Skip to content

Dropping the Mask

Hidden Brain

Hosted by Shankar Vedantam

1h 43m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the concept of covering, a sociological term coined by Erving Goffman that describes how people downplay, edit, or mute stigmatized identities to fit into mainstream society. Guest Kenji Yoshino, a legal scholar at New York University, explains that while conversion and passing are strategies limited to certain groups, covering is universal because everyone possesses some outsider identity that society pressures them to conceal. Through historical examples such as Franklin Delano Roosevelt hiding his motor disability and Margaret Thatcher adopting voice coaching to soften her working-class accent, as well as personal anecdotes from Yoshino's own life as a gay man, the conversation reveals the heavy psychological toll of masking one's true self.

The discussion further examines how covering manifests in everyday environments, from corporate motherhood penalties to introversion and addiction. Yoshino argues that pushing back against illegitimate covering demands is a crucial step toward true belonging and a universal civil rights struggle. By fostering psychological safety and practicing both distinct and diffuse storytelling, individuals can create spaces where authenticity is valued over witless conformity, allowing people to bring their whole selves to work and society.

  • Recognize that covering involves downplaying behavioral aspects of an identity, making it a universal experience for everyone. 28:16
  • Understand that unlike conversion or passing, covering happens when an individual is known to belong to a group but pressured to mute it. 25:07
  • Examine whether workplace covering demands are backed by legitimate community values or arbitrary conformity pressures. 33:42
  • Create psychological safety and use diffuse storytelling to signal that colleagues can bring their authentic selves to work. 1:07:25

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Hidden Brain Intro & Hijacking Hook

    The episode opens with a dramatic 1971 airplane hijacking to set up the theme of disguise and identity.

  2. 2:00
    Why We Mask Ourselves

    Shankar explains how people disguise themselves to fit in, and the psychological effects of such masking.

  3. 4:21
    Kenji Yoshino on FDR’s Disability Masking

    Kenji discusses Franklin D. Roosevelt’s deliberate concealment of his polio disability to maintain presidential authority.

  4. 7:17
    Margaret Thatcher’s Voice Coaching as Covering

    The conversation turns to Thatcher’s voice training as a strategic cover to hide her working‑class roots.

  5. 10:13
    Ben Kingsley’s Name Change and Identity Management

    Kenji explains how Kingsley’s stage name and role choices illustrate covering and the broader concept of identity management.

  6. 15:00
    Personal Journey: Kenji’s Coming Out and Family Pressure

    Kenji shares his own experience of coming out, parental expectations, and the pressure to downplay activism.

  7. 25:41
    Introducing Goffman’s Concept of Covering

    Kenji introduces Goffman’s theory of covering, explaining how it differs from conversion and passing.

  8. 49:01
    Corporate Covering Survey Findings

    Kenji discusses a Deloitte survey revealing that covering is widespread even among privileged groups.

  9. 56:57
    Universal Nature of Covering and Authenticity

    The episode concludes with Kenji reflecting on how covering affects everyone and the possibility of greater authenticity.

  10. 58:38
    Introverts as Historical Leaders

    The host discusses how prominent leaders like Madison and Lincoln were introverts, challenging stereotypes about leadership and introversion.

  11. 59:28
    Storytelling Strategies: Distinct vs. Diffuse

    Kenji introduces distinct storytelling—public, intentional narratives—and diffuse storytelling—offhand, everyday disclosures—to foster authenticity.

  12. 1:00:00
    Defining Covering vs. Passing

    Kenji explains the difference between covering and passing, emphasizing that covering involves known identities being downplayed under social pressure.

  13. 1:22:09
    Covering in Politics and Polarization

    The conversation turns to political identity, exploring how covering can both harm and help in polarized environments and the role of allyship.

Highlights

  • 4:50

    Hiding in Plain Sightstory

    FDR used specially designed cars and seated photos to hide his polio-related mobility issues, not to fool people, but to soften the impression that his disability mattered.

  • 8:12

    Voice Coaching for Powerstory

    Margaret Thatcher's handlers sent her to voice coaching to lower her pitch and scrub her working-class accent to project greater executive presence.

  • 18:42

    The Stigma of Desiresinsight

    A pivotal conversation with a psychiatrist shifted Yoshino's perspective from viewing his attraction as perverted to understanding it as merely thwarted.

  • 30:09

    Mitigating the Motherhood Penaltyinsight

    Studies show women cannot eliminate the motherhood penalty, but they can mitigate it through work-devotional behavior like never discussing children at work.

  • 48:42

    The Universal Nature of Coveringdata

    A Deloitte study revealed that 61 percent of workers cover, and strikingly, 45 percent of straight white men report covering traits like age, illness, or background.

  • 49:15

    The Earl Warren Professorshipstory

    Yoshino refused a named chair at NYU because Earl Warren superintended Japanese American internment, leading the dean to offer the Chief Justice title instead.

  • 1:07:01

    Distinct Versus Diffuse Storytellingstrategy

    Yoshino contrasts dramatic set-piece personal revelations with casual, offhanded remarks about one's life that normalize authenticity without demanding a podium.

Quotes

  • “And he made every effort to downplay this to the American public.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:01
  • “She dutifully went into the voice coaching and emerged on the other side with a more patrician, resonant voice.”
    Unnamed speaker · 8:38
  • “Covering demands direct themselves at the behavioral aspects of an identity.”
    Unnamed speaker · 28:06
  • “We found 61% of people overall reported covering, and of that 61%, 60% to 73%, depending on the axis of covering, said that this was somewhat too extremely detrimental to their sense of self.”
    Unnamed speaker · 48:42
  • “We should be celebrate leaders who are great orders, but we should also celebrate leaders who are great listeners.”
    Unnamed speaker · 59:55
  • “So this is just evidence that, you know, covering demands are hurtful and that they're particularly hurtful when they come from leaders within the organization.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:09:22
  • “So I'm all for this idea that, you know, covering your politics is a form of covering.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:22:57
  • “psychological safety, you know, in the team context, is a team climate marked by mutual respect and interpersonal trust in which people feel comfortable being themselves.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:47:03
  • Pfizer 13:30–13:56
  • Progressive 14:02–14:29
  • Fidelity 35:19–35:48
  • Quince 35:50–36:42
  • Angi 1:13:05–1:13:49
  • Hidden Brain Plus 1:48:52–1:49:12
  • Atlantic Union Bank 1:49:27–1:49:55
  • Angi 1:49:57–1:50:12
  • Simplisafe 1:50:12–1:50:40

About this episode

Have you ever downplayed some aspect of your identity? Maybe you don’t hide it, but you don’t bring it up with certain people, either. It turns out that these subtle disguises can have powerful effects on how we view ourselves. This week, we bring you a favorite conversation with legal scholar Kenji Yoshino. He introduces us to the concept of "covering," and talks about what happens when we soften or edit our true selves. Then, we revisit our "Your Questions Answered" segment in which Kenji answers listener questions and comments about his work.

Transcript

0:00
1:43:06

17,733 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • DEI
  • New York University
  • Monday.com
  • Deloitte
  • Earl Warren Professorship
  • Earl Warren Professorship of Constitutional Law
  • The New York Times
  • NYU
  • Northwest Orient Airlines
  • Harvard University

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated