Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
The hosts of Criminal gather in a Massachusetts studio during a relentless rainstorm to discuss personal updates, weird news, and new directions for their subscriber-exclusive feed, now officially renamed Please Continue. Amid stories about basement floods, broken toes, and public restroom hygiene myths, the hosts unpack bizarre headlines, including an elaborate e-commerce harassment campaign by eBay executives that resulted in a massive legal settlement. They also review George Saunders' ultra-short story Sticks, share their current personal obsessions ranging from walkie-talkies to soft serve, and announce development on an upcoming live tour centered on personal storytelling.
Throughout the episode, the hosts debate the finer points of modern inconveniences, childhood memories, and what makes a good public presentation. They examine everything from the logistics of staying warm during a freezing summer morning pond swim to the specific mechanics of digital content creation and influencer culture. The conversation moves effortlessly from lighthearted banter about local seltzers and Trader Joe protein pancakes to reflections on creative experimentation.
- Medical experts report that the risk of contracting a disease from sitting on a public toilet seat is vanishingly low. 3:19
- Always remember to close the toilet lid before flushing to prevent airborne contamination. 3:55
- Covering a public toilet seat with toilet paper provides no protection because the material is porous. 3:02
- George Saunders' short story Sticks offers a vivid, compact portrait of a man who decorates yard poles for various holidays. 25:30
Chapters
- 0:02Podcast Intro and Membership Pitch
Phoebe welcomes listeners, explains the new Criminal Plus format and encourages Patreon membership.
- 1:03Rainy Studio Setting and Guest Arrival
Phoebe and Lauren describe the pouring rain, their studio setup, and Lauren’s visit.
- 2:36Public Restroom Hygiene Debate
Lauren discusses research on sitting in public toilets, hygiene tips, and risks.
- 3:30Basement Flood Disaster and Sump Pump Fix
Phoebe recounts a sudden basement flooding, the frantic cleanup, and the sump pump solution.
- 8:19Rebranding to “Please Continue”
The hosts announce renaming Criminal Plus to “Please Continue” and rehearse the new intro.
- 9:20eBay Stalking Scandal and Settlement
Lauren explains the harassment campaign against eBay bloggers and their $56 million settlement.
- 23:11Reading Club: George Saunders’ “Sticks”
They read and discuss Saunders’ short story, sharing reflections and community links.
- 45:57Episode Wrap‑Up and Listener Requests
Phoebe and Lauren thank listeners, outline future plans, and invite suggestions.
Highlights
- 3:02
Public Restroom Hygiene Realitiesinsight
The guest breaks down common misconceptions about public restrooms, noting that hovering is bad for the body and toilet paper offers no barrier against germs.
- 3:39
Bathroom Contamination Risksstrategy
The guest explains that the primary danger in public restrooms comes from touching surfaces like door handles and flush levers rather than toilet seats.
- 4:50
Basement Flooding Disasterstory
The host recounts rushing out of an interview when notified that her basement was actively flooding, ultimately discovering a broken water tank.
- 9:23
eBay Executive Harassment Campaignstory
The guest details how top eBay executives orchestrated a bizarre harassment campaign against e-commerce bloggers that ultimately led to a settlement.
- 12:24
Massive eBay Civil Settlementdata
The guest reveals that the e-commerce bloggers targeted by eBay's harassment campaign received a fifty-six million dollar settlement.
- 17:04
New Live Show Experimentinsight
The hosts discuss their new experiment of building a live show around personal stories from the host's life rather than traditional crime reporting.
- 29:10
Show Title Change Announcementstrategy
The hosts officially announce that their subscriber bonus feed is changing its name from Criminal Plus to Please Continue.
Quotes
“The toilet paper is porous. It does not help you.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:07 “I have a lot of bug bites. A lot.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:12 “The risk of contracting any kind of disease from sitting down is, quote, 'vanishingly low.'”
Unnamed speaker · 3:19 “The whole idea was, let's have a show where the host gets out of the way.”
Phoebe Judge · 18:16
Sponsored segments
- Patreon 0:29–0:39
About this episode
Today, an unlocked episode of Criminal Plus that's full of exciting updates, public service announcements, and Tom Cruise's teeth. If you enjoyed listening to today's Criminal Plus episode and you'd like to hear more - join us on Patreon. It's the very best way to support our work here at Criminal. You'll have access to these special episodes with Phoebe and Lauren, plus ad-free listening, behind-the-scenes videos with Phoebe and Criminal producers, chat rooms, live events, and more. Thank you very much. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
8,559 words · 3 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Criminal
- eBay
- Criminal Plus
- Polar
- Trader Joe's
- Massachusetts
- Sticks
- New York City
- Orange Dry
- BBC
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated