
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the 125-year history of the Royal Navy submarine service, recorded on location at the Royal Navy Submarine Museum in Gosport aboard the Second World War submarine HMS Alliance. Dan Snow, along with museum curator Alexandra Geary, traces the evolution of underwater warfare from Cornelius Drebble's 1620 underwater rowboat and the American Revolutionary War's Turtle to the primitive mechanical vessels of the early 20th century. The conversation examines the immense dangers faced by submariners, highlighting that roughly one in three British submariners perished during both World Wars. Later, Vice Admiral Sir Tim McClement joins to share firsthand accounts of commanding the nuclear-powered hunter-killer HMS Conqueror during the Falklands War, detailing the controversial sinking of the Argentine cruiser General Belgrano. Finally, First Sea Lord General Sir Gwyn Jenkins discusses the technological future of the silent service and the role of uncrewed systems in modern naval strategy.
- Early submarines like the Turtle changed buoyancy by manually pumping water out of ballast tanks. 9:14
- Submariners during the world wars endured cramped quarters, six-hour shifts, and a fatality rate near thirty-six percent. 21:51
- During the Falklands War, HMS Conqueror sank the Belgrano to neutralize a major threat to British aircraft carriers. 43:02
- Nuclear submarines maintain near-limitless power and can generate their own drinking water and oxygen. 53:04
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Sponsor Pitch
Dan Snow welcomes listeners and explains how subscribers can suggest future topics.
- 0:32Ad Reads and Outro
Features Verizon and History Hit subscription ads before concluding the episode.
- 3:27Submarine Museum Tour Begins
Dan Snow enters the Royal Navy Submarine Museum and introduces HMS Alliance.
- 8:50Early Submarine History and the Turtle
Discussion of the 17th‑century Turtle and its significance as the first true submarine.
- 17:48Verizon Holiday Ad Insert
A commercial break featuring Verizon’s Simplify Plan and FiOS Wi‑Fi promotion.
- 19:30World War I Submarine Warfare
Exploration of German U‑boats, the Battle of the Atlantic, and early submarine tactics.
- 34:30Episode Conclusion and Teaser
Dan Snow wraps up the episode and teases the next segment on future submarine technology.
- 36:00World War II Submarines and Midget Ops
Coverage of British and German submarine actions, including the Tirpitz attack and D‑Day reconnaissance.
- 39:00Modern Submarine Life and Operations
Insights into life aboard contemporary nuclear submarines and their operational protocols.
- 42:37Falklands War and the Belgrano Sinking
First‑hand account of HMS Conqueror’s torpedo attack on the Argentine cruiser.
- 49:51Submarine Rationing and War Effort
Discusses the decision to ration supplies on day 75 to support the war effort.
- 50:57Interview with First Sea Lord
Dan Snow interviews General Sir Gwyn Jenkins about Royal Navy priorities.
Highlights
- 8:41
The Turtle Submarine Attemptstory
Built in 1776, the Turtle was a wooden, egg-shaped vessel operated by a single person intended to attach explosives to a British flagship in New York Harbour.
- 13:38
Ungentlemanly Naval Warfareinsight
Early submarines faced severe skepticism from traditional naval officers who viewed them as unfair and underhand, with one official comparing operators to pirates.
- 19:41
The Three Before Breakfastdata
Within an hour of World War One being declared, the German submarine U-9 sank three British warships in the English Channel.
- 21:03
Dardanelles Submarine Breakthroughstory
Despite heavy minefields and enemy fire, British E-class submarines successfully navigated the Dardanelles Straits to operate in enemy waters.
- 30:45
Operation Source Against Tirpitzstory
Miniature X-craft submarines successfully navigated German anti-submarine nets in a Norwegian fjord to cripple the formidable battleship Tirpitz with explosive charges.
- 38:36
Hot Bunking on Cold War Submarinesstrategy
Due to space constraints, crew members shared bunks on a rotating shift system known as hot bunking during long underwater patrols.
- 47:24
Firing Solutions on the Belgranodebate
The second in command of HMS Conqueror briefly stopped the captain from firing prematurely to secure a zero gyro angle firing solution against the Belgrano.
- 54:51
Blending AI with Human Crewsinsight
The First Sea Lord explains that while artificial intelligence excels at strategy, human-AI teaming provides the ultimate edge in military performance.
Quotes
“The first Royal Navy submarine was launched in 1901, and that makes it one of the first submarine services in the world.”
Dan Snow · 5:12 “The destruction or even crippling of this ship is the greatest event at sea at the present time. No other target is comparable to it.”
Unnamed speaker · 32:21 “Submarines have revolutionised our understanding of our oceans and our warfare.”
Dan Snow · 6:02 “Conqueror demonstrated how a single nuclear powered submarine could transform an entire naval campaign.”
Dan Snow · 50:04 “They are inherently stealthy. It's not called the silent service by accident.”
Unnamed speaker · 52:50 “I love this kind of analysis that says that a artificial intelligence will beat any human at any strategy game now.”
Unnamed speaker · 54:43 “However, artificial intelligence teamed with a human team will beat any artificial intelligence at a strategy game.”
Unnamed speaker · 54:51 “We have to accelerate. We have to have the advantage and the edge in this.”
Unnamed speaker · 55:32
Sponsored segments
- History Hit 0:00–0:29
- Verizon 0:32–1:29
- TikTok 17:04–17:44
- Verizon 17:48–18:45
- Covino and Rich 18:06–19:07
- Verizon 34:45–35:10
- Toyota 35:15–35:53
- Verizon 57:00–57:59
- History Hit 58:02–58:29
About this episode
For centuries, humans have been fascinated by the mysteries of the deep sea. The history of submarines is one of extraordinary invention, daring exploration and deadly warfare. From the first experimental underwater vessels of the 17th century to the devastating U-boats of the First and Second World Wars, submarines have transformed naval warfare and revolutionised our understanding of the oceans. Today, Dan visits the Royal Navy Submarine Museum in Gosport and is joined by curator Alexandra Geary to discover the eccentric origins of underwater travel and the dramatic submarine battles of WWI and WWII in honour of the 125th anniversary of the Royal Navy Submarine Service. He also speaks to Vice Admiral Sir Tim McClement, who was Second in Command on HMS Conqueror during the sinking of the Argentine ARA General Belgrano warship in the Falklands, as well as First Sea Lord General Sir Gwyn Jenkins on how AI might shape the submarines of the future. You can find out more about the Royal Navy Submarine Service at https://www.royalnavy.mod.uk/organisation/submarine-service and plan a visit to the Royal Navy Submarine Museum at https://www.royalnavymuseums.org.uk/visit-us/submarine-museum With huge thanks to Commander James 'Dally' Dalrymple and Annarose Hearsum. Produced by Mariana Des Forges, Beth Donaldson and edited by Dougal Patmore Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe. You can also email the podcast directly at ds.hh@historyhit.com mailto:ds.hh@historyhit.com. Dan Snow's History Hit is a History Hit podcast. History Hit is part of Little Dot Studios, a Certified B Corp™. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript
10,445 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Royal Navy
- torpedoes
- Turtle
- artificial intelligence
- Royal Navy Submarine Museum
- sonar
- Gosport
- Portsmouth
- HMS Upholder
- nuclear powered submarine
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated