The Case Of
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
Erin Patterson's jury has been picked and the judge has explained how some of the original attempted murder charges have been dropped.
2,441 words · 8 speakers
ABC Listen. Podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
The trial of Erin Patterson is finally underway. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silva.
And I'm Mushroom's producer, Stephen Stockwell. And you can't take two steps in Moorewall at the moment without bumping into someone associated with this trial.
That's right. I mean, you just walk down the street and there's no shortage of reporters, camera crews, documentary makers, filmmakers, lawyers. And actually, this morning, a huge jury pool was outside the courtroom. And that jury pool has been reduced down to a group of 15 who have been picked to serve on the jury for the Erin Patterson trial. Also, a big development, the jury was told that some of the charges that Erin Patterson is facing have been dropped. Things are starting to move really quickly. So we're going to bring you up to speed in this episode, get you across all of that and answer some of your questions.
The small town mystery that's gripped the nation, just a week after four people sat down for a family lunch in rural Victoria, three of them were dead.
On the menu was beef wellington, a pastry filled with beef and a pate made of mushrooms.
But Erin Patterson has strongly maintained her innocence.
It's a tragedy what's happened. I'm just kind of devastated. I love them.
So today was the last of the trial preparations. We had the jury picked today, which we'll get to shortly. But you mentioned earlier, there was some really big news around some of the charges that Erin Patterson had been facing.
That's correct. So Justice Christopher Beale told the jury today that Erin Patterson had previously been charged with three counts of attempted murder in relation to her estranged husband, Simon. The judge told the jury those charges had been discontinued, i.e. dropped. And he said, put that out of your mind when you consider the evidence in this trial. So just to clarify, Erin Patterson is still facing charges of murder and attempted murder in relation to the beef Wellington lunch. She's facing three murder charges and one attempted murder charges. That is all still going ahead and that is the subject of this trial.
Is it unusual for a judge during the jury directions to to say something like that, to outline that or or point that out?
Well, I think, given the huge public interest and widespread knowledge about the background of this case, he was kind of calling out a bit of an elephant in the room by saying that these attempted murder charges are no longer proceeding. And he was also demonstrating the trust that he's placing in this jury to follow his instructions. He's told them, put this out of your mind, do not consider it. He's not treating them like children, he's being upfront and clear with them.
Is that that's usually how a judge would work? Or do sometimes they, you know, they they're a bit more pointed in what they expect of a jury?
I think sometimes in trials, things are delicately omitted. But in this case, Justice Beale is being expressly clear about the state of play and what he expects.
Yeah, and all of this was happening today, you know, as you mentioned earlier, the jury was picked. And all of this was happening during what are called jury directions, where they're kind of told what what they're supposed to do. Can you you tell me a bit about what the jury directions are and what that process is about?
Yeah, the jury directions, essentially, I like to call it the judge's pep talk.
I mean, most people who serve on a jury haven't done this before. And safe to say, none of the jury members in this case have ever served on a trial that is as massive as this. That is obvious. So as part of this pep talk, the judge goes over the jury's responsibilities. He's told them that they are the only deciders of the facts in this case. Don't go and look at the media. If you see something on the news, change the channel, is what he said. If you see something in the paper, flip to the next page. Don't be influenced by what family and friends have to say, block that out.
It's all about what they hear and the decision that they reach independently.
Is this quite a serious, really kind of like overbearing talk that that the judge gives at this point?
No, it's not. It's what we hear in every trial. But I think the point really needs to be made when you've got a trial of this magnitude.
Yeah, yeah. And how descriptive or direct does Justice Beale get? Or does a judge usually get when they're going through and explaining what the expectations of a jury are?
With what Justice Beale said today, he explained a little bit of the trial process, that you know, there's going to be the openings first and then the evidence and then they'll go away and decide and then come back with a verdict. But he also talked about how they should assess the evidence. And he said to them, and I quote, "You should dismiss any feelings of sympathy or prejudice you may have in relation to Aaron Patterson. You must dispassionately weigh the evidence. Use your head, not your heart." So, very clear instructions. And again, the focus on what the evidence is presented to the trial and blocking out that external noise.
Yeah, right. Okay. And was this, you know, overall, just like a pretty kind of like strict, tense, terse exchange?
Justice Beale, I think, today showed that he can deliver some strict instructions, but there's also some moments of warmth. I don't think he wanted to put the fear of God into the jury panel today, which is probably a smart thing. He even cracked a bit of a joke and there was some smiles and laughter in the courtroom when he was talking about the court's sitting hours, which are going to be roughly from about 10:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. each day with a one-hour lunch break. Now, he joked that some people think that that's pretty slack. But he said, "I think you'll find it very demanding," and that the decisions they have to make are so important and the attention they have to give to these
witnesses is so intense. And he sort of laughed and he said, "You'll be grateful when the afternoon bell rings." And it was nice to see, even though we're in a triple murder trial, just a moment of warmth and humanity and acknowledging the situation that these jury members are going to find them in for the next five to six weeks. Another thing he said, which got my attention, was that he told the jury that once they've heard all the evidence over the next few weeks, that when it comes time for them to deliberate for the final time, they'll be sequestered.
And.
Oh, so we'll like put in a hotel or something?
Uh, the arrangements weren't detailed, but what sequestered means is they'll be isolated. They'll be taken away from, from um their family, their friends, they'll be kept together. Um, I don't know if you've seen the Amazon um comedy jury duty. I don't think it'll be like that, but if anyone has seen that show, you can get a bit of a glimpse as to what life could be like for the jury members.
Who, who did we have in the room today? I mean, you mentioned yesterday that Erin Patterson was in the room. Was she back in the, in the court today?
Most importantly, Erin Patterson was in the dock. Uh, she didn't need to say anything today. She sat silently, listening to all of the proceedings. Everyone will be curious to know, what was she like or what did she look like? So I'll try to give a bit of a description. Um, Erin was, was dressed in a striped, pink and white uh button up shirt. Um, during the jury instructions, she appeared pretty calm. She was listening intently and uh the courtroom was filled largely with reporters today. I think the public probably well aware that um jury instructions may not be the most interesting part of a trial. So I think from tomorrow, we'll see that uh demand for seats in the courtroom will be
very high. Uh, also in the court today, the bar table was also full with lawyers from both sides. Colin Mandy S C is the lead barrister for the defence and Nanette Rogers S C is uh leading the prosecution team and uh surrounding them are several other um lawyers as part of that team.
Now, as we mentioned in our last episode, we have had a lot of emails that have been sent to mushroomcasedayly at a b c dot net dot A U, including a um a slight avalanche overnight after our episode yesterday where people have reached out with uh with questions. A lot of those questions last night wanted to know about the attempted murder charges, which we spoke about at the start of the episode. So we've, we've answered them for you. Um, we do have one from um my dad, all right, of all people. Uh, he says, thanks to Christian for your knowledge and to Stocky for your layman's lack of it. Thanks, Dad. If the public can attend hearings, what happens if a heap of people turn up? Is it like a first come, first served basis? Or do you book by something? Do they provide crowd control? And what happens if the public behaves inappropriately, like shouting or demonstrating or carrying on?
Well, great question. So firstly, in terms of the courtroom layout, there's about, I don't know, thirty five, forty seats that are reserved for members of the public and reporters and other lawyers and security guards as well. So seating is pretty limited. I don't know the exact number of seats that will be made available for the public tomorrow when the openings get underway. But you'd probably count it on two hands. It's going to be tough for anyone who's really keen to get into that courtroom. But I think if you're in Morewell and you want to come along, the best way is just to come to court, line up and chance your arm.
As for the reporters, only six seats each day are going to be allocated to the reporters to cover the trial. Other seats will be reserved for family members and things like that. So pretty tough to get in. As to crowd control, yes, there are some police, security guards in the court. From my previous experience, if people misbehave, that is not tolerated at all by the courts. I'm sure we won't see it in this trial, but I have seen in previous trials, if people carry on or try to pull a stunt, they're kicked out of the courtroom pretty quickly.
Yep, and we have another email here from Ruby who has written in to correct us on our pronunciation, which I very much appreciate. So if you are listening and we're getting something wrong, just please get in touch. We're very responsive. Ruby is highlighting that we are pronouncing Curumburra wrong. So I think I might have said at some point Corumburra.
I think I may have said that too.
Yeah, look, we're probably both guilty of this. But it is Curumburra with a U. And this is a real point of discussion at the moment in Morewell, where we are at the moment. While we were having dinner last night, there was an email passed around correcting our pronunciation of Morewell. We should be saying Morewell, not Morwell. Yeah, so Morewell was the recommendation.
Discussion around the table as to whether or not that advice was correct. But if you have thoughts, get in touch with us. And our final question for today's episode is from Joanne. It's a really interesting one, actually, that I was, I've never considered, I'd never thought about, which was quite surprising. She's asked, my friend and I really want to know what was for dessert. This is talking about the lunch, beef Wellington, followed by what?
Great question, Joanne. Hopefully we'll hear that tomorrow. Great segue to, to what's coming up tomorrow. The trial openings will get underway and that's when the prosecution will lay out their case. We know some of the background of this story, obviously, but the prosecution is going to give a detailed overview of the case they're putting against Erin Patterson. Whether that includes the dessert, I guess we'll find out. But if, if it is mentioned by prosecutor Nanette Rogers, we'll definitely include that in the details because I'm also keen to know.
Tomorrow, one of the biggest days with the opening statements. And Christian, you'll be in the room for that?
Absolutely. I was one of the lucky reporters to win the ballot. It's like Willy Wonka's golden ticket. So, so that, that is great. And, and what I hope to do is describe the atmosphere in the court there. So the prosecution and defence will both get up to give their opening statements. This is a key moment in every trial. Big episode tomorrow.
Yep. Make sure you are following Mushroom Case Daily on the ABC listener. Get that app if you don't have it. Make sure you follow Mushroom Case Daily. That way you won't miss an episode. We'll bring that to you as soon as Christian's out of court and we can get back into our little studio here and record that and get it up for you. So yeah, make sure you're following along.
This has been a long time coming, so it's pretty momentous that this is finally getting underway.
Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
Our executive producer is Claire Rollinson and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gensh, and audio studios manager, Eric George. Thanks also to our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh and Yasmin Parry. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai people.
You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated