Skip to content

MURDERED: Alberta O. Jones

Crime Junkie

Hosted by Ashley Flowers

56m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Alberta O. Jones was the first Black female prosecutor in Louisville, Kentucky, and a prominent civil rights activist who helped register roughly 6,000 Black voters and negotiated Muhammad Ali's first professional contract. On the night of August 4, 1965, she was lured from her home by a friend and hours later her body was found floating in the Ohio River, beaten and drowned. Her rental car was discovered with blood covering the backseat, her upper dentures, and a torn piece of newspaper wiped with bloody hands.

The investigation was plagued by destroyed evidence: within days of the murder, a police sergeant took the fingerprint cards from the lab and some were found in a trash bin, with others never recovered. In 2008, a surviving print matched Arthur Porter III, who was 17 in 1965 and worked at his father's funeral home—the same facility that handled Alberta's body. He failed a polygraph showing the highest level of deception but was never charged. The case also raises questions about a wig supposedly fitted on Alberta that night but never found on her, a police car seen on the bridge near the time of death, and threats made against a detective who investigated Ali's money. The case remains unsolved after more than 60 years.

  • Fingerprint cards from Alberta's car were taken by a police sergeant and some were found in a trash bin within days of the murder; no one was ever questioned about it. 36:39
  • In 2008, a surviving fingerprint matched Arthur Porter III, who was 17 in 1965 and worked at his father's funeral home, the same facility that handled Alberta's body. 46:42
  • The wig that Gladys said was fitted on Alberta that night was never found on her body, in her car, or in her purse, raising questions about the accuracy of the alibi. 57:47
  • A witness saw a white car and a marked Louisville police car stopped on the Sherman-Minton Bridge at 4:35 AM, just outside the estimated window Alberta entered the river. 27:36
  • Alberta was managing 15% of Muhammad Ali's winnings in a trust, and a detective investigating that angle received threats against his wife before dropping the line of inquiry. 1:01:50

Highlights

  • 6:39

    Body Found in the Ohio Riverstory

    A group of boys walking along the river found Alberta floating face down 15 feet from the shore. A coroner determined she was beaten and then put in the water alive, dying of drowning between 2:30 and 4:30 AM.

  • 11:04

    The Rental Car Revelationinsight

    Alberta's distinctive pink Thunderbird was in the shop that night; she had picked up a white Ford Fairlane at 6 PM. This detail complicates the timeline and raises questions about who else knew about the rental.

  • 15:19

    The Couple Who Heard Screamsstory

    A couple was woken to screams at 2 AM and saw a man dragging a woman into a white Ford, with another man waiting inside. The location sits on a trail leading west from Gladys's house to the river.

  • 27:36

    Police Car on the Bridgeinsight

    A bakery worker testified he saw a white car and a marked Louisville police car stopped on the Sherman-Minton Bridge at 4:35 AM, just outside the estimated time Alberta entered the river. No officer ever came forward to explain it.

  • 36:39

    Fingerprints Thrown in the Trashstory

    Detective Lancaster arrived at the fingerprint lab at 4:30 AM to compare prints and was told by Officer Elliott that Sergeant Miller had taken the cards and they were found in a trash bin. Some were ruined; others were never recovered.

  • 46:42

    2008 Fingerprint Match to Arthur Porterdata

    The FBI's automated system matched a surviving print to Arthur Porter III, who was 17 in 1965 and worked at his father's funeral home. He failed a polygraph with the highest level of deception but the Commonwealth attorney refused to prosecute.

  • 57:47

    The Missing Wig Mysteryinsight

    Gladys said she fitted a wig on Alberta before she left, but no wig was found on her body, in her car, or in her purse. The autopsy noted a cut near her hairline but no pins or combs to secure a wig.

  • 1:01:37

    Muhammad Ali's Money and Threatsinsight

    Alberta managed 15% of Ali's winnings in a trust he couldn't touch until 35. A detective investigating whether Ali wanted money diverted to the Nation of Islam received threats against his wife before dropping the inquiry.

About this episode

Alberta O. Jones was breaking barriers in Louisville, Kentucky. She was the first Black woman prosecutor in the city’s history, she helped register some 6,000 Black citizens to vote, and she was a leader in the city’s civil rights movement. But on Aug. 5, 1965 – before she could make even more changes in the highly segregated city – Alberta was found dead floating in the Ohio River. The night before, she reluctantly went out late to visit a close friend, setting off a 60-year mystery that has led to more questions than answers.

Transcript

0:00
56:17

11,333 words · 3 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Unsolved Murder
  • Civil Rights
  • Evidence Destruction
  • Cold Case
  • Muhammad Ali
  • Police Misconduct
  • 1960s America

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated