Skip to content

Benn Jordan thinks the surveillance problem is much bigger than Flock

Decoder

1h 2m

Original podcast

Where to listen

--:--
--:--

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Musician, YouTuber, and investigative journalist Ben Jordan joins the show to discuss his deep dive into Flock Safety, the maker of automatic license plate readers, and the broader, interlocking surveillance apparatus involving private companies, law enforcement, and government agencies. Jordan explains how Flock built a private nationwide network bypassing traditional warrant processes, and how he uncovered severe security vulnerabilities in their cameras and software. The guest and host explore the bipartisan backlash against surveillance, the failure of companies like Flock to handle criticism transparently, and why the real danger lies in secret databases rather than public hardware. Jordan argues that instead of tearing down a single startup, society must demand rigorous guardrails, immutable audit logs, and local accountability.

  • Local politics and community engagement have a much more direct impact on daily life than national headlines. 10:07
  • Automated license plate reader networks allow law enforcement to track vehicle movements across state lines without warrants. 15:21
  • Surveillance hardware security is only as strong as the worst security hygiene across the entire connected network. 29:05
  • To find effective solutions to overreaching surveillance, critics must offer practical guardrails alongside critique. 34:13

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Show Intro and Sponsor Messages

    The episode opens with sponsor ads and a brief introduction to the show’s theme and guests.

  2. 1:53
    Ben Jordan’s Background and Flock Focus

    Ben Jordan explains his evolution from musician to investigative journalist and his recent focus on Flock Safety’s ALPR technology.

  3. 6:26
    Local Democracy and Public Pressure

    The conversation turns to how local governments and citizens are pushing back against surveillance through town meetings and policy changes.

  4. 7:20
    Flock’s Technology and Privacy Concerns

    Jordan and the host dissect how Flock’s private network of license‑plate readers works and why it raises major privacy and security issues.

  5. 26:33
    Security Vulnerabilities Exposed

    Jordan details the hardware and software flaws he discovered in Flock cameras and the company’s initial response.

  6. 42:56
    Policy Solutions and Future Outlook

    Jordan outlines potential policy and technical fixes, such as audit logs and opt‑out mechanisms, and discusses the broader debate on surveillance and civil liberties.

  7. 48:38
    Wrap‑Up and Final Reflections

    The host and Jordan conclude the episode, reflecting on the challenges and possible paths forward in balancing safety and privacy.

  8. 49:34
    Ethics of Surveillance Promises

    Speakers critique how CEOs of surveillance companies market their products as solutions while ignoring ethical concerns.

  9. 51:48
    Local-Level Data and Referendums

    Discussion of using local data, public referendums, and accountability to guide surveillance deployment.

  10. 52:58
    Journalistic Integrity vs. Company Relations

    Balancing aggressive investigative journalism with maintaining a constructive relationship with Flock.

  11. 56:35
    Guardrails and Corporate Collaboration

    Explores the tension between Flock’s desire for guardrails and the lack of concrete guidance from regulators.

  12. 1:00:03
    Nuance in Content Creation

    The host and guest discuss how nuance and ethical storytelling can build trust and audience engagement.

Highlights

  • 11:23

    Flock as Low-Hanging Fruitinsight

    The guest explains that Flock became the primary target for criticism because of its defensive PR strategy, while larger contractors like Axon and Motorola quietly built similar networks.

  • 15:09

    Bypassing Warrants via Private Networksdata

    The guest explains how Flock created a private nationwide database where police can track a vehicle's movements for 30 days without needing a magistrate judge's warrant.

  • 19:22

    Relocation of Crimeinsight

    The guest argues that putting cameras in one specific neighborhood does not reduce overall crime, but merely relocates illegal activity to areas without cameras.

  • 27:24

    Discovering Camera Vulnerabilitiesstory

    The guest describes finding Russian dark web credentials and hardware vulnerabilities that allowed complete administrative control over Flock cameras.

  • 32:32

    Bipartisan Surveillance Backlashinsight

    The host and guest discuss how opposition to automated surveillance and data centers has united politicians and citizens across the political spectrum.

  • 39:11

    The Reality of Predictive Algorithmsinsight

    The guest explains that phones do not need to record conversations because invisible behavioral patterns and transaction history give algorithms terrifying predictive power.

  • 43:06

    Proposed Solution of Immutable Logsstrategy

    The guest suggests that requiring immutable audit logs and DMV opt-out options could have provided a reasonable compromise for privacy concerns.

Quotes

  • “The point you'll hear Ben make is that he doesn't actually hate Flock as a company.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:01
  • “I think a lot of my focus now is on the lack of transparency from the government.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:04
  • “I started with, I mean, I've been a musician my entire life, pretty much.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:05
  • “I think it was a week later that Savannah Guthrie's mom was kidnapped, and Jamie was on every news network in town, being like, Ring cameras are going to solve it.”
    Unnamed speaker · 49:06
  • “These CEOs or executives or anybody from any company, they're not actually going out and doing this research in a way where they're not cherry picking data and looking for statistics that support their product.”
    Unnamed speaker · 49:44
  • “I think one thing that, that happens is in our society all too often is when we have a big controversy, especially on social media, that there is no remediation at all.”
    Unnamed speaker · 55:11
  • CrowdStrike 0:00–0:32
  • Doppel 0:47–1:12
  • AMEX Corporate 1:21–1:46
  • CrowdStrike 21:54–23:23
  • Rippling 23:21–24:28
  • Outshift 24:32–25:42
  • Pipedrive 45:37–46:51
  • QUO 47:25–48:28
  • Apple Watch Series 12 1:06:18–1:06:49
  • USA Facts 1:06:28–1:07:32
  • Odoo 1:07:32–1:08:01

About this episode

Today, I’m talking with Benn Jordan, musician, YouTuber, researcher, and investigative journalist. In the last couple of years, Benn has become a high-profile face in the creator and media spaces for his work investigating Flock Safety, the maker of automatic license plate readers and the software that powers them. Benn recently testified in front of Congress at a hearing dedicated to Flock and other ALPR systems. So of course I wanted to dig into all of that with Benn, not just because of his role as a Flock critic, but because he’s also become in some ways the face of a new front in the broader debate about surveillance and privacy. Read the full interview transcript on The Verge. Links: Benn Jordan testifies in front of Senate | Benn Jordan (YouTube) Flock values their privacy. Oh well | Benn Jordan (YouTube) We Hacked Flock Safety Cameras in under 30 Seconds | Benn Jordan (YouTube) Lawmakers introduce multiple laws to curb Flock | 404 Media The fight over Flock and other ALPRs | The Verge Sanders, AOC, Merkley propose bill to ban Flock cameras | Politico Cities terminate Flock contracts at record pace in August | Ars Technica Flock to cut several hundred jobs amid backlash | Reuters Subscribe to The Verge to access the ad-free version of Decoder! Credits: Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Decoder’s producers are Greg Ott, Kate Cox, and Nick Statt. This episode was edited by Ursa Wright. Our editorial director is Kevin McShane. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From the transcript

“SPEAKER_00: Support for the show comes from CrowdStrike. It's not a huge stretch to say that AI is the next major computing platform. Every platform shift changes the way we build software, and it changes security, too.”

Topics

  • Flock
  • Axon
  • Ring
  • Motorola
  • ALPR
  • Blockchain
  • The Verge
  • AWS AI
  • Worm
  • Apple

Page updated