Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode examines the January 2006 murder of 18-year-old Tamara Tammy C., a member of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians whose body was found by a church hiking group in the Deep Creek area of Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Investigators quickly focused on three acquaintances—Terrence Roach, Joshua Squirrel, and Michael Sli—who were last seen with the victim. Through court records and confessions, law enforcement pieced together that Terrence shot Tammy twice in the head after accusing her of stealing drugs, while his accomplices helped conceal the crime and the murder weapon. Terrence ultimately pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and a firearm offense, receiving two consecutive life sentences and a massive restitution order to support the victim's infant daughter, while his co-defendants pleaded guilty to accessory charges.
- Investigators utilized dental records provided by the Cherokee Indian Police Department and the state medical examiner to positively identify the victim. 4:35
- A community member alerted law enforcement after Joshua Squirrel entrusted them with a .38 caliber Smith & Wesson revolver. 8:35
- Terrence Roach pleaded guilty in July 2006 to first-degree murder and using a firearm in a crime of violence, avoiding the death penalty. 23:44
- The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals later vacated the large restitution judgment against Joshua and Michael, ruling they should not pay the same amount as the actual murderer. 25:58
Chapters
- 0:00Episode Introduction and Context
Delia opens the episode, setting the stage for a deep‑cut investigation into a murder in the Great Smoky Mountains.
- 1:04Background of Deep Creek and Prior Cases
Delia explains the park’s typical visitors and references a previous missing‑person episode to frame the current story.
- 2:29Discovery of the Victim on January 15, 2006
A church group finds a young woman’s body in the woods, prompting a homicide investigation.
- 4:13Identification and Early Investigation
Law enforcement identifies the victim as Tamara Tammy C., an 18‑year‑old Cherokee, and begins gathering evidence.
- 6:06Timeline of Events Leading to the Murder
Delia recounts how Tamara was last seen with friends, the night’s activities, and the key moments before her death.
- 10:30Interrogations of Joshua, Michael, and Terrence
FBI questions the three suspects, revealing conflicting stories and admissions of involvement.
- 20:16Charges, Indictments, and Legal Proceedings
The men are charged, plead, and face trials, with details on the grand jury and subsequent sentencing.
- 25:53Restitution, Appeals, and Long‑Term Consequences
Explores the financial penalties, appeals, and the ongoing legal status of the defendants.
- 28:33Broader Context: Indigenous Victims and Advocacy
Delia discusses the broader issue of violence against Indigenous women and resources for listeners.
- 29:44Closing Remarks and Resources
Delia wraps up the episode, directing listeners to further information and related podcasts.
Highlights
- 2:29
Church Group Discovers Bodystory
On January 15, 2006, a church hiking group discovered a young woman's body lying face up in the woods near Tom's Branch Road in Great Smoky Mountains National Park.
- 3:50
Autopsy Reveals Fatal Woundsdata
An autopsy at the North Carolina office of the chief medical examiner revealed that the victim had been shot twice in the head.
- 6:31
Witnesses reported that Tammy had been drinking with Terrence Roach and Joshua Squirrel at Big Dave's house before going into a back room and later emerging agitated.
- 10:49
Joshua Changes His Storyinsight
During his interrogation at a local community college, Joshua initially claimed Tammy got into a silver car, but later admitted Terrence confessed to the shooting.
- 12:37
Michael Recounts the Shootingstory
Michael Sli told rangers that Terrence carried an inebriated Tammy into the woods, woke her in cold water, and shot her after a brief scream.
- 15:27
Terrence Confesses to Murderinsight
After initially denying involvement, Terrence recanted his story to investigators, stated "I did it," and provided details about the shooting.
- 25:06
Garnishing Tribal Gaming Paymentsstrategy
The defendants were ordered to pay nearly $1.5 million to Tammy's estate, with the government garnishing their biannual per-capita payments from the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians.
Quotes
Sponsored segments
- In the Dark 9:50–9:58
- In the Dark 23:01–23:32
- In the Dark 30:07–30:13
About this episode
When a 17-year-old girl is found murdered in Great Smoky Mountains National Park authorities quickly zero in on the group of young men who last saw her. Native Hope https://blog.nativehope.org/ Office For Victims of Crime: Missing or Murdered Indigenous Persons (MMIP) https://ovc.ojp.gov/topics/missing-murdered-indigenous-persons/state-resources U. S. Department of Justice: Missing or Murdered Indigenous Persons Homepage https://www.justice.gov/tribal/mmip Sovereign Bodies Institute https://www.sovereign-bodies.org/ National Indigenous Women’s Resource Center https://www.niwrc.org/
Transcript
5,297 words · 5 speakers
Topics
- FBI
- Deep Creek area
- North Carolina
- Great Smoky Mountains National Park
- Bryson City
- Los Angeles County
- Asheville Citizen Times
- Asheville
- Swain County Sheriff's Office
- Park Service
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated