Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! Evolution with Richard Dawkins (Part 2) About this episode Our evolutionary journey concludes with Neil deGrasse Tyson, Richard Dawkins, Bill Nye, Eugene Mirman, Jim Gaffigan and Maeve Higgins, recorded live at the Beacon Theatre in NYC.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Live from Beacon Theater, StarTalk 3.
0:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Richard, when I was in college, my freshman year, I attended a full-year course on art and design. One of the more influential courses of my life. And we spent the first month or two drawing nudes. And that was fun, I thought. But it became clear to me immediately that the beauty of the human body is a highly overrated concept.
0:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? These were like regular people coming in, taking off their clothes.
1:01 Speaker 01 You can pick who you draw, you know what I mean?
1:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As I saw this, I'm thinking, if I had control of the body, I would have made some changes. Evolutionarily. So can I get you to comment on the difference between how much praising we do of the human body and how much critique should go alongside it if we were honest about ourselves?
1:23 Speaker 02 The famous cases are things like the retina being backwards. It's a historical accident. But the retinal cells, the light-sensitive cells in the vertebrate retina, but not in the octopus retina, they all point backwards. So it's as though you designed a digital camera with the pixels and the forest of wires. The photocells are all pointing backwards, away from the image. And the wires have to run over the surface of the light-sensitive screen.
1:53 Bill Nye? With that said, Richard, I'm not sure that's what Dr. Tyson was driving at. When you looked at the models there in art class, you weren't thinking, "Those retinal cells..."
2:06 Bill Nye? Doggone it!
2:09 Bill Nye? Changes could have been made. Why aren't they more like octopus?
2:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's being erudite in his example.
2:14 Bill Nye? It's cool.
2:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I could give a more basic example. I'm looking at this. Because they're facing all different directions. They're bending over, you know. And I'm thinking.
2:23 Speaker 01 I'm not sure this was an art class.
2:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We have a human body. That where between our legs, we have an entertainment system in the middle of a sewage complex. Okay? So, any engineer would not have designed that.
2:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm certain.
2:43 Bill Nye? Plus, the fuel tank, the nozzle for the fuel tank is right next to the air filter. I mean, stuff's going to go wrong.
2:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, some percentage of us choke to death. We're alive, like, in spite of our body's design.
2:55 Speaker 02 Yes.
2:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And there's a great video, which I highly recommend, where you autopsy a giraffe.
3:02 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah. There's a nerve, which is one of the cranial nerves, and it starts in the brain. And the end organ is the larynx, the voice box. But in this nerve, it's called the recurrent laryngeal. Instead of going straight to the voice box, it goes down into the chest, loops around one of the main arteries in the chest, and then goes straight back up again to the larynx. In a giraffe, that is a very significant
3:29 Speaker 02 diversion.
3:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Could you just say that again? That would just sound... Because it's like the British understatement, right? Say it again. In a giraffe, just so you want to hear that again.
3:40 Speaker 02 No, no, I can't repeat the exact words, but only yesterday, I was doing an episode. Do you know the wonderful Mr. Deity?
3:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've seen videos. Brian Dalton.
3:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, Brian Dalton. He had me on, and I was arguing with him as God about what a lousy job he'd done. And this question of the recurrent laryngeal nerve of the giraffe came up.
4:03 Bill Nye? The way it does.
4:06 Speaker 02 And he said in his wonderful, sort of whiny voice, "But, you know, we had a surplus of laryngeal nerves. We didn't know what to do with it, so we had to use it."
4:15 Speaker 02 It is a very uneconomical thing, and of course the explanation is history. The explanation is that in the ancestors, when this nerve originally started in our fish ancestors...
4:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A vertebrate ancestor.
4:27 Speaker 02 Yes, in a fish. The end organ of this nerve is straight across. It doesn't have to go south into the chest, it goes straight. It is the most direct route. And then as the land vertebrates developed a neck, fish don't have a neck, as the neck lengthened, the marginal cost of slightly increasing the length of the diversion was very small in every generation. It just added a tiny fraction of a millimeter to the diversion. It wasn't, as it were, a great increase in cost. Whereas the cost of jumping it over the blood vessels and making it go straight to the larynx would have been probably some major embryological upheaval.
5:12 Speaker 02 When we were dissecting...
5:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In other words, you'd have to disconnect it, reroute it, and reconnect it.
5:17 Bill Nye? So this is a great insight, is it has to work... All of our ancestors had to work at each stage.
5:23 Speaker 02 Yes, that's right.
5:24 Bill Nye? This is just amazing thing.
5:25 Speaker 02 It's a very important point.
5:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So how long is the nerve in the giraffe? I mean, you gotta see this all the time.
5:31 Speaker 02 You know how long a giraffe's neck is. I mean, the larynx is right near the head.
5:35 Bill Nye? Where you should be.
5:37 Speaker 02 And we dissected this nerve, and it goes...
5:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The giraffe had already died, let me just clarify.
5:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah. It had already died. And the nerve went within an inch of the larynx. And you'd think it would be so easy just to say, oh, well, I mean, any engineer would immediately have said, well, obviously that's where it goes. It goes within an inch of the larynx, it goes on and on and on and on and on, down, down, down the neck, and then round this artery, and then back, back, back, back, back, up to where it started. And it is something that no engineer would countenance, and it would be you to send it straight back, which is what...
6:19 Bill Nye? So the whole, the ideas, the big idea in evolution, Neil and everybody, is it's bottom up. It is not, there's not a designer at the top that showed up and routed the giraffe larynx wire. It just had to work at every stage. You had, talk about piston engine becoming a-
6:39 Speaker 02 A jet engine, yeah.
6:40 Bill Nye? Jet engine. And, and I'd like, another example is, you know, a grocery cart you take to a fairway market or something with two wheels.
6:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bill is now a New York resident, so...
6:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He is fairway fluent. Yes, go Bill.
6:58 Bill Nye? So imagine you took that and made it into a bicycle, but every, at every stage you go to make it into a bicycle, the wheels will be here, across from each other, then they have to be end to end or in tandem. Every stage that you do has to work and reproduce cars.
7:15 Speaker 02 You can't just throw away, you can't throw away the design and start again. It's got to, it's got to-
7:19 Bill Nye? It is really, once you see it, you go, wow, dude.
7:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so how about this, so now, what, what impresses you about the human body?
7:28 Bill Nye? Okay, okay, I'll tell you what, Neil, there are now, there are now 7.2 billion of us.
7:35 Speaker 02 Yes.
7:36 Bill Nye? So whatever it is, it works really well.
7:37 Speaker 02 I mean, I tell you what, I mean, what, what impresses me about the, the body of almost any animal is how elegantly beautiful it is from the outside. If you look at a lion, a cheetah, a gazelle, these are beautiful machines. They're high speed, fast running, either predators or running away from predators, and they-
7:58 Eugene Mirman? Gazelles, ah!
7:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, they, they are very beautiful things, and we all think they are beautiful, but if you cut them open, it's a mess.
8:09 Bill Nye? The same is true of cars and rockets and airplanes.
8:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Luke Skywalker figured this out, you know, on the ice planet.
8:17 Bill Nye? Yeah, he did.
8:20 Speaker 02 There's another nice example.
8:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I thought it was Luke. Excuse me. Han Solo.
8:29 Speaker 01 Feel that nerd rage? Oh my god.
8:35 Speaker 02 There's another...
8:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cut's open and guts spill all out.
8:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, and another nice example, which is a bit like the recurrent laryngial, the tubes that connect the testes to the penis.
8:47 Speaker 01 Uh huh.
8:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
8:52 Speaker 02 They don't go by the most direct route. They go up and they loop around...
8:58 Speaker 01 Mine hang down.
9:03 Bill Nye? Just that the prostate gland gets involved, like what's going on?
9:06 Speaker 02 Well, that's even worse, but they go up and they loop around the tube that comes from the bladder. And that's again, it's a historical accident.
9:15 Speaker 01 Is that because that's where fish had their balls?
9:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so you're cool with what animals look like on the outside, but when you cut them open, it's nasty, ugly stuff.
9:30 Speaker 02 If you look at inside a car, the exhaust manifold, the tubes all kind of cut in a nice neat row, don't they? Whereas if you look at the similar thing, the main artery leading off the heart, it's sort of, it's vaguely similar, but it's just not well-designed.
9:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, how about all this other stuff that goes on, like male pattern baldness? Where does that come from?
9:51 Speaker 02 Well, anything that tends to characterize age. The longer you've lived, the greater your chance of already having passed your genes on. And so, we're all descended from an unbroken line of people who lived long enough to reproduce. Very few of us are descended from ancestors who were very old when they reproduced.
10:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So there's no sexual selection?
10:16 Speaker 02 Not just sexual selection, but any kind of selection is weaker the older you get, because you've already passed the genes on. I mean, if you think about a more unpleasant example, like getting cancer. A gene that makes you get cancer when you're 50 has already been passed on by the time you reproduce. A gene that makes you get cancer when you're 10 has never been passed on.
10:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it would lead a very short life.
10:40 Speaker 02 So the older you get, the more likely you are to be hit by lethal genes which have slipped through the net.
10:48 Bill Nye? This is part of what I was calling "good enough." You're good enough. Your eyesight, my eyesight, is good enough to get us this far.
10:55 Eugene Mirman? Basically bald people have sex when they're 20 and no one knows they're gonna be bald.
11:00 Bill Nye? Yeah.
11:03 Speaker 01 So if you don't have kids before you go bald, you never will.
11:09 Speaker 02 Baldness is very fashionable nowadays.
11:11 Bill Nye? I was gonna say, ladies, help me out. Some guys rock the bald thing, right?
11:15 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:16 Speaker 01 I thought by ladies. Those women clapping are married to bald guys.
11:21 Eugene Mirman? I'm sure Vin Diesel is still sexually active.
11:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let me ask. As we go forward in time, what becomes of organs that are not, you know, vestigial organs? So your appendix perhaps? The toenail on your pinky toe. Of what possible value is that ever going forward?
11:42 Bill Nye? Well, of what possible...
11:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, people still put toenail polish on. I've seen women with like the tiniest little nail and a toenail polish on.
11:49 Bill Nye? Let me turn the question around two ways.
11:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, turn it around.
11:52 Bill Nye? First of all, what's the cost of having that? Does it hold you back some way?
11:58 Eugene Mirman? It's why I can't be president.
12:02 Bill Nye? And if there's no cost to it, it'll just persist? Secondly...
12:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But it won't persist forever because you can have copying errors that don't...
12:10 Bill Nye? Do you think it would inhibit a woman's chance of hooking up if she showed up without a pinky toe?
12:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If her picture on Tinder was of her toes and she was missing a toe? I think that would be a pass on that one.
12:26 Bill Nye? No, let's take it.
12:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm just thinking.
12:29 Bill Nye? No, no. Let's take a summer day in Central Park, where the women are rocking their sandals, right? And they've got their toes painted and all that stuff. And a woman shows up with no pinky. You don't think a guy would give a chin stroke and maybe veer off on that?
12:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know.
12:46 Speaker 02 I think you underestimate the, um...
12:52 Speaker 02 Although I will underestimate my tremendous respect for it.
12:57 Eugene Mirman? It's like the day in and day out.
12:59 Speaker 02 People have done, Haldane and Stebbins and people have done mathematical calculations on this question of something being too trivial to matter. If you put into the equations of evolution an assumption that something utterly trivial like a tiny little toenail or lack of a pinky, and you set a value on the selective pressure against it, you make it as low as you like, and then you calculate how many generations it would take at that low selection pressure to eliminate it, and Haldane did it, and J.B.S. Haldane. J.B.S. Haldane, and it came to something like 12,000 generations if you set it at a value so trivial that you couldn't detect it in fieldwork.
13:44 Speaker 02 12,000's not that many. That's right. Ah, ah. That's the point. Stebbins did a calculation, how long would it take a species of mouse-sized animals if they were subjected to relentless pressure to get bigger? How long would it take to become as big as an elephant? If you assume that the pressure to get bigger is so trivial that it's impossible to detect in ordinary field experiments. So you've got field biologists going around catching mice, measuring them, and it's in the noise level. They can't detect it. So Stebbins set the selection pressure at this very low level. Did he put it in the noise? That he put it in the noise, and then he calculated how long it would take
14:27 Speaker 02 to become elephant-sized, and I forget the result, but the point was that it was so fast that you wouldn't detect it on the paleontological timescales. It would look like an instantaneous change.
14:40 Eugene Mirman? How much would you have to scare mice to make them much bigger? Like said I, not me, but, uh...
14:45 Speaker 02 Yeah.
14:46 Eugene Mirman? Like, so how long is it?
14:47 Speaker 02 No, this is a fascinating point.
14:49 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, yeah.
14:49 Speaker 02 So it's why you can look in the fossil record and see a T. rex that's this big. Exactly. But there's no half a T. rex. Exactly. Right. There's a mismatch between what field biologists can measure on the one hand, it's in the noise, and what fossil hunters can measure on the other hand. And now, it probably doesn't mean, usually there are intermediaries, but if there are not, then you can appeal to Stebbins's calculation.
15:11 Eugene Mirman? So how many generations about, if it's 12,000 for people? I think it's two.
15:17 Speaker 02 Well...
15:18 Eugene Mirman? Is there a similar estimate for how many generations?
15:21 Speaker 02 I've forgotten the figure, but I mean, it's in the tens of thousands, which is which is an eye blink on the geological test.
15:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, totally. So, let me end this segment with a question for you to address. Different people give different answers to this, I want your answer. Are we getting smarter or stupider? Because sometimes, I don't know.
15:43 Speaker 02 I am completely baffled by the Flynn effect.
15:46 Eugene Mirman? The what effect?
15:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Flynn effect.
15:48 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
15:49 Speaker 02 Named after a man called Flynn.
15:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was gonna guess that, yeah.
15:52 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
15:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But it was a man, not a woman.
15:55 Speaker 02 It was a man, actually, yeah. And Flynn, he's a psychologist who's been studying IQ. Now, IQ is actually standardized so that the average is 100, but he allowed for that. And he finds that over the course of the 20th century, average IQ has been going up massively. And I must say, I don't notice it.
16:21 Speaker 02 But the data seem to be there, and I wish it were true.
16:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
16:30 Bill Nye? What it may come down to is being smart may not be of that great value.
16:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that's where I was gonna go with this.
16:36 Bill Nye? Compared to your ability to resist germs.
16:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, we tell ourselves that being smart gives us an advantage. Where I'm thinking, if being smart gave you an advantage, there'd be many more other, what we would think of as smart animals in the tree of life.
16:51 Speaker 02 Yes.
16:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And in apocalyptic earth, we're extinct, a whole lot of other animals rise up in our place, and no one ever accused them of being smart. So, can you comment on the value of being smart with regard to evolutionary survival and natural selection?
17:06 Speaker 02 We were talking earlier about the number of times things have evolved, and you know, eyes have evolved 40 times. Linguistic intelligence, the sort of intelligence we have where we can actually formulate philosophical thoughts, has only evolved once, and didn't evolve until the world had been around for more than 4 billion years.
17:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, I tweeted on this recently.
17:26 Speaker 02 Did you, yes?
17:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, with regard to farm animals. I was just wondering if farm animals, when they're just chewing their cud, if they're contemplating the history and fate of the universe? If they have theories of the universe that they're thinking about. So, then I wondered if the farm animals...
20:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know where that finger is gonna go.
20:15 Eugene Mirman? Are you giving a very long version of "Yes, it's possible"?
20:18 Speaker 02 Let me start again. You could probably make males lactate by giving them hormone injections. So you do that, and then you breed from those males who need the least amount of hormone injection in order to lactate.
20:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To selectively breed.
20:35 Speaker 02 And gradually, as the generations go by, you gradually wean them off the hormone injections. And this is actually quite an instructive illustration of something called the Baldwin Effect.
20:46 Speaker 05 The Baldwin Effect?
20:47 Speaker 02 Baldwin Effect, yes.
20:48 Eugene Mirman? Where you get very angry?
20:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There are Baldwins that live in the city.
20:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, okay.
20:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Famous actors.
20:58 Speaker 02 The idea is that originally, a change comes about through a non-genetic means, through, say, learning, or through, in this case, hormone injections. And that exposes genetic variation which was not otherwise visible. And so in this case, the hormone injection is exposing that certain males are a bit more likely to lactate than others. But they don't have the opportunity to do so until you get the hormone injection. And so you use the hormone injection as a way of bringing to the surface genetic variation which was there all the time.
21:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But unexpressed. That's an interesting way to manipulate the genome. I guess we've been doing that with wolf genes from the beginning, and creating the whole diversity of dogs. Getting the one that's slightly more friendly, that's not gonna bite you, that's a little cuter, that's smaller. And we go from a wolf to a Pomeranian, right?
21:50 Eugene Mirman? In just two weeks.
21:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Call now. What about... I'm just thinking, the wolf sees a Pomeranian, I'm just wondering, what is the wolf thinking? Like, that we must be completely messed up as humans to take a wolf gene and turn it into... A puffball. So, so, in that vein, I'm wondering, if we can manipulate genomes in this way, how real is Jurassic Park? Or, more disturbingly, how real would any eugenics movement be? Given the control we now have, or the access we now have to the human genome?
22:28 Speaker 02 You're making a distinction between manipulating genes directly and doing it by selection. The way you turn a wolf into a Pomeranian is by selection. It's just the artificial equivalent of natural selection.
22:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We could do that with humans.
22:42 Speaker 02 And we could do that with humans. There's no question about that we could do it with humans. If you really wanted to breed a human equivalent of a Pomeranian, you could do it.
22:52 Bill Nye? Kardashian joke, anyone?
22:55 Speaker 01 I'm about bringing love.
22:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But isn't that what Hitler was attempting?
22:58 Speaker 02 It is, yes. It is what Hitler was attempting. He was attempting to make these dreadful, you know, tall, blonde, blue-eyed...
23:05 Speaker 01 I'm right here, alright?
23:17 Eugene Mirman? Hitler wanted to create a comic that exclusively jokes about food.
23:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's odd if he's trying to breed blond-haired people because he had black hair, last I checked. That's just an odd fact to me. So, right, there's selective breeding.
23:31 Speaker 02 You could do selective breeding, or you could do the other half, which is the mutational part. You could induce mutation. You'd have to know a lot more genetics than we know at present, but the time will come.
23:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nothing's in the way.
23:41 Speaker 02 No.
23:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, and so, is that in our future? Should it be in our future?
23:46 Speaker 02 Should is a different question from is it?
23:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Who decides if it will be in our future?
23:48 Speaker 02 Well, that's a political question.
23:50 Speaker 01 It should probably be up to me.
23:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Want to be the...
23:54 Eugene Mirman? What sort of stuff would we be able to do if we genetically manipulated people? And would it be, like, awesome, or weird?
24:00 Speaker 02 Yes, I mean, if you wanted to make a brilliant musician, you might be able to do that.
24:06 Eugene Mirman? Oh, really?
24:06 Speaker 02 Not yet. At present, the most you can do is...
24:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, you wouldn't make a brilliant musician. You'd make a person who could be a brilliant musician.
24:14 Speaker 02 Exactly, yeah.
24:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But they have to want to do that.
24:16 Eugene Mirman? Who genetically was pretty exposed to jamming.
24:18 Speaker 02 They're still got to practice, yes.
24:20 Bill Nye? But notice that you don't know...
24:21 Speaker 01 But for every musician you tried to make, you'd make a lot of baristas, right?
24:32 Speaker 01 Which is where the morality comes in. But I love coffee, so we should do it.
24:41 Bill Nye? So another question, though, is what is of the greatest value? What trait do you want to select for? And it may be that the best thing to have in 50 years is resistance to Ebola virus.
24:53 Speaker 02 Yeah.
24:53 Bill Nye? That may be like actually much better than smart-
24:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you rank what it is we can-
24:58 Bill Nye? What's useful and what's gonna be passed forward. Rather than blue eyes, blonde hair, or whatever the heck, glasses.
25:04 Speaker 02 That's right.
25:05 Speaker 01 Yes. Genetically engineered people, well, not great.
25:10 Speaker 02 There is genetic resistance to AIDS. And I actually did a television documentary in which I went to Nairobi, where-
25:17 Bill Nye? You were born in South Africa, right?
25:18 Speaker 02 I was born in Kenya, yeah.
25:21 Speaker 01 Let's see your birth certificate.
25:35 Speaker 02 As you know, AIDS is a very, very serious epidemic in Africa. And there is a population of prostitutes in Nairobi who are resistant to AIDS. And I went with this television-
25:47 Bill Nye? Are they immune?
25:49 Speaker 02 Yes.
25:49 Bill Nye? Or it's easier on them?
25:51 Speaker 02 I think they're immune.
25:53 Speaker 01 They don't get HIV.
25:54 Speaker 02 They get HIV, but they don't-
25:57 Bill Nye? They don't get acquired immunity.
25:58 Speaker 01 But it doesn't do anything to them.
26:00 Bill Nye? So have HIV and it doesn't manifest as AIDS?
26:02 Speaker 02 I think that's right.
26:03 Bill Nye? That's what you're saying, okay.
26:04 Speaker 02 I'm not sure if that's right, but I went and interviewed- For television, you just interview one person. You don't do a statistical sample. And I interviewed one Nairobi prostitute. And I asked her how long she'd been in that profession, and she said 20 years. And I said, "What about all the friends who started at the same time as you?" She said, "They're all dead. They all died of AIDS." And I said, "Well, why do you think you didn't die?" And she said, "I think God must be looking after me." So I said, "Well, why didn't God look after all your friends?"
26:39 Speaker 02 And she said, "Well, I can't answer that. And I'll tell you this: God is extremely fond of condoms."
26:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
26:51 Speaker 05 Wow. And so, what was her feeling? So like, is this group of women who work as prostitutes, are they like being studied by?
27:00 Speaker 02 Yes.
27:00 Speaker 05 How did they figure it out, sort of first place?
27:03 Speaker 02 There's a Canadian team working on them, and working on the...
27:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Almost any verb.
27:11 Speaker 01 During this interview with a prostitute.
27:17 Speaker 05 But that's incredible, that they've survived.
27:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, it's not incredible in the biggest of pictures. This is to say it is not unreasonable that somewhere, somebody's gonna have a resistance to this virus.
27:30 Speaker 02 There's a mutation which gives you resistance, and it survives.
27:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the greatest diversity of human genes is still in Africa.
27:38 Speaker 02 Yeah.
27:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, when I look at the animal kingdom, I say, "All right, there's a newt that can regenerate its tail, and there's a snake that can see in the infrared." And I'm looking at this talent, this biological talent, expressed in the genetics of animals that we don't have as humans. So, if there is a common ancestor between humans and newts, should there be some gene within us, or some gene insertable to us, that we can turn on and then be able to regenerate limbs, first for army veterans?
28:17 Speaker 02 I do know that the genes for smelling things, which so many other mammals have, we've got most of those genes, but they're turned off. And so, our ancestors must have been able to smell as well as dogs, or maybe not quite, but certainly as well as other mammals. And we seem to have lost that ability. But the genes are still there in vestigial form.
28:38 Speaker 01 But is it because we live in cities now and it's probably best that way?
28:41 Speaker 02 No, it's not.
28:44 Eugene Mirman? Let's not turn him on too much in New York.
28:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, I think we are genetically closer to dogs than we are to newts, I presume.
28:52 Speaker 02 Yes.
28:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it harder to find where the gene is for regenerating limbs? Is it deep in us somewhere, or is that just so vestigial as to be completely lost?
29:00 Speaker 02 I'm not sure that you'd be right to call it a gene in that case. I think there's probably something deeply buried in the kind of embryology that we have, the newts have, which would make it difficult.
29:12 Bill Nye? But, Richard, also, I mean, this was the charm, the amazing, the potential. Everybody was so excited about stem cells.
29:18 Speaker 02 Yes.
29:19 Bill Nye? Right, that if you knew what you were doing, you could get stem cells to make anything.
29:24 Speaker 02 Yes, yep, well, maybe.
29:25 Bill Nye? New hips, new knees, new arms and so on.
29:27 Speaker 02 Actually, that's right, yes.
29:28 Bill Nye? As I understand it, the problem is, the cloning of Dolly the sheep was done mechanically. These guys got this fantastically fine pipette, and they poked it into the cell, which was from a mammary cell, and that's why they called her Dolly. I'm not joking. And they poked the DNA into the cell, and it fused and grew, right?
29:51 Speaker 02 Yeah.
29:52 Bill Nye? And so that technique, that cloning technique, would be exactly the same technique that you would use to affect any stem cell. And this caused lawmakers, at least in the US, to, if I may, like, totally freak.
30:08 Bill Nye? And so, that's why stem cell research was generally put to a halt. And let me go on to ramble, that you don't want to clone yourself.
30:18 Eugene Mirman? Why?
30:19 Bill Nye? Yeah.
30:20 Eugene Mirman? Imagine how fun it would be?
30:22 Speaker 01 We shouldn't clone that jacket of yours either, but...
30:28 Bill Nye? It's a radio show.
30:34 Bill Nye? But the jacket, some people like the jacket.
30:37 Speaker 01 I think a lot of people. Yay!
30:42 Bill Nye? But if you were to clone yourself, then this new person that you created would be genetically identical to you, would not have the great advantage that you get with sex. And with sex, you get a new combination of genes. And it is one very good theory of why you want a new combination of genes is because your enemies are not lions and tigers and bears or wolves. Your enemies are germs and parasites, are Spanish flu and Ebola.
31:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In that vein, Richard, do you have friends who want to reconstruct the flu virus from 1918?
31:16 Speaker 02 Well, I'm sure that there are probably-
31:18 Bill Nye? Your answer wasn't no to that question.
31:19 Speaker 02 Not friends. There are germ warfare possibilities, which are horrific. And cloning the 1918, whatever it is, 1919 flu virus would be a horrible thing to do.
31:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But we have the power to do that.
31:33 Bill Nye? Hold on, but isn't that virus still extant?
31:35 Speaker 02 I don't know.
31:35 Bill Nye? By the way, this virus killed more people with 50 million, estimates vary, 50 million people, many, many more than were killed by fighting in World War I.
31:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
31:45 Bill Nye? In the same winter.
31:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Factor two.
31:47 Bill Nye? Yeah.
31:48 Speaker 01 Is it still out there?
31:49 Bill Nye? That's remarkable.
31:50 Speaker 02 I'm not sure. I don't know that.
31:52 Bill Nye? Why would it disappear? Aren't we all descendants of people who could handle that? By handle it, I mean-
31:57 Speaker 02 Yes, I guess that-
31:58 Bill Nye? Live through it.
31:59 Speaker 01 So you go ahead and make your flu. I don't care.
32:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, most of the people that it killed already had sex and babies. It took out the top end of the age distribution.
32:10 Speaker 02 I think it took young, I think it-
32:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It also did that, but I mean-
32:12 Bill Nye? When I've been to cemeteries in Seattle, we did a show on it, and there's a lot of kids that were killed that winter, people six, seven years old. How many people, may I ask, how many people have had a flu shot this season? How many people, how many people have not?
32:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Neil, when I grew up, I swam in the Hudson River.
32:35 Bill Nye? Okay.
32:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So-
32:37 Bill Nye? Okay, I got you.
32:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't need a shot to protect me from anything.
32:40 Bill Nye? I know that sentiment, but let's say hypothetically, everybody, there were a vaccine for Ebola. How many people would not want it because you just don't believe in vaccines, Neil? Wouldn't everybody want it?
32:54 Speaker 01 I think everyone would want it. And whoever classed it, okay.
32:57 Bill Nye? So in a similar vein, I ride the subway, I meet people, I would just assume you all got flu vaccinations.
33:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, so you're saying, why wouldn't someone get the flu vaccine, right?
33:07 Bill Nye? Well, we wonder why people don't get vaccines.
33:09 Speaker 05 It's just like, you just get so busy and...
33:15 Speaker 02 No, but it's a...
33:15 Bill Nye? No, that's a good reason.
33:16 Speaker 02 But it's a serious point, that it's not just protecting yourself, it's protecting the herd. Because, the whole thing about epidemiology is that if you can get a sufficiently large number of people immunized, an epidemic won't get going. And so it is actually antisocial.
33:33 Speaker 01 I'll get a flu shot, I just haven't had it yet. So, I got a flu shot, so I'm a good guy.
33:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
33:41 Bill Nye? Well, you're on this side of it.
33:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:44 Bill Nye? Good or bad, just, I don't know, man.
33:46 Speaker 05 But, I'm sorry, he can't get the flu now, can he?
33:49 Bill Nye? Can't get this year's flu.
33:51 Speaker 05 Yeah.
33:52 Bill Nye? Unless a new one evolves.
33:54 Speaker 02 Which they do very quickly.
33:55 Bill Nye? Which can happen, and you can get infected with that.
33:57 Speaker 01 It's like cell phones, whenever you buy the one, then they...
34:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Richard, if we have control over the genetics of ourselves, of our food supply, I presume this is a good thing, but is there a downside to it? Might we be experimenting incompetently, ultimately making a mistake we would later regret?
34:39 Eugene Mirman? Like tomatoes that are wolves.
34:42 Bill Nye? Well, yeah, but like, like fish genes in tomatoes.
34:46 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
34:47 Bill Nye? And I'm not kidding, so, George Washington, apparently, uh, Richard, George Washington was, uh...
34:56 Eugene Mirman? You're not gonna like it when you hear the story.
35:01 Speaker 02 My ancestor, General Sir Henry Clinton, commanded British forces in the American Revolutionary War.
35:08 Bill Nye? And you're proud of that?
35:11 Speaker 01 So, you're bragging about him fighting in the Revolutionary War?
35:14 Eugene Mirman? You didn't say which side.
35:15 Speaker 01 Oh, which side?
35:17 Eugene Mirman? Everyone here at first was British.
35:19 Bill Nye? So, so the deal is, George Washington bred wheat. Took pollen from one wheat stalk and shook it onto the eggs, the ova of another one, to try to hybridize, or he did, I guess, hybridize wheat. And we still do that. And that's intra-species, if I may say, that is within a species. But then, when people take genes from a fish that is real good in cold water, and put it in tomatoes to try to get the tomatoes to be real good on cold days, that's when you're kind of crossing a line, right?
35:50 Speaker 01 Yes.
35:51 Bill Nye? So here's what, you can know what'll happen to the tomato, but you can't know exactly what'll happen to the ecosystem that the tomato is in. And so the famous couple of cases for this with the corn. In the US, we're crazy for our corn, Richard, we love our corn. And we had the European corn boar insect was eating the corn, "Thank you."
36:18 Bill Nye? And these guys took, these people took the gene from a virus in the soil and put it in the gene of the corn. And when the corn boar eats the corn, the corn crystallizes and the corn boars die.
36:34 Bill Nye? They also messed around so that you could spray the corn with this crazy, super-strong weed killer, Roundup. And that was great, the corn could tolerate that, but the milkweed, which lives in the same cornfield, couldn't. And so the problem there, anyone? Right, monarch butterflies. So monarch butterflies, like any butterfly, love milkweed pollen. And so when you killed all the mil-, or a lot of the milkweed, there was huge concern that you would wipe out the monarch butterfly population. Everybody likes monarch butterflies, they're so cool, they fly around. And they're probably
37:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think you like them because they're beautiful.
37:11 Bill Nye? Yeah, that way.
37:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they live in
37:14 Bill Nye? And they do extraordinary things and I've watched them, they fly really, they can fly upwind.
37:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's an example of there might be unintended
37:23 Bill Nye? Unintended consequences, so we have huge monocultures, which we call Iowa. The corn in Iowa goes on for a long time. If you ever drive or ride your bicycle across Iowa, you will not miss it.
37:36 Bill Nye? And if we did something to make that enormous crop not survive by accident, that could be huge trouble, huge trouble.
37:44 Speaker 02 So the general lesson would be that if you mess around with anything, you may destroy an ecosystem. But that doesn't particularly apply to putting fish genes in tomato plants.
37:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not specifically so, that's right.
37:55 Bill Nye? That we know of.
37:56 Speaker 02 You have to be careful with anything you do. It's not just putting genes.
38:00 Bill Nye? But what could we have a rule, okay to breed within a species, but you gotta do some super crazy diligent testing to breed between species.
38:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Should always test, always, yeah.
38:12 Speaker 02 I'm not sure that's the right division. I mean, I'm not sure that between
38:15 Bill Nye? What is it?
38:15 Speaker 02 I don't know. I mean, I think that
38:17 Bill Nye? Well, let's do it anyway.
38:19 Speaker 02 The precautionary principle where just be very, very careful whatever you do. I wouldn't make the divide between intra and interspecifically.
38:26 Bill Nye? Oh, really? Okay.
38:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Favorite line, I was told it appeared in a Kurt Vonnegut novel, I don't remember which one, where it postulates, what's the last sentence ever spoken on Earth? It's, "Let's try it this way."
38:44 Bill Nye? And that gets into this verb that "it should work."
38:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is there still enough natural selection going on so that we'll be the strongest? Or will we meddle with our genes so that tomorrow, natural selection's irrelevant?
38:58 Bill Nye? So, Neil, it's not being the strongest, it's fitting in the bestest. It's not being the greatest weightlifter. It's making sure you fit in.
39:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm talking about forces here. What is the... Of all the things that could affect us genetically, what is the greatest among them?
39:15 Speaker 02 Selection is still going on with us.
39:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what way are we evolving?
39:19 Speaker 02 Well, probably we're being selected by viruses, by bacteria, that kind of thing.
39:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're evolving, but we're not speculating.
39:27 Speaker 02 We're probably no longer being selected to get brainier. I mean, clearly, in the last two or three million years, there's been selection for us to get bigger brains and to get cleverer. That's clearly happened, if you look at the fossils. And so during that time, it must have been the case that the brainiest individuals survived and reproduced. In order for that still to be going on, it would be necessary that the brainiest individuals have the most children.
39:52 Bill Nye? Okay, is it the most children or the most children that survive to have children?
39:56 Speaker 02 Well, that, of course. But it's enough to point out that there's absolutely no reason to think that being clever makes you likely to have lots of children. Quite the reverse.
40:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The film Idiocracy built their entire plotline on that very premise.
40:09 Speaker 02 Yeah.
40:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because people who are highly educated and call themselves smart, and other people who call them smart, they like delay having children, and then they might not have children. And meanwhile, others are just having babies. The babies are just popping out. And so if that tendency is heritable, then...
40:27 Speaker 02 But Martin Rees, who's more or less typifies the great and the good in British science. He's a president of the Royal Society and all that sort of stuff. He has written a book in which he gives the human species a 50% chance of making it through this century, the 21st century.
40:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Of course, possibly going extinct that day.
40:42 Speaker 02 Yes. He's worried about massively powerful weapons falling into the hands, not of vaguely responsible governments, but falling into the hands of...
40:52 Eugene Mirman? Like New Hampshire?
40:55 Speaker 02 Well, terrorists. Terrorists.
40:57 Speaker 01 Go ahead, I'm sure.
40:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'd self-destruct.
40:59 Speaker 02 The principle of deterrence, which is the nuclear standoff, presupposes that everybody wants the world to live and go on. Now we've got people who, for religious reasons, want to die.
41:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, or quite okay with dying, right?
41:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, and so if they got their hands on a biological weapon, the normal deterrence might not apply.
41:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that's in the calculation, you're saying?
41:21 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But going forward, again, the people, like you said, the genes that will go for are the ones who have the most children. And Jim, how many kids do you have?
41:30 Speaker 01 I have five, but I haven't talked to my wife in an hour, so...
41:35 Speaker 01 Could be more.
41:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Jim, you earlier in this show commented on your poor eyesight.
41:42 Speaker 01 Yes.
41:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And your sun-sensitive skin.
41:45 Speaker 01 Yes.
41:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And your receding hairline.
41:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
41:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you have the most children of any of us here.
41:50 Speaker 01 I'm good in bed. He's also... Very good in bed. He's a generous lover. I'm a generous lover. Yeah, no, I didn't plan to start my own nationality, but...
42:07 Speaker 01 It seemed like a good idea.
42:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Bill Nye, you are who any one of us would choose to be the professor on Gilligan's Island if any one of us were caught on Gilligan's Island. Do I have agreement there?
42:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Bill, you have how many children?
42:26 Bill Nye? I don't have any.
42:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
42:27 Bill Nye? But I've still got my eye on Mary Ann.
42:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mary Ann?
42:31 Bill Nye? I'm still thinking.
42:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mary Ann from Gilligan's Island, yes.
42:38 Speaker 01 So what was the point?
42:41 Speaker 01 I mean, was the point like, "Jim, you're a moron. You have five kids. He's the science king of the world. He has none. We're doomed, is that the idea?"
42:53 Speaker 01 Let me tell you something.
42:57 Speaker 01 Alright, here, I have a question, I have a question.
43:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm picking Bill. If we're gonna survive on a desert island and make radios out of coconuts, I'm picking Bill.
43:07 Eugene Mirman? But if you just wanna hook up.
43:08 Speaker 01 You know that Gilligan's Island.
43:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What, Jim, what do you got?
43:15 Speaker 01 You know, I do have a question for this esteemed panel. I think that the overpopulation thing is a myth. I think it's an absolute myth.
43:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Says the man with five children.
43:26 Speaker 01 Yes, I do. But, you know, it's like, convince me otherwise. I've seen information that said that you can feed everyone. It's not population, it's delivering of food, it's corruption. You know what I mean?
43:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, we weren't here saying that having five kids was bad for the environment. We're saying having five kids makes your genome more populous in the future than Bill's genome. That's all we're saying. You're stating a fact. You're feeling guilty about it.
43:54 Speaker 01 No, but, no, but that's. No, I am.
43:55 Eugene Mirman? You did some great genome stuff.
43:57 Speaker 01 I did some great genome stuff. No, but I am curious, because I think that there is this ongoing, like, you know, I have five kids, and people, like, occasionally friends, and I, individually, I thought, oh, you know, there is this overpopulation crisis, but I did research into it, and it is a myth, isn't it? Or am I wrong?
44:18 Speaker 02 Well, it's surely true that we can go on feeding more people for a while, but not indefinitely.
44:24 Speaker 01 But isn't the population of the earth gonna reach a peak and then go back down? If everybody keeps having five kids. But wait a minute, there's. I'm not proposing, but wait a minute. I'm having five kids, you're having none, how many kids do you have?
44:37 Eugene Mirman? I don't know.
44:38 Speaker 01 How many kids?
44:42 Speaker 01 He's a traveling guy. I mean, stand-up comic.
44:46 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, our average is only, yeah, it's like, what, seven kids?
44:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Maeve, how many children do you have? None that I know of. None?
44:52 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
44:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, a woman can't get away with that sentence.
44:56 Eugene Mirman? Yes, she can. She's unbelievable.
45:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Richard? In a hundred years, a thousand, a million, will we recognize ourselves in that future? Or will we be so different from evolutionary drivers that we might have either more biological talent or perhaps even less?
45:16 Speaker 02 Usually, you get new species when they split, when they speciate. And that's not going to happen with humans.
45:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, don't tell me we get new species when they speciate.
45:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, no. When their eyes...
45:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I need a better answer than that.
45:28 Speaker 02 When populations are come off. When they split, it would be quite difficult for humans to evolve a new species unless a subset of humans was sent off to a different planet or something.
45:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we're all interbreeding now?
45:40 Speaker 02 Yes, we're all interbreeding now. But if we set up colonies on Mars, for example, then it would be not unexpected that they might, in quite a long time, become a separate species which could no longer interbreed with us.
45:54 Eugene Mirman? What if no one went to Australia for 2,000 years? Would that be easier?
45:57 Speaker 02 Yeah.
45:59 Eugene Mirman? All right, I don't think that's what we should do. Just throwing out an easier way to do this.
46:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Australia has already done that experiment.
46:05 Speaker 02 Yeah.
46:06 Eugene Mirman? No, but people keep flying there and hooking up.
46:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, I'm saying, but kangaroos don't keep flying there, right?
46:12 Eugene Mirman? Oh, right, wow.
46:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The animals in Australia are some of the most exotic in the world.
46:16 Speaker 02 But that takes more than 2,000 years.
46:18 Eugene Mirman? Okay, so would Martha's Vineyard be easier, then?
46:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But is there something that we can hope for? And do you see any trend lines? You think about this all the time. We're doing other stuff. Well, you're thinking about life. Is there some direction that you think... No, we won't become another species, perhaps. But the environment might put pressure on ourselves where some of us emerge, others don't. And there's some talent expressed within the genome itself so that in a million years, we won't recognize.
46:48 Speaker 02 I think cultural evolution is so much more important than biological evolution now. I mean, technology is changing so rapidly. And so that's what's really going to change. And that might include genetic engineering, genetic technology. So if we do come back in 1,000 years and find ourselves different, it's more likely to have been engineered differences by human bioengineers rather than by the normal processes of evolution.
47:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And if we become good shepherds of that legacy, there's some hope that we will be better. To ourselves, to our planet, to the...
47:28 Speaker 02 Difficult to agree among ourselves as to what would constitute better.
47:32 Bill Nye? So it's reasonable along that line that, you know, we have this urge to be altruistic, apparently observed in all sorts of species to help each other out. It could be that we will select for people that have a tendency to be better stewards of the earth. That is reasonable.
47:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And another thing is certain, we are also selecting for people who think babies look cute.
47:55 Bill Nye? Yes, and it could be we're selecting for people...
47:58 Eugene Mirman? Even when they're not cute.
48:02 Speaker 05 I think all babies are cute. What does that mean?
48:05 Bill Nye? See?
48:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, people who don't think babies are cute don't have babies, right? That's how that is.
48:10 Bill Nye? So it could be we're selecting for people who have the resources to go to colleges and, what's it called, advanced degrees and still have babies later in life. We could be selecting for that.
48:21 Speaker 02 Something like that, yes.
48:23 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, young professionals.
48:25 Bill Nye? I want to end it here. Thank you all for coming. Star Trek Radio.
Previous StarTalk Live! Evolution with Richard Dawkins (Part 1) Next A Universe of Inspiration (Repeat) Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated