Skip to content

694. Does Democracy Really Need Elections?

Freakonomics Radio

1h 12m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores sortition, an ancient Athenian practice of choosing lawmakers through random lottery rather than competitive elections. Host Stephen J. Dubner examines the growing dissatisfaction with modern electoral politics, where low voter turnout and partisan incentives often produce entrenched, unrepresentative leadership. Through interviews with political theorists like Ellen Landemore and Terry Baricius, the episode looks at how randomly selected citizens assemblies and policy juries have been used in places like British Columbia, Ireland, France, and Connecticut to deliberate on major public policy issues without the corrupting influence of ambition or party politics. While critics worry about bureaucratic complexity and bad decisions, advocates argue that sortition restores genuine political equality and public spiritedness.

  • Advocates suggest reforming government by starting with advisory citizens assemblies before delegating binding authority on specific policy domains. 38:45
  • Proponents of sortition argue that ancient Athenian lotteries were intentionally democratic, whereas modern elections function as oligarchic control mechanisms. 28:07
  • The Connecticut Citizens Assembly on Property Taxes mailed 240,000 invitations to gather roughly 100 residents paid $1,200 to recommend tax reforms. 46:04
  • A poll conducted by The New York Times and Siena found that 43% of voters are dissatisfied with both political parties. 2:16

Chapters

  1. 0:01
    Episode Introduction and Sponsorships

    The host opens the episode with a series of sponsor messages before segueing into the main topic.

  2. 1:47
    Midterm Election Context

    The host sets the stage by discussing the recent U.S. midterm elections and voter dissatisfaction.

  3. 3:02
    Critique of the Current Electoral System

    The host and guests outline the flaws of the U.S. voting system and its impact on democracy.

  4. 4:33
    Introducing Sortition and Citizens Assemblies

    The episode introduces the concept of sortition, its historical roots, and modern advocates.

  5. 12:05
    Interview with Ellen Landemore

    Ellen Landemore explains her advocacy for citizens assemblies and the theoretical basis for sortition.

  6. 35:44
    Challenges and Criticisms of Sortition

    The conversation addresses obstacles, failures, and critiques of implementing sortition in large democracies.

  7. 38:21
    Case Studies of Sortition in Practice

    The hosts review real‑world examples from British Columbia, Iceland, Ireland, France, and Connecticut.

  8. 53:34
    Future Visions and Speculations

    Guests speculate on how a sortition‑based government could function in the U.S., including agenda setting and architecture.

  9. 55:09
    Episode Introduction

    The hosts set the stage for a discussion on alternative democratic structures.

  10. 55:55
    Policy Juries and Their Role

    Describes the creation of large, statistically representative juries that vote on drafted bills.

  11. 56:33
    Rules and Oversight Councils

    Introduces a lottery‑selected rules body that sets procedural norms for all other bodies.

  12. 1:00:31
    Accountability in Sortition

    Discusses how accountability functions when decisions are made by random citizen juries.

Highlights

  • 4:39

    Democracy by Lotteryinsight

    The host reflects on serving on a Manhattan criminal jury and wonders if sortition, the ancient Greek practice of choosing officials by lottery, could improve political bodies.

  • 13:52

    Elections Stoke Fearinsight

    Terry Baricius explains that competitive electoral systems naturally favor narcissistic candidates willing to stoke fear, division, and partisanship.

  • 33:22

    Legislative Demographicsdata

    A survey of the Vermont House of Representatives revealed that out of 150 members, exactly zero were renters, despite renters making up a third of the state.

  • 41:01

    Ireland Same-Sex Marriagestory

    A sortition citizens convention in Ireland proposed legalizing same-sex marriage in a deeply Catholic country, leading to a successful constitutional referendum.

  • 46:27

    Citizen-Led Tax Reportdata

    The Connecticut Citizens Assembly on Property Taxes released non-binding recommendations that included increasing income taxes on earners making over $1 million.

  • 1:00:31

    Accountability Concernsdebate

    The host questions how a sortition government would handle a genuinely bad decision, such as a policy jury voting to repeal the First Amendment.

Quotes

  • “The case itself wasn't particularly interesting. It was a low-level drug case, but the way the jury came together to sort things out, well, that was interesting.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:30
  • “In other words, democracy by lottery, which is pretty much how our jury system still operates today.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:47
  • “The only incentives to show up are a sense of duty, let's call it, or maybe a vague fear that you might get a threatening letter someday if you don't.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:50
  • “The radical election reform I'm talking about goes back to Athenian democracy, when most public offices were filled not by election, but by a practice called sortition, from the Latin for drawing lots.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:33
  • “We need to agree on things that are not pleasant and all of us should have a say. That's a premise of democracy.”
    Unnamed speaker · 21:39
  • “The fact is that in Congress, it's not just a bunch of mostly old white men, but a majority of Congress are millionaires.”
    Unnamed speaker · 34:59
  • “They reflect the values of their community, government of the people, by the people, for the people.”
    Unnamed speaker · 36:29
  • “The rules have to be made by a body that is not then using the rules.”
    Unnamed speaker · 59:16
  • “The only punishment we have is we're not going to let you continue doing that.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:01:00
  • “They will sometimes make bad decisions. If they make a bad decision, the next jury that comes in to deal with that issue, they have no vested interest in maintaining it.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:01:22
  • hotels.com 0:01–0:59
  • Amica 0:33–0:59
  • ChatGPT 1:05–1:36
  • Mint Mobile 23:20–24:16
  • Quince 24:12–25:22
  • hotels.com 25:27–25:54
  • Schwab 50:36–51:05
  • Sylvania 51:03–51:48
  • hotels.com 51:46–52:13
  • Ozempic 1:10:38–1:11:02
  • Mazda 1:11:08–1:11:40
  • JCPenney 1:11:44–1:12:01
  • McDonald's 1:11:59–1:12:23

About this episode

Stephen Dubner recently served on a criminal jury. Twelve strangers — selected randomly and barely paid — took the job seriously. Afterward, he wondered: why can’t our politics work that way? A growing movement, inspired by Athenian democracy, says it can.

Transcript

0:00
1:12:23

11,973 words · 8 speakers

Topics

  • Connecticut
  • France
  • Freakonomics Radio
  • United States
  • British Columbia
  • Vermont
  • Ireland
  • New York
  • Democracy Without Politicians
  • Iceland

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated