Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Queries: Bill Nye Edition About this episode The Science Guy takes the mic to answer your questions for him about evolution, technology, the human exploration of space, and even Leonard Nimoy, chosen from Twitter, Facebook and Google Plus by co-host Chuck Nice.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm your host Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and this is StarTalk.
0:30 Bill Nye? We have a great show. We're gonna jump around here from logical scientific topic to logical scientific with one extraordinary diversion. Is that right Chuck?
0:39 Chuck Nice? Yes.
0:40 Bill Nye? We're gonna talk briefly about meat.
0:45 Chuck Nice? Yes, well actually I'm calling this, this whole thing "High on Nye", because we have queries for you and we've taken them from the internet, from Google+ from StarTalk.net, from Twitter, Facebook.
0:59 Bill Nye? That's social, the social media.
1:02 Chuck Nice? The social media.
1:03 Bill Nye? The electric, the electric internet.
1:04 Chuck Nice? Yes.
1:05 Bill Nye? That all the kids are crazy about. Kids are crazy for.
1:09 Chuck Nice? So what we've done is we've, we've pulled together questions specifically asked to you, Mr. Nye.
1:18 Bill Nye? Wow.
1:19 Chuck Nice? And so every one of the, every one of the questions here was addressed to you from one of our social media platforms, so I'm calling it "High on Nye."
1:30 Chuck Nice? Let's do it like this, because people kinda ask you all kinds of crazy questions from all over the world. I mean, not all over the world, I'm sorry.
1:40 Bill Nye? You don't know that. Actually, you don't know that with the internet.
1:42 Chuck Nice? Actually, they could be from all over the world.
1:43 Bill Nye? But they're all in English.
1:44 Chuck Nice? But I'm saying on very many subjects. So we have evolution.
1:48 Bill Nye? Evolution. I wrote a book on evolution.
1:51 Chuck Nice? Which was a New York Times bestseller, available from St. Martin's Press.
1:55 Bill Nye? You can go to Amazon.com.
1:56 Chuck Nice? And so I think we should start with that. And this is about evolution. Of course, you had a very famous debate that our friend Neil deGrasse Tyson refers to as "Ham on Nye."
2:10 Bill Nye? Yes, like instead of a sandwich.
2:13 Chuck Nice? Instead of a sandwich.
2:14 Bill Nye? With rye bread, yes.
2:15 Chuck Nice? So let's go with evolution here, alright? First question from Richard Bolin.
2:22 Chuck Nice? I hear this talk about the mechanisms that explain evolution. Everyone says mechanisms. What are these mechanisms, please?
2:34 Bill Nye? Oh, so the first one is, uh, first one. You, what makes evolution go is you reproduce by you. Uh, you're a living thing.
2:44 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
2:44 Bill Nye? Reproduction is what, is how changes come to be in the descendant species, the next, the offspring, the kids. Be it corn plants, uh, soybean, uh, spiders, sea jellies, or even humans.
3:01 Chuck Nice? Right.
3:02 Bill Nye? And by making replicas of yourself, you accidentally, in general, induce changes. And so that is a mechanism. Now, this works whether or not you have sex. When you have sex, like dandelions do.
3:18 Chuck Nice? Right.
3:19 Bill Nye? Then you can accelerate the process by getting this new mixture of genes. So that the offspring are inherently quite a bit, or quite a bit, somewhat more different than they would be if you didn't have sex.
3:32 Chuck Nice? Okay.
3:33 Bill Nye? So then the question is, and this is where the coin, the term, the phrase got coined. Uh, the fittest. Now, fittest in surviving of the fittest, survival of the fittest, rather, does not mean the people that lift the most weights or have the best cardio workout. Means you fit into the ecosystem the best. It's an old, it's a British usage of this term from the 19th century.
3:59 Chuck Nice? So it's not like this guy to fit.
4:02 Bill Nye? But that might not be bad because my understanding is certain chicks dig that.
4:07 Chuck Nice? Which can help you replicate yourself a little, a little easier.
4:10 Bill Nye? That's a real thing, though. That's a real thing.
4:12 Chuck Nice? Getting each other.
4:13 Bill Nye? And, uh, I mentioned in my book that I have a trainer, a friend of mine, who's also Neil deGrasse Tyson's trainer.
4:20 Chuck Nice? Okay.
4:21 Bill Nye? When he's in Los Angeles, uh, who says, no matter what they tell you, no matter what they say, women like muscles.
4:30 Chuck Nice? Really?
4:30 Bill Nye? That's what they said.
4:31 Chuck Nice? That's what he says.
4:32 Bill Nye? Well, yeah, yeah. So it could be. Anyway, that aside.
4:35 Chuck Nice? So survival of the fittest as in fit in.
4:39 Bill Nye? Fit in the best.
4:39 Chuck Nice? You fit in the best.
4:40 Bill Nye? Then there's other mechanisms, uh, in evolution, uh, where, uh, we end up with not only our size, shape, number of fingers that enable us to survive and reproduce the best, but we end up with emotions that enable us to survive. So you know the word, we throw around the word antisocial nowadays?
5:02 Chuck Nice? Antisocial.
5:03 Bill Nye? If you're a jerk, you're not gonna...
5:06 Chuck Nice? You don't make it.
5:06 Bill Nye? It's less likely you'll have babies.
5:08 Chuck Nice? Right.
5:08 Bill Nye? Or if you're a raving, um, dog dispositioned person.
5:14 Chuck Nice? Right?
5:15 Bill Nye? Uh, it's very, it's very unlikely that you'll be as successful.
5:20 Chuck Nice? I got you.
5:21 Bill Nye? And so we have this so-called urge of altruism, this urge to help each other out. And that is apparently a result of evolution. So these are examples...
5:30 Chuck Nice? Because the loner didn't make it.
5:31 Bill Nye? The loner, yeah.
5:32 Chuck Nice? Because the loner, I mean, you know, when, when you fall or you're stuck somewhere, if you're a loner, you're there.
5:38 Bill Nye? You're done.
5:39 Chuck Nice? You're done.
5:40 Bill Nye? But if the guy's there to help you up, you don't know, maybe the loner will help, I mean, maybe the guy you helped up will help you later.
5:46 Chuck Nice? Right.
5:46 Bill Nye? And we're all in this together. And if you wanna knock off a mammoth, you're gonna have... It's probably a team sport.
5:53 Chuck Nice? I was gonna...
5:53 Bill Nye? Problem.
5:54 Chuck Nice? Not something you wanna do by yourself.
5:56 Bill Nye? And how about this one last thing about that question?
5:58 Chuck Nice? The mechanisms.
6:00 Bill Nye? We as humans that are part of evolution, we are not separate creatures, independent of the earth's ecosystems. We are a result of the same processes that brought us sea jellies and dandelions and giant squid. We're all here, we're all in this together. We have so much more in common. Then we have different and you can see it in our DNA.
6:25 Chuck Nice? Okay, so there's evidence of that on a cellular level.
6:29 Bill Nye? Overwhelming.
6:29 Chuck Nice? Overwhelming evidence on a cellular level that we have, that we're part of a grand, grand scheme with everything else. Okay, very cool.
6:39 Bill Nye? Oh, and the, oh, the energy for reproduction comes from the sun ultimately, I mean, most of it. It's a green plants and we eat them and we roll.
6:46 Chuck Nice? Cool.
6:46 Bill Nye? And the earth's got primordial spin, which is not insignificant, but.
6:50 Chuck Nice? I'm gonna call that afternoon delight.
6:51 Bill Nye? There you go.
6:52 Chuck Nice? All right, so, uh, let's move on with to Steph Burt. Steph Burt, uh, do you think that one day technology will become so advanced? That it will begin to hinder our own human evolution? Can we de-evolve?
7:12 Bill Nye? Well.
7:12 Chuck Nice? Because of technology.
7:14 Bill Nye? But this gets into a tribal question and I'll put it to you this way. Let's take, let's take for example, a guy who was walking down the street.
7:22 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
7:23 Bill Nye? When he was an engineer at Boeing.
7:24 Chuck Nice? Okay.
7:25 Bill Nye? And had appendicitis.
7:27 Chuck Nice? Right. What, that could be me, wait. I was gonna say.
7:31 Bill Nye? Wow, just a second.
7:32 Chuck Nice? Continue.
7:33 Bill Nye? But because I live in a tribe that has built hospitals, it was routine. Guy took out my appendix, I'm still going, I could have babies and things.
7:45 Chuck Nice? Right.
7:45 Bill Nye? But if I lived in a different tribe without that technology, I would probably have died.
7:50 Chuck Nice? Or a different time.
7:51 Bill Nye? That's right, some people apparently survive appendicitis, but generally it kills you.
7:55 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
7:55 Bill Nye? And so, uh, so because I'm in this tribe, my genes are getting passed on where they might not otherwise have been passed on.
8:03 Chuck Nice? Right.
8:04 Bill Nye? And so there's an example of technology enabling my genes to go into the future. Could it get to the point where you can't do anything at all? You can't survive at all without technology? That is to say, you'd be plugged into some giant matrix machine.
8:22 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
8:22 Bill Nye? From the get-go and you'd be there all the time. Uh, it's possible, but I think it's quite a ways off. But from a science fiction standpoint, it is a worthy thing to consider. And it's also something to consider when you think about.
8:36 Bill Nye? Our tribes, our social systems that we have here as humans. We are, we all depend on each other and that's why there's so many of us. You know, in the bad old days, if you got the flu, whatever, you're just dead.
8:51 Chuck Nice? That was it.
8:52 Bill Nye? But now, all these things enable so many people to not die at nearly the rate they used to, which as you can, I hope anyone can agree, is both good and bad. We have, you know, one of my grandparents were around, were young, there were about one and a half billion people in the world. Now they're about seven point two going on nine.
9:16 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
9:16 Bill Nye? And so those, that's, that's gonna put quite a burden on the earth's resources. And but it's, but it's our ability to understand nature and to create technology based on science that will improve the quality of life of people everywhere. It's a great question.
9:31 Chuck Nice? It is a good question. So let me, uh, let me tack on to Steph Burt's question and ask you, with what you just said, is there a danger of us losing our humanity due to technology? What you just talked about was how our dependence upon one another uh, has got us to a point where we can continue to evolve and grow and actually increase our population because we depend upon each other. Is it possible that technology will move us in the opposite direction of that?
10:06 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah, here's why. I'll give you an example. When I, have you ever, have you ever read, uh, The Stepford Wives?
10:15 Chuck Nice? No, I can't say that I have.
10:17 Bill Nye? No, but I just want to tell you guys, they make a remake of it on movies every now and then.
10:21 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
10:22 Bill Nye? But in the original, the pill is capital T, capital P.
10:27 Chuck Nice? Uh huh.
10:28 Bill Nye? And this is an example of technology that enabled women to not have babies.
10:35 Chuck Nice? Right.
10:35 Bill Nye? And take control of their, uh, family planning in a much more practical way than.
10:43 Bill Nye? Other things that have been suggested with something like, don't look at boys.
10:47 Chuck Nice? Right.
10:48 Bill Nye? Cross your legs with an aspirin between your knees, like those are ineffective.
10:51 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
10:52 Bill Nye? And so there's an example of technology that enables us to control human reproduction, which then could enable us hypothetically to raise the standard of living of women, which will, over the course of a century or two, lower the human population by natural means, fewer people being born than are dying, and that will provide more of the Earth's resources for more people.
11:19 Chuck Nice? Whoa.
11:20 Bill Nye? Right. So there's an example, will that technology allow us to lose our humanity?
11:24 Chuck Nice? Yes.
11:25 Bill Nye? Or actually make us love each other all the way?
11:29 Chuck Nice? More.
11:30 Bill Nye? So I don't think technology will make us lose our humanity. I think as long as there are humans involved, there will be human emotions.
11:37 Chuck Nice? Fantastic. I love that. Wait, that's an emotion too, that's crazy.
11:45 Chuck Nice? All right, let's go to Google Plus and Tariq Hussain. And Tariq wants to know this. What effects do you, what effects do you think humans will have on our own evolutionary path? Through our advances in science and technology, we have extremely minimized the effects of natural selection in favor of some new mechanism of evolution. So that kind of like what you're talking about with your appendix and so forth. Is that going to, are we gonna have four fingers one day? I mean, well, actually, three fingers and a thumb one day is because of?
12:16 Bill Nye? No, I think it's gonna go the other way. Uh, I think the big, here's your, our perception, science fiction movies and science fiction thinking and stuff, is that your brains will get bigger.
12:29 Chuck Nice? Right.
12:29 Bill Nye? More powerful.
12:30 Chuck Nice? Yes.
12:31 Bill Nye? Their skulls will swell to the size of rugby balls.
12:34 Chuck Nice? The butt heads from Star Trek.
12:36 Bill Nye? Yes, yes. And that may be, but in the shorter term, your enemy, as a living thing on the Earth, is not lions and tigers and bears.
12:46 Chuck Nice? Oh my.
12:47 Bill Nye? Exactly, which can be very troublesome.
12:49 Chuck Nice? Yes.
12:49 Bill Nye? But most people are hardly affected at all by the threat of lions or tigers or bears.
12:54 Chuck Nice? Oh my.
12:55 Bill Nye? What does get you are germs.
12:57 Chuck Nice? Yes.
12:58 Bill Nye? Germs and parasites.
13:00 Chuck Nice? Right.
13:00 Bill Nye? So, uh, the people that happen to have the most robust immune systems, uh, that keep up with or stay just ahead of. Mutating viruses and bacteria and other parasites are more likely to have their genes passed in the future and the claim that evolution is not happening is absolutely wrong. Sorry, I love you, man, but no. There's evidence that people in the industrial world who can tolerate milk are more successful, their blood sugar is more stable, their hemoglobin counts are better. So, we are perhaps, perhaps, slowly weeding out infants who are not tolerant of modern diets.
13:45 Bill Nye? There's some evidence of that.
13:46 Chuck Nice? Gotcha.
13:47 Bill Nye? Very compelling evidence of that. And then, the other thing is, in order to get your genes passed into the future, you have to have offspring.
13:56 Chuck Nice? Right.
13:57 Bill Nye? So, let's take, for example, and I'm not really an authority on this, but let's take Kim Kardashian.
14:04 Chuck Nice? Okay.
14:05 Bill Nye? People would nominally say that she's very attractive.
14:08 Chuck Nice? Some, yeah.
14:10 Bill Nye? So, she has a good chance of attracting a mate who could help her genes advance into the future.
14:17 Chuck Nice? Well, in her case, several.
14:18 Bill Nye? Yeah, and so on. So, and then, you want to attract a mate that is...
14:25 Chuck Nice? Rich? I'm sorry.
14:27 Bill Nye? Young and good-looking.
14:29 Chuck Nice? Rich, young and good-looking.
14:30 Bill Nye? The triple threat. And what are you and I doing here? And so on. So, this is, this process is still going on. You know, there's a saying, "There's a lid for every pot."
14:40 Chuck Nice? Yes.
14:41 Bill Nye? Meaning that there's somebody for everyone. And that's probably true because we've all made it this far. Everybody's good enough. Keep that in mind, everyone. Everyone you meet is, from an evolutionary standpoint, is just like you. We all got here.
14:57 Chuck Nice? Right.
14:58 Bill Nye? Somebody was doing it. I know, as troubling as it is...
15:01 Chuck Nice? That is a little disturbing.
15:02 Bill Nye? ...to think that your parents had sex, but it's nevertheless true. And so, we are all in this together, so the forces of evolution are still at work. And the, the real thing that's going to weed people out is going to be that germs and parasites. That's Bill's prediction.
15:17 Chuck Nice? Excellent, excellent, excellent. All right, here's John Marcus, and John comes to us from Twitter, @thuspokejohn. You think a little much of yourself there, do you, John? How does it work that traits skip a generation or two, or sometimes three?
15:37 Chuck Nice? How often are genes presented but not active?
15:40 Bill Nye? It's magic. No, wait, it's science. Uh, when recessive genes are expressed and dominant genes are expressed is one of the great mysteries and so, or not mysteries, uh, great, um, uh, insights that people have pursued for the better part of a century and a half. And the subtle thing now is what happens with repeating genes and repeating sequences and how do they affect things and why are they there? And then there's long strands or portions of our genetic code that are unused. And so whether things dominate or recess
16:19 Bill Nye? uh, is subtle and wonderful and the guy who discovered this was, uh, Mendel messing around with his, uh, peas. And since then, we have been pursuing this, uh, very actively and there's an old expression, genealogy, where you study your family tree.
16:35 Chuck Nice? Right.
16:35 Bill Nye? And you can for yourself study, uh, recessive traits and, uh, dominant traits. But it is based on probabilities.
16:44 Chuck Nice? Okay.
16:44 Bill Nye? It's another feature of nature where you can make, uh, very good predictions, but not precise predictions. You have to run the tests, meaning you have to interact. Uh, can we say interact on the radio?
16:58 Chuck Nice? Oh, yeah.
16:59 Bill Nye? Can we interact hard and often?
17:01 Chuck Nice? Yes.
17:02 Bill Nye? Okay, that's enough. Stop, stop, stop.
17:06 Bill Nye? Anyway, this is what people do now, making crops. Making good soybean and corn and peanuts and
17:15 Chuck Nice? heirloom tomatoes.
17:16 Bill Nye? And cucumbers and studying the recessive and dominant traits of these things.
17:20 Chuck Nice? Why do I want a salad now?
17:22 Bill Nye? Uh, cause you've been talking about food. It always makes you think about sex. Wait, uh, uh, this is where, uh, this is what farmers do all day is mull these deep questions.
17:35 Chuck Nice? Fantastic. All right, uh, very quickly, uh, this is from Taylor. Taylor wants to know, can you explain the evolutionary purpose of right and left-handedness? Why are some of us right-handed and some of us left-handed?
17:46 Bill Nye? Uh, well, apparently right-handedness started to dominate in certain tribes and having everybody same-handed was of great value.
17:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're listening to StarTalk. Stay tuned for another segment.
18:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk. Here's more of this week's episode.
18:20 Chuck Nice? Stacy Pro from, uh, looks like Facebook says, uh, "What kind of technological advances would we have to make before journeys to Mars can be more than one way?"
18:34 Bill Nye? Yeah, this one-way thing, everybody, well, I think, um, fade into the past, but, uh, this was a proposal to send a few dozen people to Mars that would never come home and we would all watch them suffer starvation and death on, uh, international television, but that probably won't happen. Instead, we at the Planetary Society strongly believe that we could send an exploration mission to, uh, the vicinity of Mars, let's say, landing on Phobos by 2033, which sounds like a long way off when you're a kid, but when you're my age, doesn't sound
19:15 Bill Nye? like that far. And this we could do with the current, what everybody likes to say, "funding profiles." There's a graph that shows how much money you spend every year, and it looks kind of like a profile, I guess, and that's where this term came from. But, uh, this is a long way to go. And the technological advances that I think we need, we gotta find ways to have people keep their bones while they're in very low gravity for a long, long time, and we have to be able to breathe and eat and recycle water supplies on, I don't wanna... Trouble you, but we have to not throw water away.
19:53 Chuck Nice? That just sounds disgusting.
19:55 Bill Nye? We do it here on Earth.
19:57 Chuck Nice? I guess you're right.
19:58 Bill Nye? We have a water cycle.
19:59 Chuck Nice? We do have a water cycle.
20:00 Bill Nye? That's how we roll. So, uh, this is the, these are the kind of problems that should be, have to be solved. And I myself have always been a fan of making a spaceship that spins. So you may not get one G worth of gravity like we have here in this room.
20:15 Chuck Nice? Right.
20:16 Bill Nye? But you might get forty percent. And that would be enough acceleration to keep your bones healthy.
20:22 Chuck Nice? Okay.
20:22 Bill Nye? It should be tests worth running. And here's the reason to explore Mars. Is we would make discoveries that would change the course of humankind. We'd have adventures that would, people would talk about till the, till the end of humans.
20:34 Chuck Nice? Sounds good. Uh, let's go to Lance Elliott. Okay, this is what Lance says. There's been speculation that perhaps life could exist on Saturn's moon Titan.
20:46 Bill Nye? Uh, yeah.
20:47 Chuck Nice? It would suggest that such life would take in hydrogen and acetylene and output methane.
20:53 Bill Nye? How hard could that be?
20:54 Chuck Nice? Right.
20:55 Bill Nye? Taking hydrogen atoms and acetylene is, um, that's the old nomenclature for propane.
21:01 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
21:02 Bill Nye? Which is like propane, but it has a triple carbon bond instead of a single one. So, okay, that could be, uh, what's, these only.
21:09 Chuck Nice? So that's what he says.
21:10 Bill Nye? Let's go find out. Let's, let's build a mission, build a spacecraft.
21:14 Chuck Nice? And let's, let's get to Titan.
21:15 Bill Nye? With extraordinary instruments and sniff around. Let's go.
21:19 Chuck Nice? I don't want to sniff around if it smells like methane.
21:21 Bill Nye? Uh, the instrument would do the sniffing chart.
21:24 Chuck Nice? Oh, okay, okay, good. Since then, we've detected such depletion of hydrogen and acetylene and don't know the cause. We also don't know what's restoring Titan's methane. My question is, thank God, we finally got to it, Lance. Bill, what do you think of the possibility of life on Titan? You know, you could have just said that, Lance.
21:47 Bill Nye? I don't think, well, I don't think it's that likely. Uh, because people in astrobiology, as it's called.
21:54 Chuck Nice? Okay.
21:54 Bill Nye? Have spent a lot of time with us.
21:56 Chuck Nice? Okay.
21:57 Bill Nye? And people like methane the way we do. We have swamp gas here on Earth.
22:01 Chuck Nice? Yes, we do.
22:02 Bill Nye? Natural gas, which is methane, same word, same, uh, two different words, three different words to describe the same thing. But it looks like water is the best deal for living things.
22:12 Chuck Nice? Right.
22:12 Bill Nye? So water is not just H2O, that's sort of a shorthand, it's HOH.
22:19 Bill Nye? Is water and it's a molecule that has a polarity. It has a north and a south. It has a plus and a minus quality.
22:27 Chuck Nice? Okay.
22:27 Bill Nye? And apparently, near as any astrobiologist can tell, this polar quality of water makes it extraordinarily good for the chemistry of life. Now, it could be, because you and I are water-based things.
22:42 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
22:42 Bill Nye? We just think in water-based ways and we're not asking questions, in this case, outside the box or the periodic table edges. But maybe there is something out there, per this guy's question, but it looks like the real, what you really want is water. So we'll see. We'll see.
22:59 Chuck Nice? So, uh, there you have it, Lance. Uh, highly unlikely. Highly unlikely.
23:04 Bill Nye? But if we, after we've done Mars and Europa, I'm ready to invest. Let's build a spacecraft out there.
23:11 Chuck Nice? All right. All right.
23:12 Bill Nye? Then send it out there.
23:14 Chuck Nice? So here is a question from Dachrick Chaya or Kia, okay?
23:20 Bill Nye? Could be Kia.
23:21 Chuck Nice? Could be Kia. Doing my best here. Okay?
23:23 Bill Nye? Kia, Kia, Kia. That, that fabulous sound. Go ahead, take it.
23:28 Chuck Nice? Hello, Mr. Nye. How do you feel about NASA announcing a trip to Europa? Do you think a successful human colony will be placed on Europa before we have a successful colony on Mars? Thank you. P.S. To whoever is reading the questions, my name is pronounced Derek Chaya.
23:44 Bill Nye? Oh.
23:45 Chuck Nice? There you have it. Answer, answer was in the question there.
23:48 Bill Nye? Uh, Derek, Derek Chaya. Derek, Derek. No, we will not have a human colony on Europa before we have it on Mars. Europa is, um, an icy world extraordinarily far from the sun, influenced greatly by the extremely powerful Jupiterian, Jupiter's magnetic field.
24:05 Chuck Nice? Hmm.
24:06 Bill Nye? No, what we want to do is look for life there because there's all that seawater on Europa that we want to investigate and see if with four and a half billion years of liquid water, maybe there's something living there. So we're not going to build a colony on Europa.
24:18 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
24:19 Bill Nye? Anytime. No, it's a good question, but.
24:21 Chuck Nice? No, no, it's, I was just thinking of a very juvenile joke. You said, we're not going to build a colony on Europa. And of course, I was going to say, or Uranus, but I'm sorry.
24:30 Bill Nye? I'm shocked. I'm just shocked.
24:32 Chuck Nice? I'm sorry for even.
24:33 Bill Nye? But you have now, you're fifteen and nine and a one-year-old.
24:36 Chuck Nice? Yes, I do.
24:37 Bill Nye? They go through phase. There's a phase. Speaking of liquid and solid and gaseous water phases, anyway, we want to look for signs of life on Mars and Europa. That's what is a worthy investment of your tax dollars. And that's why I took the job as CEO of the Planetary Society.
24:53 Chuck Nice? Ah, fantastic. Alright, let's go to, uh, Lim Lipka, coming to us from Google Plus. Len wants to know this. The Mars One mission is considered a one-way ticket. What would be projected, the projected lifespan of the astronauts and what would prevent us from retrieving them during that estimated time?
25:17 Bill Nye? Well, everybody, there was one, uh, study done, I'm almost sure it was something associated with the National Research Council, which is associated with the National Academy of Sciences. And they thought people would live less than 70 days before chaos caught up with them and they wouldn't be alive anymore. So, uh, even if you're off by a factor of 10.
25:42 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
25:43 Bill Nye? 700 days is just not enough time to mount a mission to Mars. It's not like you guys, it's not like going to the Alps and getting the guy hanging from the rope. It's just so far away. It takes, you can only go to Mars successfully economically every 26 months, every two years and a little bit because of the orbits of Earth and Mars. You just can't economically get to Mars when it's on the wrong side of the sun. It's just...
26:08 Chuck Nice? That's all there is to it. It's just got to line up, it's got to line up and that's it.
26:12 Bill Nye? You have to launch before, you have to get the spacecraft to catch up with Mars and so on. So, you can't just, you can't just do that. And this, that people have this perception is kind of cool, but things are just much, much farther away in space than you're real. There's a lot of space.
26:28 Chuck Nice? Right.
26:29 Bill Nye? In space.
26:30 Chuck Nice? In space. So, the whole idea of total recall, it's not...
26:33 Bill Nye? It's not likely.
26:34 Chuck Nice? Not likely. Oh, damn, got it. Alright, let's move on to Casey, coming to us from Twitter and says, "Hey, Bill, with private sector space travel, do you feel it will lead to less moral obligations towards astronauts' lives? In other words, hmm, will there be a kind of like..." There'll be more astronauts, so we don't care if they die.
27:00 Bill Nye? Actually, it would almost certainly go the other way. No, because astronauts historically have been military pilots.
27:07 Chuck Nice? Right.
27:07 Bill Nye? And it's the civilian space program in the United States, for example, is still closely tied to the traditions and the hierarchy of military. And if you are a military commander and they tell you to do something, that's your deal. You follow orders. And that's why they indoctrinate you and you boot camp and you rise up through the ranks and you just get, the chain of command becomes imbued in.
27:31 Chuck Nice? Right, and so.
27:33 Bill Nye? On the other hand.
27:35 Chuck Nice? It doesn't make a difference if you want to go up or not.
27:37 Bill Nye? And those people have their tickets paid for. That is to say, if you're an astronaut, the governments of the world are paying your salary and your rocket fuel and your tang. But when you are a commercial citizen.
27:54 Chuck Nice? Right.
27:55 Bill Nye? Buying a ticket, people expect the same level of safety as you have in commercial airplanes.
28:00 Chuck Nice? Okay.
28:01 Bill Nye? Actually, it will go the other way. People will be outraged when there's a crash that kills civilians.
28:07 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
28:08 Bill Nye? Now.
28:08 Chuck Nice? Wow, that is an excellent point.
28:11 Bill Nye? You have to sound so surprised, Sean.
28:15 Chuck Nice? But yeah, you know, when you think about it, how often do we hear about a helicopter going down? An F-15 going down? We hear about some type of test plane going down. No one is outraged because we did not care for the safety of that pilot. It's just like, that dude knew what he signed up for? Oh, well.
28:39 Bill Nye? That's right.
28:39 Chuck Nice? Big deal.
28:40 Bill Nye? That's right.
28:40 Chuck Nice? But let an airliner go down.
28:42 Bill Nye? Oh, man, people are totally freaked. Reasonably so, too. You're paying, you buy a ticket, you're hoping, you're expecting, rather, not to get killed by it.
28:52 Chuck Nice? Right.
28:53 Bill Nye? You're a military pilot who loves flying and realizes this machine you're sitting on is extraordinarily powerful. You know what you're getting into. Doesn't make it great, but it is a very different outlook from the passenger.
29:07 Chuck Nice? Excellent. Wow.
29:09 Bill Nye? Passengers' point of view.
29:09 Chuck Nice? Hey, great question there, Casey, and there's your answer. It's actually going to go in the opposite direction. Well, you're better off.
29:18 Chuck Nice? You're better off not being an astronaut and, and, and, and having
29:23 Bill Nye? Buying a $200,000 ticket.
29:25 Chuck Nice? There you go. All right, let's, uh-
29:27 Bill Nye? With that said, keep in mind Virgin Galactic had a crash killing a test pilot. But test pilot is the same kind of guy.
29:34 Chuck Nice? Yeah, same kind of guy. And it's funny because now that you've mentioned that, the big question that ensued that crash was, is this the end
29:45 Bill Nye? I know.
29:46 Chuck Nice? Of commercial space flight?
29:48 Bill Nye? No.
29:48 Chuck Nice? All over the news the next day. All over the news.
29:51 Bill Nye? No, people redouble their efforts because this guy was a, was an explorer.
29:56 Chuck Nice? Right.
29:57 Bill Nye? He was out there pushing the envelope. And if you want to know, by the way, everybody, just in airplanes, uh, there's a graph of propulsion and altitude and that when you look, when you draw all the lines to figure out where the best place to operate your airplane is, it kind of looks like the back of an envelope. There's a horizontal line, there's a downsloping line, a downsloping line of the other direction. It kind of looks like the back of an envelope. And so that's where this expression, pushing the envelope, came from.
30:29 Chuck Nice? Oh.
30:29 Bill Nye? Yeah. It's a, it's a
30:31 Chuck Nice? Very cool.
30:32 Bill Nye? Based on a graph.
30:33 Chuck Nice? Based on the graph. Fantastic. All right, let's switch gears here because you are a man of many talents and, uh, your knowledge spans many subjects.
30:42 Bill Nye? Oh, yes.
30:43 Chuck Nice? And-
30:44 Bill Nye? Just ask me about it.
30:45 Chuck Nice? And here's the great thing is a lot of our listeners know that you are indeed an engineer.
30:50 Bill Nye? Yes. I have a license.
30:52 Chuck Nice? You're a licensed engineer.
30:55 Bill Nye? I am.
30:56 Chuck Nice? So here's the deal. Let's move into some, uh, technology and engineering questions that people want to know specifically from you, Mr. Nye. Uh, Paul Johnson wants to know this. Is it possible we have reached close to this level of civilization technology here on Earth? And just don't know it? Okay, in other words, what's he saying is where we are right now technologically, is it possible that sometime in the past in unrecorded history, uh, there's tens if not hundreds of millions of years unaccounted for on our planet where billions of species have lived and died, could we have experienced some other technological explosion without
31:41 Chuck Nice? knowing it and like kinda went into a dark ages and started all over?
31:45 Bill Nye? I don't think so.
31:46 Chuck Nice? Okay, why not?
31:47 Bill Nye? They're done. Because I think you'd have evidence of it and every time humans do anything, they leave stuff by like pyramids and
31:55 Chuck Nice? Right.
31:56 Bill Nye? And I say humans, but there's no evidence whatever that the ancient dinosaurs had a space program, for example.
32:04 Chuck Nice? Right.
32:05 Bill Nye? They would have deflected the asteroid and they'd still be running the show.
32:08 Chuck Nice? There you go.
32:09 Bill Nye? So it's very, very unlikely. It's great science fiction and this idea that ancient people knew more about math than we do.
32:19 Chuck Nice? Totally not true.
32:21 Bill Nye? Doesn't seem very likely, especially when you look, you know, people, the pyramids are perfectly square. They're really square, but they're not perfectly, yeah, they're really good, they're not perfect.
32:31 Chuck Nice? I think it's that those guys had a lot more time on their hands.
32:34 Bill Nye? The other thing they had was energy and where it really impressed me, if you ever go to Pompeii
32:40 Chuck Nice? Okay.
32:41 Bill Nye? And, uh, and, uh, outside of Naples, Italy, Napoli, you see, they had slaves.
32:49 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
32:50 Bill Nye? So they could just build all kinds of cool stuff.
32:52 Chuck Nice? Manpower, baby.
32:53 Bill Nye? And now we have fossil fuels and we have built all kinds of new stuff. What we wanna do is take humankind to the next level where we don't rely exclusively on fossil fuels for our livelihood, resources and food so that we can, dare I say it, chuck working together, change the world. These are great questions and they all lead to these, these big ideas, these big science fiction ideas, which I think are so charming.
33:41 Chuck Nice? Welcome back. Here's more of StarTalk.
33:46 Bill Nye? We have questions Chuck.
33:47 Chuck Nice? Yep, we're still in our cosmic queries and we've got questions from all over the internet and you know, all of these questions have been specifically directed at you.
33:58 Bill Nye? A man can dream.
33:59 Chuck Nice? There you have it. So let's continue right now with some more technology and engineering because you're an engineer.
34:06 Bill Nye? I am.
34:07 Chuck Nice? And this is from James Koltus. And James wants to know this. What do you think of the possibility of biological interstellar ships? Biological interstellar ships. I gotta tell you, I've never even heard of this.
34:21 Bill Nye? Well, this is where you'd make your ship out of space weed.
34:28 Bill Nye? And
34:28 Chuck Nice? First you gotta make sure you don't smoke it.
34:31 Bill Nye? Well, it's like seaweed, sea plants. You'd make it out of space plants.
34:35 Chuck Nice? Space plants?
34:37 Bill Nye? Woven together in a space plant ship.
34:39 Chuck Nice? Okay.
34:40 Bill Nye? And it would then, you know, the way you do, fly around, you know, in space. And everybody would live inside and breathe, um, space plant produced oxygen and stuff.
34:54 Chuck Nice? Right.
34:55 Bill Nye? So I'm open-minded, but I don't have a clear vision.
34:58 Chuck Nice? I was gonna say, something tells me you don't have to leave Earth to fly in this spaceship. However, he does give me a little, he gives me a little bit of clarification. He defines it as this, ships that use advanced biochemical mechanisms and evolve and learn along with the passengers. And I guess this would be along the lines of a biochemical computer, which is something they were talking about a little while ago.
35:28 Bill Nye? Yeah, so why have a biochemical computer?
35:31 Chuck Nice? I, I don't know why.
35:33 Bill Nye? I know, I have one.
35:34 Chuck Nice? Oh, you do? Yeah.
35:35 Bill Nye? I'm using, yes, I'm using it to create these sounds.
35:38 Chuck Nice? Yeah, exactly.
35:39 Bill Nye? So, uh, I follow you, but you, what you'd want is like the Borg, uh, that would also be your spaceship, or you'd have this distributed computing power in the fabric, or in the skin, or in the superstructure, or in the chassis, the bus of your spaceship. It sounds cool. You should write a science fiction story.
35:58 Chuck Nice? Yeah, I was gonna, yeah. The ship is alive.
36:01 Bill Nye? Yes.
36:01 Chuck Nice? There you go.
36:02 Bill Nye? It turns on you. That's what'll happen.
36:04 Chuck Nice? Of course it does.
36:05 Bill Nye? Right.
36:05 Chuck Nice? The ship definitely has to turn on you.
36:07 Bill Nye? It's gonna take you the whole freaking movie to either resolve the situation, or you're just...
36:12 Chuck Nice? Or kill the ship.
36:13 Bill Nye? Yeah, or just, yeah.
36:14 Chuck Nice? And, and then your, your, your quandary becomes, if we kill the ship, how do we get home?
36:19 Bill Nye? God, Chuck, it's written itself.
36:21 Chuck Nice? (laughing)
36:22 Bill Nye? It's written itself.
36:23 Chuck Nice? (laughing)
36:24 Bill Nye? And I just cannot help but hearken to that moment when Hal remarks, "I could see your lips move."
36:31 Chuck Nice? (laughing)
36:32 Bill Nye? Hal the computer in 2001 Space Odyssey is reading the guy's lips, knowing that they're planning to unplug him.
36:40 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
36:41 Bill Nye? So Hal tries to kill them all.
36:42 Chuck Nice? Well, there you have, there you have it, though it's a wonderful idea. It's, uh, you should write the science fiction novel about it. There you have it, straight from Mr. Nye himself.
36:51 Bill Nye? You might think, take it straight to video.
36:52 Chuck Nice? Let's take it straight to...
36:54 Bill Nye? Lead on.
36:55 Chuck Nice? All right, here we go. Thomas Charles Davis II would like to know, well, actually, he first says, "I am an artist, and I want to be more involved with science and NASA. What should I do?"
37:08 Bill Nye? Join the planetary society.
37:10 Chuck Nice? I knew somehow you were gonna say that.
37:12 Bill Nye? Yeah, so we, uh, you have to have art in everything you do. This is to say, art is what humans do. Humans create art.
37:21 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
37:21 Bill Nye? And to think of science and exploration as completely separate or unrelated to art, I'm always a little troubled by that. And so, uh, I think many of us agree that when you make a really elegant engineering thing... Like Brooklyn Bridge, for example.
37:38 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
37:38 Bill Nye? Golden Gate Bridge.
37:39 Chuck Nice? Okay.
37:40 Bill Nye? Everybody goes, wow, that looks great. So that has an artistic quality. In the same way, when you make a really cool-looking suit.
37:49 Chuck Nice? Okay.
37:49 Bill Nye? You say, wow, that's quite practical. It keeps you warm or makes you stand up straight or allows you to brush against subway railings without getting your skin burned.
38:01 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
38:02 Bill Nye? These things converge. So you want to have art and aesthetics in everything you do.
38:07 Chuck Nice? There you have it. That's actually a good answer, and it is true.
38:09 Bill Nye? You don't have to sound so surprised, Mr. Nice.
38:11 Chuck Nice? You're right, you're right, you're right. I mean, you know, you don't really think about how important aesthetics are when it comes to aesthetics and technology until you think about an Apple product.
38:21 Bill Nye? Yes, right.
38:21 Chuck Nice? You know?
38:22 Bill Nye? Yes, right.
38:22 Chuck Nice? When you think about an Apple product, you see exactly how important it really is.
38:26 Bill Nye? That's right. People want their technologies to look good. And I mean, to me, it's all, they're all connected. As the old saying goes, you can't fight a dirty ship. Let me rephrase that.
38:38 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
38:38 Bill Nye? If things are not ship-shaped on your ship, it's not as effective at its job of being a fighting machine.
38:46 Chuck Nice? Right.
38:46 Bill Nye? This is to say, you keep things neat and tidy or in aesthetically pleasing way so that it's more effective, it's more useful. In the same way, you don't want to have pure utilitarian things because it doesn't appeal to people.
38:58 Chuck Nice? Exactly.
38:59 Bill Nye? And I understand there is, there is great value in clutter. It has its own patterns and wonder. Yes, yes, yes. No, I'm digressing. Imagine, Bill Nye digressing. Weird. Lead on, Mr. Nice.
39:12 Chuck Nice? All right, Nate Owens.
39:15 Bill Nye? Could be.
39:15 Chuck Nice? Yes, I'm just going to read what he says and let you handle it.
39:19 Bill Nye? All right.
39:20 Chuck Nice? If the near-Earth asteroid Apophis passes through the keyhole in 2029, will seven years be enough time to prepare to deflect it? And he says, personally, I think NASA should let it crash into the Pacific so that we can teach Congress space programs are important. So that was, that was his commentary on it. So the question is,
39:40 Bill Nye? Yeah, I get you.
39:40 Chuck Nice? What we have time?
39:41 Bill Nye? So Apophis is an asteroid named after the Greek god of worry or anxiety.
39:46 Chuck Nice? Oh, dear. Oh, dear!
39:48 Bill Nye? And the keyhole is a mathematical shape in space that would, in this case, if I understand his question, would mean it's on course to hit the Earth next time it comes around.
39:58 Chuck Nice? Right.
39:58 Bill Nye? 2036. Well, it is to be hoped that if it's, as it gets closer, we will be able to determine Whether or not it's passing through the keyhole. And so you'll actually have quite a bit more than seven years because its trajectory will be clear into the 2022s and 2025s. And then you would have, you would have time, perhaps, to mount a mission to give the thing a nudge. However, with all that said, right now, it looks like Apophis is gonna miss.
40:25 Chuck Nice? Right.
40:25 Bill Nye? It would be extraordinarily small chance. Now, I haven't looked at this in quite a while, but less than one in a hundred thousand.
40:32 Chuck Nice? I'll take those odds.
40:33 Bill Nye? It's not zero.
40:34 Chuck Nice? Not zero.
40:35 Bill Nye? It's not zero.
40:36 Chuck Nice? But I'll take them.
40:37 Bill Nye? But, uh, right now, that's why people are not panicked about Apophis. But at the Planetary Society, we emphasize to everyone, there are about a hundred thousand enormous asteroids that cross, cross the Earth's orbit. And we don't know where most of them are, let alone whether or not they're gonna hit us.
40:54 Chuck Nice? There you have it.
40:55 Bill Nye? Ancient dinosaurs, near as anybody can tell, did not have a space program. And it caught up with them. It caught up with them. This is a worthy investment to look for signs, to look for asteroids and to learn to build systems that would give one a nudge. Just a little nudge.
41:15 Chuck Nice? All right. All right, here we go. Um, Paul Duma. Paul wants to know this. How much material would be needed to make a Dyson sphere? Would it require more than is in our solar system?
41:27 Bill Nye? A Dyson sphere, if I understand, it depends how big you want it. You want it to go around the sun.
41:31 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:32 Bill Nye? With the Earth inside, and then we'd capture all the sun's energy and do things.
41:37 Chuck Nice? Uh, yeah.
41:37 Bill Nye? Uh, I think it's really difficult. Uh, I haven't run that number. That sounds like something that'd be fun to do. Compute the total mass of a Dyson sphere. It seems to me unless it's extraordinarily thin.
41:49 Chuck Nice? Right.
41:50 Bill Nye? To keep the, the Earth within it would require, I mean, a sphere, just if you wanna run the numbers. It's a volume.
41:59 Bill Nye? Goes as 4 thirds pi r cubed, 4 thirds times pi, the ratio of circumference and diameter, times the radius cubed. It's, surface area goes, I guess it'd be the derivative of that, right? So it would be, um, I'm kidding, but it would be, uh, be 4 pi r squared. The derivative of the cu- of the volume would be the surface area. So it's be 4 pi r, it's a lot of r.
42:21 Chuck Nice? Yeah.
42:22 Bill Nye? When you get 150 million kilometers, 93 million miles, and you square that, and that's now, that's, that's an enormous number of kilometers. And I don't think there's enough material on the earth or the solar system to build that.
42:35 Chuck Nice? To even build it.
42:36 Bill Nye? Yeah, that's a good question. There was a little outlouding there.
42:38 Chuck Nice? Yeah, a little outlouding.
42:39 Bill Nye? Hey, you know Chuck?
42:40 Chuck Nice? It's time, my friend.
42:42 Bill Nye? There's four minutes left. It's time for the lightning round.
42:45 Chuck Nice? And the lightning round is brought to you by Personal Questions.
42:48 Bill Nye? Wow.
42:49 Chuck Nice? It's all about that bill.
42:51 Bill Nye? Wow.
42:51 Chuck Nice? These are all personal questions for you. Here's Kalen Manzer. If you and Neil were given the entire US budget for one year, what would you do with it?
42:58 Bill Nye? Fix everything. No, we would address climate change. We would raise the standard of living of women and girls through education. And we would improve transportation systems so that we would use less energy. The key to the future Chuck.
43:11 Chuck Nice? Wow.
43:12 Bill Nye? Is not to do less, but to do more with less.
43:15 Chuck Nice? I'm voting for you guys. Okay? That's a ticket I'm voting for. Here's, um, Ellie St. Sire says, what in your opinion was Leonard Nimoy's greatest tribute to science? Uh, what is your favorite Star Trek, the original ser- the original series?
43:32 Bill Nye? Well, my favorite Star Trek, this isn't a hard question, is City on the Edge of Forever. I mean, many such journeys are possible. Anyway, the, um, the importance of Leonard Nimoy is hard to underestimate. The guy gave us, Star Trek writ large, and he was a huge part of it.
43:48 Chuck Nice? Mm-hmm.
43:49 Bill Nye? Gave us this optimistic view of the future. Through magic? No! Through what Chuck? Science! Yes! He was a science officer, lead on.
43:59 Chuck Nice? That's right. This is from Louis Demela. What is your ideal future for this planet and our species?
44:07 Bill Nye? Where we raise the standard of living of women and girls so that the human population naturally decreases, so that there are more resources for each person, so that we have a sustainable energy system, comfortable transportation system, so that people everywhere have a comfortable, happy, have the opportunity to be comfortable and happy, uh, for forever, for, till the extent of humankind.
44:33 Chuck Nice? A noble, noble cause, no doubt. Tricia McClellan wants to know this. Hey, since we've got more Cosmos, why not more Science Guy?
44:42 Bill Nye? Your people need you, Bill! I'm working on it. Hey, I'm a host on StarTalk Radio. The longest journey starts with a single step. You're listening to StarTalk Radio and you should do what I do when I listen to this show, Chuck.
44:55 Chuck Nice? What's that?
44:56 Bill Nye? Turn it up loud! Next question.
45:01 Chuck Nice? Nathan Smith wants to know, as a student in STEM, what types of things do you suggest I do now to accelerate science literacy in the United States of America?
45:13 Bill Nye? Well, as always, the single, oh, I have to add this. The, uh, single best indicator of whether or not anyone will pursue a career in math and science is not science class as such. It's, right now, it's algebra. So whatever you can do to promote human understanding of algebra will writ large change the world!
45:36 Chuck Nice? Fantastic! And Brittany wants to know this. Bill, have you ever invented something? If not, what would you like to invent?
45:45 Bill Nye? I have a couple patents, Chuck.
45:46 Chuck Nice? Do you?
45:47 Bill Nye? Yes.
45:47 Chuck Nice? Alright.
45:48 Bill Nye? Uh, the improved ballet toe shoe, a magnifying glass made of water, and, um, and then the, uh, digital abacus, which helps you learn binary arithmetic. But what would I like to invent? This other baseball thing I'm working on. So stay tuned, uh, to StarTalk in general. This has really been fun, Chuck.
46:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for listening to StarTalk Radio. I hope you enjoyed this episode. Many thanks to our comedian, our guest, our experts, and I've been your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson. Until next time, I bid you to keep looking up.
Previous The Future of Humanity with Elon Musk Next StarTalk Live! from SF Sketchfest 2015 Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated