Skip to content

How to Return Stolen Art (Update)

Freakonomics Radio

Hosted by Stephen J. Dubner

50m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This final installment of a three-part series examines the complex economics, ethics, and politics of returning stolen art and artifacts from major Western institutions to their countries of origin. Host Stephen Dubner reports from museums in Glasgow, London, Washington, and New York, speaking with curators like Patricia Allen, Smithsonian secretary Lonnie G. Bunch III, and market design economist Tom Wilkning. The episode explores how institutions are shifting from defensive posturing to new policies of ethical returns, shared stewardship, and long-term leases, focusing particularly on the contentious history of the Benin bronzes and other plundered treasures.

  • Museums can establish objective criteria for repatriation, such as evaluating the cultural importance of objects and the status of those making requests, while removing outdated requirements like pre-approval of storage facilities. 17:53
  • Long-term leases and shared stewardship agreements offer a viable framework for countries of origin to regain ownership of cultural patrimony while keeping items accessible abroad. 33:50
  • Institutions can implement ethical returns policies that allow ethical considerations to trump traditional scholarship and acquisition resources when determining what to maintain. 28:42

Chapters

  1. 0:01
    Podcast Sponsorships and Intro

    The episode opens with a series of sponsor messages before the hosts begin discussing the return of stolen art.

  2. 3:01
    First Look at Benin Bronzes

    The hosts arrive at Glasgow’s Kelvin Grove Museum to view Benin bronzes and learn about their colonial history.

  3. 6:57
    Interview with Patricia Allen

    Patricia Allen explains her background, the museum’s repatriation efforts, and the complexities of returning Benin artifacts to Nigeria.

  4. 59:00
    California Closets Introduction

    The host introduces California Closets and its focus on design for everyday moments.

Highlights

  • 3:01

    Visiting Glasgow's Benin Bronzesstory

    The host visits the Kelvin Grove Museum in Glasgow with curator Patricia Allen to view artifacts looted from the Kingdom of Benin in 1897.

  • 10:56

    Museums as Warehouses of Lootinsight

    Patricia Allen describes how major Western museums have transitioned from perceived treasure troves to warehouses of loot and harbingers of doom.

  • 15:00

    The Met's History of Plunderdata

    Andrea Bayer explains how the Metropolitan Museum of Art's first director excavated and removed thousands of objects from Cyprus, a paradigm no one follows today.

  • 18:42

    Revising Glasgow's Return Criteriastrategy

    Glasgow Museums removed the requirement that recipient communities must have specific museum facilities, acknowledging that demanding strict storage conditions acts as a barrier to returning looted items.

  • 27:10

    Building Collections from Basementsdata

    Lonnie Bunch describes how the National Museum of African American History and Culture acquired 40,000 artifacts, with 70 percent coming from people's private basements, trunks, and attics.

  • 33:50

    Using Long-Term Leases for Antiquitiesinsight

    Economist Tom Wilkning explains how complementing export bans with fixed-duration, long-term leases can strengthen incentives for protecting antiquities and generate revenue for countries of origin.

Quotes

  • “The British shipped thousands of objects, from everyday tools to religious and historical objects, back to England.”
    Stephen J. Dubner · 5:02
  • “Glasgow Museums is currently holding 19 pieces that we have identified as coming from Benin, probably taken during the punitive expedition of 1897 by Britain.”
    Unnamed speaker · 13:04
  • “The Met was founded toward the end of the 19th century. Its first director was an Italian-American soldier and amateur archaeologist.”
    Stephen J. Dubner · 14:52
  • “The only thing I can mention about the Parthenon marbles is that every time I read one thing, I almost immediately read its opposite the following day.”
    Unnamed speaker · 43:29
  • “The British Museum has thus far refused, but many other institutions, including the Glasgow Museums, have begun to repatriate their Benin pieces.”
    Stephen J. Dubner · 5:29
  • “The Glasgow Museums have also announced the return of seven antiquities to India and more than two dozen artifacts to the Lakota tribe of Native Americans.”
    Stephen J. Dubner · 13:22
  • “The British Museum is famous for not saying much publicly about their various controversial holdings, including their Benin bronzes.”
    Stephen J. Dubner · 43:49
  • Angi 0:01–0:26
  • LabCorp On Demand 0:38–0:59
  • PNC Bank 1:11–1:16
  • California Closets 59:00–59:28

About this episode

Museums are purging their collections of looted treasures. Can they also get something in return? And what does it mean to be a museum in the 21st century? (Part 3 of an updated series originally published in 2023.)

Transcript

0:00
50:48

9,049 words · 14 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Art Repatriation
  • Museum Curation
  • Cultural Heritage
  • Market Design
  • Colonial History
  • Ethics

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated