Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of Criminal examines the suspicious deaths of two husbands married to Raynella Dossett-Leith in East Tennessee. In March 2003, Raynella called 911 to report that her second husband, David Leith, had shot himself in their bedroom. Investigators immediately questioned the suicide scenario because multiple shots were fired, including one into the wall and another through the mattress, alongside unusual positioning and no fingerprints or gunshot residue on the weapon. Although Raynella had an alibi for much of the morning, investigators grew deeply suspicious, particularly when they uncovered striking parallels to the 1992 death of her first husband, Ed Dossett. Ed, a popular district attorney general, had reportedly been trampled to death by cattle while terminally ill with cancer, a story local farmers and family members dismissed as implausible.
- Investigators noted that a multi-shot suicide with a bullet missing the target entirely is highly unusual. 10:20
- Local farmers familiar with Ed Dossett's cattle described them as remarkably calm polled Herefords not prone to stampeding. 19:26
- Medical examiners and investigators struggled to pinpoint an exact time of death, relying instead on a broad window between 6:00 AM and 9:30 AM based on body temperature. 29:39
- David Leith's daughter was immediately suspicious of the suicide ruling because her father was afraid of guns, deeply religious, and showed no signs of depression. 27:46
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Sponsor Ads
The episode opens with sponsor messages and a brief introduction by host Phoebe Judge.
- 1:06Raynella and David Leith Background
The hosts introduce the Leiths, outlining their public personas and family life.
- 3:44The 2003 Murder‑Suicide Incident
Details of Raynella’s 911 call and the discovery of David’s body are recounted.
- 9:36Investigation Findings and Suspicion
Investigators note multiple gunshots and inconsistencies that raise doubts about a suicide.
- 18:30Ed Dossett’s Death and Rumors
The story of Raynella’s first husband’s accidental death and ensuing speculation is explored.
- 29:04Alibi and Forensic Evidence for Raynella
Raynella’s alibi for the morning of David’s death and the lack of forensic ties are examined.
- 31:27Medical Examiner’s Verdict and Homicide Conclusion
The medical examiner declares the death a homicide, citing the second shot that killed David.
- 32:01Episode Wrap‑Up and Next Episode Teaser
The hosts conclude the episode, previewing Part 2 and providing production credits.
Highlights
- 3:44
The 911 Callstory
On March 13, 2003, Raynella Dossett-Leith hysterically called 911 to report that her husband David had shot himself.
- 6:09
Strange Bedroom Sceneinsight
First responders found David Leith under the covers in bed with a gunshot wound to his forehead, undisturbed breakfast tray nearby, and a dryer running.
- 9:49
Investigators discovered three discharged rounds in the bedroom, including a shot into the wall, a shot through the mattress, and the fatal shot to the head.
- 18:46
First Husband's Cattle Deathstory
Raynella's first husband Ed Dossett died in 1992 when Raynella claimed he fell from his wheelchair and was trampled by cattle while battling terminal cancer.
- 19:26
Disputing the Cattle Stampededebate
Local farmers and Ed's cousin disputed the cattle trampling story, stating Ed's polled Hereford cattle were extremely gentle and the enclosure was too small.
- 27:46
Daughter Doubts Suicideinsight
David Leith's daughter Cindy immediately doubted the suicide ruling because her father feared guns, was deeply religious, and was actively planning his future.
- 29:39
The medical examiner estimated David died between 6:00 AM and 9:30 AM because his toes were still warm when authorities arrived.
Quotes
“The lead investigator on the scene made notes as he examined the room.”
Unnamed speaker · 6:22 “The gun is laying on the mattress next to his hand.”
Unnamed speaker · 9:36 “He was on his right side. His right arm was outstretched. His left arm was sort of bent at the elbow and laying on the mattress.”
Unnamed speaker · 5:57 “The medical examiner concluded that this must be a homicide.”
Unnamed speaker · 31:27 “The medical examiner said he saw what appeared to be a hoof print on Ed's overalls.”
Unnamed speaker · 22:45
Sponsored segments
- FAIRE 0:00–0:29
- thisiscriminal.com 0:48–0:59
About this episode
On March 13, 2003, Raynella Dossett Leath called 911. She said she had just come home to find her husband dead in their bedroom. When the police arrived, the lead investigator examined the scene – and he felt like things didn’t add up: “I'm not saying it stinks, I'm just saying it's strange.” Diane Fanning's book is Her Deadly Web. To listen early to Part 2 of this story, sign up for Criminal Plus at patreon.com/criminal. We're marking one year on Patreon by offering 20% off of an annual membership. Just use the code "CELEBRATE" at checkout. Phoebe is going on tour this month with a brand new live show called "Don't Worry." Get tickets and see all of our tour dates at thisiscriminal.com/live. Say hello on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts. Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, invitations to virtual events, special merch deals, and more. We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery. Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop. Episode transcripts are posted on our website. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
4,569 words · 6 speakers
Topics
- Oak Ridge
- Knoxville
- East Tennessee
- Knox County
- Vox Media Podcast Network
- East Tennessee State University
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated