The Case Of
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
The murder trial of Erin Patterson starts this week. Kristian and Stocky break down the week ahead and what to expect in the courtroom.
1,400 words · 8 speakers
ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
Here we go. Nearly two years since that fateful lunch at Erin Patterson's house. We're in Morewell for the trial. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
And I'm Mushroom's producer, Stephen Stockwell.
Socky, I've just returned from the Morewell Court. They're ironing out the final issues in the pre-trial before this case finally gets underway. And from tomorrow, we'll be able to deliver daily episodes, living up to the name of this podcast, Mushroom Case Daily.
That's right. We're going to be your eyes and ears inside the La Tro Valley courthouse here in Morewell, almost two hours south of Melbourne. But before we go too much further, let's just have a little bit of a look back at how we got here.
The small town mystery that's gripped the nation and made headlines around the world. Just a week after four people sat down for a family lunch in rural Victoria, three of them were dead.
Erin Patterson invited her in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, over for lunch, along with Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, and her husband, Ian. On the menu was beef wellington, a pastry filled with beef and a paté made of mushrooms.
Three people are dead and one man is fighting for his life this morning after a suspected mushroom poisoning in South Gippsland in Victoria.
In a statement on behalf of the families, the four were described as cherished individuals. Parents, grandparents, siblings, children and pillars of faith within their community.
Erin Patterson, sitting in the dock, an accused triple murderer.
But Erin Patterson has strongly maintained her innocence. We keep an open mind to this. It may be very innocent. It's a tragedy what's happened. I'm so devastated.
I just can't fathom what has happened. I love them.
So that's how we got here. This is now the trial of Erin Patterson. She's charged with murder and attempted murder. We're in Morewell. The trial will be starting this week. What have you been up to today?
Well, the first thing I did was actually drive down the highway and get into town, checked into the motel, ran into the courtroom, made it with about two minutes to spare. And as I said, dealing with some last minute pre-trial issues, this is totally normal for big criminal trials and everyone's just gearing up for the jury selection, which is the first step tomorrow.
We've had some busy days. So you've been at court. I've been at our house in Morewell building the studio that we're recording from at the moment. So every day we'll be recording an episode of Mushroom Case Daily from this studio that has been created. So we can get it to you as quickly as possible. So that update's coming out. It's been going well. What's, I mean, I spent a little bit of time at the courthouse this morning as well. I saw you as you ran in. And, you know, there was a sort of gaggle of journalists. What's the, what was the kind of vibe? What was the mood down there?
We have heard that there's going to be a lot of media attending court and I guess the proof will be in the pudding later this week, but already it's definitely a larger than normal media presence at court. And certainly it's not a stretch to say that we normally don't get such attention on cases in Morewell, in the Latrobe Valley. So already the courtroom today was pretty full. It's not exactly a small room, but you have to remember that when you've got a case of this magnitude, normal sized courtrooms often don't quite cut it. And the court has had to take extra logistical measures to ensure that they can meet the demands and expectation of the media who have descended on this town to cover this case.
Do we know how many people are expected to come to, like how many media are expected to come to town for this?
I think it's tough to put a number on it, but the court's actually set up an overflow room in Morewell. They've also set up an overflow room back in Melbourne for other reporters who aren't able to come. Down here for the trial. So this is really unprecedented levels of interest in a case.
Yeah. Any sort of recognisable faces that you were you were seeing around, anyone people might know? Erin Patterson?
Erin Patterson was there in the flesh and you'd expect she'll be there every day for the trial as well.
So she's she in the courtroom. So previously, we'd just been seeing her on on video links a lot of the time. Um. But she's in in the courtroom today.
In the courtroom, in the flesh.
Wow, okay. Um. And where do we go from here? What is the plan for this week?
The first thing that's going to happen will be selection of the jury and they're going to be drawn from the local area. So we'll have more to say about that process in our next episode. The jury will also be given some instructions by the judge, things that they'll need to consider. And then, once that's done, we get into the trial. We get into the prosecution openings, a defence response, and then a very thorough examination of all the evidence that the prosecution has put forward. Now, it's worth reminding everyone again that Erin Patterson has pleaded not guilty to all of these charges. And at the end, once all the evidence has been presented, the prosecution will get to sum up their case.
The defence will have another go to sum up their arguments. And then the jury will be sent out to make up their mind and come back with that critical verdict as to whether Miss Patterson is guilty or not guilty of these charges.
So the, you know, the real pointy end of this, as we start start this process, it's going to be a very big week. We've got, um, you know, a lot of interesting episodes that are becoming your way over the next few days, as well as talking through, uh, what's happening with the jury tomorrow. We're also going to be answering some of your questions. Mushroomcasedaily@abc.net.au is our email address. You can get in touch with us. Eliza, John, Cassie, we've got all of yours. They're pencilled in. We've got some other questions coming through as well. So if you want to get in touch, please send us a question. We'll do our best to answer it on the pod. But I would absolutely recommend, uh, putting a little reminder in your phone now, a little alarm for like, you know, tomorrow evening. So you don't forget to listen to our next episode of Mushroom Case Daily.
We're really stoked to be here and what we really want to do is Put you in the courtroom as best as we can. There's no television feed for people at home. There's not a public feed for people to listen in. So we're going to do our best to try to be your eyes and ears and tell you what the jury hears. That's really the aim of our podcast. And we really hope we can also try to explain the legal system as best we can. So people can follow along what is undoubtedly a case that's gripped the world.
So jump onto the ABC Listen app. Make sure you follow Mushroom Case Daily so you don't miss an episode.
And we plan to just bring you the good, the bad and the ugly of what happens in court, in front of the jury, of course. It should be a really interesting ride.
Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, ABC Court reporter Christian Silver and producer Stephen Stockwell.
Our executive producer is Claire Rollinson and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gensh, and audio studios manager, Eric George. Also, thank you to our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh and Yasmin Parry. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai people.
You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated