Skip to content

#492 — The Second Plane, 25 Years Later

Making Sense with Sam Harris

37m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In this 25th-anniversary reflection on September 11, Sam Harris examines how the events of that day revealed the lethal power of religious ideas and argues that Western intellectuals and institutions continue to misunderstand the threat of jihadism. Drawing on his experience writing "The End of Faith" in the immediate aftermath of the attacks, Harris analyzes the motives of the 9/11 hijackers and the persistence of what he terms "Islamo-leftism" or the red-green alliance in elite universities and progressive politics. He contends that ignoring the ideological roots of religious extremism in favor of political excuses or moral panic puts open societies at risk. Furthermore, he reflects on how financial independence from advertisers, made possible by listener subscriptions, has allowed him to speak freely on controversial subjects without succumbing to self-censorship.

Throughout the episode, Harris critiques the tendency of secular liberals to rationalize terrorist acts as reactions to poverty or foreign policy, emphasizing instead that the perpetrators acted out of sincere religious certainty regarding martyrdom and paradise. He connects the events of 9/11 directly to the atrocities of October 7, 2023, in Israel and warns against the abandonment of liberal values such as free speech, scientific rationality, and political equality for women. The discussion underscores why a clear-eyed understanding of religious doctrine remains essential for preserving open societies against theocratic threats.

  • Recognize that the 9/11 hijackers were driven by sincere religious beliefs about martyrdom rather than poverty or foreign policy grievances. 1:44
  • Understand that jihadism operates as a machine converting religious scripture and belief directly into mass murder. 7:20
  • Distinguish between criticizing dangerous religious ideologies and exhibiting bigotry or xenophobia against individual people. 13:06
  • Support independent media models like listener-supported podcasts to guarantee creators freedom from corporate and advertiser self-censorship. 18:04
  • Acknowledge that even extremely wealthy public figures can be terrified of defying ideological moral panics on social media. 20:04

Chapters

  1. 0:21
    Introduction and 25‑Year Reflection

    Sam Harris opens the episode by noting the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and the generational shift in memory.

  2. 1:44
    The Moment of the Second Plane

    Harris describes the psychological impact of the second plane and its significance in revealing intent.

  3. 2:58
    Defining Jihadism and Its Ideology

    He explains how jihadist beliefs convert religious faith into mass murder and the dangers of that ideology.

  4. 3:39
    Personal Academic Roots

    He recounts his PhD work on belief and how 9/11 spurred his first book, "The End of Faith."

  5. 8:35
    Critique of the U.S. Response

    Harris argues that America’s war on terror and nation‑building efforts caused more harm than good.

  6. 15:10
    Modern Confusion and Identitarian Islamism

    Harris discusses the rise of “Islamo‑leftism” and how elite institutions mischaracterize jihadist motives.

  7. 25:43
    Implications for Immigration and Society

    He outlines how liberal societies should vet ideological commitments to protect core values.

  8. 27:57
    Reflection on the Last Quarter Century

    Harris reflects on the enduring relevance of his earlier arguments and the ongoing threat of jihadism.

  9. 29:01
    Podcast Business and Listener Support

    He explains why the podcast relies on listener subscriptions rather than advertising and thanks supporters.

Highlights

  • 1:12

    The Meaning of the Second Planeinsight

    The impact of the second plane hitting the South Tower proved that the attacks were intentional and suicide-driven, shattering any notion that the event was an accident or the act of a lone lunatic.

  • 3:34

    Origins of The End of Faithstory

    The immediate horror and moral outrage following the September 11 attacks prompted the creation of a manuscript that became The End of Faith and launched a career focused on secularism and belief.

  • 5:50

    Profile of the 9/11 Hijackersdata

    Twelve of the nineteen hijackers attended college and all four pilots held FAA credentials, demonstrating they were not poor or desperate men driven to terrorism by a lack of alternatives.

  • 11:18

    Success of the War on Terrordata

    Independent analysis indicates that counterterrorism efforts have successfully stopped around 100 attacks on American soil over twenty-five years, preventing widespread domestic chaos.

  • 14:26

    Reaction on Elite Campusesinsight

    Student groups at elite universities celebrated the October 7 massacre of civilians, framing the carnage as resistance to occupation and decolonization.

  • 18:41

    Subversion of Liberal Toleranceinsight

    Islamists and their apologists strategically weaponize the norms of liberal tolerance and identity politics to subvert liberalism itself from within Western institutions.

  • 31:29

    The Economics of Digital Contentinsight

    Consumers cannot price digital media purely by the minute or track, as the fundamental question is whether valuable and independent work should exist at all.

  • 33:21

    The Isolation of J.K. Rowlingstory

    Author J.K. Rowling barely survived the severe career backlash and public denunciations from actors in her own film franchises after pushing back against gender identity mandates.

Quotes

  • “the second plane proved that all this horror, this mass murder of thousands of innocent people, was intentional.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:44
  • “We didn't kill all of these people directly. It's estimated that we killed anywhere from 20,000 to 50,000 civilians in Afghanistan and Iraq in all our years of waging war there.”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:20
  • “The war in Iraq always seemed like a bad idea, though I admit it's hard to imagine the counterfactual and be confident that leaving Saddam Hussein and his psychopathic sons in place for the last 20 years would have been good for the people of Iraq or for the world.”
    Unnamed speaker · 9:41
  • “The new confusion is a kind of religion. It's identitarian.”
    Unnamed speaker · 15:10

About this episode

On the 25th anniversary of September 11th, Sam discusses the significance of the second plane, the writing of The End of Faith, the failure to take jihadist belief seriously, the costs of the war on terror, the abandonment of America's Afghan allies, the continuity between 9/11 and October 7th, the rise of Islamo-leftism, the misuse of "Islamophobia," and other topics. Making Sense has no advertisers and no sponsors, which is what allows Sam to talk about whatever he thinks is most important, with no one else having a say. If you already subscribe, thank you. If you'd like to subscribe, you can start at SamHarris.org https://www.samharris.org/subscribe. Subscribers can also join the Making Sense Community to keep the discussion going. This is the recording Sam refers to at 13:18. https://x.com/IDFSpokesperson/status/1716867039300846031?s=20 If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to gain access to all full-length episodes at samharris.org/subscribe http://samharris.org/subscribe.

Transcript

0:00
37:36

6,047 words · 1 speaker

Topics

  • Religious Extremism
  • Free Speech
  • Middle Eastern Politics
  • Media Independence
  • Political Ideology
  • Cultural Assimilation
  • Terrorism
  • Secularism

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated