Skip to content

Lore Alive 2: In Dreams

Lore

Hosted by Aaron Mahnke

23m

Original podcast

Where to listen

--:--
--:--

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This immersive audio drama episode explores the historical New England Vampire Panic through the harrowing story of the Tillinghast family in Exeter, Rhode Island. The narrative follows Stuckley, an orchard keeper whose disturbing dream about dying apple trees precedes a wave of fatal illnesses in his household, claiming his children Sarah and Richard. As the fever overtakes his wife Elizabeth, ghostly visitations and shared dreamscapes blur the line between life and death, driving Stuckley toward a desperate and terrifying ritual at the family graveyard to save what remains of his family. The presentation draws on documented historical records to illustrate how fear and grief compelled ordinary people to commit unthinkable acts during a century-long regional panic.

  • The Tillinghast family tragedy in Exeter, Rhode Island, represents the earliest documented instance of the New England Vampire Panic. 22:22
  • Stuckley Tillinghast experienced a vivid nightmare involving a withering orchard that seemingly foreshadowed the fatal illnesses of his family members. 1:55
  • Historical records confirm that the family's actions during this crisis involved desperate rituals born from intense fear and grief. 22:32

Chapters

  1. 0:05
    Lore Alive Intro & Sponsor

    The host introduces the episode and thanks Warby Parker for sponsorship.

  2. 0:46
    Background on Mercy Brown & New England Panic

    The host explains Mercy Brown and the broader vampire panic in New England.

  3. 1:36
    Stuckley’s Dream and the Orchard

    Stuckley’s haunting dream of a dying orchard sets the supernatural tone.

  4. 2:45
    Family Tragedy and Rising Fear

    The deaths of Sara, Richard, and the spread of illness terrorize the family.

  5. 13:59
    Dreams Become Reality

    Elizabeth’s dreams of her mother, father, and Stuckley blur the line between sleep and waking.

  6. 17:48
    Confrontation with Stuckley

    Elizabeth confronts Stuckley about his plan to dig her grave and kill her.

  7. 18:43
    Stuckley’s Motive and Plan

    Stuckley explains his misguided belief that stabbing Elizabeth will save her.

  8. 19:42
    Elizabeth’s Plea and Aftermath

    Elizabeth pleads with Stuckley, revealing her desire to join him in the afterlife.

  9. 20:38
    Wrap‑Up & Final Sponsor Message

    The host concludes the story and delivers the final Warby Parker ad.

Highlights

  • 1:56

    Stuckley's Orchard Dreamstory

    Stuckley describes a harrowing dream where his apple garden rots into black liquid and bone, setting an ominous tone for the tragedies to follow.

  • 5:49

    Sara's Ambitioninsight

    Elizabeth reflects on her daughter Sara's academic hunger and unusual desire to travel the world alone rather than settle into a traditional marriage.

  • 10:08

    Richard's Final Wordsstory

    Stricken by the same illness that killed his sister, young Richard speaks in his sleep, claiming Sarah has returned to the house for him.

  • 11:54

    Elizabeth Falls Illstory

    Elizabeth contracts the same rapid fever and cough that took her children, plunging her into a surreal state filled with intense childhood and family dreams.

  • 16:34

    Sara's Spectral Visitinsight

    Elizabeth awakens to find her deceased daughter sitting at the foot of her bed, warning her about Stuckley's desperate mission in the graveyard.

  • 17:58

    The Looming Desperationdebate

    Sara reveals that Stuckley plans to dig up her grave and pierce her heart with a knife in a misguided attempt to halt the illness.

  • 22:08

    Historical Context of Exeterdata

    Aaron Manke reveals that Stuckley's orchard dreams and the subsequent family deaths are grounded in real historical records from Exeter, Rhode Island.

Quotes

  • “La pesadilla de Stuckley. Eso es lo que comenzó todo, incluso si no fue su culpa.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:01
  • “Me tiré a las raíces, traté de sacar la infección que se estaba propagando con mis dedos.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:37
  • “I was suddenly awash in them. Dreams of my mother, my father, who had toiled away in the tannery until he died of his own cough, barely forty years of age.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:15
  • Warby Parker 0:25–0:42
  • Warby Parker 20:56–22:04

About this episode

Welcome to Lore Alive, a special Halloween bonus series that brings dark tales from history to life with immersive sound design and voice actors. Today's tale puts us in the middle of the first known New England vampire exhumation, and the terrifying dream that plagued a heartbroken father. Lore Alive was created by Aaron Mahnke, with writing and direction by Nicolas Tecosky, audio production and sound design by Brandon Grugle. This week's episode starred J. Garrett Mitchell as Stukeley, Sarah Palm as Sarah, and Amanda Cucher as Elizabeth. ————————— Lore Resources: Get Ad-Free Lore: lorepodcast.com/support https://www.lorepodcast.com/support Official Lore Merchandise: lorepodcast.com/shop https://www.lorepodcast.com/shop ————————— Series Sponsor: Warby Parker: Right now, buy one pair and get additional pairs for 20%. Go to WarbyParker.com/LORE https://www.warbyparker.com/lore to try on any pair virtually! ©2026 Aaron Mahnke. All rights reserved.

From the transcript

“SPEAKER_00: Todos los viernes de octubre, traemos una historia de la historia a la vida con un diseño de sonido inmersivo y actores talentosos para crear una atmósfera que se ajuste a la historia. Es el estilo que conoces de otros programas que he hecho, como 13 días de Halloween, aplicado a verdaderas historias de los cimientos más oscuros de la historia. Por cierto, toda esta serie de bonus de Halloween fue posible por el generoso apoyo de Warby Parker, mi favorito de prescripción, fabricante de láseres.”

Topics

  • Lore Alive
  • Exeter, Rhode Island
  • New England
  • 13 Days of Halloween

Page updated