SCOTUS Just Barely Preserves Birthright Citizenship
Hosted by Kate Shaw, Leah Litman and Melissa Murray
- 59m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In this emergency episode, hosts Leah Litman, Kate Shaw, and Melissa Murray react to the Supreme Court's 5-4 decision in Trump v. Barbara upholding birthright citizenship, along with two same-day rulings: West Virginia v. BPJ on trans athletes in sports and NRSC v. FEC on campaign finance. The central argument is that the 5-4 vote count is the real story, not the outcome—four justices are willing to say the 14th Amendment does not guarantee birthright citizenship, and Justice Kavanaugh's concurrence explicitly invites Congress to legislate it away. Melissa Murray frames the decision as "Dobbs, part two," arguing the issue is not settled and will be pursued through legislation. Justice Jackson's concurrence directly calls Justice Thomas's dissent a return to Dred Scott's core tenet, while Alito's solo dissent is described as reading like "a Fox News segment in Century Schoolbook font." On the trans sports case, the hosts dissect Kavanaugh's "because sports" reasoning and the 6-3 equal protection holding that carves out an exception for sex discrimination in athletics. The campaign finance decision allows a single individual to effectively give $551,300 to a candidate by striking down coordination limits. Both Litman and Murray say the term has radicalized them on court reform.
- The Court upheld birthright citizenship by only 5-4, meaning four justices are willing to say the 14th Amendment does not guarantee it, making this a crisis rather than a victory. 3:04
- Kavanaugh's concurrence says the Constitution itself does not mandate birthright citizenship, only a 1940s statute does, effectively inviting Congress to repeal it. 10:14
- Justice Jackson's concurrence directly calls Justice Thomas's dissent a return to Dred Scott's core tenet, calling the Reconstruction Amendments an anti-caste reset, not a spot treatment for slavery. 5:53
- The Court struck down campaign finance coordination limits, allowing a single individual to effectively give $551,300 to a candidate by routing money through party committees. 51:36
- Both Leah Litman and Melissa Murray state that this term has changed their minds on Supreme Court reform, calling it a pro-democracy measure that must be on the table. 55:33
Highlights
- 3:04
Constitution Exists by One Voteinsight
Melissa Murray opens by saying the Court held 5 to 4 that the Constitution exists, emphasizing that five people decided the proposition that the Constitution says what it says is meaningful.
- 5:53
Jackson Calls It Dred Scottdebate
Justice Jackson's concurrence quotes that the dissent proposes a return to Dred Scott's core tenet, and calls the Reconstruction Amendments an anti-caste, anti-subordination reset for the nation, not a mere spot treatment for slavery.
- 10:14
Kavanaugh Invites Congress to Actinsight
Melissa Murray explains that Kavanaugh's concurrence says Congress can repeal birthright citizenship tomorrow, effectively licensing the administration to pursue the same goal through legislation.
- 28:31
Jackson Takes Thomas to the Woodsheddebate
Justice Jackson's concurrence directly attacks Thomas's colorblind Constitution position, noting he now suggests the citizenship clause was only a race-conscious remedial measure for freed slaves, and lists a long catalogue of cases where his colorblindness harmed Black Americans.
- 32:30
Kate Shaw describes Alito's solo dissent as reading like a Fox News segment in Century Schoolbook font, noting it sneers about birth tourists and warns about the intensifying trend of the foreign-born population.
- 38:31
Because Sports, Because Biologyinsight
Kavanaugh's opinion uses the phrase "biological sex" seven times and argues Title IX protects against discrimination solely on the basis of biological sex in the sports context, with the hosts noting the reasoning is essentially "because sports."
- 51:36
$551,300 to a Single Candidatedata
Leah Litman explains that by striking down coordination limits, a single individual can now effectively give $551,300 to a candidate by routing money through national and state party committees, compared to the $7,000 direct contribution limit.
- 55:33
Court Reform as Pro-Democracy Measurestrategy
Melissa Murray says she was never fully on the court reform bandwagon but this term has broken even her, arguing that expanding the number of justices, limiting terms, or stripping jurisdiction must all be on the table.
About this episode
In their second emergency episode in two days, Leah, Melissa, and Kate break down the Court’s final day of the term and folks, it’s a doozy. We’ve got America’s preeminent “father of daughters” Coach Brett Kavanaugh’s majority opinion allowing states to exclude trans women and girls from female sports teams, a massive blow to campaign finance law, and the survival of birthright citizenship by the skin of the 14th Amendment’s teeth. To top it all off, we got an Alito retirement fakeout courtesy of NPR. Get tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE on November 6th in Washington, DC: Crookedcon.com http://Crookedcon.com Buy Melissa’s book, The U. S. Constitution: A Comprehensive and Annotated Guide for the Modern Reader https://bookshop.org/p/books/the-constitution-annotated-for-the-contemporary-reader-melissa-murray/8e7f0dfa472fc3ca?ean=9781668221938&next=t& Buy Leah’s book, Lawless https://bookshop.org/p/books/lawless-how-the-supreme-court-runs-on-conservative-grievance-fringe-theories-and-bad-vibes-leah-litman/5b562d6fcb316d6e?ean=9781668054642&next=t, now out in paperback Follow us onInstagram https://www.instagram.com/strictscrutinypodcast/?hl=en,Threads https://www.threads.net/@strictscrutinypodcast, andBluesky https://bsky.app/profile/strictscrutiny.bsky.social For a transcript of an episode of Strict Scrutiny please email transcripts@crooked.com mailto:transcripts@crooked.com
Transcript
10,793 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Birthright Citizenship
- Supreme Court
- Fourteenth Amendment
- Trans Rights
- Campaign Finance
- Court Reform
- Dred Scott
- Reconstruction Amendments
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated