Skip to content

Sunscreen: Could It Be Toxic??

Science Vs

50m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode investigates whether sunscreens are toxic or cause cancer, and whether blocking the sun leads to vitamin D deficiency. The host and producer Michelle Dang break down the science behind popular claims, examining animal studies on oxybenzone, FDA maximum usage trials, and long-term randomized controlled trials in Australia. They explain that while sunscreen chemicals can be detected in human blood at very high experimental doses, there is no evidence of harm at normal everyday use levels. The conversation also explores how daily sunscreen use impacts winter vitamin D levels and reviews research showing that sun exposure is not linked to melanoma in people of color, offering practical guidance on UV indices and application amounts.

  • Chemical sunscreens are absorbed into the bloodstream during heavy use, but toxicological reviews show no clear evidence that these chemicals harm humans at realistic exposure doses. 13:03
  • Homemade DIY sunscreens made from ingredients like beef tallow and zinc oxide fail laboratory testing and typically provide an SPF of less than six. 18:41
  • Applying SPF 50 sunscreen daily for a year can reduce vitamin D storage and lead to a higher risk of vitamin D deficiency by the end of winter. 31:17
  • Sun exposure is not linked to melanoma in non-white individuals, and people with the darkest skin tones do not routinely need sunscreen to prevent skin cancer. 40:55

Chapters

  1. 0:34
    Episode Introduction and Sunscreen Debate

    Wendy Zuckerman opens the episode, framing the controversy over sunscreen’s safety and effectiveness.

  2. 1:23
    Toxicity Claims About Sunscreen Chemicals

    Hosts discuss allegations that sunscreen ingredients seep into the bloodstream and may disrupt hormones.

  3. 7:45
    Oxybenzone: Mechanism and Hormone Disruption Studies

    The conversation turns to oxybenzone, its role as a UV filter, and early rat studies suggesting estrogenic effects.

  4. 10:54
    FDA Maximum‑Usage Trials and Blood Absorption

    Review of FDA studies showing chemical sunscreen absorption into blood at high exposure levels, but no evidence of harm.

  5. 18:20
    Melanin, Skin Tone, and Sunscreen Recommendations

    Discussion of melanin’s natural protection, differing guidelines for darker skin types, and the role of sunscreen in anti‑aging.

  6. 21:18
    Practical Sunscreen Tips and Summary

    Hosts wrap up with actionable advice on SPF, application timing, and vitamin D supplementation, concluding the episode’s key takeaways.

  7. 28:09
    Vitamin D Production and Sunscreen Impact

    Exploration of how sunscreen blocks UVB rays needed for vitamin D synthesis and the results of a large Australian study.

  8. 34:48
    Skin Cancer Risk: Observational vs. Randomized Studies

    Comparison of observational studies linking sunscreen use to higher skin cancer rates with RCTs showing reduced squamous cell carcinoma risk.

Highlights

  • 8:15

    Unrealistic Rat Dosesdata

    Early studies that suggested sunscreen chemicals act as hormone disruptors fed rats massive amounts of the chemicals, which would take a human between 35 and 277 years of full-body application to replicate.

  • 10:40

    FDA Maximum Usage Trialsstrategy

    FDA studies applied sunscreen to 75 percent of participants' bodies over several days and found that chemical ingredients like oxybenzone entered the blood above certain thresholds, though the FDA concluded this does not indicate people should stop using sunscreen.

  • 18:34

    Ineffective DIY Sunscreensdata

    When researchers tested 15 online recipes for homemade sunscreens made with ingredients like beef tallow, they found that several lacked UV-blocking agents entirely and the rest offered an SPF under six.

  • 31:17

    Sunscreen and Winter Vitamin Dinsight

    A year-long Australian study found that participants applying SPF 50 sunscreen daily built up lower vitamin D stores during summer, resulting in a 35 percent increased risk of vitamin D deficiency by the end of winter.

  • 40:25

    Lack of Link in People of Colorinsight

    A systematic review revealed that sun exposure is not linked to melanoma in non-white populations, as natural melanin acts as a built-in sunscreen equivalent to SPF 15 or higher.

  • 50:56

    Practical Application Guidelinesstrategy

    Experts recommend applying one shot glass of sunscreen for the entire body and one full teaspoon specifically for the face, ears, and neck 20 minutes before going outside when the UV index is three or higher.

Quotes

  • “Melanin sites, the cells that make the melanin, then the melanin is like sunscreen for your DNA?”
    Unnamed speaker · 0:00
  • “Two hours after applying it to the skin, these toxic environmental estrogens can actually be detected in the blood.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:41
  • “The FDA concluded that study, quote, "These findings do not indicate that individuals should refrain from the use of sunscreen," end quote.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:35
  • “The more, the more melanin that you have in your skin, the more likely it's doing a similar job to sunscreen.”
    Unnamed speaker · 42:40
  • Zepbound 3:20–3:43
  • Born in Roma Fragrances 4:51–4:58
  • Nordstrom Rack 22:35–22:55
  • Google Chrome 23:02–23:20
  • Apple Watch Series 12 23:27–23:49
  • Zocdoc 23:59–24:18
  • Apple Watch Series 12 52:18–52:42
  • Zocdoc 52:52–53:15

About this episode

Sunscreen is supposed to protect us from dangerous stuff like cancer, but all over social media, people are saying that we’ve been getting it all wrong. We’re being told that our sunscreen is full of toxic chemicals, that wearing it could mess with our vitamin D levels — even that sunscreen itself actually increases our risk of skin cancer. So, what can the science tell us here? Should we toss our SPF-filled creams and sprays in the bin?? And could the answer here be different depending on your skin tone? We talk to researchers Dr. Brandon Adler, Prof. Rachel Neale, and Dr. Adewole Adamson to find out. Find our transcript here: https://tinyurl.com/ScienceVsSunscreen In this episode, we cover: (00:00) The internet freak-out over sunscreen (05:06) Is sunscreen toxic? (20:46) Does sunscreen mess with vitamin D? (29:29) Does sunscreen work to prevent skin cancer? (34:40) Do people with darker skin need sunscreen? (44:38) How to wear sunscreen correctly This episode was produced by Michelle Dang, with help from Meryl Horn, Rose Rimler and Ekedi Fausther-Keeys. We’re edited by Blythe Terrell. Wendy Zukerman is our executive producer. Fact checking by Erica Akiko Howard. Video editing and sound by Bobby Lord. Music written by Bobby Lord, Bumi Hidaka, So Wylie, Emma Munger and Peter Leonard. Thanks to Humdinger Studios in Melbourne and Wolff Island Studios in New York City. Science Vs is a Spotify Studios Original. Listen for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. You can also find us on YouTube, TikTok and Instagram. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
50:52

8,592 words · 14 speakers

Topics

  • Oxybenzone
  • Australia
  • Science Versus
  • chemical sunscreen
  • UVA
  • Bemotrizonal
  • SPF 50
  • Brisbane
  • mineral sunscreen
  • Hawaii

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated