Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! from SF Sketchfest 2015 About this episode Explore the Moon, asteroids and Mars from the stage of San Francisco’s Nourse Theater with Bill Nye, Eugene Mirman and guests astrophysicist Dr. Yvonne Pendleton, “Mars Czar” Dr. G. Scott Hubbard and comedian H. Jon Benjamin.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:18 Bill Nye? Greetings. Eugene, Eugene, we're on fire. Welcome, welcome, welcome. Tonight we have a fabulous show. We're gonna be talking about... Space.
0:31 Bill Nye? So our first guest tonight is, may I say, full disclosure? Wait, okay, that would take a long time. Some disclosure. He's a friend of mine. He is former director of the Ames Research Center here in the Bay Area. He was the first Mars program director. He developed the airbag assisted landing for rovers on Mars. He's on the board of the B-612 Foundation. You'll hear about that. He's the editor of New Space Magazine, and most importantly to me, so on the board of the Planetary Society. Ladies and gentlemen, Dr. Scott Hubbard. Doctor, so good to see you. One-armed guy hug, yes. Thank you. He's the Mars czar. The Mars czar. Well, wait, wait, there's more.
1:15 Bill Nye? Like so many of you, our next guest got her PhD in astrophysics. She's now the head of SIRV, which is a fabulous NASA acronym. She's advancing space science and human exploration into the solar system. Ladies and gentlemen, Dr. Yvonne Pendleton.
1:36 Eugene Mirman? And we have one more comic guest. It is my great pleasure to introduce. He plays my father on Bob's Burgers, and he is... The voice of Archer, ladies and gentlemen, H. John Benjamin.
1:51 Bill Nye? Wow. You got us a crowd, peoples.
1:54 Speaker 03 Yeah. Let's get this started!
2:01 Eugene Mirman? Sorry.
2:03 Bill Nye? Are there any questions on what we've covered so far?
2:07 Eugene Mirman? There will be a quiz.
2:10 Bill Nye? Let me ask you this, Dr. Pendleton, Yvonne.
2:13 Speaker 04 Yes.
2:13 Bill Nye? What is this ZRV?
2:16 Speaker 04 This acronym stands for the Solar System Exploration Research Virtual Institute. And what that means...
2:24 Bill Nye? What?
2:25 Speaker 04 And I did not pick the acronym, okay. But what this means is, we have researchers across the country, about 300 of them, but they communicate primarily, you know, through computers and using technology.
2:38 Bill Nye? Like the kids do.
2:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, and we... Yeah.
2:42 Eugene Mirman? Like using Snapchat?
2:46 Speaker 04 Something a little different, but we save a lot of money that way, and we get a lot of cross-team collaboration. So you get groups of people who would never really even go to the same meetings, talking to each other and getting new ideas and doing new science.
3:01 Speaker 03 I'm skeptical. No, no, not, I'm sorry.
3:05 Bill Nye? I am skeptical.
3:06 Speaker 03 That's my go-to thing to say, right. There's gonna be a lot of that.
3:12 Bill Nye? I am skeptical.
3:14 Speaker 03 Thank you.
3:16 Speaker 04 What are you skeptical about?
3:17 Bill Nye? It reminds me a little bit, in the future, the offices will have no paper. So there, you're saying you got 300 people, these are all in the US?
3:25 Speaker 04 These are in the US, we also have eight international partners.
3:28 Bill Nye? And what is, what is our goal at ZRV?
3:33 Speaker 04 So the goal is, instead of having a bricks-and-mortar institute that you had to build, you bring people together, and they're the best teams that you could make, regardless of where they are, geographically located or what. They might have a lab facility that another group wants to use, or something like that.
3:50 Bill Nye? What have we do, how long have we been in business?
3:53 Speaker 04 Well, ZRV has only been up and running for about a year, but it had its predecessor institute, which was only focused on the moon.
4:01 Eugene Mirman? Was that the University of Phoenix Online?
4:06 Bill Nye? No, when you say focused on the moon, it wasn't just telescopes.
4:11 Speaker 04 It wasn't just telescopes. It was the same thing. It was a virtual institute called the NASA Lunar Science Institute. And that was around for four years before survey came online. And before that, there was something that Scott Hubbard started, which is the NASA Astrobiology Institute, and it's still going. It's maybe 16 years? 16 years old. Teenager. Yeah. Teenager's doing science.
4:37 Bill Nye? You're an astrophysicist?
4:38 Speaker 04 Right.
4:39 Bill Nye? So were you working on the moon?
4:41 Speaker 04 Not exactly.
4:43 Bill Nye? How many people here are not astrophysicists? A couple, a couple.
4:48 Speaker 04 A few.
4:49 Bill Nye? But you guys aren't that into the moon, right? Generally, writ large.
4:52 Speaker 04 Not usually. We try to go observing when the moon is out of the way, you know? The connection is that I'm really interested in the origin of the basic building blocks of life, the things that make up all of you sitting in the audience and us sitting up here. And where did those come from? They came from the stars? And how did they evolve? And how did they get transported to a place like the Earth? So I studied comets and the stuff that comets bring a long time before I realized that we've got the moon right next door where those comets have been dumping that stuff for four and a half billion years. What a little place. Those bastards.
5:28 Bill Nye? Just dumping.
5:29 Speaker 04 Dumping it wherever they want.
5:33 Bill Nye? Okay. So I gotta say, from my own experience, I was very skeptical that there was water on the moon.
5:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
5:44 Bill Nye? Because...
5:45 Speaker 04 We didn't leave any?
5:48 Bill Nye? Right. And why wouldn't it all evaporate into the icy blackness of space? But your claim, or your observation, or they have found, you know them...
5:58 Speaker 04 It's proven, yes. That there's water on the moon? In many different forms. At least three different sources. Is one of the forms water?
6:10 Eugene Mirman? I think it has around three.
6:13 Speaker 04 Actually, not liquid.
6:15 Eugene Mirman? Not liquid.
6:16 Speaker 04 But we found ice in the bottom of the craters where, you know, you kind of expected it should be there.
6:21 Bill Nye? Bottles.
6:22 Speaker 04 But there is, there are the makings of water, OH radicals, oxygen, hydrogen, all over the surface of the moon, and that is getting interacted by, with the sun, the solar particles from the sun come, and they bring more hydrogen, and then you get water. So that's another way. And then there's a third part. But wait, there's more.
6:44 Bill Nye? Wait, there's more.
6:45 Speaker 04 Now...
6:46 Bill Nye? Okay, well, then one of those two, enumerate those two. First of all, H2O molecules.
6:50 Speaker 04 The ice inside the crater is ice.
6:52 Bill Nye? OHEs that get nailed with an H.
6:54 Speaker 04 That's the one on the surface, yeah.
6:56 Bill Nye? And they make some more H2Os. And now the third one.
6:59 Speaker 04 The third one. It turns out that the moon wasn't this dry body in the sky that we thought it was.
7:07 Bill Nye? Oh, no.
7:08 Speaker 04 No. And, and because the moon and the earth share a history, what we found, when we found water in the rocks on the moon, when Apollo astronauts picked up these rock samples, and later we were able to find out there was quite a bit of water in those rocks, we learned that those rocks came up from deep inside the moon, and it's because the earth was probably wet at the time when that big Mars-sized object hit the earth and created the moon, some of that water went to the moon.
7:37 Bill Nye? So, I look like nobody, but I've hit, I've touched a moon rock, right, okay?
7:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:43 Bill Nye? It's not wet. So, what's, what do you say, there's a lot of water in a moon rock? What are we talking about?
7:53 Speaker 04 You know, we get excited about a little tiny bit of water, we think is a lot, because we thought it was really dry. So instead of one part in a billion, there are six parts in a billion, or something like that.
8:04 Bill Nye? Hmm.
8:05 Eugene Mirman? But that would be enough for horses to live there.
8:11 Eugene Mirman? Like one horse. Yeah, one horse.
8:16 Bill Nye? So, we are all about, or my understanding is, you're trying to get humans to the moon, right?
8:22 Speaker 04 Well, it's not that we, Servey, are trying to get humans to the moon, but should humans want to go back to the moon, or near-Earth asteroids, or the moons of Mars, those are all the things we study, we could help tell you what you need to know before you go.
8:35 Eugene Mirman? That sounds great.
8:38 Eugene Mirman? Like what kind of stuff?
8:39 Speaker 04 Well, for instance, space is a pretty harsh environment, and so you need to know...
8:43 Eugene Mirman? As harsh as junior high or worse?
8:48 Bill Nye? So, we're gonna go, hypothetically, we're gonna go to the moon, and you're gonna give me a shopping list of stuff to take?
8:55 Speaker 04 What we would do is tell you what to wear, where to touch, and when to flush.
9:01 Eugene Mirman? Are you the Us Weekly of space travel?
9:07 Eugene Mirman? Who wore it best?
9:12 Bill Nye? And the whole, there's a whole outfit you gotta have.
9:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, it better have some metal on the outside of it, so that when you go up to that asteroid and you touch something, you know, you don't get zapped.
9:22 Bill Nye? Oh, is it static electricity?
9:23 Speaker 04 Well, the thing is, it's kinda complicated, but there are these plasmas in space, and when the plasma field is low...
9:32 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
9:32 Bill Nye? What is a plasma?
9:33 Eugene Mirman? Nice try, just saying plasmas in space like we all knew that.
9:38 Speaker 04 Well, just think of it as highly energetic particles that are going, zipping around you, and so there are places, for instance, on the moon, there are places where the solar wind comes across the moon's surface, and it can reduce the plasma field, and when the plasma field is reduced, then any rover that's, you know, its wheels are turning along the surface of the moon, it would need to have something to protect it so that you're grounded, once that plasma gets...
10:08 Bill Nye? Oh, so you're gonna get zapped?
10:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, so you're gonna get zapped.
10:10 Bill Nye? Your hair stands on end and...
10:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, and it turns out the same thing might be true for astronauts going up to an asteroid, they might need to have some sort of protection around their suit, so we're finding out stuff like that.
10:20 Bill Nye? So, I got one number in my notes, on the moon, 600 million tons of water?
10:25 Speaker 04 There are lots of numbers like that, that one, you know, various people will say...
10:30 Bill Nye? Seems like there's an infinite number, if I understand.
10:34 Speaker 04 Okay, peer-reviewed, published numbers. But the thing is, it's ongoing research, and I wouldn't stick with just one number right now because another study could come out soon that might say something different. I don't know. The point is, there's a whole lot more than we thought would be there. And why do you care? You care because water is a resource. I mean, it's something we all need, not just humans, to live, but, you know, if you want to make fuel to go somewhere else, like to Mars.
11:03 Bill Nye? Is this where finesse comes in?
11:05 Speaker 04 Finesse, that is a cool name for one of our teams that we have.
11:09 Bill Nye? So, now, Dr. Hubbard, you're on the NAC, for example, right?
11:14 Speaker 05 That's right. Not "the group."
11:16 Bill Nye? Oh, yeah. The NAC had one hit.
11:21 Eugene Mirman? My Sharona.
11:22 Bill Nye? Yeah, there he is. There he is.
11:25 Eugene Mirman? Yeah. I mean, science aside, you're in the band The NAC.
11:28 Speaker 05 That's right. I'm on the NASA Advisory Council.
11:33 Bill Nye? So, here's...
11:34 Speaker 05 Does it play music?
11:35 Bill Nye? Here's just the point I wanted to make.
11:36 Eugene Mirman? They also have a band.
11:37 Bill Nye? Dr. Hubbard, your NAC doesn't start with a K.
11:43 Speaker 05 No, it starts with an "N."
11:45 Bill Nye? But just notice that the NAC is an acronym within an acronym.
11:48 Speaker 05 It's an embedded acronym, the worst kind, yes.
11:51 Bill Nye? And so then, finesse is, as I understand it, Field Investigations to Enable Solar System Science and Exploration, right? Finesse is a program within your virtual institute.
12:03 Speaker 04 Right. We have nine teams, and that's one of them, and that one is run out of NASA Ames Research Center.
12:10 Speaker 03 Wait, so finesse is an acronym, too? Finesse?
12:13 Bill Nye? Finesse is an acronym.
12:14 Eugene Mirman? Inside NASA, inside Ames.
12:16 Speaker 04 Inside SERVI.
12:17 Eugene Mirman? Inside SERVI.
12:18 Speaker 04 Yeah. We love our acronym.
12:21 Bill Nye? Russian dolls of letters.
12:23 Eugene Mirman? Yeah. Just so that no one can cut funding, because they just, how would you even know where to start? [laughter]
12:31 Speaker 03 He has finally figured it out.
12:33 Speaker 04 That's good, I like that.
12:35 Speaker 03 We need more acronyms.
12:37 Bill Nye? What has Finesse done? What is it doing that enables? It's human, you were trying to enable human exploration, is that right?
12:44 Speaker 04 We are. We're trying to address science questions that human exploration needs to know the answers to. And so what Finesse is doing is looking at analog sites on the Earth that would be comparable to, you know, where you might be exploring on an asteroid or on the moon.
13:01 Bill Nye? E.G. Exempligradia. For example?
13:04 Speaker 04 Oh, well, in Idaho, there's a Craters of the Moon place in Idaho.
13:09 Bill Nye? That's a state park, or a national park.
13:11 Speaker 04 Yep, and they go there and they do remote sensing with their robots and things. They have their scientists in what they call the back room, so that if you were on the moon and you were doing this robotically, you wouldn't be able to just run out and turn a switch. So they make themselves do all that kind of stuff here, and they try to figure out, you know, well, what would you really have to do if you were on the surface of the moon and this happened or that happened? Or what would you have to do if you're going up to, you know, a big boulder on an asteroid?
13:40 Bill Nye? Yeah. And so, do you also mess around with those delays?
13:44 Speaker 04 They do, they build that in as well, right?
13:47 Speaker 03 What are the delays?
13:48 Speaker 04 The time delay, so that, you know, when you send a message up to the moon and it comes back, it takes like three seconds, and it turns out that there's a natural built-in computer delay that is almost that long, going, you know, like, across the world, so...
14:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, we gotta fix that.
14:07 Bill Nye? But the speed of light's still an issue, yeah.
14:10 Speaker 04 Yeah.
14:11 Bill Nye? Even at the institute.
14:13 Speaker 03 Gotta finesse it.
14:14 Speaker 04 We can't solve everything, yeah.
14:16 Bill Nye? So, what is in the solar wind that we're all, we always talk about the solar wind?
14:20 Speaker 04 Electrons and protons, and hydrogen. And so when the hydrogen comes out...
14:24 Bill Nye? Well, hydrogen is a proton, yeah.
14:25 Speaker 04 Exactly, so, I mean, so we use those terms interchangeably, but with you, I know I could just say hydrogen, right? But electrons and protons are coming through.
14:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, but with me, you can't.
14:37 Bill Nye? So, is there some scheme that you guys work at, work on, they're finessing, to scrape up O-Hs and Hify them into H2O?
14:48 Speaker 04 You know, that particular team isn't working on that particular problem, but that is the kind of thing that new teams that come into SURVEY in the future might actually decide to address. So what we do is we provide funding for five years for the current teams, but in another year, we're gonna have another competition, and new teams are gonna come in and join the old ones, so that you always have this memory, corporate memory going on.
15:13 Bill Nye? So when you say "funding," what are my tax dollars doing?
15:17 Speaker 04 So NASA provides the funding for SURVEY, for these teams, and it's both the Science Mission Directorate and the Human Exploration part of NASA. And so they together give the funds to us at the central office.
15:31 Bill Nye? But how much money is it? A hundred dollars?
15:32 Speaker 04 About fifteen million a year.
15:34 Bill Nye? Fifteen million. What?
15:35 Speaker 04 Okay, and the teams only get, you know, there are nine teams, so they get some smaller part of it, right?
15:42 Speaker 03 So you split it nine ways?
15:43 Speaker 04 Yeah. They get most of it, because, you know, we're a virtual institute, so we don't need a lot to run the central office. And so we fund them, and then they have to report back to us what they're doing. And I'm just amazed at how productive these teams have been. In less than a year, there are many hundreds of peer-reviewed publications that have already come out of these teams.
16:03 Bill Nye? Go SURVEY is what I'm getting.
16:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
16:06 Bill Nye? So...
16:07 Speaker 04 It's a lot of banker bucks.
16:08 Bill Nye? What a she-bear you are.
16:41 Bill Nye? If the earth gets hit with an asteroid, even a small one, like the size of the stage, for those of you on the radio, it's not that big. It would be very troubling. Is that accurate?
16:55 Speaker 05 I would say so, yes. If an asteroid the size... Asteroid the size of the stage hits San Francisco... If it hit the stage... Right here, what would happen? You would be obliterated. You would be atoms. We would be, but how, but sure, that...
17:09 Bill Nye? That would be a relief, let's be honest.
17:11 Speaker 05 But how far would it go? And the first ten rows, no, this entire, this entire section of San Francisco...
17:18 Bill Nye? So even the balcony?
17:18 Speaker 05 ...would be turned to atoms. But meaning for what, ten miles, five miles, a hundred miles? Well, it depends on how big the thing is. If we had something that was about, let's say, fifty feet, would you buy that? Okay, fifty feet, you know? Seventeen meters, that's the size of the thing that blew up over Chelyabinsk in Russia two years ago. And it damaged about a thousand homes. It blew up at sixty thousand feet. It was like an airburst coming down. And about eleven hundred people were sent to the hospital. And if that had gotten all the way to the ground...
17:57 Bill Nye? Nobody died.
17:58 Speaker 05 Nobody died, but if that...
18:00 Bill Nye? So we're fine?
18:02 Speaker 05 As long as it doesn't get to the ground. Well, what happens if it hits the ground?
18:05 Bill Nye? So it has to be bigger in order to get to the ground?
18:07 Speaker 05 Yeah, it depends on what it's made of and how it comes in and a whole bunch of...
18:11 Bill Nye? What angle?
18:12 Speaker 05 Physics stuff. Sure, but what happens when it hits the ground? If it had gotten all the way to the ground, it would have been the equivalent of something that would be in thousands of kilotons.
18:24 Bill Nye? Hiroshima, Nagasaki kind of deal?
18:26 Speaker 05 Smaller than that, but still... But enough to create...
18:29 Bill Nye? How long would...
18:30 Speaker 05 Mothra.
18:34 Speaker 05 Against Godzilla, you know, not so good, but...
18:37 Bill Nye? So...
18:38 Speaker 05 But in 1908, the famous Tunguska event happened.
18:43 Eugene Mirman? Not so famous, because I'm...
18:44 Speaker 05 Okay, that was...
18:46 Bill Nye? 30th of June.
18:47 Speaker 05 Another thing that happened in Russia, in Siberia, unfortunately, it only flattened a couple hundred miles worth of trees and a few reindeer, but if that had hit here, it would have wiped out the entire Bay Area.
19:02 Eugene Mirman? So that was Russia as well?
19:03 Speaker 05 Yes.
19:04 Eugene Mirman? So asteroids only hit Russia?
19:05 Bill Nye? Well, John, that's...
19:07 Speaker 05 And tornadoes only happen in trailer parks.
19:13 Bill Nye? That's pretty good. Dr. Hubbard, you're from Kentucky, right?
19:16 Speaker 05 I know from where I speak.
19:18 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah. No, so, but John, you raise a good point. Just if you are...
19:23 Eugene Mirman? Finally.
19:23 Bill Nye? ...an asteroid...
19:26 Bill Nye? You're an asteroid and you're gonna come in from the north, human map north. It's a good chance you'll hit Russia. It's 11 time zones across. The Chelyabinsk blew up, it was about 2 and 1/2 minutes or almost 3 minutes before the sonic boom hit the ground, right? Everybody ran to the windows to watch it and the wham.
19:43 Speaker 05 Yeah, right.
19:44 Bill Nye? But if you get just a little bigger, you're saying Chelyabinsk was 17 meters?
19:49 Speaker 05 Thereabouts.
19:49 Bill Nye? Yeah, what if you get into the 30 and 50 meters, like the size of a football field?
19:54 Eugene Mirman? Putin would just punch it.
19:58 Speaker 05 It blew his shirt off, that's why he was...
20:03 Speaker 05 So if you're in, a size of asteroid's in the miles...
20:08 Bill Nye? 5/8 of a mile up to a mile kind of size.
20:10 Speaker 05 Exactly. Then you're talking extinction event, as in what happened to the dinosaurs 60 million years ago.
20:16 Bill Nye? Everything going bad for everybody.
20:18 Speaker 05 10, 20, 30 kilometers.
20:21 Eugene Mirman? So we'd become like birds and kimono dragons.
20:24 Speaker 05 Only the cockroaches would survive, I don't know. And then if you get down to the 100 meter-ish, 300 feet or so, you're talking about cataclysms that are city killers. And then down to the 30, 50 meter range, you have tsunamis.
20:42 Bill Nye? This sounds like science fiction, but it's a real deal.
20:45 Speaker 05 Yes.
20:45 Bill Nye? I mean, and...
20:46 Speaker 05 There are maybe a million of these near-Earth objects.
20:50 Bill Nye? There you go, Eugene.
20:51 Eugene Mirman? That's thousands.
20:53 Bill Nye? It's a thousand thousand.
20:55 Eugene Mirman? Technically.
20:55 Bill Nye? It's a thousand thousand, that's what it is.
20:57 Speaker 05 A thousand thousand.
20:58 Eugene Mirman? There's millions of them headed for Russia.
21:03 Eugene Mirman? And a handful towards Texas.
21:06 Bill Nye? But here's the thing, it could be, this is, you know, people speculate, why haven't we heard from another civilization? People do bring that up, yes?
21:13 Eugene Mirman? I've never.
21:14 Bill Nye? And it may be that you have to pass the asteroid test, right? That if you don't have a space program and a virtual institute, for example, or an astrobiological institute, biology institute, you accidentally let yourself get hit with a big rock and everybody dies, it's like...
21:33 Speaker 05 The reasons the dinosaurs went extinct is that they didn't have a space program.
21:37 Bill Nye? As far as we know.
21:39 Speaker 05 Right?
21:43 Bill Nye? We want to be, we want to know a lot about asteroids, right?
21:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, I'd like to tell you that.
21:48 Bill Nye? And you messed around with Rosetta, didn't you?
21:50 Speaker 04 Well, before we go to Rosetta, I'd just like to tell you that not all asteroids are those big, heavy metal kind that we're talking about. And what we're finding out is some of them are big rubble piles. And if you go up to them too fast, or you touch them too hard, they're going to disintegrate into a whole bunch of little pieces. But something is holding them together, and the little ones are spinning fast.
22:12 Eugene Mirman? Is it dark matter?
22:13 Speaker 04 And it is, I'm pretty sure it's not dark matter, but...
22:16 Bill Nye? Is it roxy?
22:18 Eugene Mirman? Why wouldn't anyone tell me what dark matter is?
22:24 Speaker 04 So anyhow, my point is that this is why we have to study these ahead of time, because you don't want to find one coming towards you and go out after it to try and mitigate whatever's going to happen.
22:34 Bill Nye? Mitigate's the same as Bruce Willis, kind of thing?
22:37 Speaker 04 Yeah. And go up and touch it and find it's going to break up into big chunks that are all going to come and hit the Earth.
22:43 Speaker 05 As, as they say, you can't deflect them if you can't find them.
22:48 Bill Nye? You know, they say that.
22:49 Eugene Mirman? That's unfortunate that they say that.
22:53 Speaker 05 Imagine that you're, you know, looking for a piece of charcoal against the black sky, you know, how would you find that? Well, turns out, if you're looking away from the sun, the sun's heating it up, it's glowing because it's hot and so you could look in the infrared, you can find these guys.
23:08 Bill Nye? Now, when you say glowing and hot, Scott, I've had, I think maybe many of us have experienced a barbecue cookout.
23:15 Speaker 05 Right.
23:16 Bill Nye? It's not, it's not like that, is it?
23:18 Speaker 05 No, but it is much warmer than the blackness.
23:20 Bill Nye? Let me throw some numbers out here.
23:22 Speaker 05 Uh, probably, uh, 300 Kelvin.
23:24 Bill Nye? 300 Kelvin? That's like us.
23:27 Speaker 05 Yeah.
23:28 Bill Nye? Yeah.
23:29 Speaker 05 Cause it's warmed by the sun.
23:30 Bill Nye? Wow. Uh, Kelvin, anyone?
23:32 Speaker 05 250, 300.
23:33 Bill Nye? Yeah, he's a good guy.
23:37 Bill Nye? Zero Celsius is 273 Kelvin.
23:40 Speaker 05 Right, yeah, so we're talking.
23:41 Bill Nye? 273 degrees Celsius.
23:42 Speaker 05 We're talking, you know, 60, 70...
23:45 Bill Nye? So, it's as hot as a regular old day on an asteroid?
23:49 Speaker 05 The, the side facing...
23:51 Bill Nye? Facing the sun, so you wanna get in?
23:53 Speaker 05 You need a space telescope.
23:54 Bill Nye? Oh, tell, do you have one?
23:56 Speaker 05 I just so have... It just so happens, I have the plans here.
24:02 Bill Nye? You do, though, right? It's called Sentinel.
24:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's called Sentinel. And it's a, in fact, this was not, uh, invented out of nothing, a National Academy of Sciences about six years ago said, "If you wanna find these things before they hit the earth, put a telescope out in deep space, maybe where Venus is, and look out there with the right size of telescope in the infrared where it's glowing, uh, because of the sunlight, and you can find these. Can't find them from the ground, too much atmosphere."
24:30 Bill Nye? Are you guys at the institute working on this?
24:32 Speaker 04 Uh, we don't have a telescope and we don't have, uh, the means to fund a telescope. 15 million dollars a year won't do it.
24:38 Eugene Mirman? What if we got rid of healthcare, would that help?
24:43 Bill Nye? Briefly.
24:46 Speaker 04 But the thing is, if you don't find the asteroid that's coming to hit us, you won't need the healthcare.
24:50 Bill Nye? From time to time, the last few months or a year, people at NASA, the asteroid redirect mission. Now, the asteroid redirect mission, the plan is to go out and get an asteroid, a small one, charming one. And this thing, as I recall, is seven meters, which is not very big. I mean, as things go. If seven meter, seven meter rock hits the earth, nothing happens. It just burns up, yeah?
25:18 Speaker 04 Well, the idea about studying the asteroid, if you do bring it back, or if you bring a boulder from an asteroid back, is really more about the technology that would be involved in learning how to do all the things you want to do with it, as much as anything else.
25:33 Bill Nye? Okay. This sounds like, I mean, the technology that Bruce Willis needed, for example, would be a lot bigger and more importantly catastrophically huge than this little thing.
25:47 Speaker 05 Ah, well, so if I put on my Professor Hubbard hat from Stanford.
25:52 Bill Nye? At Stanford.
25:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, at Stanford. But also from Berkeley. The, I, if I were to give the ARM mission grade, I would have to give it a D.
26:03 Bill Nye? That's not very good.
26:04 Speaker 05 Why? Well, the reason it's not an F is because there are...
26:09 Bill Nye? Oh, cool.
26:10 Speaker 05 It's because...
26:10 Bill Nye? You know how often I ask that question?
26:12 Speaker 05 Why isn't it a C minus? Is because there are two technologies that are very useful if we want to send humans to Mars, which is everybody, is the horizon goals, where we want to go. And that's the solar electric propulsion for pushing stuff around.
26:28 Bill Nye? How does that work?
26:29 Speaker 05 Well, you bring in sunlight and you use a certain type of gas. You create one of these plasma things.
26:36 Bill Nye? With xenon?
26:37 Speaker 05 Yeah, xenon, yes. The warrior princess or something? Yeah.
26:44 Speaker 05 But the ARM mission, in my opinion, and it's now shared by the NASA Advisory Council, is that...
26:53 Bill Nye? Coincidence?
26:54 Speaker 05 Pretty cocky. Perhaps. Pretty cocky. We, we, we took a vote and, you know, wrote, and wrote it down, and it has nothing to do with science. There were two of us there. Yeah, you know.
27:09 Speaker 05 And it has very little to do with human exploration. And it has almost nothing to do with planetary defense. And it'll probably go up in cost by a factor of pi. Other than that, it's fine.
27:20 Bill Nye? Factor of pi, like 3 and some change.
27:22 Speaker 05 Yes.
27:22 Bill Nye? So I have here the asteroid redirect mission recommendation by the NAC thing. Let's see. "There's a risk in meeting the full set of requirements. It includes capturing an asteroid, which should cause the ARM cost cap to be exceeded." Has anybody ever exceeded a cost cap here? Anyone? Yeah. Is that English? Yeah, so...
27:44 Speaker 05 We worked hard on that.
27:45 Bill Nye? It means maxing out your credit card. Yes.
27:48 Speaker 05 Yes.
27:49 Bill Nye? A little more than that.
27:49 Speaker 05 Only in this case, the cost cap is $1.25 billion.
27:54 Bill Nye? The budgetary goalposts moving in budget overruns that will threaten other programs. That's a reason to not do it.
28:01 Speaker 05 Yeah. Preserve the two technologies. If you're sending humans to Mars, could be very useful. The other stuff, I don't find the rationale personally for doing.
28:12 Bill Nye? Well, you weren't alone. The whole council said this is madness or not the best idea. You guys both were comet asteroids from two different directions.
28:22 Speaker 04 We're trying to study them to find out what they're made of and how they formed.
28:25 Bill Nye? And Scott, you're trying to find them.
28:27 Speaker 05 Sentinel is going to look out there and find the million that could be a threat.
28:32 Bill Nye? And so we can pass the asteroid test if we can figure out something akin to the asteroid redirect mission that would actually be useful.
29:04 Bill Nye? We have studied asteroids using the Rosetta spacecraft.
29:09 Speaker 04 I love the Rosetta mission. I think it's so cool.
29:11 Bill Nye? What did you love about it?
29:12 Speaker 04 Well, it's a comet. And they landed on a comet. That is so hard. And it was amazing.
29:17 Speaker 05 A comet is not an asteroid, right?
29:19 Speaker 04 No.
29:19 Speaker 05 No.
29:20 Speaker 04 A comet has a lot of ice in it.
29:22 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
29:22 Speaker 04 Asteroids, it turns out, have... Some asteroids have a little bit of ice. So we've got asteroids that are starting to act like comets and comets that look a little bit more like asteroids. So, you know, we say they're different. They are different. They come from two different regions of the solar system, but... They have some similarities. And they both hit the Earth.
29:40 Bill Nye? As the kids say, it's a spectrum.
29:42 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
29:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
29:43 Speaker 04 There you go.
29:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's some asteroids that are born as comets.
29:46 Speaker 04 Right.
29:51 Bill Nye? But can't change themselves.
29:52 Speaker 04 No, they can't morph.
29:53 Bill Nye? Yeah. So, but asteroids, if I understand it, are the closer to the sun part of the solar system, and comets are from the farther from the sun part of the solar system.
30:02 Speaker 03 Right. But in the Oort Cloud.
30:04 Bill Nye? The Oort Cloud.
30:05 Speaker 04 Or the Kuiper Belt.
30:06 Bill Nye? Kuiper Belt.
30:07 Speaker 03 Oh, so it's where they came from, that's where, okay.
30:09 Speaker 04 Well, because where they came from determines what they're made of, because way, way far out there, you know, beyond Pluto, we're gonna visit Pluto, you know, we're gonna get there on July 15th of this year, we're gonna fly right by it.
30:20 Bill Nye? You guys know that? Yeah, all of us.
30:24 Bill Nye? Well, actually, John, in a sense, yes, everyone, everyone on Earth will be involved in this, so.
30:30 Speaker 04 Yeah.
30:32 Bill Nye? Dr. Hubbard, you and I crossed paths from time to time. Were you at the launch of New Horizons?
30:38 Speaker 03 No.
30:38 Bill Nye? 2006, January of 2006. You were there, yes, we partied.
30:41 Speaker 04 Yeah.
30:42 Bill Nye? Yes. We did, we did, on the deck there.
30:45 Speaker 04 I think we did, actually.
30:45 Bill Nye? Yeah. So, you guys, I am not an expert on rocket launches, but...
30:51 Speaker 03 But you know when you partied in 2006.
30:54 Bill Nye? Yeah.
30:55 Speaker 03 New Horizons is in Jamaica, right?
30:59 Speaker 03 Where everyone wears no clothes and they, yeah, yeah.
31:03 Bill Nye? This is a NASA party, it's a little different vibe.
31:06 Speaker 03 Like sandals.
31:07 Bill Nye? Yeah. But, if I may, in all seriousness, New Horizons is the name of the mission, and mission is space people talk for rocket ship. And so, I, as you may know, on the Science Guy Show, I went to a space shuttle launch. There's a huge freaking rocket, and this is radio, our most visual medium.
31:34 Speaker 03 It was a windy day.
31:39 Bill Nye? It took it a long time, there was no sock, no foam rubber thing on the microphone. So it took noticeable amount of time to get up through the clouds and up into space. But then, New Horizons in 2006 was like, shoo, and it was gone. It was the fastest rocket anybody's ever shot. The asteroids, astronauts who went to the moon went two and a half days to get there, something like that. This thing went past the moon in nine hours.
32:08 Eugene Mirman? Wow.
32:08 Bill Nye? And yeah, your tax dollars at work.
32:11 Speaker 04 And it's been going ever since.
32:12 Bill Nye? Yeah, and it's been going even faster than that because it went by Jupiter and got a shoo, a little, but it's in space, so it just went, uh, past Jupiter.
32:26 Bill Nye? It will arrive in the vicinity of Pluto, Bastille Day, depending on your time zone, 14th and 15th of July of this year. And we will finally get a look at Pluto.
32:36 Speaker 04 Right.
32:37 Bill Nye? And we can all then take a meeting about what actually goes on on Pluto. Icy cloud, watery thing, solid rock.
32:44 Speaker 04 Let me tell you about the resolution you will see, though. It's the equivalent of if New Horizons were passing that close to Earth with its instruments, it would be able to see the buildings or the skyline of Manhattan, or any city. So it's that.
32:58 Eugene Mirman? So it'll find all the cities on Pluto.
32:59 Speaker 04 You'll find all the cities.
33:03 Bill Nye? The ones, the big ones, yeah.
33:05 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, things like New York.
33:09 Eugene Mirman? It won't see like Burlington, Vermont.
33:14 Eugene Mirman? It could, no, it wouldn't find the band Phish jamming.
33:19 Bill Nye? The thing that's gonna be extraordinary are the pictures, right? And the thing that has always, I've found so compelling, it makes me so crazy, are the pictures of Mars. And because Mars is a place, I mean if you were dressed properly, your suit, you could walk around, you could have a picnic. And along with some other things that Dr. Hubbard has done, you wrote a book, Explore Mars.
33:44 Speaker 05 Yes, and the foreword was written by, I had some guy named Bill Nighy.
33:49 Bill Nye? The foreword really is brilliant.
33:51 Eugene Mirman? I generally buy books in fact for the foreword.
33:55 Bill Nye? But the significance of pictures is huge in our scientific understanding of things, right?
34:02 Speaker 05 It carries such a vast amount of information and our eye-brain combination is so good at integrating that into an understanding. I mean you go from just an image to understanding in a blink, so to speak.
34:14 Bill Nye? Along this line, what is next for the Virtual Institute? And what is next on Mars? What are we trying to achieve in both of these things?
34:25 Speaker 04 We would really like to understand what you need to know before you go. And so that means that you want, if you're going to send humans beyond low Earth orbit again, whether it's to the moon or to near Earth asteroids or to the moons of Mars and then eventually Mars, you want them to go with the knowledge of what they need to take with them, what they're going to find when they get there, how to protect themselves along the way from radiation, that kind of stuff. That's what our institute's all about, what do they need to know before they go.
34:58 Bill Nye? We have four rovers on Mars. Dr. Hubbard, you worked on the first three.
35:04 Speaker 05 Right, and Opportunity is still operating after 10 years later. Imagine that.
35:09 Bill Nye? You guys, I mean it's amazing.
35:12 Speaker 05 The warranty, the warranty was only good for 90 days.
35:16 Bill Nye? I know, 90, so you guys, it's like, it's really, it's like if you had a car with a three-year warranty and you didn't change the oil, didn't rotate the tires for 120 years, that would be, that's a bargain, right?
35:30 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, it's like the original Chevys.
35:35 Bill Nye? That's your tax dollars at work.
35:37 Speaker 05 Yeah. The next step is a sample return because we've done the flyby, we've done the orbiter, we've got rovers, we've got still Opportunity and Curiosity is operating.
35:49 Bill Nye? Yeah, huge thing.
35:50 Speaker 05 And the next step is now that we've got all this information is to go and pick that piece of Mars that will tell us, are we alone? You know, is that piece of Mars that we pick, we bring back and we see evidence of past life?
36:04 Bill Nye? So why do we have to bring it back?
36:06 Speaker 05 Ah, there's a bunch of reasons.
36:07 Eugene Mirman? How else could you put it in your mouth?
36:09 Speaker 05 Yeah. You can't taste it.
36:14 Bill Nye? There you go. Have you thought about getting him at the institute?
36:20 Speaker 04 I won't now.
36:21 Eugene Mirman? Can I come and taste all the different things you get from space?
36:26 Speaker 05 Can you get high from it? Yeah. Right. So imagine if you've got samples here, and we've done this with the samples that the astronauts brought back from the moon, instead of having 10 scientists look at it, can have thousands of scientists look at it. Instead of one moving laboratory, you have dozens of laboratories all over the world. And that's the power of looking at a sample.
36:48 Speaker 04 And 10 years, or 15 or 20 years in the future, you can use the new technology and the new instruments to look at those same samples if you took good care of them.
36:58 Speaker 05 Yeah, and find new stuff. Like the water in these rocks. You know, when I was in charge of the lunar prospector mission, we said it was a cup of water and a cubic yard of dirt was what we found in those shadowed craters.
37:11 Bill Nye? That would be detectable, though, yeah.
37:12 Speaker 05 But what they found from these old lunar samples that people brought back from the Apollo mission was this parts per billion that nobody even knew was there. And that would not have happened if we didn't have the samples.
37:27 Eugene Mirman? How hard would it be to take the water that does exist on the moon and access it to make water that we could realistically use?
37:34 Speaker 05 The stuff that is in the shadowed craters would probably be easier, but you could probably mine the other stuff. But by comparison, Mars has maybe tens of billions of gallons of water. I mean, there are places on Mars that are 80% water ice. And so you just stick in a shovel and warm it up, and there you go, you've got water.
37:58 Bill Nye? Boom, done. So to get the sample, this thing... It's taking a long time. We only do this every, we only go every 26 months because of the orbits of Earth and Mars. So what is the next thing? We gotta get a 2020 rover.
38:13 Speaker 05 Right.
38:13 Bill Nye? Which will be like the Curiosity rover, which landed in 2012. 10 years later, or 8 years later, will land on Mars. Does it land in 2020?
38:21 Speaker 05 It launches in 2020.
38:22 Bill Nye? Launches in 2020, so it lands in 2021 and a half.
38:26 Speaker 05 Yeah, end of 2020, beginning, it depends on the specific.
38:29 Bill Nye? Yeah, it depends, okay, so.
38:31 Speaker 05 But.
38:31 Bill Nye? That thing's gonna get a sample.
38:32 Speaker 05 It's going to cache a sample.
38:35 Bill Nye? C A C H E.
38:36 Speaker 05 C A C H E, yes, it's gonna put in somewhere between 20 and 40 little sort of chalk-sized chunks of Mars, picked from a bunch of different places.
38:46 Bill Nye? Cause it's driving around picking them up.
38:47 Speaker 05 Cause it's moving around.
38:48 Bill Nye? Then what happens?
38:49 Speaker 05 Then the second.
38:50 Bill Nye? They're sitting there on Mars.
38:51 Speaker 05 Yeah, so then if you had the budget all lined up, then 2 years after that, you'd send something that would orbit, and then 2 years after that, you'd send the lander that would go out, grab that sample, that little ball, that cache, and put it in a rocket, the rocket would point at the sky and fire, and the ball would go up.
39:12 Bill Nye? Carefully.
39:13 Speaker 05 And rendezvous with the waiting orbiter and bring it back. So it's gonna be 2026 or 2028.
39:20 Bill Nye? This is the Mars ascent vehicle.
39:22 Speaker 05 The Mars, the M A V.
39:23 Bill Nye? The M A V.
39:24 Eugene Mirman? So basically, in around 2029 or 2030 is when we would get stuff.
39:30 Speaker 05 That's right.
39:30 Eugene Mirman? That when we'd get to really look at this one.
39:32 Bill Nye? Get a taste.
39:32 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, get a taste of Mars.
39:34 Speaker 05 Taste of Mars.
39:34 Eugene Mirman? Then I could finally open my little bistro taste of Mars. Where I'd have one rock from Mars and everyone would put it in their mouth and put it back down.
39:44 Bill Nye? So couldn't we just go there right now? If we had the chain, the coin, the money? Couldn't, I mean, do we need to know more about it to land there?
39:55 Speaker 05 You mean to do the sample return mission?
39:56 Bill Nye? No.
39:58 Speaker 05 To send you?
39:59 Bill Nye? Yeah, well, yeah, I'm not really, somebody's qualified. Would go there and walk around with a hammer and look for signs of life, right?
40:09 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, maybe Richard Dreyfuss.
40:13 Bill Nye? No, because this is an old thing, and I think, Dr. Ober, I've heard you speak about this. What our very best robots do in a week, a human can do in about a minute.
40:24 Speaker 05 That's right.
40:25 Bill Nye? Is that right?
40:25 Speaker 05 That's right, yeah. If you take a really good field astrobiologist and say, "Go over there and tell me what that rock is," he or she will look around and say, "Oh, okay, pick it up, use the rock hammer, break it open, look at it in the microscope," and "Gerocite, ha!"
40:41 Bill Nye? Gerocite!
40:42 Speaker 05 Yeah, perfect, just in a minute. It takes the spirit, opportunity, curiosity, rovers, all the commands and all the work they had to do, on the order of days, to accomplish the same thing.
40:55 Eugene Mirman? Is it significantly more expensive to send people because of how you have to keep them alive?
41:00 Speaker 05 Yeah, so you're, so assuming you want to keep them alive... They've all died. Yeah.
41:06 Eugene Mirman? But meaning then, like, the three or four trips over a period of like, basically like sixteen years or something?
41:12 Speaker 05 Yeah, so if you were, if you had ten to a hundred times more money...
41:16 Bill Nye? Oh, just a second, ten to a hundred, that's a range.
41:20 Speaker 05 It is. Because, you know, I mean, do you want to just have linoleum in your spacecraft? Or, you know, a really nice...
41:26 Eugene Mirman? No, you would have really nice, like, Victorian doors.
41:32 Eugene Mirman? We would send a very fancy spaceship.
41:35 Speaker 05 I mean, do you want real mahogany or veneer?
41:38 Bill Nye? Yeah, stuff like that.
41:39 Speaker 05 Important decisions, so, yeah, because it's very difficult to compare the generic robotic mission with the generic human exploration mission, but sending humans, because of the life support and all the other issues, is at least ten times, maybe as much as a hundred times more expensive.
41:57 Eugene Mirman? So, meaning we could do it in three years if somebody was like, "Here's nineteen million dollars"?
42:02 Speaker 05 If you had, if you had, well, Jeff Bezos just wrote a blank check.
42:05 Bill Nye? Jeff Bezos of Amazon.
42:06 Eugene Mirman? Should we try texting him? Has anyone just texted?
42:14 Speaker 05 So if you had, you know, at your disposal, you know, many, many tens of billions of dollars, and you didn't care how you spent it, you didn't need to spread it out like the government does, because they have a year-to-year budget. Right. And you could just have one big glob of money, you could do it in a single mission.
42:34 Bill Nye? So a mission.
42:35 Speaker 05 That's why you have to wait.
42:36 Eugene Mirman? And how much would that mission cost? Like, maybe we could do a Kickstarter.
42:40 Bill Nye? That's what we're talking about.
42:42 Speaker 05 Right.
42:43 Bill Nye? The annual budget for planetary science is one and a half billion dollars, which sounds like a lot, but it's not that much. It's nine percent of the NASA, less than 10% of the NASA budget.
42:54 Speaker 05 Which is one half of 1% of the federal budget.
42:57 Eugene Mirman? You guys love being bummed about this.
43:01 Bill Nye? Well...
43:02 Eugene Mirman? With good reason.
43:03 Bill Nye? Yeah, so...
43:04 Speaker 05 Just to remind you, you're getting a good deal.
43:07 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
43:07 Bill Nye? Yeah.
43:07 Eugene Mirman? No, I think it's a great deal. I'd give it more money.
43:10 Bill Nye? Yeah, exactly.
43:11 Eugene Mirman? But I have very little say.
43:12 Bill Nye? You know, we advocate for getting more money for planetary science, because these extraordinary discoveries are made for, not on the cheap, but for a lot less money than a lot of other stuff that we spend, and even NASA spends money on. But here's the interesting thing, that I think people like, in what is called, Scott, I think, New Space?
43:31 Speaker 05 New Space.
43:32 Bill Nye? You were editor-in-chief of New Space Magazine?
43:34 Speaker 05 That's correct. Peer-reviewed journal.
43:36 Bill Nye? There are people, like, at SpaceX, and Jeff Bezos, you just mentioned, Elon Musk at SpaceX, Jeff Bezos, who just want to go to Mars. Let's go, boom, go. Because if we had the cash, the C-A-S-H, and the drive...
43:52 Speaker 05 The other cash.
43:53 Bill Nye? Yeah, you could just go there, right? I mean, you could. We know enough about the Martian surface, the Martian atmosphere, the Martian gravity, the radiation environment.
44:02 Speaker 05 The one big thing...
44:03 Bill Nye? Oh, that!
44:04 Eugene Mirman? Ah!
44:07 Speaker 05 Is right now, nobody's got a single rocket that will get the kind of tonnage you need to Mars to support human beings, A and B.
44:16 Bill Nye? Tonnage is, uh...
44:17 Speaker 05 Like, lots of stuff, you know, ten, forty...
44:19 Bill Nye? Tang!
44:20 Speaker 05 Forty metric tons of life support. That's what it comes down to, is how do you support someone or a group of four or six people going out, you know, the six, seven months it takes to get there, spending some time there, and then the six, seven months back, so maybe three years round trip.
44:37 Eugene Mirman? Maybe you stop at asteroids and pick up some of the materials you might need.
44:41 Speaker 05 That's right.
44:42 Eugene Mirman? That's my recommendation.
44:43 Speaker 05 Oxygen is us, right, you know?
44:48 Bill Nye? But Yvonne, that's part of the idea, right?
44:50 Speaker 04 Exactly, if we understood what was there and where they are.
44:55 Bill Nye? The asteroids.
44:56 Speaker 04 We could do that.
44:57 Bill Nye? Yeah, be a way station.
44:58 Speaker 04 Right, absolutely could be.
45:00 Speaker 03 Or you could stop on the way.
45:01 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, exactly, and you would get like Kit Kats and then, you know, oxygen and water.
45:07 Bill Nye? And everything you need.
45:08 Eugene Mirman? Fossil fuels.
45:09 Bill Nye? So, you guys, we are on the way to Mars. Here's the plan, right there. I hope you enjoyed StarTalk Radio. Turn it up loud!
Previous Cosmic Queries: Bill Nye Edition Next Autism and Animal Science with Dr. Temple Grandin Page updated October 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated