Skip to content

Episode 372

Sword and Scale

Hosted by Mike Boudet

54m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode covers the October 13, 2021, murder of postal worker Jason Schaefer in Longmont, Colorado, and the subsequent investigation that led to the conviction of his ex-girlfriend, Devon Schreiner, and her current boyfriend, Andrew Ritchie. Investigators unravel a complex web of family drama and tangled relationships involving Devon, her estranged sister Rosa, and multiple romantic partners. The narrative details how clues such as vehicle sightings, postal scanner GPS tracking, and an incriminating bathroom selfie led law enforcement straight to Devon as the shooter in a black hoodie. Both Devon and Andrew were eventually convicted of first-degree murder and complicity, leaving their young son without either parent.

  • Postal scanners record location data and GPS breadcrumbs that can place a suspect at a specific location for hours. 38:08
  • Investigators examine cell phone evidence to recover incriminating photographs, such as selfies wearing the exact outfit seen on surveillance footage. 44:44
  • An accomplice who helps plan or monitor a victim can be charged with complicity to commit first-degree murder. 52:18

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Introduction and Host Disclaimer

    The show opens with a warning about adult content and a brief host introduction.

  2. 0:35
    The Fatal Shooting Incident

    Jason is shot while delivering mail, and emergency responders are called to the scene.

  3. 1:49
    Witness Accounts and Initial Investigation

    Neighbors describe the shooting, the suspect’s hoodie and mask, and the police begin gathering evidence.

  4. 6:31
    Police and Paramedic Response

    Paramedics perform CPR on the ground while police secure the scene and interview witnesses.

  5. 9:20
    Suspect Identification and Motive Exploration

    Detectives interview a former employee and uncover a custody dispute that may have motivated the crime.

  6. 52:18
    Co‑Defendant Andrew Ritchie’s Complicity

    Andrew Ritchie, Devon’s partner, is arrested for aiding the murder after following Jason on the day of the shooting.

  7. 55:48
    Trial, Conviction, and Aftermath

    Both Devon and Andrew are tried, convicted of first‑degree murder, and sentenced to life without parole, leaving their child parentless.

  8. 58:24
    Devon's Tragic Separation

    The host reflects on Devon's lifelong separation from her son, highlighting the emotional toll of the case.

  9. 59:17
    Closing Thoughts and Gratitude

    The host thanks listeners, notes the podcast's longevity, and encourages family time over dark content.

  10. 1:00:57
    Spinquest Halloween Promotion

    An ad promoting Spinquest's Halloween-themed casino games and special offers.

Highlights

Quotes

  • “It keeps the blood moving to the brain and heart for a few more minutes, and sometimes those minutes matter.”
    Mike Boudet · 6:42
  • “The detective wasn't guessing either. He already knew it was her.”
    Mike Boudet · 45:17
  • “The force hits his body. Before realizing what's happening, there's more.”
    Mike Boudet · 1:43
  • “I'm reminded of the one saying, 'All is fair in love and war.'”
    Mike Boudet · 58:42
  • “And although it's probably a very true statement in a lot of ways, there should probably be a footnote that instructs dummies like these two sisters to keep your family out of it.”
    Mike Boudet · 58:50
  • “Go be with your family, tell them you love them, give them a hug, stay safe.”
    Mike Boudet · 59:44
  • Toyota 12:22–13:36
  • Gilead Sciences 14:30–14:47
  • Babbel 14:49–15:29
  • Gilead Sciences 50:32–50:34
  • Babbel 50:40–51:18
  • Spinquest 1:01:00–1:01:28

About this episode

Thirty-three-year-old Jason Schaefer was delivering mail on a quiet afternoon in Longmont, Colorado, when bullets assaulted him. Witnesses saw a figure run from the mailboxes, covered in a hoodie and mask, and at first, the case seemed to point in one direction. But as detectives traced Jason’s final day, they uncovered a tangled web of jealousy, custody fights, family betrayal, and secrets hiding in plain sight, all surrounding a young father who never made it home from work. Get instant access to all episodes, including premium unreleased episodes, commercial-free at swordandscale.com

Transcript

0:00
54:44

9,316 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Post Office
  • Longmont
  • OnDeck
  • Heather Hill Circle
  • Fort Collins
  • United States Postal Inspection Services
  • iHeart's Ruby Studio
  • Apple Podcast
  • iHeart Radio app
  • Colorado

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated