Skip to content

1047: Adobe has a big problem

Syntax - Tasty Web Development Treats

Hosted by Scott Tolinski and Wes Bos

35m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

The hosts discuss a newly released, clean-room reimplementation of the Adobe Creative Suite created in just two weeks by developer Brandon Thomas, known as Echelon on GitHub. They explore how surprisingly well complex Photoshop files, half-tone filters, masks, and layers open in this new Rust-based alternative compared to traditional alternatives like GIMP or Affinity Photo. The conversation shifts to the current state of software development, AI coding agents, and the broader industry backlash against restrictive APIs and Model Context Protocol (MCP) implementations by companies like Figma. They argue that while copying existing tools is becoming easier through AI, true moats remain rooted in exceptional user interface design, deep attention to detail, and solving real user bugs.

  • Do not rely on weak alternatives for professional raster design because software like GIMP fails to properly render Photoshop features like smart objects and texts. 0:53
  • Capture user errors and bugs early using error tracking software like Sentry so that development teams and AI agents can address them before users abandon the project. 25:25
  • Consider 3D printing a custom modular rack using PETG material to neatly organize computer hardware and Raspberry Pi clusters under a desk with proper airflow. 28:34

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Adobe Suite Clean‑Room Clone Launch

    Wes introduces a new clean‑room port of the Adobe Creative Suite that promises speed and feature parity.

  2. 0:46
    Wes’s Personal Photoshop Experience

    Wes shares his 25‑year Photoshop history and his surprise at the new clone’s performance and quality.

  3. 1:31
    Feature Parity and UI Challenges

    Wes and Scott discuss the clone’s feature coverage, UI quirks, and the importance of a polished interface.

  4. 2:22
    Scott’s Adobe Hater Backstory

    Scott recounts his 2017 decision to ditch Adobe and the alternatives he’s tried since.

  5. 6:39
    Clean‑Room Process Explained

    Wes explains how the clean‑room team documents and tests the clone, highlighting legal and technical hurdles.

  6. 8:00
    Industry Adoption and Future of Photoshop

    The hosts speculate on how the clone could influence Adobe’s AI strategy and the broader creative workflow.

  7. 14:48
    Figma’s MCP Stance and AI Tools

    Scott critiques Figma’s restrictive MCP policy and its impact on AI‑powered design tools.

  8. 24:17
    Bug Reporting and Sentry Integration

    Wes emphasizes the need for robust error tracking and encourages using Sentry for crash reporting.

  9. 28:34
    Sick Picks – 3D Printing Rack

    Scott showcases his upgraded 3D‑printed rack for Raspberry Pi clusters and other hardware.

  10. 30:48
    Sick Picks – Insta 360 Luna Camera

    Wes explains why he chose the Insta 360 Luna over other gimbals for his video workflow.

  11. 34:55
    Wrap‑Up and Sign‑Off

    The hosts conclude the episode with final thoughts and a friendly goodbye.

Highlights

  • 0:00

    Adobe Suite Recreated via AIinsight

    The guest discusses discovering a newly forked, clean-room reimplementation of the entire Adobe Creative Suite built in just two weeks.

  • 5:01

    Opening Complex Photoshop Filesstory

    The guest tests a complex Photoshop file containing eight stacked filter layers, blend modes, and masks, noting that it opens faster and renders accurately.

  • 7:20

    Explaining Clean Room Softwarestrategy

    The guest breaks down the clean-room development process, where one agent maps out software features and passes the specs to an implementation agent to avoid legal issues.

  • 14:48

    Figma and MCP Restrictionsdebate

    The host explains how Figma blocks certain AI tool harnesses within their MCP, drawing parallels to companies locking down their APIs to protect their business models.

  • 22:42

    The Only Remaining Moatinsight

    The hosts debate software moats, concluding that the only real moat left is caring enough about a project to polish the interface and fix bugs past the first two days.

Quotes

  • “I have been a Photoshop user for 25 years. I've tried all of the alternatives, you know, PhotoP, GIMP, Affinity. I have, I've tried them all and they're not as good.”
    Wes Bos · 0:46
  • “I'm shocked at how good and fast this is. I had another one of those like, holy smokes moments with this type of thing.”
    Wes Bos · 1:37
  • “The interface is nice. It's the whole UI is also built in Rust, which I thought you would like, quite like that, Scott.”
    Wes Bos · 9:54
  • syntax.fm 8:55–9:06
  • Sentry 24:56–26:31

About this episode

Someone just clean-room ported seven Adobe apps to Rust, and Wes is shocked at how good it is. Scott and Wes break down what it gets right, what’s still missing, and why copying software is easy but inventing what comes next is the hard part. Show Notes 00:00 Welcome to Syntax! 00:12 Adobe Is in Trouble: A Clean Room Port of the Entire Suite ArtCraft 02:22 Scott’s Long Running Adobe Grudge Since 2017 03:42 Figma Is Not a Raster Tool: Why Every Alternative Falls Short 04:40 Opening Real Photoshop Files: Masks, Half Tones and Blend Modes PhotoCraft Github 06:30 What Clean Room Porting Actually Means 09:54 A Familiar Interface, Entirely Built in Rust 10:15 Don’t Trash the Whole Thing Over One or Two Bugs 12:14 What’s Missing: Artboards and the Tiny UI Interactions 13:53 Where Are the Vibe Coded Photoshops? Four Months Later 14:33 Figma’s Locked Down MCP and the Backlash 17:22 Dylan’s Clap Back at Anthropic’s Own Closed Ecosystem 18:08 The Real Photoshop Replacement Will Be a New Way of Working 21:35 Good UI Is Still the Moat 22:28 Caring About Your Project Past Two Days 23:05 Audio Crackles and Paper Cuts: The Bugs Only Humans Chase 24:56 Brought to you by Sentry! 26:28 Copying Is Easy: The Hard Part Is Inventing What Comes Next 27:28 DaVinci Resolve Keeps Shipping Useful Releases 28:26 Sick Picks + Shameless Plugs Sick Picks Scott: KWS V2 Rack Wes: Insta360 Luna Hit us up on Socials! Syntax: X Instagram Tiktok LinkedIn Threads Wes: X Instagram Tiktok LinkedIn Threads Scott: X Instagram Tiktok LinkedIn Threads Randy: X Instagram YouTube Threads

Transcript

0:00
35:08

6,290 words · 2 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Photoshop
  • Figma
  • Adobe
  • MCP
  • Premiere
  • Illustrator
  • Print
  • GIMP
  • Anthropic
  • Pi

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated