Skip to content

How to Combat Pain

Hidden Brain

Hosted by Shankar Vedantam

57m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Shankar Vedantam interviews Rachel Zoffness, a pain psychologist at the University of California, San Francisco, on why our culture misunderstands pain. Zoffness dismantles the biomedical model—diagnose the problem, fix the tissue, pain goes away—using two construction worker stories: one who felt excruciating pain from a nail that passed between his toes without causing any tissue damage, and another who had a four-inch nail embedded in his face near his prefrontal cortex but felt only a mild toothache for six days. Her central claim is that the brain is the body's danger detector and constructs pain using all available information, including context, emotion, and social input.

Zoffness introduces the biopsychosocial model, arguing that Western medicine focuses only on the biological domain and misses two-thirds of the pain problem. She describes practical strategies: mapping a patient's "high pain recipe" and constructing a "low pain recipe" by addressing sleep, diet, social connection, and emotional health. She shares the story of Sam, a 17-year-old bedridden for four years who, through a pacing protocol targeting multiple factors simultaneously, eventually graduated high school and went to college. She also recounts how one patient's sister discovered that regular cherry gummy bears produced the same pain relief as CBD gummies, demonstrating the power of expectation in pain modulation.

  • Pain is constructed by the brain using all available information, not simply transmitted from damaged tissue, as shown by phantom limb pain and the two nail stories. 16:31
  • Focusing only on the biological domain of pain means missing two-thirds of the problem, since psychological and sociological factors are equally important. 33:22
  • Everyone has a unique 'high pain recipe' and can construct a 'low pain recipe' by identifying and changing the specific ingredients that amplify their pain. 38:25
  • Social connection reduces pain because being with others triggers dopamine, serotonin, and endogenous opioids, while chronic loneliness raises cortisol and suppresses the immune system. 36:28
  • Seventy percent of studies on pain and optimism show a real connection between hopeful thoughts and reductions in pain intensity, frequency, and disability. 42:15

Highlights

  • 5:31

    Tale of Two Nailsstory

    Zoffness tells two construction worker stories: one who felt excruciating pain from a nail that passed between his toes with no damage, and another who had a four-inch nail in his face but felt only a mild toothache for six days.

  • 6:50

    Brain as Danger Detectorinsight

    Zoffness explains that the brain uses all available information—memories, senses, emotions, social input—to decide whether to make pain and how much, framing pain as a protective alarm rather than a direct readout of tissue damage.

  • 11:04

    Hurt and Harm Are Not the Sameinsight

    Zoffness states that the myth that pain and damage are one and the same is the core misunderstanding that leads to mistreatment of chronic pain.

  • 18:41

    Mateo's Firework Accidentstory

    A 12-year-old boy lost his hand to a firework explosion and experienced phantom pain in the missing limb. Zoffness explains this through the brain's body map, the homunculus, which had not yet updated to reflect the amputation.

  • 31:50

    Biopsychosocial Model Explainedstrategy

    Zoffness describes pain as living in the overlap of biological, psychological, and sociological factors, noting that neuroscience has known this for 65 years but it has not yet reached mainstream medicine.

  • 38:25

    High Pain Recipe Frameworkstrategy

    Zoffness describes how she helps patients map the specific biological, psychological, and sociological ingredients that construct their worst pain days, then builds a low pain recipe by changing each ingredient.

  • 45:22

    Kai's Placebo Gummy Experimentstory

    A patient's sister swapped his CBD gummies for regular cherry gummy bears and found his pain disappeared identically, demonstrating that expectation and belief can physiologically lower the brain's pain alarm.

  • 51:06

    Sam's Pacing Protocolstrategy

    A 17-year-old bedridden for four years with 40 medications and no diagnosis was helped through a gradual pacing protocol targeting sleep, nutrition, social behavior, and movement, eventually graduating high school and attending college.

About this episode

Pain feels like a simple message from the body. If your elbow hurts, there must be something wrong with your elbow. If your back is painfully stiff, you need some work done on your back. But psychologist Rachel Zoffness says our minds play a much larger role in our experience of pain than many of us realize. This week, we look at what's really happening when we experience pain, and how a better understanding of this process can open up new possibilities for treatment and healing.

Transcript

0:00
57:25

8,363 words · 5 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Pain Neuroscience
  • Chronic Pain
  • Biopsychosocial Model
  • Phantom Limb Pain
  • Pain Management
  • Brain Plasticity
  • Placebo Effect
  • Social Connection

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated