Why Don't We Have a Surgeon General?
- 1h 13m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
The episode covers the three nominees for Surgeon General in Trump's second term: Dr. Jeanette Neshwat, Casey Means, and Dr. Nicole Sapphire. Neshwat was nominated in November 2024 but withdrawn the day before her confirmation hearing after journalist Anthony Clark found she had misrepresented her medical credentials—claiming a degree from the University of Arkansas when she actually completed a residency there as an employee, and obtaining her MD from the American University of the Caribbean, a for-profit school previously owned by DeVry. She was also criticized by Laura Loomer for not being anti-vax enough, and after withdrawal took a job at Walter Reed working on Havana Syndrome.
Casey Means, a Stanford graduate who quit her surgical residency six months early, runs a functional medicine practice in Portland and co-founded Levels, a health tech company valued at $300 million. Her brother Callie Means, who claimed to have been a high-level lobbyist, was revealed by Vanity Fair to have been an executive assistant. Her confirmation hearing in February 2026 was a disaster, particularly when Senator Tim Kaine pressed her on flu vaccine efficacy for three minutes before she finally conceded. She had also failed to disclose payments totaling over $400,000 from supplement and wellness companies. Trump acknowledged her lack of votes on April 30, 2026.
Dr. Nicole Sapphire, the current nominee, is a radiologist at Sloan Kettering with a supplement company called DropRx that sells herbal tinctures including Kava, which the FDA has warned about. The hosts note that the administration's failure to confirm any nominee is itself a form of harm reduction, and that the average confirmation delay for Trump nominees has doubled from his first term.
- Neshwat's MD was from the American University of the Caribbean, a for-profit school previously owned by DeVry Education Group, not the University of Arkansas as she claimed. 8:02
- Vanity Fair fact-checked Callie Means and found he was an executive assistant at Mercury, not the director brokering high-level deals he claimed. 35:23
- Casey Means failed to disclose payments including $59,000 from Function Health, $130,000 from Amazentis, and $200,000 from Tati Westbrook's Hair Vitamins. 1:01:38
- The End Chronic Disease Coalition, which RFK Jr. touts, is largely made up of companies whose products would benefit from expanded HSA rules. 33:09
- According to Brookings, the average confirmation delay for Trump nominees has doubled from his first term to his second. 1:11:43
Highlights
- 5:46
Scott Stapp as Surgeon Generalstory
Aubrey reveals that Neshwat's sister Jaclyn is married to Scott Stapp from Creed, leading to a bit about Thanksgiving with the band and the administration's inability to get Creed to play at the inauguration.
- 8:02
Neshwat's Resume Fraud Exposeddata
Journalist Anthony Clark discovered Neshwat did not earn her medical degree from the University of Arkansas as claimed, but completed a residency there as an employee. Her actual MD was from the American University of the Caribbean, a for-profit school previously owned by DeVry.
- 14:39
Neshwat Sent to Havana Syndromestory
After her nomination was withdrawn, Neshwat was placed at Walter Reed working on treatment of Havana Syndrome, a condition that is hotly debated between mass psychogenic illness and chemical warfare explanations.
- 18:03
Casey Means Quits Surgery on Tuckerstory
A clip of Casey Means on Tucker Carlson describing how she quit her surgical residency in her fifth year after realizing she was only trained to do procedures and bill for them, not to understand why patients are sick.
- 33:09
End Chronic Disease Coalition Exposedinsight
The coalition RFK Jr. touts as dedicated to ending chronic disease is largely composed of companies whose products would be covered under proposed expanded HSA rules, making it a front for profit rather than public health.
- 36:42
Cali Means Businessstory
A Vanity Fair excerpt describes Callie Means walking around his office as an executive assistant muttering 'Cali means business' to himself, while his colleagues recall his air of self-importance and bigger plans that didn't include them.
- 56:59
Flu Vaccine Hearing Meltdowndebate
Senator Tim Kaine asks Casey Means whether the flu vaccine prevents hospitalization in children. She circles for three minutes with phrases like 'I believe vaccines save lives' before finally conceding at the population level it does.
- 1:11:19
The Mono Grifter Standardinsight
The hosts conclude that Dr. Sapphire is only a 'mono grifter'—selling herbal tinctures—compared to the previous nominees who were grifting from multiple angles, and call this the best the administration can do in 2026.
About this episode
We’re nearly halfway through Trump's second term and we still don’t have a Surgeon General. What gives? Support us: Hear bonus episodes on PatreonWatch Aubrey's documentaryBuy Aubrey's bookListen to Mike's other podcastGet Maintenance Phase T-shirts, stickers and more Links! White House withdraws nomination of Janette NesheiwatTrump’s Surgeon General Pick Distorted Key Parts of Her Résumé Dr. Janette Nesheiwat takes role at Walter Reed treating Havana SyndromeWhen Did RFK Jr Start List...
Transcript
12,221 words · 6 speakers
Topics
- Surgeon General Nomination
- Health Misinformation
- For-Profit Medicine
- Confirmation Hearings
- Wellness Industry
- Political Nominations
- Medical Credentials
- HSA Reform
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated