Skip to content

The left and right agree on one thing: no data centers

Decoder

37m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In this episode of Decoder, host Nilay Patel speaks with Verge policy reporter Gabby DeVae about the growing bipartisan backlash against AI data centers across communities like Hernando County, Florida, and Tucson, Arizona. They examine how data center build-outs have become physical targets for public frustration regarding AI, surveillance, rising housing and utility costs, and a perceived lack of economic benefits for locals. The discussion explores how this issue is scrambling traditional political alignments, turning conservative voters toward local environmental concerns, and setting up data center politics to play a major role in upcoming midterm elections.

  • Monitor local zoning board meetings and municipal discussions to understand how your community is handling data center proposals. 7:40
  • Recognize that data center developments often require minimal long-term staffing after the initial construction phase is completed. 10:19
  • Pay attention to how local utility costs and water management regulations intersect with large-scale industrial real estate projects. 16:48

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Intro and Sponsor Ads

    Opening with sponsor messages and a brief intro to the podcast.

  2. 1:37
    Host Introduction and Guest Overview

    Neelai Patel introduces the show and Gabby DeVae, outlining the topic of AI data center backlash.

  3. 4:33
    Political Realignment Around Data Centers

    Discussion of how data center protests are scrambling traditional party lines and influencing midterm politics.

  4. 13:43
    Closing and Call to Action

    Wrap‑up with final thoughts, audience engagement prompts, and episode credits.

  5. 28:47
    Strategic Responses and Future Outlook

    Speculation on how tech firms, politicians, and communities might address opposition and shape future policy.

Highlights

  • 3:48

    Widespread Community Angerinsight

    Local residents are expressing intense anger over data center construction due to localized concerns regarding high humidity, cooling requirements, and groundwater safety.

  • 4:58

    Populist Technocrat Divideinsight

    The opposition to data centers crosses party lines, aligning populist factions against tech development rather than fitting traditional left-right culture war molds.

  • 6:51

    Rumor Mill and Social Mediastory

    Extreme concerns, such as claims that cattle born near data centers are stillborn, spread rapidly via internet rumor mills from single isolated anecdotes.

  • 10:10

    Limited Long Term Jobsdata

    Despite initial construction booms, maintaining data center facilities requires very few permanent workers, defying promises of major job creation.

  • 15:09

    Shifting Political Endorsementsdebate

    Frontrunner candidates in Florida's gubernatorial primary who took tech industry donations are facing voter backlash from proud Trump supporters.

  • 17:55

    Noise and Frequency Pollutionstory

    Data centers generate persistent noise pollution that frustrates nearby residents, even among industry insiders who live near facilities in Virginia.

  • 27:48

    Specific Zoning Interventionsstrategy

    Protesters are utilizing land-use experts to present dry, technical presentations on writing specific local zoning ordinances against hyperscale data centers.

Quotes

  • “Data centers are very local. They're happening to people in their backyards and a data center being built in Florida or Georgia or Tucson has nothing to do with me in New York.”
    Unnamed speaker · 30:57
  • “People are going to the meetings or encountering one another. There have been stories of bridges across party lines from people who would never like each other normally because they both hate the data centers.”
    Unnamed speaker · 31:14
  • Amex Corporate 0:00–0:19
  • Midi 0:29–0:58
  • Amex Corporate 1:45–2:10
  • Michelob Ultra 12:39–13:22
  • Hilton 13:47–14:14
  • Indeed 30:02–30:32
  • Home Depot 38:38–39:37

About this episode

Our guest today is Gaby Del Valle, a policy reporter here at The Verge, and we’re discussing the growing backlash against AI data centers. Gaby recently reported a fantastic piece about Hernando County, Florida, where last month the county commission unanimously approved a year-long moratorium on data center construction. So I wanted Gaby to talk me through what these protests look like on the ground, from voters whose party affiliations have typically aligned them with big business. Read the full interview transcript on The Verge. Links: Right-wingers protesting data centers have a lot in common with the left | The Verge No data centers in my backyard | Jasmine Sun Who’s afraid of the big, bad GPU? | The Verge NY becomes the first state to enact a data center moratorium | The Verge The fight against AI data centers is just beginning | The Verge Florida gives millions in tax breaks to data centers under DeSantis-backed law | Tampa Bay Times Subscribe to The Verge to access the ad-free version of Decoder! Credits: Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Decoder is produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and edited by Ursa Wright. Our supervising producer is Greg Ott, and our editorial director is Kevin McShane. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
37:33

7,315 words · 9 speakers

Topics

  • data center
  • AI
  • Florida
  • Arizona
  • Tucson
  • The Verge
  • New York
  • Humans First
  • Wisconsin
  • Utah

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated