Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast StarTalk Live! Evolution with Richard Dawkins (Part 1) About this episode Science and rationality take the stage when Neil deGrasse Tyson welcomes Richard Dawkins and Bill Nye to NYC’s Beacon Theater to discuss evolution, with help from comics Eugene Mirman, Jim Gaffigan and Maeve Higgins.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Eugene Mirman? Welcome to StarTalk Live. It is my incredibly great pleasure to bring out for you the host, director of the Hayden Planetarium, ladies and gentlemen, Neil deGrasse Tyson!
0:48 Eugene Mirman? All right, it is my great pleasure to bring out two comics. The first of which, she is here from Ireland. She's super funny. Ladies and gentlemen, Maeve Higgins!
0:59 Speaker 02 Thank you, Eugene. Hi!
1:03 Eugene Mirman? It is also my pleasure to bring out an incredible comedian. Ladies and gentlemen, Jim Gaffigan!
1:08 Speaker 03 Thank you, thank you, thank you!
1:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Eugene, you didn't mention that Jim Gaffigan has an album called Mr. Universe. That's right. So, do have a seat. I want to bring out a friend. I've known him for about 12 years. And he's a tireless defender of how we all got here. Give a warm New York welcome to Richard Dawkins!
1:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I will note, Richard did arrive with very British-looking leather shoes. But we had access to moon shoes to put on his feet. More on that later in the show. So, Richard, thank you for donning some moon shoes for us. And tonight, we'll be talking about how humans got here, how life got here, all the spectrum of life we find in the biodiversity of the world. And a good friend of mine has also written a book on that, and I said, "You gotta come join us for the show." The one, the only, Bill Nye!
2:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let's get this party started. Richard, you've had an extraordinary career. You're retired now. You were professor of the public understanding of science at Oxford for many years, a post funded by Charles Simone. He was one of the Microsoft billionaires, if I remember correctly. But he felt deeply that more people needed to know about science. And I just want to applaud your tireless effort to try to get the world to think rationally about this world. And so, thank you. Thank you.
3:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I suppose with his earnings over the years, he could have bought an island and moved there, but instead, he... That's not true. Oh, not true. A small island, then. He founded the Richard... A rock. Richard Dawkins Foundation for Science and Reason, which occupies a lot of his work of late. So, let's get started here. Evolution, we all learn it in our biology class. And you've written on evolution eloquently in many books. My first exposure to you was with The Blind Watchmaker, but that's just one of many books you've written. So I'm just wondering if you could highlight, just for a couple of minutes, just what evolution is. I know it took Darwin many books to do this, but I know you can do it in two minutes.
4:10 Speaker 04 It's why we all exist, it's why all living things exist.
4:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, there we go.
4:17 Speaker 04 It is an astonishing fact that on this planet, the laws of physics got channeled through this remarkable process, Darwin's Evolution by Natural Selection, to produce objects like us, and like kangaroos, and like wombats, and like oak trees, which are, while never actually disobeying the laws of physics, they do remarkable things. They walk, they run, they have sex, they think, they swim, they fly.
4:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They have sex?
4:45 Speaker 04 And they have sex.
4:46 Eugene Mirman? They listen to jazz?
4:52 Speaker 04 And for many centuries, it seemed obvious to everybody that because living things look as though they've been designed, that must mean that they were designed. And it took till as late as the middle of the 19th century, until two geniuses, Charles Darwin and Alfred Wallace, realized what was really going on, which is a purely natural process, an utterly natural process, gave rise to this magnificent complexity, this beauty, and this illusion of design. It works by very, very slow change from generation to generation. It depends upon there being, Darwin wanted to put it like this, but it depends upon there being something like genes, something where you have information.
5:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He didn't have that vocabulary.
5:35 Speaker 04 He didn't have that vocabulary, but we now understand that what happens is that there is highly accurate, high-fidelity information, really like a computer language, which is copied from generation to generation, and within each generation, programmed the development of the body in which it sits. And therefore, the fate of the program is bound up in the fate of the body in which it sits. It's driving around in a vehicle, which is you and me, and a dog, and a rhinoceros. It's driving around in the vehicle.
6:08 Eugene Mirman? Are you gonna stop with those examples? There's no more?
6:11 Bill Nye? Well, and you don't, you probably want to leave out my old boss. I was never sure about him.
6:17 Speaker 04 It doesn't matter what the vehicle is, it can fly, it can swim, all of them are doing the same thing. They're preserving and propagating the instructions that gave rise to them. And as the generations go by, the ones that survive to reproduce, the genes pass on the instructions for making them. And so we are, all of us, descended, by all of us, I mean every living creature, descended from an unbroken line of successful ancestors. Millions and billions of animals died without ever reproducing. Not a single one of your ancestors failed to achieve at least one heterosexual copulation.
6:56 Bill Nye? Troubling as that sounds, because it includes your parents.
7:06 Speaker 04 And had at least one child. We have the genes of an unbroken succession of successful ancestors. And it was those genes that made them successful. And that's why birds are so good at flying, fish are so good at swimming, hedgehogs are so good at whatever hedgehogs do, moles are so good at digging, etc.
7:24 Eugene Mirman? Gambling. Hedgehogs are famous for their gambling.
7:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So getting back to how we might have all learned evolution in our biology class.
7:33 Bill Nye? And by the way, Dr. Tyson, did everybody learn evolution in biology class?
7:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, sorry. You have independent evidence to suggest something different. We'll get back to that. So, I'm just curious, we learned evolution as reproduction, variation, and the product, and it gets carried on. We learned to reject Lamarckianism on the assumption that you can't acquire properties that you then pass genetically. But over the years, we've learned more nuances in the simplified idea of Darwinian evolution. You know, I've heard terms like epigenetics, there are these terms that involve the modification of the genome. After it's already been established that you perhaps could then pass on. What is going on with Darwin now?
8:15 Speaker 04 The big change came with the introduction of genetics into the evolutionary story. Darwin had no concept of genetics.
8:22 Bill Nye? You guys, just stop and think. This guy, or these two guys, came up with this theory that is the basis of life. And they didn't know what DNA was. They had no idea. Wallace and Darwin, I mean, maybe they had an idea, but they did not have X-ray evidence. It's really an extraordinary convergence.
8:39 Speaker 04 Darwin's ideas of genetics were actually completely wrong. What he did have was that there's something that is passed on from generation to generation.
8:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With variation.
8:47 Speaker 04 With variation, that's all he needed. Then Mendel came along, roughly the same time, but Darwin didn't know about it, and showed that genetics was digital. Again, one wouldn't have called it digital in those days, but you either get a gene or you don't get a gene. Genes don't blend, they don't mix. Every one of your genes came from one of your parents, from one of your four grandparents, from one of your eight great-grandparents, etc. They don't blend, they don't mix, they just pass unchanged through the generations. All that changes is the frequencies of them. Some of them survive, some of them don't survive. And that was the great insight of the 1930s. The neo-Darwinian synthesis of the 1930s. People like Ronald Fisher, J.B.S. Haldane.
9:30 Speaker 04 They changed evolution into a genetic view whereby what happens is that as the generations go by, some genes become more frequent in the gene pool. You could literally think of the gene pool as like a bag of balls being stirred about.
9:45 Eugene Mirman? Like a McDonald's playpen.
9:46 Bill Nye? And Haldane is the guy that said, "If there is a God, he must have been..."
9:51 Speaker 04 I'd have an inordinate fondness for Beatles.
9:55 Bill Nye? Because there's a lot of Beatles. A lot of different kinds of Beatles.
9:58 Speaker 04 Haldane also had a nice one. A lady said in an audience such as this, "I simply don't believe that there's been enough time to go from a single-celled ancestor to people like us." And Haldane said, "Madam, you did it yourself, and it only took you nine months."
10:23 Bill Nye? Plus a few minutes.
10:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What role does the environment have on our genes?
10:34 Speaker 04 The main role the environment has is in providing the selection pressure on which genes survive and which don't.
10:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it doesn't alter the genes that we would pass on?
10:45 Speaker 04 The genes that we pass on are altered by the environment in a selective sense. If you're asking, "Does the environment cause mutation? Does the environment cause genes to change?"
10:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's clear.
10:57 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, it does, but not in a very biologically interesting way. Things like cosmic rays cause genes to change.
11:04 Bill Nye? That's pretty interesting.
11:06 Eugene Mirman? Cosmic rays?
11:07 Speaker 04 I said biologically.
11:08 Eugene Mirman? Astraphysical cosmic rays? Are you saying the Fantastic Four is possible?
11:15 Bill Nye? Richard, let me just add, correct me. The thing is, species make more copies of themselves than can survive in an environment. And that's what leads to trouble.
11:25 Speaker 04 This was the big point Darwin made, that there's overproduction, and therefore there's competition. And a minority of individuals usually are the ones that give rise to the next generation. And that minority are the minority that have the genes that it takes to be good at it. It's only a statistical effect, it's not an absolute thing.
11:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, but about epigenetics, we did a show on that for Nova Science Now. It was new to me, just a few years ago. It would not have been new to the biological community. I'm just curious, when I learn about it, and where your genes can actually be altered from what you were born with, and then you would then pass them on to a next generation. Is that true? Did I misunderstand that?
12:05 Speaker 04 Uh, no.
12:07 Bill Nye? No, or no, you didn't misunderstand?
12:09 Speaker 06 This is different from those Travelling Pants movies, right?
12:17 Speaker 06 Because I did two of them.
12:21 Speaker 02 I think, is it like, if you're like, an Irish girl, and you wish you had like, olive skin, so you put on fake tan, and then your kid has olive skin?
12:31 Speaker 02 And then she's like, the sexiest one, and then she gets to...
12:37 Bill Nye? She gets to what? Is there video?
12:39 Speaker 02 She gets to do it.
12:42 Speaker 02 I'm just asking.
12:44 Bill Nye? There's all these...
12:45 Speaker 02 For a friend.
12:46 Speaker 06 If there's genes, why do I have so many recessive genes?
12:50 Speaker 02 Aw, Jim!
12:52 Speaker 06 Balding, eyesight, pale sexy skin.
12:58 Bill Nye? So, one of the remarkable insights in evolution, and I write about it in my book,
13:06 Bill Nye? is you only have to be good enough.
13:13 Bill Nye? I'm not just talking about you.
13:15 Speaker 02 He does have to.
13:16 Bill Nye? Talking about all of us.
13:17 Speaker 06 You know, I made me out of shape, but I can still kick his ass.
13:22 Bill Nye? All of us, you just have to be good enough. Like, if you were gonna design somebody from the top down, you'd probably make some changes, yeah? I mean, the exhaust pipe and the plumbing, there's some issues.
13:35 Bill Nye? But in evolution, you just have to be good enough to make it to the next generation.
13:40 Speaker 04 Yeah, but don't forget, you're competing with others, and so that "good enough" one, I think, is a bit overdone. You're competing with hundreds of others, and if you're just good enough, some of us are going to be a bit better.
13:52 Eugene Mirman? So why don't I have wings?
13:54 Speaker 04 Well, that's a very good-
13:54 Eugene Mirman? And it would definitely make me better.
13:57 Speaker 04 That's a very good question.
13:59 Speaker 06 I mean, the one thing I do know so far is that I'm the smartest person on this panel.
14:06 Speaker 06 Right? I mean, that's pretty obvious.
14:09 Speaker 02 Because you're wearing glasses.
14:11 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's the glasses.
14:16 Eugene Mirman? But why don't people have wings, considering everyone wants wings?
14:19 Speaker 04 It's an excellent question, why don't people have wings? They wouldn't be better off with wings. Wings can get in the way. A queen ant has wings, and she flies and gets mated, and then she digs a hole and starts the nest. The first thing she does is bite her own wings off.
14:34 Eugene Mirman? Oh.
14:34 Speaker 04 Because they get in the way. You don't need wings. Worker ants don't have wings. Ants only grow wings in order to fly, to get mated.
14:41 Eugene Mirman? So I wouldn't want ant wings, but what about regular, like, pretty bird wings?
14:46 Bill Nye? Well, I'll take this one, Richard.
14:51 Eugene Mirman? Yes Neil?
14:52 Speaker 06 So, you dig us out of this one?
14:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I'll save you on this one Richard. So, I ventured a guess, that...
15:00 Bill Nye? Hold it, hold it! You're gonna, you're gonna take over with "I venture a guess"?
15:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I got this one. That, if you had wings, you would either be dead, or have more successful sex.
15:17 Eugene Mirman? The latter is sort of one of the reasons I'm curious.
15:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so...
15:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, the point is-
15:23 Eugene Mirman? I would definitely hide them.
15:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The act of having a feature doesn't always mean you'll be better at reproducing. Just because it would be fun to fly around. You're flying around while other people are not flying around having sex. Their genes get passed on.
15:35 Speaker 06 Are you guys saying the wings are the thing holding you back from getting laid?
15:41 Eugene Mirman? I'm saying if I had wings, yeah, I would definitely-
15:43 Speaker 06 I think there's some other issues.
15:46 Eugene Mirman? Alright.
15:47 Speaker 04 Okay, well let me answer your question. Is there was a science fiction movie in which a man of our size had wings? Bird-sized wings?
15:55 Eugene Mirman? I'm, I'm curious.
15:56 Speaker 04 He couldn't get off the ground.
15:58 Eugene Mirman? We'll call it X-Men.
16:01 Speaker 04 You've got to be fairy-sized. I mean, little fairies, they could have wings. You could have fairies!
16:06 Eugene Mirman? Wait, why couldn't a person-
16:08 Speaker 04 Okay, Jorkins believes in fairies, right.
16:11 Eugene Mirman? Wait, that was-
16:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Richard, she got you on that.
16:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
16:14 Eugene Mirman? Well, why couldn't you just have enormous wings that were fairy-sized in proportion?
16:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You would then need enormous chest muscles.
16:19 Speaker 04 You wouldn't have big enough chest muscles.
16:21 Speaker 06 How do you explain those Victoria's swimsuit models? They're wearing wings, aren't they?
16:28 Bill Nye? Never tried to explain it, I just sort of accepted them.
16:35 Bill Nye? No, but he's talking about if you, and a bird, and the queen ant are made of roughly the same material, we are constrained by the same laws of physics.
16:46 Eugene Mirman? Right. No, no, I understand now why it'd be very different.
16:48 Bill Nye? You were just joking.
16:49 Eugene Mirman? No, no, I could have tiny wings, but they would be ineffective.
16:52 Bill Nye? But you noted if-
16:53 Eugene Mirman? That's what I've gained.
16:54 Bill Nye? But, would you be able to-
16:56 Eugene Mirman? People will hook up with me still, yeah.
16:57 Bill Nye? Yeah, yeah.
16:59 Eugene Mirman? He's an man with tiny wings, it's weird enough.
17:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Eugene, it's a deep law of physics, actually.
17:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
17:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, the bigger you get,
17:07 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
17:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? the higher is the ratio of your mass to your surface area. Okay? And, your surface area is what air goes across in order to give you lift. So as you get bigger, you require that much more surface area for you to attain lift. And, so, for you, at your weight... No, no, sorry!
17:33 Eugene Mirman? He means it in general. We would all have the same difficulty in flying, I understand. Not because of my tummy.
17:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At the American Museum of Natural History, we have collections of birds. Well, before I get to the bird collection, I'm feeling like dinosaur femurs and this sort of thing. And they're all heavy, long bones of other large creatures. And then they show me the femur of a penguin, a bird. Even though it doesn't fly, it felt like it was made of styrofoam. So, the very architecture of birds is lighter than any of the rest of us.
18:08 Eugene Mirman? What about pterodactyls?
18:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know.
18:10 Speaker 04 They're light too.
18:12 Eugene Mirman? They're very light?
18:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
18:13 Bill Nye? So you can go...
18:14 Eugene Mirman? That can't even be a pterodactyl!
18:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bill!
18:16 Bill Nye? Also, what's cool is go to the Air and Space Museum, Washington DC, and you can see the gossamer condor and the gossamer albatross, which they flew across the English Channel. A guy just like you, pedaling a bicycle. He was a world-class athlete of some sort, but the wings are in eighty feet across.
18:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
18:34 Bill Nye? And they're made of super lightweight stuff, and that guy was just barely able to do it.
18:38 Speaker 04 Whereas something like a tiny insect, hardly needs any wings at all, it just more or less floats.
18:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so they have much more surface area relative to their body.
18:47 Speaker 06 That's why those Victoria's Swim seat ladies are so thin.
18:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's got the one-track mind.
18:54 Bill Nye? He's not alone.
19:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Evolution, people accuse it of being random, but it's not really random. It's something in the variation pool survives and that's selected for by the environment. I get that correct. Okay.
19:25 Speaker 04 It's kind of the opposite of random. It's opposite of random.
19:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, the opposite of random. So, in that, we have convergent evolution, which has always intrigued me. Where the capacity for sight, eyesight, has independently developed in the tree of life. And yet has enabled different species to see just fine. That's an extraordinary fact.
19:46 Speaker 04 It is. Sight, eyes of one sort or another, have evolved several dozen times independently. And often have exactly the same design. I mean, the vertebrate eye, which is a camera eye, and the mollusk eyes, especially squid and octopus eyes, are very, very similar indeed. What do you mean by a camera eye? With a lens that focuses a real inverted image on a retina. As opposed to a compound eye, say, or a parabolic reflector eye, which some mollusks have.
20:16 Speaker 06 What kind do people have?
20:18 Speaker 04 We have a camera eye.
20:19 Speaker 02 Camera eye?
20:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
20:20 Speaker 06 A camera eye. And then what's the other eye, what's like a common thing that has that?
20:24 Speaker 04 Well, a compound eye is a thing that insects have and shrimps have and things, where you have a great big hemisphere and lots of little tubes pointing out all over the hemisphere in different directions. And so each tube is looking at a different part of the visual field.
20:39 Speaker 06 It sounds fairly erotic. I think I have that. I have that.
20:43 Speaker 04 Insofar as there's an image at all, it's not an inverted image. Because that tube is looking up there, that tube's looking down there. Whereas in our eyes, that light there is focused on the bottom of my retina and that there is focused on the top of my retina. So, a camera eye has an inverted image. It's a mildly interesting philosophical question, why we see the world the right way up. But I think there were some experiments by a man called Stratton, who actually wore glasses that turned the world upside down. And it took him a few months to get used to it. And then when he took the glasses off, he couldn't see anymore. Brilliant!
21:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hence the expression, "Don't try this at home." Or how about this, "Don't try this while you're driving a cab."
21:26 Speaker 04 Neil, you're quite right. I mean, eyes have evolved independently many, many times. But convergent evolution tends to mean that animals that are not related look very alike because they're doing the same thing. Things like woodlice and pill millipedes, which look exactly the same. When one's a millipede and one's a crustacean, but they look the same.
21:47 Speaker 02 Yet they get so offended when you mix them up at parties.
21:54 Speaker 02 They're all the same to me, I'm sorry.
21:57 Speaker 04 Well, yeah.
21:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, of course, knowing the genome of these things gives you the identity that would otherwise be confused if you just saw their external, just what they look like.
22:06 Speaker 04 Yes, I mean, if you saw a dolphin superficially, you might think it was a fish. But actually, you don't need the genome to know it's not a fish. I mean, it bears its young, it suckles them, and that kind of thing. So it's quite clear that dolphins are mammals. But they are very convergent on, say, tarpons, fast swimming fish in the surface of water.
22:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what I wonder, I just back up for a quick second here. If we say that evolution's anything but random, yet you publish a book called "The Blind Watchmaker", what do you expect people to think by reading that title, other than the whole thing is random?
22:40 Speaker 04 Okay, very important difference between "blind" as in not foreseeing. A watchmaker knows what he's making. He's making a watch, he knows what it's for, it's for a purpose. Every cog, every spring, every screw, every rivet is designed for a purpose. The blind watchmaker, natural selection, has absolutely no foresight at all. It's not random, but it's not foresightful. It blindly follows the path of survival.
23:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whatever that takes.
23:08 Eugene Mirman? So he's not trying to end up with a beaver, but he ended up with a beaver?
23:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:12 Eugene Mirman? As the example of how a beaver came to be.
23:14 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so if I combine these forces, everything you know, this formidable knowledge of life on Earth, and how it got here, and how it speciated, or the forces that drive the speciation. In my field, we invest a fair amount of our intellectual capital thinking about what aliens might look like. To the point where we have to actually constrain the question to say we're looking for life as we know it. Because life as we know it requires liquid water, and a certain temperature range, and certain conditions. So then we design our experiments and our spacewalks to kinda hang with that. So what I wonder is, if we have convergent evolution, might other aliens on other planets have limbs and sight?
23:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And can we judge what they might look like based on your body of knowledge of the biology of life?
24:06 Speaker 04 One of the things you can do is to ask the question of life on this planet, how many times has it evolved? In the case of eyes, it's about forty times. In the case of, say, echolocation, the thing bats do when they use echoes to find their way around, that's only evolved four times. In bats, dolphins, well, tooth whales, and two families of birds. So I'd put more money on eyes evolving than on echolanging evolving. Stings, hypodermic injection of poison, has evolved about twelve times. I think it's a profoundly interesting question. I think we should be speculating more about what life would be like. Never mind about eyes, I mean, would it have to be based on carbon? I suspect it would.
24:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I would suspect that as well.
24:51 Speaker 04 I think only carbon has the necessary...
24:53 Speaker 02 I have, like, very big eyes and a tiny mouth, and I used to get bullied that I looked like an alien. And my comeback was, but there's no such thing, no offence. But I was like, there's no such thing, you know, like, how do you know? And they were like, the X-Files, you know?
25:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So they cited as evidence for why you look like an alien, the aliens they've seen on fictional television shows.
25:16 Speaker 06 Let's stop saying "they", it was me, alright?
25:20 Speaker 06 I was trying to pick her up, it didn't work. Ooh, you look like an alien! Why do so many aliens in movies look like seafood?
25:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
25:32 Bill Nye? That's actually not a bad question.
25:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The aliens also have bigger heads compared with their bodies. They're baby proportions. So, we're trying to get this esteemed man to comment on the thought process of Hollywood.
25:44 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
25:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know if this is not what you studied.
25:47 Speaker 02 I'd like to know what you picture if you do think of maybe...
25:52 Speaker 04 I would...
25:57 Bill Nye? Could we say that most living things on Earth are in the ocean? So if you're gonna create an alien, maybe you start with the ocean?
26:04 Speaker 04 I would rather say things like, "Does there have to be something equivalent of DNA?" And I think that there does.
26:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And information encoding.
26:11 Speaker 04 Information encoding which has to be very high fidelity. It's gotta be extremely accurate. So, I would bet that it won't be DNA itself. That would be too improbable. And if it was DNA, it certainly wouldn't have the same DNA code, which is highly improbable. But there would be something like DNA. It might not even be a one-dimensional code, which is what DNA is. It might be a two-dimensional matrix.
26:33 Eugene Mirman? What would it mean for it to be two-dimensional?
26:35 Speaker 04 A sheet of...
26:36 Eugene Mirman? Sure, but what would it mean for then the creature that had two-dimensional DNA?
26:40 Speaker 04 That might not matter. I mean, that would all be going on in miniature.
26:43 Eugene Mirman? Like huge pants?
26:44 Speaker 04 Yes.
26:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very flat. Could you tell me? I've seen this word "neotony." What is that?
26:50 Speaker 04 Oh, right. That's when juvenile characters are retained into reproductive adulthood. The classic example is the axolotl, which is a salamander, except that it's not a salamander. It's a tadpole. So, it's an adult and it reproduces in the tadpole form. And Julian Huxley did a brilliant experiment. He took some axolotls and injected them with Xeroxing. And he turned them into salamanders, which had never been seen before.
27:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This sounds diabolical.
27:18 Speaker 04 Yes.
27:19 Bill Nye? And by the way, how much do you need? Like, an injection every day? Once?
27:23 Speaker 04 I can't remember. But what's interesting is that his brother, Aldous Huxley...
27:27 Eugene Mirman? He did the same thing, turned him into a salamander?
27:29 Speaker 04 Almost, almost.
27:32 Eugene Mirman? One shot in the neck!
27:34 Speaker 04 It had been already recognised that we humans are a neotinous species. We're juvenile apes. We're apes that have retained juvenile characters into adulthood. If you look at a juvenile chimpanzee, it looks much more human than an adult. So Aldous Huxley speculated that if you could somehow prolong human life, and he had a fictional character, the Duke of somebody or other, who lived to be 300 years old, and turned into a gorilla. Because that was the analogue of his brother Julian's experiment with injecting axolotls with Xeroxing.
28:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is what your professional ancestors have been thinking about?
28:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
28:13 Bill Nye? Neotony, by the way, has the word neo in it, which means new. So it's like, the new thing stays new. The baby stays new.
28:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? My name is Neo.
28:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Richard, let me ask you, evolution is an understanding of how life speciates, and how it can grow or reduce in complexity depending on the needs of the survival of the organism. But at some point, we must presume, we went from non-life to life. So does evolution say anything about that, or any of your professional community? Where do you go there?
28:45 Speaker 04 We know the key step that had to be taken, which was the origin of what you could call the first gene. It wouldn't have been DNA, but it would have been something self-replicating. There's got to be accurate copying. So there had to be some kind of a chemical accident which produced the first self-copying molecule. And it had to be self-copying in an interesting way, that was possible for there to be mistakes which were also copied, and therefore competition between the different types.
29:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Slightly different.
29:15 Bill Nye? Let me ask you, how analogous is this primordial copying to crystals? Crystals and growth?
29:21 Speaker 04 Crystals are a pretty good model for it. In fact, Graham Cairn Smith had an actual theory of the origin of life, that it started with inorganic crystals, and flaws in the crystal, because a crystal grows by atoms...
29:34 Speaker 04 Joining on to existing atoms on the crystal. And if you get a flaw in the crystal, then it's replicated throughout the rest of the growth of that part of the crystal.
29:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the Andromeda strain, the bug that came from space was crystalline.
29:47 Speaker 04 That's right.
29:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Correctly.
29:49 Speaker 04 And it was able to keep its chemicals separate, which of course it still does. In a way, DNA is a crystal, because it makes copies of itself.
29:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's behaving in that way.
29:56 Speaker 04 It's behaving, but it's an information-rich crystal. That had to be the first step. It could have been a very, very improbable step. It could have been so unlikely that it only happened once in the universe. And that's not impossible. Oh, that's so troubling. No, no, it's not. It really isn't. Since we don't know what's in the rest of the universe, if it did only happen once, if there is only one planet in the universe where this singular event happened, then it has to be this planet. That's brilliant. No, but I hope it makes you feel special. Well, I don't believe that, but it is an interesting thought.
30:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here's my argument against that. Okay. If going from non-life to life was so hard, it wouldn't have taken just a few couple of hundred million years on Earth for that to have happened. Here is the timeline of Earth. And at the beginning of Earth, we were like heavily bombarded by leftovers in the solar system, so it's not fair to start the clock there. Let the surface cool a little bit so that complex molecules have some chance of forming. So you subtract off half a billion years. That's about how long our models show that we've been bombarded. Within two or three hundred million years, life appeared.
31:05 Speaker 04 That's a very good argument, and that's one of the reasons why I don't believe what I've just said. It's an interesting thought. We can't rule out that possibility, because anthropically, we have to be on the one planet. And what that would mean, if anybody out there wants to believe that we are alone in the universe, what that means is that the origin of life on this planet was a stupefyingly improbable event, and therefore we're wasting our time speculating about it, because we're not looking for a plausible theory. We're looking for a highly implausible theory. Which is another of the reasons why I don't actually believe that. But there are people who do believe that we are unique in the universe. They want to believe it, and they do believe we're unique in the universe.
31:50 Speaker 04 All I'm saying is that it follows from that, that the origin of life is so improbable. That chemists are wasting their time trying to speculate about how it happened.
31:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because in science, we look for generalized ways that things happen.
32:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
32:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And if you can generalize how life formed, but it only happened once in the whole universe, you're barking up the wrong.
32:08 Bill Nye? With that said, let us keep in mind, we landed Philly on asteroid CP67.
32:18 Bill Nye? And asteroids here on Earth show up loaded with amino acids.
32:23 Speaker 04 Wonderful. This is one of the great things, the famous Miller-Urey experiment, where he managed to get lifelike molecules in his.
32:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Complex organic chemistry.
32:33 Speaker 04 It wasn't necessary. They're turning up all the time in asteroids. And so, the raw materials for making life are all over the universe. I mean, that's a very, very salient, encouraging.
32:43 Eugene Mirman? The building blocks of life are all over in asteroids?
32:45 Speaker 04 Yes.
32:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, yeah.
32:47 Eugene Mirman? Great. I didn't know. Thank you.
32:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so Earth is being spoon-fed these ingredients?
32:54 Speaker 04 Yes.
32:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All the time?
32:55 Speaker 04 All the time.
32:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It just means that we are made of some of the most common ingredients in the universe. Another argument in favor of whatever we became, why think it wouldn't happen that way also?
33:06 Bill Nye? I did this, may I ask if you guys heard about this, I did this debate in Kentucky.
33:15 Bill Nye? And on their website, they point out that in the Urey-Miller experiment, they only got 0.001% amino acids or something. If I may, just a minute, that you got any complex molecules is infinitely more than zero. And so, get your head in the game. Like, for crying out loud, if you add four and a half billion years, some stuff can go down. That's all I'm saying.
33:42 Bill Nye? But that fundamental, that inability to grasp sort of that enormous idea of, like, dude, dude.
33:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Richard, what's your favorite Hollywood alien?
33:55 Speaker 04 I don't have one, but I can tell you what my wife's Lala says when she's asked, as a Doctor Who girl.
34:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, your wife is a Hovian?
34:06 Speaker 04 She played Doctor Who's glamorous companion.
34:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I didn't, why didn't I know this?
34:13 Speaker 04 I don't know.
34:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait, you are by marriage related to not just Hovian fans, but people who are actually in Doctor Who?
34:22 Speaker 04 Yes.
34:28 Speaker 04 She was the companion to one of the Doctor Who's, who was Tom Baker.
34:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
34:34 Speaker 04 And whom she actually briefly married.
34:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh-oh, okay.
34:40 Speaker 03 Let's dig into this.
34:44 Speaker 04 Does her current husband know about this?
34:48 Speaker 04 The question that Neil has just posed to me of my favorite science fiction, Alien, she goes to Doctor Who conventions, and the commonest question she gets is, "What's your favorite Doctor Who monster?" Because they have monsters. And her answer always is Tom Baker.
35:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A bit about our special guest's sneakers. They're actually manufactured by General Electric. As bizarre as that sounds, General Electric actually did research back in the 60s and produced rubber and plastic products that the Apollo astronauts took to the moon that could survive very high temperature ranges and still retain their flexibility and their integrity. And since we're not going to the moon anymore, what else might they have done with this? And they decided they'd just make sneakers. And so, these are basically moon shoes that were done by our esteemed guests. So, I'm just sad that rather than say, "Oh, our latest astronauts reported back from Mars",
36:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't get to say that, I get to say we're wearing shoes made of extra ingredients invented in the 60s.
36:18 Bill Nye? Doctor Tyson, you're wearing leather shoes. That goes back somewhat more than 50 years.
36:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I'm just saying that cows never went to the moon. Alright, so in spite of the fairy tale, that material went to the moon.
36:32 Eugene Mirman? But cows can't have dreams and goals.
36:37 Speaker 02 Maybe that's what they're saying the whole time. Moon.
36:53 Speaker 02 I'm actually blushing. I'm blushing, I'm so sorry.
36:57 Eugene Mirman? That was brilliant.
36:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Moon. Moon. I will never hear a cow the same again.
37:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, I want to talk about human evolution, because we care about humans. But if we took how we got to humans. So, we went from non-life to life, in some way that is not yet fully understood, but the plausibility is there. Then we went from single-celled to multi-cell life.
37:26 Speaker 04 Yep.
37:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was a big gap in time, from the time we had single-celled ancestors, right?
37:31 Speaker 04 Yep.
37:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that must have been hard. It sounds like it was easier to go from non-life to life than from single-cell life to multi-cell life. Because we spent more time as single-celled ancestors than we did as not-life at all.
37:43 Speaker 04 I'm not sure about that, I mean...
37:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I am sure about it.
37:47 Speaker 04 Multi-cellular life is another of those things that's evolved convergently. I mean, they're multicellular bacteria, and there are several different kinds of multicellular protozoa.
37:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A lot of years went by between the first life and the Cambrian explosion of life, where...
38:01 Bill Nye? Cambrian explosion isn't the only multicellular organism.
38:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but isn't that when you first got sight and limbs and locomotion?
38:08 Speaker 04 Well, but that's different from multicellular.
38:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
38:10 Bill Nye? And they had hard shells, that's why we're able to... that's part of why we're able to find them.
38:15 Speaker 04 I mean, nobody really knows why the Cambrian explosion happened, there are lots of...
38:18 Bill Nye? And you guys, the explosion took 220 million years. My uncle was a geologist, he worked for DuPont Diamond, he blew stuff up all day. It's a lot quicker than 220 million years.
38:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wrong adjective, I guess. Okay, so...
38:33 Bill Nye? Well, but I mean, they use the word explosion, and everybody's charmed by it, but I just like to remind people, it was a long old thing.
38:39 Speaker 04 The Cambrian explosion's overrated as well, you're quite right.
38:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Overrated?
38:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Fill that to the trial of bites. So, let's get on to humans here. We astrophysicists conveniently sent an asteroid this way to get rid of T-Rex, so that our mammalian ancestors wouldn't have to keep running underfoot, avoiding being Odurs. Then we have primates. There's a branch of the tree of life that we call primates, I guess.
39:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is that correct?
39:07 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we're in that branch with our primate relatives. Is that a fair?
39:10 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Characterization? Okay. So, the fossil record shows that we have very close ancestors that we called Neanderthal.
39:17 Speaker 04 Well, they're not ancestors.
39:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, sorry, sorry.
39:19 Speaker 04 Cousins.
39:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cousins.
39:21 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But they're no Neanderthal today.
39:23 Speaker 04 No.
39:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, did our ancestors?
39:25 Speaker 04 Well.
39:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Eat them? Or cross-breed with them? Or is there any reason why they're not here and we're here?
39:32 Speaker 04 We did cross-breed with them. There's genetic evidence, and modern genetics is very good now at reconstructing history in fascinating ways. And it's clear that a significant, not a large, but a significant proportion of the genome of Europeans, not Africans, but Europeans, has some Neanderthal admixture.
39:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, when I was in high school, definitely, there was this one guy.
39:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You felt a Neanderthal?
40:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think he definitely was a Neanderthal.
40:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, so who was cross-breeding with the Neanderthal?
40:07 Speaker 04 The Homo sapiens who were around at the time.
40:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do we have a word for them?
40:11 Speaker 04 They're sometimes called... Party animal? Well...
40:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Party animal. And venturer.
40:16 Speaker 04 Just call them sapiens.
40:17 Bill Nye? Same, just like us.
40:18 Speaker 04 Yeah, they were just like us, yeah.
40:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, we cross-bred? Did we breed them out of existence?
40:25 Speaker 04 No, I think they died out and possibly we killed them, or outcompeted them. But there was a certain amount of cross-breeding.
40:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and that's evidenced in the genome?
40:34 Speaker 04 Exactly. That's the only evidence.
40:36 Bill Nye? Richard, let me ask you this. So, compared the size of the brain of a Neanderthal with his overall or her overall body weight, compared with our size of brain and our overall body weight?
40:46 Speaker 04 Slightly larger.
40:47 Bill Nye? Who's slightly larger?
40:48 Speaker 04 Neanderthal.
40:49 Bill Nye? They had more brain for their body than we do.
40:51 Speaker 04 Yes.
40:52 Bill Nye? Yet we kicked their empanages.
40:54 Speaker 04 Well, brain size is very variable anyway. Well, yeah. All our brains are different sizes and it doesn't correlate well with... Ability. Ability.
41:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, what leaves me curious is that we would interbreed with Neanderthal. When I'm thinking they might have just been all rounded up and killed. I mean, we'd do that with our own species.
41:14 Speaker 04 Surely.
41:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Surely we would do that with a competing species.
41:17 Speaker 04 Sounds highly plausible, yes.
41:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I mean, I'd hate to say that, but why would we treat another species competing with us better than we treat each other competing with us?
41:25 Speaker 04 Quite.
41:25 Eugene Mirman? We definitely treated Neanderthals not great, right? Because they're all dead.
41:32 Speaker 06 They're gods.
41:33 Eugene Mirman? They're gods. And we might have first had sex with them and you're wondering why...
41:37 Speaker 06 Maybe we had sex with them and then we killed them.
41:39 Eugene Mirman? Yeah. That's probably what happened.
41:42 Speaker 06 I hope we didn't have sex with them and killed them at the same time.
41:46 Speaker 04 I mean, nobody knows.
41:46 Eugene Mirman? Early man was not polite.
41:48 Speaker 04 Let me ask you this: is it possible disease took him out? Yes, nobody knows. We're speculating in a vacuum here. We don't know.
41:56 Eugene Mirman? Oh, so they could have just had a cold, all of them. Which at the time might have been terrible.
42:01 Speaker 04 Most species that have ever existed have gone extinct and it's not an unusual thing.
42:05 Eugene Mirman? So it's not necessarily our fault?
42:06 Speaker 04 No.
42:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so...
42:08 Speaker 04 Don't feel bad about that.
42:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In any case, Neanderthal and we have a common ancestor at some point in the primate tree.
42:16 Speaker 04 Yes.
42:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and that's true for us and any other primate.
42:20 Speaker 04 And any other animal or plant or bacterium.
42:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and so I once had this conversation with you that I want to recreate here. All humans are fertile with one another generally, okay? Unless you have some deformity. So, we can reproduce with anyone who has ever been human. But at some point, there's a branching of the tree where some other branch of primates went into another direction. Let's say the chimpanzees. So we can't mate with chimpanzees, but both we and chimpanzees ought to be able to mate with the species that is at the vertex of that split, is that correct?
42:56 Speaker 04 Yes, it might not be that far back, but what you could certainly say is that there exists an extinct animal that we could mate with, which could mate with that one, which could mate with that one, which could mate with the vertex, which could mate with that one, which could mate with that one. I mean, I once illustrated this with a thought experiment. You would do one of these human chains, and you hold the hand of your mother, who holds the hand of her mother, who holds the hand of her mother. And as you pass along the line of this enormously long line of creatures holding each other's hand, you eventually come to the common ancestor with chimpanzees, and who stands there with, holding in one hand, her descendant who becomes human, and holding in her other hand, her descendant who becomes chimpanzee.
43:40 Speaker 04 And then you go all the way down the chimpanzees. There is a continuous line connecting us to chimpanzees, up towards the vertex, and then back down again. And if you walked along the line, at no point would you be able to say this individual is of a different species from that. They're all of exactly the same species as the next one in the chain. Every creature ever born is a member of the same species as its parents and its children. But yet, if you have a sufficiently large number of generations, you then come to a point where you can no longer interbreed. It wouldn't be a sudden change, it would be a gradual loss of fertility.
44:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so the woman at the vertex, she could then go back and extend her hand backwards?
44:21 Speaker 04 Yeah.
44:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then you could go back to rodents?
44:24 Speaker 04 And to jellyfish.
44:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Jellyfish, oak trees?
44:27 Speaker 04 Yes.
44:28 Speaker 02 Because I was thinking it sounded like a really awkward threesome, but when you put it that way, it sounds totally fine.
44:34 Speaker 04 It is actually, it's a very arresting thought, but it's more or less inescapable.
44:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, the Human Genome Project, that's, I guess, is it completed?
44:42 Speaker 04 Yes.
44:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so in there is Neanderthal, is chimpanzee. In there, it ought to be that which we still have in common with other life forms on Earth, correct?
44:52 Speaker 04 Exactly, yes.
44:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so what's to stop you or your peeps from just going in there and just creating Neanderthal in the lab? And have them walk out the back door?
45:03 Speaker 04 Well, actually, Neanderthals is a particular case because the genome is now being worked on by Svante Parbo and his colleagues, and they will get the Neanderthal genome. And so it would be possible to make, clone one.
45:16 Eugene Mirman? Could we create a Neanderthal in a lab?
45:18 Speaker 04 Yes, probably.
45:19 Eugene Mirman? Why haven't we?
45:20 Speaker 04 Oh, not yet.
45:21 Eugene Mirman? I mean, other than morality?
45:24 Speaker 04 We have the genome, and I'm conjecturing with reasonable confidence that the embryological technology will exist before this century is out, when you could recreate it. Whoa. And would people do it just for curiosity? A lot of people would think it was highly unethical to do it. I don't really see that myself. I mean, it's an interesting question.
45:43 Bill Nye? Can I ask you about this idea?
45:45 Eugene Mirman? Of course, it's unethical.
45:46 Bill Nye? This idea that your model, and I love your model, like from The Ancestor's Tale kind of thing, where one person's holding this hand, the threesome.
45:56 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
45:57 Bill Nye? But in the case, I'm fascinated by the mosquitoes in the London Underground.
46:01 Speaker 04 Yes, yeah.
46:02 Bill Nye? So this is where a new species is becoming right before our eyes, and I say becoming because there's, I'm asking you to speak to this, there's a spectrum, right? Like, certain of them can mate with the ones upstairs, and certain of them cannot.
46:17 Speaker 04 The London Underground Tube Railway is a peculiar ecology for mosquitoes. There are plenty of puddles of water and things down there, they can breed, and so they are breeding a separate species of mosquito before our very eyes. They never come out and cross the street with other? Well, I don't know that.
46:34 Eugene Mirman? Well, they don't have the card. You have to have the card to exit.
46:41 Speaker 04 The MetroCard, yeah. The London Underground's only been in existence since the 19th century, and so it's a fast process.
46:48 Bill Nye? So this process, my understanding, was accelerated by World War II, where humans went under-
46:54 Speaker 04 They went underground to use them as air raid shelters.
46:56 Bill Nye? Yes.
46:57 Speaker 04 That's right, yes.
46:58 Bill Nye? And so the mosquitoes who lived down there had their food come walk down to them every night. Why bother going upstairs?
47:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
47:05 Bill Nye? Why get a MetroCard?
47:07 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
47:07 Bill Nye? Just stay here, you know, light a cigarette, and just wait for the humans.
47:11 Speaker 03 What are the differences between those mosquitoes and regular ones?
47:14 Speaker 04 I can't remember what the difference is.
47:16 Bill Nye? Well, they just can't breed, or most of them can't breed them.
47:19 Speaker 04 There probably are anatomical differences as well, I can't remember.
47:21 Bill Nye? I've often wondered if they're not better at hunting in the dark and so on.
47:24 Speaker 04 Something like that.
47:25 Bill Nye? But in other words, we've seen it in a human lifetime, a new species of insect come into being. So you make predictions with theories and here it happens.
47:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we're gonna end segment one. We are live at the Beacon Theater, New York City.
Previous Cosmic Queries: Star Trek Next StarTalk Live! Evolution with Richard Dawkins (Part 2) Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated