Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: How social media bots could tank your stock price About this episode Zignal Labs CEO Josh Ginsberg talks with Recode’s Kara Swisher about the “massive amounts of bot activity” that his media intelligence company has started detecting on social media. In everything from political elections to the debates over Roseanne Barr and Samantha Bee’s controversial statements, bots are insinuating themselves into the discourse, and provoking humans into being more outraged. Sometimes the goal is just to sow discord, Ginsberg says, but other times there are clear financial incentives to targeting certain companies. He talks about what businesses and regular people can do to better gird themselves against these bot attacks and predicts how a technology called “deepfakes” could make the problem worse.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Thanks to ZipRecruiter, which is the presenting sponsor of Recode Decode and the smartest way to hire. If you run a tech company, you're busy. Dev sprints, investor pitches, meetings, cold pizza for dinner. So when you're hiring, you want to spend your time on viewing candidates who have all the skills you need. That's where ZipRecruiter can help. Their matching technology scans thousands of resumes to actively find people with the right experience and invites them to apply to your job so you get qualified candidates fast. If you're hiring, it's time to get smart. Try ZipRecruiter for free right now at ziprecruiter.com/decode. That's ziprecruiter.com/decode.
0:40 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as the lifelike robot that replaced the real Kara Swisher three years ago. Oops, I shouldn't have said that. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Josh Ginsberg, the CEO and co-founder of Zignel Labs. It's a media intelligence company that helps its consumers see what people are saying and what stories are emerging from across the internet. He previously worked in politics and public affairs, directing campaigns for Arnold Schwarzenegger and Mitt Romney, and working on the Strategy Department of the Republican National Committee. Josh, welcome to Recode Decode. There's so much to talk about.
1:16 Speaker 01 Thank you so much for having me.
1:17 Speaker 00 Okay, we also have some information about some new products you're doing. Now, let's go over your background a little bit. I like people to know how people got you. You're just a political guy, right? You're just a...
1:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, I have a little bit of a...
1:27 Speaker 00 In the old Republican Party.
1:28 Speaker 01 Exactly, the old Republican Party. I have a little bit of probably a non-traditional background to becoming a CEO of a technology company. So yeah, my background is in politics and public affairs. I've served on three presidential campaigns. My first one was in 2000, on the 2000 Bush campaign. I actually started as an intern, and it was a summer job, which was great, down in Austin, Texas. And it was in the Strategy Department, which was fascinating for me because one of the biggest things that we were doing was seeing how can we get then-Governor Bush's message out there, which we'll talk about how this is relevant to what we're doing now.
2:11 Speaker 01 And it was such a great experience, I actually managed to convince my high school to let me take my first semester of senior year off to stay down in Austin, Texas to work on the campaign. And then, I guess you could say I was bitten by the political bug from there.
2:26 Speaker 00 And so you did those campaigns and they were sort of traditional. What did you, the things you did, just your basic?
2:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, at that point, it was really, I mean, by the way, we had georgewbusch.com and we actually put it on our signs.
2:38 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
2:39 Speaker 01 And the fact that we put the website out there was like a really big deal.
2:43 Speaker 00 At the time, yeah.
2:44 Speaker 01 So if you think about it from just how media has evolved in just, you know, less than 20 years, that's really significant. And I'd say that's a pretty big theme that I kind of saw throughout my career in each step. You know, after working on the 2000 Bush campaign, you know, I worked on the 2004 Bush campaign and eventually made my way up here to California to be Governor Schwarzenegger's political director. Which was sort of another great lesson in terms of how to use the media. He's probably one of the best communicators I've ever seen.
3:18 Speaker 00 Sure.
3:18 Speaker 01 And so, kind of consistently throughout my career, that's always been a really important part of what we were trying to do. How do you get your message out? How does it move throughout that media spectrum and eventually reach the public?
3:32 Speaker 00 Right. And how it gets there, like one message gets iterated and how it gets iterated. And there used to be traditional methods of doing that. And then you worked for Mitt Romney.
3:39 Speaker 01 Then I worked for Mitt Romney. I was his national field director in 2008, so the one that he didn't quite win.
3:45 Speaker 00 No, didn't quite.
3:46 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:46 Speaker 00 Quite at all. But, you know, he was actually, it was the first place where you did see memes happening. Remember binders full of women and all kinds of things?
3:53 Speaker 01 Oh, totally. It was actually really interesting. I was talking to someone about this the other day. We were at a point in that campaign where we were still having arguments of, hey, what's a better platform for us to get our message out? Is it MySpace or is it Facebook? So, just to give you a sense, I mean, that was a decade ago and, you know, now...
4:08 Speaker 00 Sure. It was MySpace, as it turns out.
4:10 Speaker 01 Yeah. Turns out, we bet on Facebook, so that was, that was smart.
4:14 Speaker 00 But also, I remember, there were a couple of different points when he had that recording, when he talked about people, like, it was, there was a couple of times where he really got bitten by internet kind of memes and viral, viralities.
4:25 Speaker 01 There is, there is.
4:26 Speaker 00 And Obama benefited from it. On the flip side, I don't think there was an error by the Obama people at all in that.
4:32 Speaker 01 No, look, they did a great job using sort of that media landscape to their advantage. And if you think about sort of how things have evolved, I mean, the difference between 08 and 2012 was huge, too. I mean, thankfully, I was out of politics by that point. But that's something that really consistently occurred.
4:52 Speaker 00 Right. And that was the Palin-McCain.
4:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was Palin-McCain.
4:57 Speaker 00 Right, which who was an internet phenomenon then was not.
5:00 Speaker 01 Yes.
5:00 Speaker 00 Same thing. Like, it sort of went back to bit with that SNL clip that went around, and it had a lot of impact, from what I could tell on the campaign.
5:07 Speaker 01 Huge amount of impact. And if you think about it, there was new ways of getting out your message at that point. I mean, how do you use the internet to your advantage? How do you make sure that that coalesces in the right way with more traditional types of media, like newspapers? I mean, that's when you really started that landscape starting to shift even more.
5:25 Speaker 00 Even more. And we're going to talk about that more. So you went off and did this company. You got sick of politics?
5:29 Speaker 01 I got it.
5:30 Speaker 00 Politicians.
5:31 Speaker 01 That's the nice way of saying it. Yeah, I mean, after politics, I went into public affairs. So I worked at a large public affairs firm that was owned by one of the massive holding companies. I started two public affairs firms of my own, where our clients ranged from the boutique nonprofit to the Fortune 10 company, and really, everything in between. And the bottom line, and I think where our company, Signal Labs, really comes into play, is every single time, and every single step along the way, we faced the exact same issue. Now, the landscape looked different, but the issue was the same, which is, how can I hear what is being said about myself out there, but most importantly, take action on those things?
6:09 Speaker 00 Right.
6:10 Speaker 01 So when we were doing everything, you know, quote unquote, "the right way", in order to hear what was being said about us, is we'd have 10, 20-year-olds in a back room, constantly doing Google News searches, with a wall of TVs in front of them, and later on, with TweetDeck. And every eight minutes or so, I'd get a new email saying, "Hey, here's a new story that mentions your CEO, or your company, or your candidate."
6:32 Speaker 00 Right.
6:33 Speaker 01 And my question was always the same, which is, I mean, hey, that's great, but is it moving? Is it trending? Is it positive? Is it negative? Most importantly, what type of action should I take?
6:41 Speaker 00 Right. Just not, just because it's there. First, it'd be, it's just, it's on there.
6:44 Speaker 01 Right. Exactly.
6:46 Speaker 01 And so when we started Signal Labs, and I had two great founders.
6:49 Speaker 00 Did you have to use the word labs? That seems.
6:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, it was a very Silicon Valley story.
6:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, lab.
6:54 Speaker 01 It was either that or, you know, taking out a vowel.
6:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
6:58 Speaker 01 We liked our vowels.
6:58 Speaker 00 All right, okay. Signal.
7:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:00 Speaker 00 That would have driven me crazy.
7:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, us too.
7:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, but you did use the Z.
7:04 Speaker 01 Although we might own the URL. I don't know.
7:06 Speaker 00 All right, okay, all right. So you created this to make it more able for people to use in a dashboard format?
7:12 Speaker 01 Exactly. So, and we really targeted three things that we said we have to get really good at in this new type of media environment. In order to help people make better decisions and execute on those actions. And the first one was we said, okay, look, we have to look across the entire media spectrum. So we have to bring everything from social media, traditional media, and television. And one of the things that always fascinated me and was really important for us as a company is to be able to see how stories traveled. So, for example, a couple of years ago, we did a study where we found one of the most powerful news cycles, where stories that started in social media, bounced up into local television, bounced up into national newspapers, and bounced up into national television.
7:55 Speaker 00 Right.
7:55 Speaker 01 And by the time it gets to national television, I mean, that story's baked. There's not a lot you can do about it.
7:59 Speaker 00 Right.
7:59 Speaker 01 So that's a really important element. Now, that's changed, just in the past couple of years, and we'll talk about that.
8:04 Speaker 00 Right.
8:05 Speaker 01 The second thing is we said, okay, look, we gotta see all of this happening in real time, because everything's moving that fast. We have to build an infrastructure for our platform where we can feed all of those data streams down a real-time processing pipeline to analyze it in all of the relevant ways. And the third thing, we said, all right, then we're talking about millions of data points coming in really fast. We gotta really nail how this is visualized. So in a split second, even if there are millions of data points, the end user can say, okay, this is what's important and this is what's not. So we went and we hired a guy from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory who was doing data visualization for the Mars rover lander. And his job was taking data off of Mars and visualizing it for NASA.
8:46 Speaker 00 Sure.
8:46 Speaker 01 And we said, all right, let's take that same concept and now do that for media data points. So that was our approach.
8:52 Speaker 00 The rocket guy.
8:53 Speaker 01 So we had to get a rocket scientist.
8:54 Speaker 00 So what you have is like all kinds of points of information and data to make a cogent argument about whatever is happening, or a cogent
9:01 Speaker 01 Exactly.
9:01 Speaker 00 Snapshot of what's happening. But there's lots of dashboards. Everyone has it. We have a social media dashboard. We have this, this is working, this is not working, this headline's working, this is not. But this is more sentiment and everything else, correct?
9:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's everything. I mean, there are dozens of ways of slicing and dicing. There's probably hundreds now. And so you can really see what does the environment look like and how do you take action on that? So we work a lot with large corporations, large enterprises, to be able to see that. We actually started off in politics and then sort of transitioned.
9:32 Speaker 00 Which has a twitchy effect, but everything's twitchy now, right?
9:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would say that is the world that we live in now.
9:38 Speaker 00 That is the world we live in. So you do this for corporations and it's just media and like this is what's trending, but it's not more than that. It's like this is what's trending. This is the impact of this, this is who's doing it, this is where it's coming from, this is the sentiment about whether it's negative, positive, or neutral.
9:54 Speaker 01 Exactly. So it's what's accelerating, but then it's also, okay, well, are my key messages getting across?
10:00 Speaker 00 Right.
10:01 Speaker 01 What's my brand health?
10:02 Speaker 00 Right.
10:02 Speaker 01 How's my CEO being perceived? Or are those messages resonating? Who are the best people to go out there and be influencers? Who are the other influencers I need to be aware of?
10:11 Speaker 00 Right.
10:12 Speaker 01 So it's pretty, it's actually very broad in terms of all the different types of use cases you can have, and those get customized for those corporations.
10:18 Speaker 00 For those corporations, what they're supposed to do with it, because they're aware of these things but haven't been paying attention as much as they should have.
10:25 Speaker 01 I would say one thing that I learned in my political days is if you can't measure it, it's almost impossible to manage it. And so if you take that same concept for media news cycles and corporate communications and marketing teams, it's the same thing.
10:39 Speaker 00 Right.
10:40 Speaker 01 What's really interesting is it's actually expanded beyond communications teams and marketing teams. And now it's much more part of the C-suite, the executive teams as well.
10:48 Speaker 00 Right, that they have to because it affects employees, it affects the stock market, it affects investors, it affects everything.
10:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, we were at a, I was at a large company back in New York a few weeks ago, and the communications person brought to this meeting the chief risk officer, the general counsel, the person from marketing. If you think about it, a few years ago, if the head of comms went to, you know, someone from risk, "Hey, come to this meeting," they'd say, "What are you doing? Go write me a press release." But now it's so vital to a company to have those elements.
11:20 Speaker 00 And so that's what we're going to talk about, this new product that you have that is about, because it's not just managing your corp, because there's like lots of different negative news articles, or something happens that's bad for a company, or a bad quarter, and they manage that. They try to get the best messages out and stuff like that. But you've started to look into the area where misinformation, not misinformation.
11:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a dis.
11:40 Speaker 00 A dis, not a miss. They're not just saying something stupid. Talk about this new product that you're doing, because I think that's one thing, people have to have those capabilities going forward, no matter what, the first ones you talked about.
11:53 Speaker 01 For sure. I mean, that's sort of table stakes nowadays. And one thing that we saw, so in the beginning of this year, we started seeing some really interesting anomalies in our data. And by anomalies, I mean spikes in volume that didn't necessarily make sense, or influencers. And we said, "Okay, why is that person considered an influencer?"
12:13 Speaker 00 Right, right.
12:14 Speaker 01 And we gave this data to our data science team, and they came back and they said, "Look, these are actually synthetic mentions. These are artificial. These are not real people." And so we sort of took a step back, and we said, "Okay, well, what's going on here?" And what we saw was there was massive amounts of bot activity that were impacting corporate brands, corporate reputations, that had an impact on market cap, all of these other things. And when we dug in even deeper, we saw these were all coordinated. And to give you a sense of the magnitude, we literally have not found a company in the past six months that have not gotten hit with a major bot attack. So those same forces-
12:51 Speaker 00 This is separate, let's make this clear, people have been concerned with hack attacks, data attacks, all kinds of things like that, this is different, explain what that is.
12:58 Speaker 01 This is for sure different, although in some ways related, because they're coming from similar types of nefarious actors out there. But what this is, are people are spinning up fake accounts or fake sites, and they're using that to amplify false news stories or negative news stories about a corporation. And they're using that in order to really impact the bottom line of the company, the company's corporate reputation. So we found those same forces that were impacting our politics, that's been pretty well-publicized. It's now happening in the corporate world in a really major way, and time and time again, as we go to companies, they say, "Well, I guess this actually makes a lot of sense." We had no idea it's happening.
13:43 Speaker 01 It's something that everyone really needs to be made aware of right now.
13:45 Speaker 00 All right, and so explain what happens, give me the scenario, and then in the next section, we'll talk about what that may, and we'll talk more deep about it, but very briefly, what does that mean, that something happens?
13:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, so let me give you an example from just one of our customers here. We had a customer who, a false news story, this was a couple of months ago, was put out about them, that a bunch of their customers were leaving and going to a competitor. What we saw was a bot network spin up, so a bunch of fake accounts. They spun it up and they started amplifying it, until that story started trending. So it was a false news story from a random blog, got it to start trending, the mainstream media then saw it, they wrote traditional news articles on it, blogs, things like that. Then Wall Street saw it, Wall Street said, "Okay, something's going on here," and they actually saw their market cap drop several billion dollars.
14:38 Speaker 00 So there's an opportunity to make money.
14:39 Speaker 01 So there's an opportunity. So we're seeing situations like that happen, time and time again now.
14:45 Speaker 00 So this was a fake news story that was started and then amplified. So a bot network works in that they start attacking it, and then others start to attack it?
14:53 Speaker 01 And then others start to attack it as well.
14:54 Speaker 00 Right. So but the original bots are attacking and then they have support bots, right? Is that correct?
14:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, so a lot of times, and it depends on the type of bot attack. And if you sort of look at the motives, that's always kind of a good place to start. So sometimes it's about corporate reputation. Okay, how can you hit that that corporation's reputation that can impact all the things we've been talking about? The other one is more around cultural weaponization. Okay, how can you take very specific points in our culture? So, you know, for example, when Roseanne made that terrible tweet.
15:25 Speaker 00 Right, about Valerie Jarrett.
15:27 Speaker 01 Yeah. More than 60% of that conversation was being amplified by bots.
15:32 Speaker 00 So it seemed noisier than it was.
15:34 Speaker 01 It seemed noisier than it was. It spun people up. The goal of a lot of these bot networks is not for it to just be bots. It is to bring humans into the conversation, too, so they can start to see that. It's to sow discord within the media landscape. Then you also see examples like the stock price issues that we talked about. And then you see it in our politics, too. So, once you start looking at those sort of four motives, it starts to make sense what these malicious actors are doing.
16:05 Speaker 00 Okay. All right, when we get back, we're talking with Josh Ginsberg. He has a company called Signal Labs. It is a media intelligence company, but it's started to look at the impact that bots have on corporations. Obviously, bots have had an impact on politics and our culture, and we'll be talking about that and more when we get back.
17:03 Speaker 00 And get 90% off when you sign up for classes. You will not find a better price. So sign up for classes now using my link, u d e dot my slash decode and get access to life changing classes for 90% off. And make sure you download their app for your phone so you can stream your studies wherever you are. That's u d e dot my slash decode. That's u d e dot my slash decode.
17:31 Speaker 00 We're here with Josh Ginsberg. He is the CEO and co-founder of Zignal Labs. It's here in San Francisco. He does media intelligence, which helps companies see how they're being perceived on social media. A lot of people do that. A lot of companies do that. But you're focused now more on nefarious players. It's obviously a growing problem in politics. The Russians obviously use the tools of social networks really well. And in fact, didn't, people always think they hacked them. They didn't hack them. They use them properly. And now these bot networks are doing that. Now, we talk a lot about bots and in politics and the ability to swarm and to create a lot of faux outrage and to create news that doesn't exist and things like that. But it's moved into the corporate space. Do you think companies have a sense of this? Like that, that they are being attacked?
18:15 Speaker 01 For the most part, no. I mean, I think that, because it's really impossible to see if you don't have technology to see it. It just looks like natural conversations. And so time and time again, when we go to companies and we show them this data and these analytics, they're pretty surprised. And once they have that awareness, it really starts to make sense. But if not, you're responding to things and you're using resources on, on elements in the media that just really are not that important. And so it can have a real impact on a company.
18:46 Speaker 00 That you get reactive, that you get instantly reactive or you do something or you make decisions and stuff like that. Let's talk first about the two cultural ones, Roseanne Barr and Samantha Bee.
18:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:56 Speaker 00 So those are two opposite sides. Same thing, same week, same thing. So explain what happened in each of those cases.
19:02 Speaker 01 So in the first instance, you had Roseanne Barr. And Roseanne put out a terrible tweet about Valerie Jarrett. And what you saw almost instantly were bot networks wake up. And they started amplifying what Roseanne said. And what's interesting was it was kind of on both sides of the issue. So there was one bot network or one side of the bot networks that were saying, this is terrible of Roseanne, you know, et cetera, et cetera. There was another side that was saying, hey, you're being too hard on Roseanne. You know, the liberals are getting too upset. So you have both these things. And what ended up happening was real people would then join the conversation because they were outraged.
19:45 Speaker 00 On either side.
19:46 Speaker 01 On either side. So really, the goal there was to sow discord within Western culture.
19:52 Speaker 00 And who was that? Who are those bots?
19:54 Speaker 01 Well, so sometimes we were able to track those back. It depends on how sophisticated the bot network is. In some cases, you can't. It's more difficult.
20:03 Speaker 00 So they wake up? Who wakes them up?
20:05 Speaker 01 Usually, there's some sort of nefarious actor who's controlling these networks behind the scenes. Sometimes, it's a group. You know, in politics, you hear about this, a bunch up on the Hill, that they're looking into various agencies overseas that do this. So it's coming from a lot of different angles. And again, some of this is economically motivated, some of this is culturally motivated.
20:27 Speaker 00 Right. And so the attacks on Roseanne, and then Samantha Bee, when she said the terrible thing about Ivanka Trump, which is also tasteless, not nearly, not the same level of...
20:36 Speaker 01 Both not advisable.
20:37 Speaker 00 Not advisable, but not as bad as what Roseanne did. But the reason for that, then, is that humans were justifiably upset on both sides of that. But it creates a ginning up effect.
20:49 Speaker 01 It's a ginning up effect. It kind of, it forms this poisonous environment within our public sphere. And if you think about it, these people who are doing this are not necessarily looking at it in that moment. They're playing the long game. Okay, how can we poison this? How can we make it cloudy, these issues murky? So when they do go out there and do something that's more economically motivated, or motivated to impact our democracy or politics, it sort of has the waters all muddied. So that discord that they're sowing, to use that term, it really has a major impact on how we digest the news, how we trust. Yeah, there's some really interesting statistics in terms of trust.
21:30 Speaker 00 But your business is getting companies to pay attention and to use your technology to do that. Give me an example of, you were talking, when we met yesterday, about Harley-Davidson, for example.
21:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, there was a really interesting situation that happened last week.
21:45 Speaker 00 So Harley-Davidson background, said they're not going to make as many motorcycles in the United States. Donald Trump was their best friend, and now is angry at them, and has been... Tweeting, not a bot tweet about them, attacking them quite heavily.
21:57 Speaker 01 Exactly. And so what we saw was a tweet came out that said, that quoted, and I'm putting the quote in quotes, that Harley Davidson CEO basically called the president a moron. And all of a sudden, what you saw was that just go crazy. It went viral. It started trending. We saw at one point, more than 70% of that conversation were bots. And when you traced it back, and you know, to actually to Twitter's credit, they've removed the initial tweeter from the platform, but it wasn't a real person. So someone created a fake account. They made up this fake quote, and then you could see that they created these bot networks that
22:38 Speaker 01 all of a sudden started amplifying this. And so if you think about it, I thought that was a real quote when I first saw it. I think almost everybody thought it was a real quote when they first saw it. And you're seeing it over and over again, and it starts trending. And then the president starts to respond to those things. And all of a sudden, this spins out of control. So that impacts Harley Davidson. That impacts international trade policy. It impacts, you know, everything around President Trump. So there's a lot of reasons why these actors really want to start playing in this space. And if you're a corporation, and you have no idea that that's what's happening, you're in a major disadvantage.
23:17 Speaker 00 Right, right. And so you have Harley Davidson. Now, give me another example of another.
23:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's, so here's another example. AMD, back in March, the chipmaker. So a small security outfit out of the Middle East came out with a blog post basically saying, hey, there's flaws in AMD's chips, which by the way, is not how you expose flaws. There's a whole process. None of that happened. So they did that. What we saw was a bot network start to amplify that to a point where then
23:48 Speaker 00 What does that look like? What is an amplification?
23:50 Speaker 01 So picture it this way. Yeah, so picture it this way. This blog post is basically sitting on the corner of the internet. All of a sudden, a bot network gets spun up and it starts retweeting it and it starts pushing it around all these different platforms until more people start to see it. It gets more exposed within mainstream news reporters. More stories get put out. Now, to AMD's credit, they actually, and folks around them, called it stock manipulation. They say, hey, this is manipulating the company. That's false, which is the right way to handle that. But, you know, that has have a hit. People did hear, hey, there is a flaw with AMD. Now, the really interesting thing is, we started to create a database of all these bots.
24:34 Speaker 01 So every time we see a bot spin up.
24:36 Speaker 00 Where they spin into action.
24:37 Speaker 01 So, we actually already had this bot network in our database and we got an alert the split second that it started to occur.
24:45 Speaker 00 That this group of networks, bot networks?
24:48 Speaker 01 Correct. And this one has been going from technology company to technology company, taking negative stories and amplifying them to really start weakening the industry, weakening those companies, really hitting those to those, the reputations of those brands.
25:05 Speaker 00 And so then you track them and then you can tell the companies, this is bullshit.
25:09 Speaker 01 You tell the companies, there's situational awareness, there's offensive measures you can take, there's defensive measures. You know, calling it out is always a good thing. You can make decisions in terms of how much you want to expose it. Sometimes it makes more sense to not say anything. I mean, there's also situations where companies start seeing over and over again and they freak out and they make this big announcement, no, this is not true. Well, sometimes the only reason people heard about that is because of the company's announcement.
25:40 Speaker 00 Right, right. So, talk about this concept, because here you are, you want to give people this intelligence about what they're doing, but at the same time, like you're saying, it's pernicious, essentially. It's like getting a virus. You can't, you can't, just can't get rid of it. In the old days, there were whisper networks. They were like, there'd be whispers about a person, a politician, a company, an issue. And then sometimes it would make it in the mainstream by legitimate news organizations doing investigations or whatever of any of these things. What's the difference now, when you're doing media intelligence, between now and then? Because now, you don't need... It moves much faster and has a similar impact.
26:16 Speaker 01 Well, you kind of hit the biggest thing, which things move so fast now that you don't necessarily have time for that fact checking. And it's happening across every platform that exists, basically instantaneously. So, a coordinated attack can move very quickly, and if you're a company, your job is to react. Your job is to tamp things down. If you don't know where it's coming from, you're at a major disadvantage.
26:41 Speaker 00 Right.
26:42 Speaker 01 And I think when we're talking about this, sort of in the public now, we've been talking about it a lot in relation to politics and elections and things like that. We really haven't been talking about it in the context of how does this impact corporate America? And that's what's really important to do.
26:57 Speaker 00 Right, so talk a little bit about that.
26:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I think this is the, one of the biggest things that corporate America needs to be aware of now. Those same forces are really impacting the markets. They are impacting corporations. What's going to happen when they start making major company decisions based off that? They need to know where it's coming from. They need to know what the motives are behind it. They need to make sure that they have a strategy to deal with those issues as they start to come in. It's a completely new landscape.
27:26 Speaker 00 So, let me give you an example, like Roseanne Barr. Bob Iger fired her, essentially, after the comment, which most people would assume he would do, just because of the comment. Was he more, the question is, was he more affected by the reaction or the right thing to do? Those are the kind of decisions you can make quickly. I'm assuming he would have fired her.
27:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, that was a, that was a comment that, you know.
27:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, you pretty much get fired for it.
27:45 Speaker 01 You're probably getting fired.
27:46 Speaker 00 But it has impact. It has economic impact on the company. It has economic impact when people are there. But lesser issues that aren't so clear cut, like I noticed TNT didn't fire Samantha Bee. Like, it was, there was, it felt like there was a huge hubbub, and maybe there wasn't. Maybe there was a little one, and it was a stupid comment, but they didn't.
28:05 Speaker 01 It gets bigger and bigger, and, yeah.
28:06 Speaker 00 Right, right. So, how do you then explain to corporations that they have to calm themselves down, just like people, right?
28:12 Speaker 01 Well, one of the things that we really try and do, and again, you need technology to do this, it's impossible to do without the naked eye, is you really remove the bot networks from the convert, from the analytics. So, you say, hey, this is what's bot-generated, this wasn't. Then you also take a step further. This is the part of the conversation that was influenced by those bots.
28:31 Speaker 00 Right, because then humans come into it.
28:32 Speaker 01 Right. And so, once you remove that, then you can start really seeing, okay, what is the real problem? A lot of times, they are based off of real problems.
28:41 Speaker 00 Right.
28:41 Speaker 01 But a lot of times, they're not.
28:42 Speaker 00 Right, right.
28:43 Speaker 01 And so, you need to be able to see all of those things.
28:45 Speaker 00 So, is there less conversation actually going on than we think? Like, less or not? It feels like there isn't. Like, whenever Donald Trump tweets something, then it breaks into like, an enormous rondelet every issue like that.
28:58 Speaker 01 I mean, in some ways, it'd be great if it was that cut and dry. Is there less conversation or not? Because often, what happens is the bots come in, the bot networks, those nefarious actors, and then they cause more conversation. So, they're kind of lighting these fires throughout the internet.
29:14 Speaker 00 Right.
29:15 Speaker 01 To create more and more conversation. And it really just feeds off of each other.
29:19 Speaker 00 Right.
29:19 Speaker 01 And if you think about sort of how they're impacting how I talk about things, you talk about, that we all talk about things, how we're all digesting news, information, it's really widespread. And the fact that so much of this is being manipulated by individuals or groups.
29:37 Speaker 00 Or whatever.
29:37 Speaker 01 Or foreign states, whatever it is. I mean, it's pretty scary. It's kind of out of the spy novel type.
29:42 Speaker 00 Right, right, right. It was actually a plot on Homeland.
29:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, it was a plot on Homeland.
29:45 Speaker 00 It was. What, he took a picture? He, there was a couple.
29:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, it got amplified, yes.
29:49 Speaker 00 They amplified a lot of stuff, which was really interesting, which created decisions that were then bad and then created more mess. It was, it was.
29:57 Speaker 01 And that's now happening every single day. I mean, I would, the first thing that I always urge people of is just be aware this is happening.
30:04 Speaker 00 Right.
30:05 Speaker 01 You need to be aware of that.
30:06 Speaker 00 That implication. And then, from a corporate point of view, to be aware that you, you can't react, right? That you shouldn't react until you know where it's coming from.
30:15 Speaker 01 Or you should react differently, depending on where it's coming from, how it's getting to you. You know, if it's impacting something like your stock price, that's a, then you need to bring in other players, you know? Bring in the investor relations team, the risk team, the cybersecurity team. It really changes the communications landscape for a corporation.
30:38 Speaker 00 We're here with Josh Ginsberg. He has a company in San Francisco called Zignal Labs. He has that longtime political history. When things were easier, were things easier then?
30:45 Speaker 01 It didn't feel like it, but looking back, man, we traded a lot.
30:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, I know. I know. It was easy, right? It was just some annoying local news reporter that got some good tip. So let's talk about what companies can do, because I do want to, and then I want to get back to politics, this midterm election's coming up, when this is, it's disinformation, it's manipulation of these networks, it's just using the networks well for disinformation. But let's talk about what people can do, companies can do. I mean, obviously, every company can't just now have a social media presence. They've got to understand the impact of social media on them in order not to be as twitchy, presumably.
31:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, and there's a whole strategy. And the other thing that we're seeing, too, is there's a converging of, you know, before, social media team worked differently than the communications team, which worked differently than the marketing team. We're seeing all of those things really start to converge. So all of those, whereas they used to be really siloed, they're all turning into one. So that's step one, is making sure that you have the internal communication within those different groups and teams. Then number two, when you start to see this start to happen, you need to be able to see, okay, where it's coming from and what are the motives. Once that gets established, then you're able to start figuring out what your strategy is. Are you going to say, hey, this is manipulation? Hey, this is a bot network that's coming out. There are certain offensive
32:05 Speaker 01 strategies that you can do, too, in terms of how are you pushing out your message? As you can map sort of that new landscape of where are the bots, where are the influencers?
32:16 Speaker 00 How do you stop them? They just go away. They just fade back. They make a mess and then fade back.
32:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, but the other thing is, if you tell your message in the right way, or you give your message to the right influencers, you need to know how's that going to be amplified by real people?
32:33 Speaker 00 You want to amplify it yourself.
32:34 Speaker 01 Yeah. How do you use that to your ability, too? So there's a lot of different things that you need to look at from a landscape perspective, as well as just sort of a general strategy perspective, as you're reacting to these things.
32:49 Speaker 00 So when you bring it to a corporate con, here's, look, this new thing just was bot-related. What's the first thing they do? It depends on the situation.
32:57 Speaker 01 Depends on the situation, although if it's an economically motivated situation, you know, that's, that's pretty relevant. That means that you need to be aware of how this is going to impact stuff like your stock price. If it's more of a corporate reputation situation.
33:14 Speaker 00 Right, which it's often.
33:15 Speaker 01 Which often it is. Or if it's about your CEO, you know, that's really important, too. And so to be able to get out there and correct the record, to be able to go out there and, and really make sure your message is being amplified. Here's another interesting thing that we see time and time again. And I'll give you a real world use case to illustrate this. We found bot networks that get, I'll use the term woken up, based off of certain keywords. So for example, we found a bot network where every time a major technology company's name is used in the same headline as the word vulnerability. It'll wake up, it'll start to amplify it. And so if you're a technology company.
33:56 Speaker 00 So whenever Facebook and fuck up happens, go ahead.
33:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean.
33:59 Speaker 00 Whatever.
33:59 Speaker 01 You can check that.
34:01 Speaker 00 Privacy fuck up. Sorry, Mark, but it's true.
34:04 Speaker 01 I'm just glad to know I can curse on this podcast.
34:06 Speaker 00 Yes, you may. Please feel free.
34:08 Speaker 01 Great, thanks. So if you know that, if you know that's part of the landscape, how do you then, number one, make sure from a defensive perspective that those headlines aren't coming out?
34:17 Speaker 00 Right, which you can't.
34:18 Speaker 01 Which you, which you can't, but you might be able to sort of figure out the best way to frame a story based off that. Or from an offensive perspective, how do you use that in a positive way? You know, that's a less sophisticated bot network. Now, what's scarier, the more sophisticated bot networks. So let me give you an example of one of those. We found bot networks, what we call are using a three wave strategy. So basically.
34:41 Speaker 00 Three waves?
34:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
34:43 Speaker 00 It's like the ocean. I like your little thing.
34:45 Speaker 01 I like it.
34:46 Speaker 00 You're getting paid the big bucks if you have. Theories.
34:48 Speaker 01 It's a new world. We can come up with new fun names.
34:50 Speaker 00 I'm bringing you the third wave, Harley Davidson CEO.
34:54 Speaker 01 We'll call one Akira Swisher's strategy.
34:56 Speaker 00 Okay, all right, okay, yeah.
34:57 Speaker 01 So, in a third, in a three-wave strategy, there's three basically bot attacks that happen over usually a two to four week period.
35:06 Speaker 00 Okay.
35:06 Speaker 01 And the first two waves, the bot networks are testing messages. What's resonating with different groups that they want to get that out to?
35:13 Speaker 00 Right.
35:14 Speaker 01 And so they're just doing little tests and you can kind of see how that happens through our technology. The third wave is where they're using what they learned to really make an impact, to pack a really big punch. That's sort of the scary time.
35:27 Speaker 00 Right.
35:27 Speaker 01 So if we can show a company, hey,
35:29 Speaker 00 They're preparing.
35:30 Speaker 01 Now we can prepare for that. We can see what's starting to happen. Also, how can you participate in those waves too? There's all sorts of offensive and defensive measures.
35:39 Speaker 00 Like what, participating, ride the wave essentially?
35:40 Speaker 01 Well, you can start to see, okay, well, people are reacting when they push out this type of message to you. How are you going to respond to that in the moment? How can you blunt that at that time? So you're saving yourself when it gets to that third wave. So there's a number of patterns like that that we start to see.
35:58 Speaker 00 That you can see, and presumably the third wave is to sink you essentially.
36:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, and you have alerting function, we have alerting functionality that can tell you, hey, this is, we've got a three-wave coming at you.
36:07 Speaker 00 Yeah, and it's going to be bad. So how do corporations react now? When you show that, like, a lot of technology companies get hit here. You've got a lot of others and you can see it. You can see, it was interesting, you were looking, I think the Microsoft one was the ICE issue, which the employees were concerned. It was a real thing.
36:24 Speaker 01 They were, they were concerned. It was a legitimate issue that they had. But what we saw was, there was a concern, so it came from sort of a real person that tweeted out, hey, look, this is what's happening. Microsoft is working with ICE. But then during that conversation, 52% of all conversations within that were bots. They're being amplified by bots. So if you're Microsoft, you know, does that change the way you respond to things? Knowing that the level of intensity probably felt a little bit more because the bots were amplifying that.
36:56 Speaker 00 Right, right.
36:57 Speaker 01 You change your strategy in terms of...
36:59 Speaker 00 Right, so you don't get quite as intensive, you think, as the bots?
37:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
37:02 Speaker 00 But then, real people see them. That's the difficult... I think that's the fascinating part. All right, just finishing up, I want to talk about what happens in the next elections and everything. You know, you're a political guy, so you still do political clients or not?
37:14 Speaker 01 We have some political customers.
37:16 Speaker 00 Right. So corporations are just waking up to what politics has been under siege. But it seems like, just from reading recent reports about the government's not ready for the next thing, the companies just met. It is in a few months. What do you imagine the next... what has to happen next? You're not going to stop these bot networks, presumably. Is there a way to stop them?
37:38 Speaker 01 It is challenging.
37:39 Speaker 00 You're creating... you're chronicling them, but they could move away and create new ones all the time.
37:44 Speaker 01 Well, that's the thing. This is constantly evolving. I mean, it's on us to make sure we're staying one step ahead of all of those. That we can say, okay, you know, what's the next iteration of the three-wave strategy? You know, that's really important.
37:56 Speaker 00 Well, four waves.
37:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, four. Get ready for five.
37:58 Speaker 00 A tsunami. Tsunami.
38:01 Speaker 01 The tsunami strategy. So, but I think people do need to be made aware in this election cycle. This is happening. We're seeing it right now. Every single primary, this is happening. All of these different messages are getting pushed around. And again, it's happening on both sides of the aisle. It's not like, hey, the Republicans are doing this, the Democrats are doing that. I mean, oftentimes, it's probably outsiders who are also jumping in there to sow discord. When we see major issues spike up... You know, immigration was a really good example of this.
38:34 Speaker 00 A good example, yeah.
38:35 Speaker 01 We saw that huge percentages of that conversation were malicious actors just trying to spin people off. And again, across all platforms. And the way that the media writes about that is also impacted, of course it is.
38:51 Speaker 00 Right, because they see it and they think it's a bigger deal. I just was dealing with someone who was, we were tweeting, we were doing a Tim Cook interview and they wanted to tweet something and I said, "Don't tweet it, you're going to get a lot of bullshit tweets back at you and then you think that's the issue." And there was dozens and dozens on one issue. And I was like, "This is bot-related, this has to be..." It was just too many people responding to the same thing. And it was really, but they were like, "Well, we got to ask about that." I'm like, "No, we don't. Like, it's not an issue. It's just, you're now being pushed around by, I'm sure, Russians somewhere in St. Petersburg or something like that."
39:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, let me, like, let me give you an example of that. So Bloomberg did a story about Nestle back in last September. And it was about how they were fined as a water rights issue, effectively. Maybe not necessarily the sexiest issue, but, and they were going to places where, you know, they could get water for very inexpensive or free and bottling it and they were selling it for billions, that's what the story was about. And I think the folks at Bloomberg probably thought they had a hell of a story on their hands because it kept getting talked about. And when we looked into this, time and time again, and this has been, this is an example where this story comes up at least monthly and it just spikes huge amounts, it starts trending.
40:01 Speaker 00 Right.
40:02 Speaker 01 It's all bot networks. It's all these nefarious actors that are trying to push across an environmental message. So, that can have those types of impacts.
40:09 Speaker 00 Right, that they keep going on it, that it keeps living. And then so companies think it's still a thing and so does the media, so we'll just react to it.
40:16 Speaker 01 So the same thing's happening in our politics, too.
40:19 Speaker 00 Right. Right. So are you worried about these elections, these next elections?
40:22 Speaker 01 I think everybody should be worried about this. I mean, this is, and I think the first thing is just people need to be aware that this is occurring. Now, it's not too late, there's things that we can do about it. I think it's important to have these conversations out in the open. It's important for media outlets to be aware this is happening. It's important for politicians, for elected officials. And that's what's going to get us to get to a point where we can start blunting some of these issues.
40:48 Speaker 00 What about the responsibilities of platforms in this? Which are the most manipulable? You use Twitter a lot, obviously Twitter is the cesspool that has become... A media organization, whatever it is, I call it, you don't have to call it a cesspool.
41:00 Speaker 01 I would say, um, one of the major issues is that this is not a platform specific issue. Because if it was, then you can just say, okay, well, this platform just needs to fix it.
41:12 Speaker 00 Clean it up.
41:13 Speaker 01 And a lot of these platforms are genuinely taking legitimate steps to try and clean it up. Well, I mean, you've seen both Facebook and Twitter.
41:20 Speaker 00 Knock people off.
41:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, they're removing, um, accounts that are fake and things like that. But when it's happening across networks, you know, the Senate Intelligence Committee just went to Tumblr and said, hey, you were manipulated in 2016 election, what are you doing for the 2018 election? Um, so, and by the way, once people saw it on Tumblr, then it went to Reddit, then it went to Facebook, Twitter, then it went into mainstream news. So it's across the board.
41:46 Speaker 00 Across the board, all the platforms.
41:47 Speaker 01 So I think it's important that, um, all the platforms are working to clean it up. And I, and I think they are taking.
41:54 Speaker 00 And share information.
41:55 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I think they are taking genuine steps in order to do so. But those activities, of course, need to continue. And I, I think they are. And I think, you know, us as consumers, us as readers of this media, also just need to have that level of awareness.
42:10 Speaker 00 It's interesting that people don't get quite as bothered by, say, a Samantha Bee or Roseanne Barr, these bots, or politics. But when it comes to corporations, wait a second, this could like affect us. So what would the, the head of Harley-Davidson do in that instance? What did he do?
42:26 Speaker 01 Harley-Davidson, actually, I think, did a good job. Number one, I think they contacted the platforms, they had those users removed that were, you know, talking about this. Uh, and then they issued a statement saying, hey, this is not real. Now, that's maybe a little bit of an easier example, because so many people were paying attention to it. Well, what happens if it's a little bit smaller? What happens if a little bit happens every day and it's kind of this low-grade fever, not necessarily enough for it to really get on companies' radars?
42:54 Speaker 00 Did you hear someone got sick at a Disney park?
42:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:55 Speaker 00 Or the stuff around, there was a story, the conspiracy theories around, uh, phones taping you when you're, and then sending you ads.
43:03 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:03 Speaker 00 Which they proved today, not so. Um, but people persist. I think that's actually just crazy people.
43:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:10 Speaker 00 But that could be just conspiracy.
43:12 Speaker 01 But then they get amplified and then real.
43:14 Speaker 00 Yeah. But then it would affect these businesses. It was like, look, I'd like to ding Facebook and Google all day long, but not for things they don't do.
43:21 Speaker 01 I agree.
43:21 Speaker 00 Do you know what I mean? Like, let's focus on the shitty things they do versus the shitty things they don't do.
43:25 Speaker 01 But I think that is sort of the situation that we're in nowadays. What's true, what's not true. It's really difficult to tell. And you made a point earlier that I think was really good. One of the largest things that we've seen over the past couple of years is trust in institutions have plummeted. I mean, study after study shows that the two places where trust in institutions have sunk the most is, number one, media and, number two, corporations. So, what's true and what's not? That's really difficult to discern in this media environment.
43:54 Speaker 00 And what does the impact of Trump behaving this way have on it?
44:00 Speaker 01 I mean, it's probably not helping. And the other thing is-
44:02 Speaker 00 It's not helping.
44:03 Speaker 01 People are using these political issues as vehicles to hit corporations.
44:09 Speaker 00 Right.
44:10 Speaker 01 Because what they look at is, alright, let's look at the culture, let's look at corporations, what can we tie together that will get people spun up the most? And in this political environment-
44:19 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:20 Speaker 01 It's political issues.
44:20 Speaker 00 That's a really good one. And then using these tools, these technology tools. Do you see any upcoming ones that are gonna be dangerous? VR, suddenly?
44:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I'll tell you what I'm probably the most nervous about is this issue with deep fakes. So, what happens-
44:33 Speaker 00 Oh, what's a deep fake?
44:35 Speaker 01 So, that's when you, and I'm sure your listeners are gonna hear my explanation and be like, man, you got like 15% of that. But-
44:41 Speaker 00 Okay.
44:41 Speaker 01 I'll do my best. But, so that's an example where you can take any individual, and you get enough video, you get enough audio, you get enough visual-
44:49 Speaker 00 Ah, you deep fake.
44:50 Speaker 01 And so then, all of a sudden, I can show a CEO, and I'll do a PG version of a deep fake, but a CEO, I can make it look like a CEO went and robbed a bank. And that video can look extremely genuine to the naked eye. You start amplifying that, all of the sudden, you get stories about a CEO robbing a bank. Now, let's take that a step further. What if it's a foreign leader that you have showing videos saying that they're gonna do something to the United States? What happens if it's, you know, you can sort of go down the line-
45:22 Speaker 00 Yep.
45:22 Speaker 01 -for politicians, everything else. So, you combine-
45:25 Speaker 00 This is another episode of Homeland, but go ahead, yeah.
45:27 Speaker 01 There you go.
45:28 Speaker 00 Yeah.
45:28 Speaker 01 Maybe I should just take ideas from home.
45:29 Speaker 00 Watch Homeland, it has a lot of things. Either that, there's actually a movie you should watch called Minority Report that has a lot of ideas, like a lot of this stuff.
45:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:38 Speaker 00 And, you know, I try to avoid Tom Cruise smoothies, but nonetheless, this one is full of ideas like that.
45:43 Speaker 01 That's a great movie.
45:45 Speaker 00 Conceptual ideas. All right, so if you're a corporation, you need to be paying attention to this. You need to understand. And if you're a user, what, just turn off Twitter, or what?
45:53 Speaker 01 No, I mean, I think, look, I think Twitter, Facebook, all these platforms serve a really great purpose in terms of getting news and information. But as you're digesting that news and information, you just need to be aware, you need to be extra vigilant, what's real, what's not. Do research, make sure you're reading from trusted publications. You know, everyone's got that crazy uncle that likes to throw out those memes.
46:18 Speaker 00 I know, it's always the crazy, but they're like, the whole world is crazy. Let me just, let me just end by saying, we looked at my name, and apparently, I don't have many bots, but lots of people are pissed at me.
46:26 Speaker 01 Yes.
46:27 Speaker 00 So Kara Swisher is just being attacked by regular people.
46:30 Speaker 01 Kara is very clean on the bots. Regular people might be a little bit pissed off.
46:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, so I create all kinds of problems, but just, it's all real.
46:37 Speaker 01 It's a badge of honor.
46:38 Speaker 00 Thank you so much, but bots, please don't come after me, because I would ignore you too.
46:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, forget this, this is not a trigger.
46:43 Speaker 00 This is not a trigger, but thank you so much, Josh. This has been really fascinating. Again, it's Josh Ginsberg from Zigil Labs. Their product is called, what is it, Bot Intelligence?
46:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, Bot Intelligence Platform.
46:52 Speaker 00 Right, which I think a lot of companies will be, either availing themselves, or there's lots of people, there's going to be a lot of business in this area.
46:58 Speaker 01 I think so.
46:59 Speaker 00 As we move forward, because people have to know what's real and what's not. Or maybe, maybe not, we'll never know. Anyway, by the way, it's all a simulation, anyway, Josh, according to most.
47:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, so we got that.
47:08 Speaker 00 So it doesn't matter.
47:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, we're in an episode of Westworld right now.
47:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. All right, it was great talking to you. Thanks for coming on the show. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcasts for more. If you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and tell other people about the show. This helps them discover great interviews like this one. We welcome bot reviews also, as long as they're positive. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other podcasts, Too Embarrassed to Ask and Recode Media with Peter Kafka. You can find those shows wherever you found this one. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode, and thanks to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Wednesday, tune in then.
47:55 Speaker 02 Hi, Recode Decode listeners. I want to tell you about a new podcast, The Arthur Brooks Show. That's me, Arthur Brooks, and I'm president of the American Enterprise Institute. I'm making a new podcast with Vox Media. Now, as president of AEI, that's a Washington think tank, I see bitter disagreement all the time. And it's terrible. We need some way to disagree, not less, but better. So this is a series that looks at the art of disagreement. The first episode is out July 12. Find it on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcasts. And most of all, subscribe right now.
Previous Recode Decode: Tinder parent company Match Group prepares for battle with Facebook Next Recode Decode: Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated