sell overseas. So that's pretty much, very much in our DNA, to help the small business.
5:36 Speaker 02 So the opportunity today is that there are a lot of consumers in China. We're basically a consumer-facing company, over 500 million active consumers on our platform buying things. But most of those consumers are inside China.
5:51 Speaker 01 Yep.
5:52 Speaker 02 So the trade flow...
5:53 Speaker 01 Is it 90% of revenue, or more than 90%?
5:55 Speaker 02 More than 90% of the revenue is coming from China. So the trade flow is going from the US. You know, if you're sitting in China, you're importing stuff into China from all over the world, including the United States. And that's always been our business model.
6:10 Speaker 01 So the, you know, on-again, off-again speculation that you see sometimes in the press of a big move by Alibaba in the US, M&A-wise, is we're not going to see that? Is that...
6:23 Speaker 02 Well, we have not tried to do a big M&A transaction in the United States. We're making investments. We're trying to partner with entrepreneurs here and invest in minority equity stakes in companies here. We're looking for innovative people. We're looking for people that are highly entrepreneurial. We're looking for people who are, who want our help in expanding their markets into China.
6:53 Speaker 01 Got it. So you're, you're looking for strategic fits versus simply an ROI situation?
6:57 Speaker 02 Absolutely. We never make, I mean, I'm responsible for M&A of our company and I just want to reiterate, we will never make a investment or acquisition purely for EPS or, you know, IRR, financial reasons. It's always with a very strong strategic lens that we look at these things.
7:18 Speaker 01 Okay. I know, one more related topic and I know you weren't here this morning when Senator Mark Warner was here, but he stands on the other side of the aisle from the Trump administration and he had some strong comments about a big Chinese internet companies Alibaba named, talked about them being deeply penetrated by the Communist Party in China. This is, I'm sure, not the first time you've heard comments like that from a US politician. What, what do you think when you hear that? And is there a nuance there the Senator is missing?
7:56 Speaker 02 Well, I'm sure in a lot of American companies, there are Republicans.
8:01 Speaker 02 There are employees who belong to the Republican Party, right? So China happens to have a single party system. That's a difference in the political system, but there's nothing, Communist Party per se is not a, it seems like a dirty word here, but in China, that's the form of government. What's happening right now is, you know, over the last 30 years, China has been a manufacturing country, but it's focused on, a lot of the manufacturing is low end. Apparel's, they're, we're assembling iPhones and making $20 per phone while Apple with all the IP and the technology makes $600 of profits on an iPhone, right?
8:44 Speaker 02 So there is a, there's a recognition by the government of China. That we need to upgrade our technology. We need to upgrade our manufacturing sector. Focus more on higher value add manufacturing. Things like robotics, aeronautics, high-tech medical equipment. And that's part of the China 2025 manufacturing plan. There's nothing wrong with a country wanting to upgrade its own manufacturing sector. Go higher tech, be more innovative. But then, from the Chinese perspective, what we're seeing is there are a lot of people in America that want to stop China from doing that. So that's that's kind of an unfathomable, you know, we're wondering why that's the case. And I think Senator Warner is in that camp.
9:27 Speaker 02 They want to hold China back. I still don't understand it. I tend, I would disagree with his characterization of Chinese companies.
9:37 Speaker 01 What is the bound, so one of the senior most leaders of the company. What is the balance you're striking between what's, you talked about what the Chinese government wants to see and what the balance you're striking between that, what the Chinese government wants to see and what's, you know, and what's good for Alibaba and Alibaba shareholders. My assumption is they don't always align.
10:01 Speaker 02 Well, I think we work for our customers. Jack Ma has always said, if you have to rank our constituencies by priority, you start with our customers first, employees second, and shareholders third. Okay, it's because if you're pushed, right, you have to choose among the three. You always want to serve your customers. Otherwise, you wouldn't have a business. And then you need to have the talent, the employee resources to be able to enable you to serve those customers. If those first two things work out, then the shareholders will be taken care of. So we would, we never think about of ourselves as only serving our shareholders.
10:46 Speaker 02 We have a lot of constituencies. Government is important because they regulate us. They create the environment. In which we operate, so we have to have good relationship with the government. And I think it's no different from a company in the United States where, you know, every company here has a government relations department or a regulatory department that deals with the day-to-day interaction with the government. Sometimes, regulation may not be totally consistent with making profits, but that's fine because there are constraints, there should be constraints on making profits if you're destroying social value.
11:26 Speaker 02 So, I think, you know, I don't see China being anything, anywhere different from the United States.
11:34 Speaker 01 Okay, we're gonna shift gears for a second. I've been, in the US, in retail, one of the biggest news items of the last year was Amazon's acquisition of Whole Foods. The idea of a digital-first company buying a big physical retailer is a very new idea here. Alibaba's been at this in their own way for several years now. Why don't you just quickly walk through, what is the innovation you think you all have created with the convergence of digital and offline? I know you have grocery stores, call it Huma, and, which are part offline, part digital.
12:16 Speaker 01 Can you just quickly lay out what you're seeing there that we're not seeing here in the US?
12:22 Speaker 02 Sure. I think what's different is the consumer. The consumer is very, very mobile in China. We have more than 80% of our transactions that's being done on a mobile phone, okay? So when you have a mobile device, the distinction between online and offline is kind of blurred because you could, you could set a home and order something online and have it delivered to you on a mobile device, or you can carry your phone and walk into a store and use that phone as a device to learn more about the product and also pay for the item. So that's really the insight we have when we talk about new retail. The whole consumer experience has been transformed because of the mobile phone.
13:02 Speaker 02 And we want the same customer to be able to, you know, walk into a store, buy something, take it away, and then the next week, they're on the phone, they're sitting at home or their office, and they don't want to go into the store, but then they can order and have something delivered to them. And one of the most important things about having store-based operation for an e-commerce company is that those store locations are also fulfillment spots. I mean, it's not a secret to, you know, say that if the inventory is closer to the consumer, the logistics, the delivery is faster. So it's very, very important, I think, in that, you know, you take, think about the Amazon scenario. There's over 400 stores, Whole Foods stores.
13:46 Speaker 02 If people are ordering groceries online, if they could fulfill and deliver from those Whole Foods stores, that's a much faster proposition. In our case, in the HeMa case, we can deliver items within 30 minutes. In fact, that's our core value proposition. That's our promise to the consumer.
14:04 Speaker 01 And this is someone, this is someone not coming into the store and having delivered from there?
14:07 Speaker 02 Correct.
14:08 Speaker 01 Or coming into the store and then having, picking out and having delivered to them?
14:11 Speaker 02 It's not coming to the store.
14:13 Speaker 01 Yep.
14:14 Speaker 02 Just simply, you're sitting at home, or you're in your office, and you could, you could schedule it and say, "I want this item to be delivered to my home because I'm cooking dinner at 6 o'clock, but right now, I'm in my office." So there's, there's a lot of flexibility, and we want to give the consumers a total experience, whether they're online or in-store.
14:33 Speaker 01 And the economics on a business like that, you know, delivery in the US, you know, for a lot of companies is very challenging. I think even, I think even Amazon and their Prime Now, you know, one hour, two hour, they won't talk about the numbers, but I think, you know, it's clear it's a challenge, challenging to make those numbers stand up right. Are these delivery businesses profitable already? How do the economics work out?
14:57 Speaker 02 Yeah. Our, we are profitable. Our grocery stores, if you combine the online and offline P and L, they're profitable. So including the delivery, it's, it could be run on a profitable basis. The reason it's profitable is, number one, they have scale, and with scale, you can actually map out delivery routes in a much more efficient way. If you, if the store only gets, you know, 15 orders a day, then they're, each trip is, and if you only deliver to one customer on each trip, that's pretty costly. But if the store gets like 1,500 or... 5,000 orders a day online.
15:41 Speaker 02 Then there's a lot of room to map out your delivery routes. So the same guy that's making the delivery is serving five to 10 customers. And that's where technology and the data about mapping out the routes makes a lot of sense. So we can make that a much more efficient operation than a one-off type delivery situation.
16:06 Speaker 01 How tempting is it to, if you feel you're ahead in a space, and this is just one example, how tempting is it to license that technology or export that excellence in a certain category, whether it's another mature market like the US or an emerging market?
16:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. I think the model has to be, you have your own operated stores, but then you take the standard operating procedure and the technology and you license it to other people. But the key thing is the licensee, whoever licenses your technology, is willing to make the change. And not just say, "Oh, now I've got this great technology, then everything will work out." Changes like, for example, organizational structure. How do you manage an online presence with an app? Who runs the app and who runs the store? Every store has a store manager. And you have to make sure that the people that are running your online operation
17:08 Speaker 02 and your offline business, their interests are perfectly aligned. And most retailers are not organized that way.
17:15 Speaker 01 Most retailers here in the US?
17:18 Speaker 02 Most retailers in the US or in China are not organized that way. And there has to be a lot of willingness and true resolve and commitment to making those changes to make it work.
17:31 Speaker 01 So that's a no on bringing some of this to the US? Or have you not even entertained those conversations?
17:38 Speaker 02 No, we have not entertained those conversations. I think the US market, when you're serving US consumers, is a very different market from China.
17:46 Speaker 01 Let's talk for a bit about your global M&A strategy. We've talked about the US and I can harp on it for another hour, but that would be a little boring. So, how do you think about where you're going to buy? Where you're going to invest? And the types of businesses, whether they're consumer-facing or other? How do you weigh this out for us?
18:09 Speaker 02 There's sort of two areas, two things that we think about. Number one, what we are good at, can we be helpful in a new market? So we're good at developing emerging markets. Our experience in China over the last 19 years, you know, growing an e-commerce marketplace from basically zero to something that's really large. What does that experience tell us about helping a company in Indonesia or India for that matter? That's one area. The other is to look at the demographics. Whether the country has a young population, how mobile is the population?
18:50 Speaker 02 You know, when you look at most of the Southeast Asian countries, they're basically leapfrogging. Nobody uses computers. Everybody's accessing the internet on a mobile phone. So you look at all those things and also...
19:03 Speaker 01 And that's attractive?
19:04 Speaker 02 Those are attractive, absolutely. Young population, mobile population. And also another thing that people kind of overlook is whether the country has a strong manufacturing base. Alibaba has been successful in China. Well, there are a lot of consumers, but the flip side of the coin is that... The merchants can easily find sources of product that they can buy, they could source, and because China is a large manufacturing base. So in countries where they don't produce a lot of things themselves, you have to import, that's a different kind of organization of your merchant base, you know, because you have to provide the sourcing opportunities for them.
19:46 Speaker 02 So those are some of the factors that we look at when we grow into a new market.
19:51 Speaker 01 Let's talk about India for a second. One, I'm fascinated by it. Two, there's been a lot of activity there very recently. So Amazon set up shop in India back in 2013. In the past few months, probably in the past month, Walmart has announced their intent to buy a majority stake in the number one or the number two player there, homegrown player Flipkart. You also have investments in payments company Paytm, grocery delivery company there, Big Basket, and also you also invested in Snapdeal, which was an e-commerce site, a distant third. For Amazon, that is, they failed in China. They're still in China, but they will say they missed it. So this is the market they say they cannot miss.
20:35 Speaker 01 What is your strategy in India?
20:38 Speaker 02 Well, if you look at India, it's very, very early. We're in the first inning, right? Total industry GMV for e-commerce this year is going to be less than 20 billion US dollars. China is close to 1 trillion today. So, you know, very, very early days. We want to take a very patient approach. In fact, Amazon is doing a very good job educating consumers of the benefits of buying online and good service. They provide a very good service in India. Our strategy is to look at high-frequency use cases. So online payment.
21:23 Speaker 02 Today, Paytm, you know, we have an investment in Paytm, which is the largest mobile payment company in India. The app is no longer just a payment tool.
21:36 Speaker 02 It's your portal, you know, to access other services that require payment, like buying movie tickets, buying train tickets, buying gold fund for investments. India gold is a very important asset to own. And so with all these use cases, you're creating engagement. You're creating high-level engagement. That's why we're involved in a grocery company, because grocery is almost daily. It's something that, you know, highly engaging. So we want to enter through high-frequency use cases and build an e-commerce business on top of that. I think some of the other e-commerce players go into the market and they focus on electronics.
22:20 Speaker 02 Lots of GMV, lots of volume today is selling, you know, Samsung phones and Huawei phones and a little bit of Apple, a lot of Xiaomi phones. But how often do you buy a phone? I mean, it's going to be once every six months or 12 months.
22:38 Speaker 01 Come on, I'm a journalist. Once every two years, maybe.
22:42 Speaker 01 Six months for you, two years for me.
22:44 Speaker 02 Anyway, it's not every day.
22:47 Speaker 01 We're going to open up to questions in just a bit. Hopefully, we have some good ones. We haven't touched... I'll acknowledge you guys have big cloud business, big media business that we have not even gotten to. So if you have any questions there, that'd be appreciated. One last question, US-related. Private company in the US called Wish, valued at $8 billion on paper. They're competitive with one of your products, which is AliExpress, selling globally to consumers outside of China.
23:20 Speaker 01 You know, knowing a little bit about where AliExpress is strong globally and where Wish is strong, seems like there's complementary... There could be a complementary match there. Do you follow that business, Wish, closely? And is it, you know, something you think could make sense in the future as part of the Alibaba umbrella?
23:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, of course I follow that business. And every time I watch a Lakers game, they sponsor the jersey, Wish. And so I'm like, it must be making a lot of profits.
23:53 Speaker 01 Worth the $40 million right there. They got Joe's attention, yeah.
23:58 Speaker 02 And, uh, no, I, look, first of all, I think they're in a similar business as ours, sort of this cross-border consumer business. We're very positive about that business. And because having one foot in China, serving global consumers, you know, for Alibaba is an advantage because we're close to the merchants, we're close to the factories, we're close to the sellers. I think this business is bound to have competition because other people can see opportunities. And our view of competition is that makes us better. We have to keep asking ourselves, are we serving consumers better? Are we, are we falling behind? And it's just like in sports, you have to play against good teams
24:42 Speaker 02 in order to get better. So we welcome that competition and, you know, we follow the company and hope to, you know, have a chance to talk to them at some point. But at this point, we're not doing anything to, you know, we're not having any conversations.
25:00 Speaker 01 Okay.
25:03 Speaker 01 Is that a question there?
25:04 Speaker 03 It is.
25:05 Speaker 01 Okay, just tell us who you are.
25:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, John Ford from CNBC. I want to ask you about 5G. And if you will, give us a couple of scenarios. People expect the US and China to lead in 5G. The next couple of years will be key. What are a couple of ways you expect for 5G to be an accelerant to Alibaba's cloud business and an accelerant to the commerce business, both in-person and maybe off-site, at home, on the phone? What are the ways that that low-latency network is going to, I guess, allow you to pull ahead? You said you expect to pull ahead of Amazon in the next couple of years.
25:43 Speaker 02 Yeah. We're looking at 5G, the proliferation of 5G, as a catalyst for an Internet of Things strategy.
25:54 Speaker 02 With the ability of devices at the edge to
26:01 Speaker 02 you know, to run data and have computing that's done locally. That's gonna, you know, slightly be different. It'll be different from a cloud business. But that's something that's very exciting from our standpoint. And you can, you can think of scenarios where a lot of compute can happen locally and consumers will benefit from that. So that's gonna be a very important catalyst for, you know, e-commerce business or gaming business or a lot of other types of businesses. And, and these devices will proliferate.
26:38 Speaker 03 But how so? How are people gonna be buying more in the store or buying more at home because there's a 5G network? What kind of scenarios are you gaming out?
26:46 Speaker 02 I think, you know, you could be buying not just from your cellphone. You can buy from your refrigerator, you know. If you run out of milk and you push a button on your refrigerator and, and, you know, the smart refrigerator makes the order. So there could be a lot of scenarios where different devices are. The, the device is gonna get smarter. The device is not your phone, but it's gonna be something else.
27:14 Speaker 01 Not an Amazon Echo?
27:17 Speaker 02 Oh, maybe an Amazon Echo, maybe. By the way, our Tmall Genie, which is a similar product, is, is the best-selling, you know, personal assistant in China today.
27:29 Speaker 01 That's a good, good comeback. Here we go.
27:34 Speaker 03 Tell us who you are, please.
27:35 Speaker 04 Chithu Patel from Box. You know, if you think about a lot of Chinese companies that are getting to scale, one of the big reasons why there's a lot of successes, you folks seem to intrinsically understand scale at a very different level than what some of the American companies have been advantaged in doing. What would you give as advice to people over here on principles around understanding scale that we don't have the benefit of just being able to experiment with because we don't have a billion people in an addressable market over here that you have the advantage of doing? What, what, what lessons would you teach us? From a scale perspective?
28:11 Speaker 02 Well, first, I think you have to make sure that your technology, systems, and also people can scale. I think we're kind of spoiled in a China market with 800 million Internet users. And everything that you do, you're assuming that it's going to be tens of millions or hundreds of millions of people that is going to be using your product. I think for a company that's in this market, first of all, there's plenty of scale in this market as well.
28:53 Speaker 02 You know, I think a lot of companies in the United States are also looking at overseas markets, including China. So my advice is, don't listen to politicians that criticize China. Look at the Chinese market as an opportunity. And there are a lot of partners, potential partners, companies, ourselves included, could be your partners to explore the China market together.
29:21 Speaker 01 One last quick one. Just tell us who you are, please.
29:24 Speaker 05 Hi, Joe. This is Hans from GB. Hi. As an investor in Alibaba, then also wish Xiaomi, Xiaohongshu, some of our companies compete against you, some of our companies collaborate with you. So I get a lot of question in the US, like, is Alibaba good for the startup system in China? Since Alibaba is so strong, it's everywhere, and it's investing in all these companies. And then, secondly, if Alibaba is so strong in China, does that encourage startups in China to expand beyond China and go for the rest of the world? What do you see and how do you answer when people ask you what's Alibaba's impact on the startup system in China?
30:00 Speaker 02 I think Alibaba is good for innovation and good for entrepreneurs because the space that we're in, e-commerce.
30:09 Speaker 02 Is a pretty good business. So there's always new competition. Five years ago, there's there's company A, now there's company B. We, you know, you're investing in a lot of them. So I think there's always going to be entrepreneurs that see the opportunity and say Alibaba is doing it this way, but we can find a different way of doing things and beat Alibaba at their own game. I think there's plenty of people today that think that way. And I think that's healthy. It makes us better. It keeps us on our toes.
30:46 Speaker 01 All right. I think that's all the time we have, Joe. Thank you so much.
30:50 Speaker 02 Thank you.
30:52 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to this interview from the Code Conference 2018. We'll be releasing all of the interviews from this year's event in this podcast feed and on Peter Kafka's show, Recode Media. If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe to Recode Media with Peter Kafka to hear interviews with people like 21st Century Fox CEO James Murdoch, Spotify CEO Daniel Ek, and Facebook COO and CTO Sheryl Sandberg and Mike Schrepper. If you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and tell other people about the show. And don't miss my other podcast, Too Embarrassed to Ask. You can find that show and Recode Media wherever you listen to Recode Decode. Thanks for listening to this special episode of Recode Decode, and thanks to our editor Joel Roby and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg Next Recode Decode: 'Valley of Genius' author Adam Fisher Page updated October 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated