Skip to content

SCOTUS Kills Independent Agencies, Expands Presidential Power

Strict Scrutiny

Hosted by Kate Shaw, Leah Litman and Melissa Murray

53m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Strict Scrutiny hosts Kate Shaw, Leah Litman, and Melissa Murray break down three Supreme Court decisions issued the same day. The centerpiece is Trump v. Slaughter, a 6-3 ruling that overturns Humphrey's Executor and gives the president the power to fire the heads of every independent agency, with the sole exception of the Federal Reserve. The hosts dissect the opinion's reasoning as a triumph of the unitary executive theory and flag its reliance on a Lost Cause narrative about Andrew Johnson and the Tenure of Office Act, which they describe as channeling Confederate sympathizer Andrew Johnson as a constitutional hero.

The second case, Trump v. Cook (5-4), preserves Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook's job while she challenges her firing via a Truth Social post. Chief Justice Roberts explicitly cited protecting the nation's most important financial institution as the reason for reaching issues the lower courts had not addressed. The hosts note the inconsistency: the same court that found presidential removal power essential for accountability elsewhere drew the line at the Fed for purely economic reasons.

The third case, Watson v. RNC (5-4), held that federal election-day statutes do not prohibit states from counting absentee ballots cast by Election Day but received afterwards, preserving grace periods in roughly 30 states. Justice Barrett wrote the majority; Justice Alito's dissent included a screed against mail voting and excused Trump for generating election-integrity concerns.

  • The Slaughter decision overturns Humphrey's Executor, giving the president power to fire heads of all independent agencies except the Federal Reserve, and leaves open whether line officials within those agencies are also removable. 7:13
  • The court's Slaughter opinion relies on a Lost Cause narrative, portraying Confederate sympathizer Andrew Johnson as constitutionally correct in opposing the Tenure of Office Act. 26:24
  • Roberts explicitly cited protecting the nation's most important financial institution as the reason for reaching beyond the lower courts' rulings in the Cook case, making the economic rationale for the Fed exception the stated text. 39:50
  • Watson v. RNC held 5-4 that federal election-day statutes do not prohibit states from counting absentee ballots received after Election Day, preserving grace periods in roughly 30 states. 47:04
  • The court left unresolved whether the president can fire line officials within agencies, not just their heads, which the hosts describe as an invitation to further litigation. 8:26

Highlights

  • 7:13

    Slaughter Holding Explainedstrategy

    Kate Shaw explains the core holding: the president must have the power to remove any officer exercising significant executive power, and because all agencies exercise such power, Congress cannot insulate their heads from removal.

  • 12:49

    Monarchy Logic in the Opinioninsight

    The hosts describe the court's reasoning that the founders wanted to throw off a monarchy and that the only way to guard against one is a super-powerful president. Leah Litman summarizes it as 'George III may have been on to something and the founders were too woke.'

  • 26:24

    Lost Cause Narrative in Slaughterinsight

    Leah Litman explains that Roberts portrays Andrew Johnson, a Confederate sympathizer, as constitutionally correct in opposing the Tenure of Office Act, which was designed to protect Reconstruction. The hosts call it 'absolute boss level Southern grievances.'

  • 32:31

    Path Back to Spoils Systeminsight

    Kate Shaw argues the decision is a step toward reinstituting the spoils system, where government offices are awarded based on personal favors and political loyalty rather than merit, making government conducive to both incompetence and corruption.

  • 34:23

    Gorsuch Concurrence Goes Off the Railsdebate

    Kate Shaw confesses she initially thought Gorsuch's concurrence had something sensible to say, observing Congress didn't intend the president to have complete control over agencies. But it then pivots to arguing the administrative state should be dismantled entirely via nondelegation.

  • 39:50

    Roberts Admits the Economic Reasoninsight

    Roberts wrote that the court sees 'no reason to leave the public in limbo or to sow doubt as to the status of one of our nations and the world's most important financial institutions,' making the economic rationale for the Fed exception explicit rather than subtextual.

  • 47:04

    Five-to-Four Absentee Ballot Rulingdata

    The court came within one vote of overturning absentee ballot grace periods in roughly 30 states. Justice Barrett's majority held that federal election-day statutes say nothing about ballot receipt, while Alito's dissent included a screed against mail voting.

About this episode

In this emergency episode, Leah and Kate break down today’s incredibly consequential decisions in Trump v. Slaughter and Trump v. Cook, which followed the Project 2025 playbook to rewrite almost a century of precedent regarding presidential power. They also discuss how close the Court came to ruling that states can’t count absentee ballots that are cast by election day but received after election day in Watson v. RNC. Get tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE on November 6th in Washington, DC: Crookedcon.com http://Crookedcon.com Buy Melissa’s book,The U. S. Constitution: A Comprehensive and Annotated Guide for the Modern Reader https://bookshop.org/p/books/the-constitution-annotated-for-the-contemporary-reader-melissa-murray/8e7f0dfa472fc3ca?ean=9781668221938&next=t& Buy Leah’s book, Lawless https://bookshop.org/p/books/lawless-how-the-supreme-court-runs-on-conservative-grievance-fringe-theories-and-bad-vibes-leah-litman/5b562d6fcb316d6e?ean=9781668054642&next=t, now out in paperback Follow us onInstagram https://www.instagram.com/strictscrutinypodcast/?hl=en,Threads https://www.threads.net/@strictscrutinypodcast, andBluesky https://bsky.app/profile/strictscrutiny.bsky.social For a transcript of an episode of Strict Scrutiny, please email transcripts@crooked.com mailto:transcripts@crooked.com.

Transcript

0:00
53:39

9,446 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Separation of Powers
  • Unitary Executive Theory
  • Independent Agencies
  • Presidential Power
  • Federal Reserve
  • Election Law
  • Administrative State
  • Supreme Court

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated