Skip to content

Red Herring

Radiolab

Hosted by Lulu Miller

36m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In the early 1980s, amid intense Cold War paranoia following a grounded Soviet submarine on Sweden's coast, the Swedish military began detecting a mysterious underwater noise on their hydrophones. Convinced it was the sound of invading Soviet submarines, the Navy chased phantom periscopes and dropped depth charges for over a decade, spending millions and creating diplomatic friction. But as two marine biologists eventually discovered in 1996, the classified sound was actually being produced by schools of herring releasing gas bubbles from a specialized canal connected to their swim bladders.

  • When investigating unusual acoustic data, consider biological sources like marine life before assuming advanced military technology. 23:28
  • Herring possess a unique anatomical canal linking their swim bladder directly to their anal opening to release gas. 27:22
  • Top-down military secrecy cultures can prevent open scientific critique and cause organizations to double down on incorrect assumptions. 33:31

Chapters

  1. 0:02
    Cold War Summer Intro

    Lulu introduces the episode, framing it as a Cold War summer mystery.

  2. 0:44
    Archival Story Hook

    Lulu reveals the archived story “Red Herring” and sets up the mystery.

  3. 5:02
    Swedish Sub Incident 1981

    The narrative of a Soviet submarine beached on Swedish shores and the national shock.

  4. 6:37
    Swedish Navy Response

    Swedish military’s efforts to locate and neutralize the submarine using hydrophones and bombs.

  5. 10:32
    Persistent Submarine Sounds

    Repeated sonar detections of submarine sounds despite no physical evidence.

  6. 11:23
    Fish Fart Hypothesis

    Magnus and Hakan propose that the sound could be herring bubbles, not submarines.

  7. 15:10
    Military Investigation Begins

    Swedish officials form a secret committee to investigate the mysterious sounds.

  8. 31:03
    Field Test with Herring

    The team tests herring bubbles in controlled and wild settings to compare with the sonar sound.

  9. 32:47
    Conclusion: Herring, Not Submarines

    The Navy confirms the sound originates from herring schools, ending the decade-long mystery.

Highlights

  • 2:16

    A Nation on Edgestory

    In October 1981, a Soviet submarine ran aground on Sweden's rocky coastline, plunging the neutral nation into a state of acute Cold War anxiety and daily fear of nuclear conflict.

  • 8:43

    Chasing Phantoms with Bombsdata

    After hearing hydrophone detections in a Stockholm harbor in 1982, the Swedish military dropped depth charges for a month without finding a single submarine.

  • 23:48

    Listening to the Secret Soundinsight

    After fifteen years of top-down secrecy, civilian scientists were finally brought into a secret naval base to listen to the classified typical sound, which sounded like distant Donald Ducks.

  • 27:22

    The Herring Anatomyinsight

    Herring differ from most fish by having a canal running straight from their swim bladder to their anal opening, letting them push out gas bubbles.

  • 32:03

    Solving the Mysterystory

    When placing a hydrophone into a net full of stressed herring, researchers finally recorded the exact typical sound that had haunted the Navy.

  • 34:07

    Submarines That Split Apartdebate

    Military sonar operators watched objects on their screens split from one into two and four, leading them to hypothesize impossible shape-shifting Soviet submarines.

Quotes

  • “But we here at Radiolab are offering you something different, which we are calling Cold War Summer.”
    Lulu Miller · 0:13
  • “We heard the typical sound.”
    Unnamed speaker · 11:46
  • “The herring is different. The herring is special because they have a canal straight from the swim bladder to the anal opening.”
    Unnamed speaker · 27:22
  • “The typical sound that had haunted the Swedish Navy for over a decade was not made by Soviet submarines.”
    Unnamed speaker · 32:47
  • Capital One 20:29–20:54
  • AT&T 20:57–21:38
  • Bombas 21:43–22:38

About this episode

A deep-sea Cold War mystery with subs and bombs and science.

Transcript

0:00
36:04

6,317 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Herring
  • Sweden
  • The typical sound
  • Swedish military
  • Radiolab
  • Stockholm
  • Soviet Union
  • Swedish Navy
  • Hydrophone
  • 1981

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated