Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Brittany Wallace-Shank, 23, vanished on November 30, 2018, after her car went off Fawn River Road near Sturgis, Michigan. She arrived barefoot at a stranger's house, told 911 her boyfriend left her after a wreck, then fled before deputies arrived. The car was barely damaged—stuck in a shallow ditch, still drivable—yet no one could explain her injuries or why she ran.
The investigation centered on an unidentified man Grandma Vicky described as thin, blonde, with mutton-chop sideburns, who was with Brittany at her house that evening. Ashley Houli, a close friend who claimed to be Brittany's sister, became a focal point: she possessed a gas receipt from Fawn River Road timestamped 6:11 PM that night, and her relationship with Brittany's separated husband Eric Schenk complicated the picture. Eric was at Ashley's apartment that evening, and body-cam footage from a December 2018 traffic stop shows him calling Ashley his girlfriend. Phone calls between Brittany and a man named Zach Bowman, who was in prison, reveal coded language and tension about someone in the group.
The case was marked by significant investigative gaps: the car was never processed for evidence, Eric was not formally interviewed until five years later, and Ashley's polygraph status is contradictory. An abandoned property on Fawn River Road burned down by arson, and a Ring cam video of a white Cadillac sparked claims of hearing Brittany screaming, but neither led anywhere. Brittany has never been found.
- The car was still drivable after going off the road, suggesting Brittany may have been fleeing someone rather than a crash. 7:11
- Ashley Houli possessed a gas receipt from Fawn River Road timestamped 6:11 PM on the night Brittany vanished, which she claimed to have found in her stolen car. 47:09
- Eric Schenk was not formally interviewed by law enforcement until nearly five years after Brittany's disappearance. 53:27
- Phone calls between Brittany and Zach Bowman, recorded on a prison line, contain coded language suggesting she had information about someone in the group. 1:10:55
- The car was never processed for forensic evidence because investigators initially assumed Brittany was hiding from police rather than in danger. 31:16
Highlights
- 2:17
The 911 Call That Started It Allstory
A woman arrives barefoot at a stranger's house in the cold, tells 911 her boyfriend left her after a car wreck, then flees before help arrives.
- 14:06
The Mystery Man Descriptiondata
Grandma Vicky describes the man as thin, white, early to mid twenties, 5'6" to 5'8", short blonde hair, thick mutton-chop sideburns, wearing a yellow sweat suit with black.
- 43:05
Eric Calls Ashley His Girlfrienddata
Body-cam footage from a December 2018 traffic stop shows Eric Schenk telling officers he's looking for his wife and that the car belongs to his girlfriend, Ashley Houli.
- 47:09
The Gas Receipt on Fawn River Roaddata
A receipt for $20 of gas at the Marathon Station on Fawn River Road, timestamped 6:11 PM on November 30, was found in Ashley Houli's possession, placing her near the scene that evening.
- 53:27
Five Years Before a Formal Interviewinsight
Eric Schenk, Brittany's separated husband, was not formally interviewed by St. Joseph County investigators until nearly five years after her disappearance, and even then it was only 45 minutes.
- 1:10:55
Coded Language on a Prison Lineinsight
Brittany tells Zach Bowman that Pocket (Ashley's boyfriend) was picked up by police, and warns him not to say anything, suggesting she has information that could be dangerous.
- 1:14:22
The Polygraph That May Not Have Happeneddebate
Brittany's father was told by the sheriff's office that both Ashley and Eric passed polygraphs, but Ashley claims she never actually took one—she was pre-screened for three hours but the exam was cancelled because she hadn't slept enough.
- 1:19:24
The Arson on Fawn River Roadstory
An abandoned property on Fawn River Road tied to rumors of captivity and sex trafficking burned down by arson; investigators found women's underwear and a knife with possible blood stains, but tests came back negative.
About this episode
On November 30, 2018, 23-year-old Brittany Wallace Shank showed up barefoot and bleeding at a stranger's door asking for help. She said the man she was with had crashed their car and ran away. Deputies were on the way. But before they arrived, Brittany disappeared into the darkness. She has never been seen again.
Transcript
14,818 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Missing Persons
- Cold Case
- Drug Use
- Small Town Crime
- Investigation Failures
- Domestic Relationships
- Evidence Handling
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated