Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of In Our Time examines Thomas More's influential 1516 book Utopia, exploring its complex mix of serious political philosophy, biting satire, and humanist wordplay. The hosts and guests discuss how More, drawing on classical dialogue forms and his experiences as a lawyer and diplomat, created a fictional island where private property is abolished and gold is treated with disdain. Yet they also unpack the darker, more authoritarian elements of More's ideal commonwealth, including its strict surveillance, slavery, and patriarchal structure. Ultimately, the discussion highlights the book's enduring legacy as both a foundational text for socialist thought and the prototype for modern dystopian literature.
- Recognize that More's invented word utopia puns on two Greek roots meaning both an ideal place and no place at all. 12:43
- Understand that the Utopians use gold for chamber pots and slave chains to deliberately subvert the sixteenth-century obsession with wealth and social status. 20:22
- Note that More structures Utopia with total uniformity and constant surveillance to scaffold individual virtue and prevent pride. 26:50
- Consider how Book One explores the socioeconomic roots of crime, arguing that harsh executions cannot stop theft caused by poverty and enclosure. 34:03
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Introduction and Advertisements
The episode opens with a brief BBC ad break and a host greeting before segueing into the main discussion.
- 1:59Thomas More and the Birth of Utopia
The hosts introduce Thomas More, his background, and the circumstances that led to the writing of Utopia.
- 4:25Humanist Context and Erasmus Influence
Panelists explain how the humanist movement and Erasmus shaped More’s ideas and the text of Utopia.
- 5:06The Structure of Utopia: Book One and Book Two
The discussion covers the narrative framing, the preface letter, and the two books’ content and order.
- 12:00Utopian Society: Property, Wealth, and Gold
The panel explores Utopia’s critique of private property, wealth, and the symbolic use of gold.
- 28:35Surveillance, Uniformity, and Moral Governance
The conversation examines Utopia’s surveillance state, uniformity, and the moral framework it proposes.
- 30:45Gender Roles and Patriarchy in Utopia
Panelists discuss the depiction of women, equality, and the underlying patriarchal structures in the text.
- 40:54Translations and Reception in Early Modern Europe
The episode covers the first translations, their political contexts, and how Utopia was received in England and beyond.
- 44:39Legacy and Influence on Later Thought
The hosts reflect on Utopia’s impact on political theory, literature, and its enduring legacy.
- 52:50Machiavellian Debate on Virtue and Expediency
Discussion of how Machiavelli’s ideas contrast with Utopian ideals regarding war and virtue.
- 53:51Exploring Amerigo Vespucci’s Influence
Examination of Vespucci’s role in the travel genre and its connection to Utopia.
- 54:48Dystopia vs. Utopia in Modern Literature
Comparison of classic dystopian works with Utopian themes, noting the difficulty of envisioning true utopias.
Highlights
- 4:51
Writing Utopia While Bored on Diplomacystory
Thomas More began writing Utopia while on a diplomatic mission in the Low Countries after trade negotiations came to an abrupt end and he found himself bored.
- 13:14
Punning Titles and Greek Jokesinsight
The full title of Utopia contains multiple puns and plays on whether a commonwealth can be both useful and entertaining, written in Latin with Greek jokes meant for a humanist elite.
- 20:22
Gold as Chamber Potsstrategy
To strip value away from wealth and social status, Utopians use gold for chamber pots and slave chains, while children use gemstones as baubles.
- 28:18
Surveillance as a Pillar of Virtueinsight
The guests explain that Utopian surveillance and lack of privacy, which modern readers view as sinister, were intended by More as a way to scaffold individual virtue.
- 31:32
A Skull-Shaped Map of Utopiainsight
The definitive 1518 version of Utopia includes a map shaped like a human skull, serving as a memento mori to remind readers that wealth and social standing do not matter in death.
- 34:03
The Brutal Reality of Enclosuredebate
In Book One, Hithlade argues against the execution of thieves, pointing out that economic displacement through land enclosure forces people into starvation and crime.
Quotes
“but the other, utopia, means no place at all.”
Unnamed speaker · 12:43 “a lot of people read it as quite dystopian, because we're quite interested in in our own privacy and our own things that are ours today.”
Unnamed speaker · 19:31 “I think is also a bit of a reflection of the way in which, well, for instance, the Holbein, the very famous Holbein of Thomas More, he is wearing a gold chain, right?”
Unnamed speaker · 20:29 “It will be so easy to be virtuous, is what he's saying, if you lived in this society.”
Unnamed speaker · 28:29 “But he certainly is in dialogue with, because Moore, you know, Cicero's Deoficis is an absolute core text, you know, this foundational Roman text of what is it to be good?”
Unnamed speaker · 52:50 “It's so striking that what the genre has become is dystopias.”
Unnamed speaker · 55:12 “But all those dystopias are masquerading as utopias.”
Unnamed speaker · 55:22
Sponsored segments
- Humana 0:00–1:06
- Toyota 1:10–1:43
- Food Lion 22:13–23:06
- Toyota 23:11–23:47
About this episode
In 1516, the publication of one small book would coin a new word and give rise to centuries of literature, theory, and thought. In his most influential work, the lawyer and Tudor politician Thomas More (1478-1535) described a seemingly perfect – but entirely fictional – island called Utopia. In 1535, less than two decades after writing the book, More was executed for refusing to accept King Henry VIII as supreme head of the church of England. Misha Glenny and his guests discuss why More’s exploration of service and the ideal state has been read as a blueprint for society, a scathing satire, and as a timeless warning. This In Our Time episode examines the 16th-century origin and legacy of one of most influential works of political philosophy. The discussion explores Utopia’s roots in Renaissance Humanism, what the book has to say about tyranny and governance, and why utopias can so often seem dystopian. With Laura Ashe Professor of English Literature at Worcester College, University of Oxford Cathy Shrank Professor of Tudor and Renaissance Literature at the University of Sheffield And Joanne Paul Honorary Associate Professor in Intellectual History at the University of Sussex Producer: Martha Owen Reading list: Terence Cave (ed.), Thomas More’s ‘Utopia’ in Early Modern Europe: Paratexts and Contexts (Manchester University Press, 2008) J. H. Hexter, More’s Utopia: The Biography of an Idea (Princeton University Press, 1952) Richard Marius, Thomas More: A Biography (Harvard University Press, 1999) Thomas More (ed. Joanne Paul), Utopia (Oxford University Press, 2025) Thomas More (ed. George M. Logan), Utopia (Cambridge University Press, 2016) Thomas More (ed. Gerard B. Wegemer and Stephen W. Smith), The Essential Works of Thomas More (Yale University Press, 2020) Joanne Paul, Thomas More: A Life and Death in Tudor England (Michael Joseph, 2025) Joanne Paul, Thomas More: Classic Thinkers (Polity, 2016) Howard P. Segal, Utopias: A Brief History from Ancient Writings to Virtual Communities (Wiley-Blackwell, 2012) Cathy Shrank and Phil Withington (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Thomas More's Utopia (Oxford University Press, 2023) Quentin Skinner, The Foundations of Modern Political Thought, vol. 1: The Renaissance (Cambridge University Press, 1979) In Our Time is a BBC Studios production A world-class seminar every week. Spanning history, religion, culture, science and philosophy, In Our Time celebrates the pursuit of knowledge and the enduring power of ideas. In each episode, host Misha Glenny and expert guests explore the characters, events and discoveries that have shaped our world.
Transcript
10,240 words · 8 speakers
Topics
- Utopia
- London
- Antwerp
- Gulliver's Travels
- BBC.com
- Worcester College
- University of Oxford
- University of Sheffield
- University of Sussex
- Bruges
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated