How honest should you really be? Tips for sharing good and bad news
Hosted by Marielle Segarra
- 22m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of Life Kit explores the science of communication and honesty, featuring social psychologist Vanessa Bohns in conversation with reporter Andy Tagle and host Marielle Segarra. The discussion examines why people hesitate to give feedback, how to share good and bad news effectively, and when remaining silent or ghosting creates more harm than clarity. Bohns explains that people often overthink the exact words to use when the primary value of speaking up is simply showing that someone cares. Listeners learn practical strategies for deciding whether to deliver hard truths, how to ask deeper questions without being intrusive, and how ethical frameworks can guide difficult moral dilemmas.
- Consider whether the feedback you give is actionable before weighing in, as people are more receptive when they can actually use the information. 6:35
- Ask permission before offering feedback to avoid making unwanted suggestions and to give the other person a sense of autonomy. 8:55
- Build intimacy quickly by asking deeper, more personal questions during conversations instead of sticking exclusively to small talk. 12:21
- Share your successes and happy news with friends and family to give them an opportunity to celebrate and bask in your accomplishments. 14:52
- Use structured ethical frameworks like consequentialism and the golden rule to navigate right-versus-right dilemmas when there is no obvious answer. 21:16
Chapters
- 0:13Podcast Intro and Hook
Marielle Segarra opens the episode, posing questions about when to speak or stay silent.
- 1:46Defining the Core Question
The hosts discuss the fundamental dilemma of whether to say something at all.
- 3:53Honesty vs. Actionability
Vanessa explains when honesty is best policy, focusing on actionable information.
- 4:52The MUM Effect and Feedback Hesitation
The MUM effect describes why people avoid giving honest feedback to avoid embarrassment.
- 6:58Practical Interventions for Giving Feedback
Strategies such as removing oneself and imagining the other person help decide if feedback is needed.
- 13:32Asking Questions and Building Intimacy
Research shows that deep, reciprocal questions foster closeness and intimacy.
- 20:25Sharing Good News and Vulnerability
The episode covers how sharing successes and vulnerabilities can strengthen relationships.
- 23:29Ethical Decision-Making and Takeaways
Listeners receive a recap of six takeaways and guidance on navigating complex honesty dilemmas.
Highlights
- 3:54
When Is Honesty Useful?insight
Honesty is only the best policy when the information provided is actionable and helps someone perform better or avoid embarrassment.
- 5:41
Researchers found that out of 150 people who encountered strangers with visible lipstick or chocolate on their faces, only four said anything.
- 7:01
Removing Your Own Discomfortstrategy
A reliable test for giving feedback is imagining whether a third party should deliver it, which removes personal anxiety from the equation.
- 10:24
Why People Choose Ghostinginsight
People ghost others not out of a lack of caring, but because having difficult conversations causes personal discomfort and awkwardness.
- 13:02
Going Deep Quicklyinsight
Asking more personal questions about fears or past experiences builds emotional closeness much faster than everyday small talk.
- 14:52
Capitalization and Good Newsinsight
Sharing positive news with others expands happiness and gives supporters an opportunity to enjoy your success by association.
- 17:41
Vulnerability and Competenceinsight
While sharing vulnerabilities increases likability and trust, it can simultaneously make coworkers or colleagues question your current competence.
- 21:16
Resolving Moral Dilemmasstrategy
When faced with competing ethical obligations, taking time to weigh consequences and apply the golden rule helps resolve difficult choices.
Quotes
“It says, I see you. I care about your suffering. I want to help you in some way.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:29 “The MUM effect because it stands for minimizing unpleasant messages.”
Unnamed speaker · 4:54 “When we share vulnerabilities, people tend to like us more.”
Unnamed speaker · 17:51 “The negative stuff we complain about or share sticks with people more than the positive.”
Unnamed speaker · 19:58 “Takeaway four, your people aren't just there to help you on the bad days. A support system can and should celebrate your successes with you too.”
Unnamed speaker · 16:17 “If you want to project professionalism and competence at the office, for example, maybe gossiping in the hallway for all to hear right before that staff meeting isn't the best idea.”
Unnamed speaker · 20:37
Sponsored segments
- ProLon 2:13–2:45
- Southern Environmental Law Center 2:45–3:07
- Legacy Box 3:08–3:42
- Saatva 11:14–12:04
- Leesa 12:05–12:19
- Charles Schwab 25:36–25:51
About this episode
Should you tell a colleague that you heard they might be fired? A stranger that they have spinach in their teeth? Your followers that you just won a big award? In this episode of Life Kit, reporter Andee Tagle speaks with social psychologist Vanessa Bohns, author of the new book Should I Say Something? The Science of What to Share — and What to Keep to Yourself. Bohns shares tips on when to be honest, the best ways to share good and bad news, and what to say when it feels like there's no right thing to say. Follow us on Instagram: @nprlifekit https://www.instagram.com/nprlifekit/?hl=en Sign up for our newsletter here. https://www.npr.org/newsletter/life-kit Have an episode idea or feedback you want to share? Email us at lifekit@npr.org mailto:lifekit@npr.org Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include sponsor-free listening and convenient playlists of popular help topics like personal finance, getting healthy, and more. Learn more at plus.npr.org http://plus.npr.org/. See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences. NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript
4,417 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Carnegie Corporation of New York
- Carnegie.org
- Cornell University
- Should I Say Something: The Science of What to Share and What to Keep to Yourself
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated