Skip to content

Are natural history museums going extinct?

Science Friday

17m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Natural history museums across the country are facing unprecedented closures and financial strain, highlighted by the recent shuttering of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University in Philadelphia and rumors surrounding the Sternberg Museum of Natural History in Kansas. Museum leaders Dr. Jason Cryan and Dr. Barbara Tears explain that traditional static exhibits struggle to compete with modern entertainment and AI-driven experiences, while operational funding and federal grants decline. The discussion explores the severe challenges of relocating massive scientific collections, the necessity of specialized climate-controlled facilities, and why physical specimens remain irreplaceable for modern genomic research and spectral imaging.

  • Natural history museums must evolve from static exhibits into experiential, welcoming community service organizations to stay relevant. 1:45
  • Grant funding typically covers short-term projects rather than the critical operational budgets needed for staff, utilities, and maintenance. 4:54
  • Moving natural history specimens costs anywhere from one dollar to ten dollars per specimen depending on size and scope. 12:58
  • Physical museum specimens remain essential because researchers cannot extract DNA or perform spectral imaging from digital pictures alone. 16:40

Chapters

  1. 0:02
    Opening and Museum Closures

    Flora introduces the episode, noting recent closures of historic natural history museums and setting the stage for discussion.

  2. 0:36
    Challenges Facing Museums

    Guests discuss how COVID, rising costs, and competition from digital experiences threaten museum relevance and sustainability.

  3. 3:54
    Funding Models and Declining Grants

    The panel explains various funding sources—government, private donors, and grants—and highlights the shrinking federal support and difficulty of securing long‑term operational budgets.

  4. 5:36
    Political and Philanthropic Shifts

    They examine how changing political climates and newer philanthropists’ priorities affect museum funding and the risk of losing traditional donor support.

  5. 10:16
    Collections Management and Relocation

    The conversation turns to what happens to artifacts when a museum closes, including legal, logistical, and ethical considerations of moving large collections.

  6. 12:06
    Costs and Logistics of Moving Specimens

    Detailed discussion of the practical challenges and expenses involved in relocating various types of collections, from plant sheets to dinosaur fossils.

  7. 15:58
    Preservation, Digitization, and Future Value

    Guests explain why physical specimens remain essential despite digital advances, and how digitization supports global research and conservation efforts.

  8. 17:23
    Cultural and Educational Impact of Museums

    The panel reflects on the broader societal benefits of museums, including inspiration, STEM education, and community engagement.

Highlights

  • 1:45

    Museum Relevance Challengesinsight

    The guest explains that museums face intense competition from traveling exhibitions, AI, and AR experiences, forcing them to become more engaging and community-focused.

  • 4:54

    Short-Term Grant Pitfallsinsight

    The guest points out that while short-term grants are helpful, securing sustaining operational funding for staff and utilities is much more difficult.

  • 12:58

    Cost of Moving Specimensdata

    Based on 25 years of NSF funding data, the guest calculates that relocating museum collections averages between one and ten dollars per specimen.

  • 13:46

    Rigorous Storage Requirementsstrategy

    The guest details the strict environmental controls needed for museum storage, including reinforced floors for heavy cabinets and rapid air handling.

  • 15:06

    Modern Genetic Preservationinsight

    The guest explains that modern museums now utilize ultra-cold freezers to preserve genetic and tissue material for future genomic work.

  • 16:40

    Why Originals Still Matterinsight

    The guests argue that digital scans cannot replace physical specimens because researchers constantly need the original source for DNA extraction and spectral imaging.

Quotes

  • “There are a million requirements, and it is very expensive to retrofit a space to be adequate for museum collections.”
    Unnamed speaker · 14:44
  • “We lose our past. We lose an understanding of the way that our environments have developed, and we also lose a really important clue as to where they're going.”
    Unnamed speaker · 17:25
  • “Even though a museum worker or a researcher from around the world with an internet access can search through our collections, oftentimes, it's necessary to go back to the original source and verify and study further.”
    Unnamed speaker · 16:25
  • Planet Visionaries 8:24–8:32
  • Bear 9:05–9:08
  • Science Delivers 9:38–9:55

About this episode

The country’s oldest natural history museum, in Philadelphia, has closed its doors to visitors. Will other museums follow?

Transcript

0:00
17:37

2,859 words · 6 speakers

Topics

  • IMLS
  • Natural History Museum of Utah
  • The Hays Post
  • Herbarium of the New York Botanical Garden
  • American Alliance for Museums
  • Institute for Museum and Library Sciences
  • National Science Foundation
  • Rolex Perpetual Planet Initiative
  • Honnold Foundation
  • Jane Goodall Institute

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated