Skip to content

Donor 106

Criminal

Hosted by Phoebe Judge

47m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Eve Wiley grew up in a small Texas town believing her father Doug was her biological parent, until she discovered an email on her mother's computer at age sixteen revealing she was conceived using anonymous donor sperm. Years later, at-home DNA testing and genealogical sleuthing uncovered an even darker truth: her parents' fertility doctor, Dr. Kim McMorris, had secretly used his own sperm instead of the donor's. Finding that deceptive fertility fraud was not illegal under existing laws, Eve channeled her outrage into activism, successfully lobbying the Texas legislature to pass a bill making fertility fraud a criminal offense akin to sexual assault.

  • Commercial DNA testing can unexpectedly reveal biological connections that expose medical deception by fertility doctors. 18:46
  • Fertility fraud was historically difficult to prosecute because deception resulting in a child was often shielded by the blessings doctrine. 42:01
  • Advocacy and media outreach can successfully drive legislative change to criminalize undisclosed sperm substitution by medical professionals. 44:58

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Sponsor Ads

    The episode opens with sponsor messages and a brief host introduction.

  2. 1:15
    Eve Wiley’s Early Life and Family Dynamics

    Eve discusses her upbringing in a small Texas town and her relationship with her sister.

  3. 3:25
    Father’s Illness and Early Loss

    Eve recounts her father’s heart condition, death, and the emotional impact on the family.

  4. 6:27
    Discovery of Donor Conception

    Eve learns she was conceived with donor sperm after finding emails in her mother’s account.

  5. 7:03
    Confronting the Mother and Legal Realities

    Eve confronts her mother about the donor, learns the law doesn’t consider it illegal, and seeks legal counsel.

Highlights

  • 6:27

    Discovering the Secret Emailstory

    At age sixteen, Eve snooped through her mother's work computer and accidentally stumbled upon emails discussing artificial insemination and California Cryobank.

  • 12:28

    Uncovering the Wrong Donor Profiledata

    Eve learned her mother was given a single line of characteristics for donor 106, which completely contradicted her late father Doug's physical traits.

  • 22:31

    Identifying the Doctor as Fatherinsight

    After noticing close DNA matches on 23andMe and tracing family lineages, Eve realized her half-brother's uncle was actually her fertility doctor, Dr. Kim McMorris.

  • 27:19

    Discovering No Laws Against Itinsight

    When Eve consulted attorneys after discovering the truth, she learned that what Dr. McMorris had done was not legally classified as a crime.

  • 35:11

    The First Recorded Fertility Fraudstory

    Professor Dove Fox explains that the earliest reported case of fertility fraud took place in 1884 in Philadelphia involving Dr. William Pankost.

  • 42:01

    The Blessings Doctrine Defenseinsight

    American courts historically blocked lawsuits over deceptive reproductive practices under the principle that having a healthy baby is always a blessing rather than a legal harm.

  • 44:58

    Passing the Texas Anti-Fraud Lawstrategy

    Following persistent weekly lobbying efforts by Eve Wiley in Austin, Texas passed a law classifying doctor-perpetrated fertility fraud as a type of sexual assault.

Quotes

  • “I grew up in a really small town in East Texas.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:15
  • “I was like, Mom, I know Doug is not my father. I know I'm from a donor.”
    Unnamed speaker · 9:06
  • “The only bill, because legislators really want to understand unintentional consequences, but the only reference was from a bill California passed in the 90s.”
    Unnamed speaker · 34:25
  • BetterHelp 0:00–0:41
  • Fetch Pet Insurance 0:41–1:12
  • Shopify 23:18–24:12
  • Kachava 24:18–25:19
  • Fetch Pet Insurance 32:07–32:58
  • Quince 33:06–34:04

About this episode

One night when Eve Wiley was 16, she started reading through her mother’s emails, and discovered a secret her mother had been keeping from Eve her whole life. “I always knew there was something. I just didn't know what it was.” Tickets for our brand new live show, Don't Worry with Phoebe Judge, are on sale now! Learn more and see all of our tour dates at ⁠⁠⁠thisiscriminal.com/live⁠⁠⁠. Say hello on ⁠Facebook⁠, ⁠Instagram⁠ and ⁠TikTok⁠. Sign up for our ⁠occasional newsletter⁠. Follow the show and review us on ⁠Apple Podcasts⁠. ⁠Sign up for Criminal Plus⁠ to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, invitations to virtual events, special merch deals, and more. We also make ⁠This is Love⁠ and ⁠Phoebe Reads a Mystery⁠. Artwork by ⁠Julienne Alexander⁠. Check out ⁠our online shop⁠. Episode transcripts are posted on ⁠our website⁠. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
47:35

7,009 words · 3 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Texas
  • California Cryobank
  • Austin
  • 23andMe
  • Nacogdoches
  • United States
  • Indiana
  • Colorado
  • New York
  • Philadelphia

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated