Will the Blue Wave Come for SCOTUS?
Hosted by Kate Shaw, Leah Litman and Melissa Murray
- 1h 41m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In this live episode recorded at the Howard Theater at Crooked Con following the 2026 midterms, hosts Leah Litman, Melissa Murray, and Kate Shaw celebrate Democratic electoral gains while connecting the post-election landscape to the Supreme Court. The hosts and guest Sherrilyn Eiffel argue that despite the blue wave, structural reforms to the high court—including hearings, ethics enforcement, and potential expansion—are essential because the Roberts Court has actively degraded democracy through campaign finance deregulation, voting rights dismantling, and partisan gerrymandering. They also analyze recent oral arguments in St. Mary Parish v. Roy, critiquing the conservative justices' efforts to establish a constitutional right to use public funds to discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals.
- Supreme Court reform must remain a core priority on any pro-democracy agenda to address institutional decay. 23:26
- Voters overcame significant structural distortions, such as gerrymandering and voter suppression, to achieve electoral success. 22:53
- Advocates must pursue structural transformation and long-term discipline to block ongoing abuses of executive and judicial power. 54:39
- Legal challenges to anti-discrimination laws risk creating constitutional entitlements to discriminate under the guise of religious freedom. 34:01
Chapters
- 0:00
- 2:35Podcast Launch and Host Introductions
The episode opens with the hosts introducing themselves and setting the stage for a discussion about the Supreme Court and the recent election.
- 5:01Election Overview and Supreme Court Connection
Hosts recap the election results, celebrate the blue wave, and outline how the Supreme Court will be discussed in relation to the political shift.
- 30:00Supreme Court Distortions of Democracy
The hosts analyze how the Court has eroded democratic norms through campaign finance, voting rights, and gerrymandering, citing specific cases and decisions.
- 33:17Case Spotlight: St. Mary's Catholic Parish v. Roy
A detailed discussion of the oral arguments, legal theories, and implications of the case involving religious schools and anti‑discrimination law.
- 53:12Future of the Court and Democratic Accountability
Hosts discuss how the new political majority can use its power to hold the Court accountable and outline steps toward a more balanced judiciary.
- 57:47Closing Remarks and Call to Action
The show concludes with a summary of key points, encouragement to engage in reform efforts, and final sponsor messages.
- 59:46Episode Introduction and Host Greetings
The hosts open the show, set the stage for a discussion on the Supreme Court and recent elections.
- 1:00:56Corruption as a Voter Issue and Court Obstruction
The panel examines how corruption topped voter concerns and how the Supreme Court has blocked anti-corruption legislation.
- 1:01:51Supreme Court Reform: Institutionalist Perspective
The hosts discuss the need for Court reform, citing historical injustices and the importance of restoring democratic confidence.
- 1:17:32Game Segment: “This or That” and Political Satire
A light‑hearted game where the hosts choose between positive and negative political scenarios, highlighting recent election outcomes.
- 1:40:10Thank‑You Notes and Community Recognition
The hosts thank listeners, partners, and activists for their support and celebrate the blue wave victories.
Highlights
- 33:25
St. Mary Parish v. Roy Overviewinsight
The hosts break down the major Supreme Court case regarding Colorado's universal pre-K program and whether religious schools can take public funds while discriminating against LGBTQ+ parents.
- 35:27
Conceding the Right to Discriminatedata
Justice Sotomayor gets the attorney for St. Mary's to admit that their position permits Catholic schools to reject children simply because their parents are homosexual.
- 55:53
Collapsing Institutional Foundationsinsight
Guest Sherrilyn Eiffel explains that healthy democracies require shoring up cracked foundational institutions like the Supreme Court, rather than relying solely on electoral wins.
- 1:02:47
Lessons from Reconstruction Failuresstory
Sherrilyn Eiffel warns that ignoring the Supreme Court's historical gutting of the Fourteenth Amendment invites repeating the severe dislocation and second-class citizenship experienced by Black Americans.
- 1:11:03
Questioning Judicial Institutionalismdebate
Sherrilyn Eiffel challenges the label of institutionalism for Chief Justice John Roberts given ethical scandals, leaks, and unprecedented declines in public confidence.
- 1:32:00
Playing the Long Democracy Gameinsight
Sherrilyn Eiffel reflects on the multi-generational sacrifice required for civil rights progress, comparing current political patience to historical freedom movements.
Quotes
“The case, of course, is St. Mary Parish versus Roy, and it is about whether there is a constitutional right to use public funds that the taxpayers give you to discriminate against gay and trans people.”
Melissa Murray · 5:23 “If you let fascists go and don't hold them accountable, they come back worse and stronger, right?”
Leah Litman · 57:19 “The Supreme Court did these things. Supreme Court reform has to be on any pro-democracy agenda.”
Leah Litman · 23:23 “I know what 5,000 lynchings between the 1880s and the 1930s.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:02:30 “terrible pain and dislocation for people, and also the destruction of the core of our democracy.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:03:23 “People in a democracy have to believe in something.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:05:41 “That's why we feel sick, you know? And, and, and so I think, so I think.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:06:09 “We all know deans and other people have lost their jobs because of stuff like this.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:12:48
Sponsored segments
- Americans United for Separation of Church and State 0:00–0:50
- TrivaPro 0:56–1:17
- Smalls 12:31–14:31
- Mint Mobile 14:32–15:39
- Alloy Health 29:17–31:19
- Three Day Blinds 32:11–35:03
- Quince 50:22–52:20
- Crooked Media 1:43:05–1:44:13
- Coca-Cola 1:44:14–1:44:42
- Underdog 1:44:43–1:45:51
About this episode
Post-blue wave and on the eve of Crooked Con, Kate, Melissa, and Leah break down what went right on election night, and how the Supreme Court did its very best to prevent it by disenfranchising voters and enabling Trump’s lawlessness. Then, some executive branch news both welcome (see ya, Harmeet Dhillon) and horrifying (the ascension of Stephen Miller to chief of staff), before a breakdown of the biggest case SCOTUS heard last week. Is there a constitutional right to use public funds to discriminate against gay and trans people? Brett Kavanaugh seems to think so! Finally, Sherrilyn Ifill, founding director of the 14th Amendment Center for Law & Democracy at Howard University, joins to talk about one of the most important tasks for Democrats ahead: Court reform. Favorite things: Leah: Barrett Adair’s Election Night Instagram content https://www.instagram.com/barrettadair/?hl=en; Stacey Abrams https://bsky.app/profile/cockymf.bsky.social/post/3mzblvaxovs2l, Ayanna Pressley https://bsky.app/profile/ayannapressley.bsky.social/post/3mzbufgxh522m, Debbie Dingell https://bsky.app/profile/mediaite.com/post/3mzcmnri4ds2l, & Mallory McMorrow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ea7tDjiyXbotelling Haley Stevens to go pound sand and dragging her for filth; Governor elect Amy Acton not picking up the phone when Vivek called to concede and adding that she doesn’t plan to speak to him https://bsky.app/profile/headquartersnews.bsky.social/post/3mznsowoegm2g. Melissa: American Hagwon https://bookshop.org/p/books/american-hagwon-min-jin-lee/c4f5cd7b2ff52c1a, Min Jin Lee Kate: The Most Dangerous Way to Misread the Midterm Results https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/06/opinion/trump-era-blue-wave-democrats-midterms.html, M. Gessen Take the Strict Scrutiny survey https://crooked.com/strictsurvey. New Strict merch available here https://store.crooked.com/products/were-gonna-need-a-bigger-court-graphic-t-shirt. You can now listen to Strict Scrutiny for CLE credits in California, New York, Texas, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Washington, and Oregon! More info at crooked.com/strict_cle http://crooked.com/strict_cleGet tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE on November 6th in Washington, DC: Crookedcon.com http://crookedcon.com/Buy Melissa’s book,The U. S. Constitution: A Comprehensive and Annotated Guide for the Modern Reader https://bookshop.org/p/books/the-constitution-annotated-for-the-contemporary-reader-melissa-murray/8e7f0dfa472fc3ca?ean=9781668221938&next=t&Buy Leah’s book, Lawless https://bookshop.org/p/books/lawless-how-the-supreme-court-runs-on-conservative-grievance-fringe-theories-and-bad-vibes-leah-litman/5b562d6fcb316d6e?ean=9781668054642&next=t, now out in paperback Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/strictscrutinypodcast/?hl=en,Threads https://www.threads.net/@strictscrutinypodcast, andBluesky https://bsky.app/profile/strictscrutiny.bsky.socialFor a transcript of an episode of Strict Scrutiny please email transcripts@crooked.com mailto:transcripts@crooked.com
Transcript
16,707 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Mississippi
- Texas
- Voting Rights Act
- North Carolina
- Vote Save America
- New York Times
- Holy Trinity Episcopal School
- Fourteenth Amendment
- CrookedCon
- The 14th Amendment Center for Law and Democracy
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated