Skip to content

UPDATE: Melissa Casias

Crime Junkie

Hosted by Ashley Flowers

15m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Ashley Flowers delivers three updates on the Melissa Casias case. The first covers escalating public pressure: a Fox News article about aerospace engineer James Tony Moffett and his son Andrew dying in a plane crash in South Carolina, both from Huntsville, Alabama—the same city where chemist Amy Eskridge called home before her 2022 death was ruled a suicide. The FBI reached out to Agent Mata for assistance amid the media attention. Private investigator Thomas McNally, licensed in Arizona but not New Mexico, has been making aggressive public Facebook posts calling for Mark Casillas to be investigated, prompting the family to worry about their safety.

The second update covers Rick Valerio, the man found crying on his horse near a church. Mata confirmed Valerio admitted to being intoxicated every time he rides, but no connection to Melissa has been established. The blue truck Valerio owned was only visually inspected, showing old rusty damage, and no license plate readers exist on the relevant stretch of Highway 518.

The third update is the most complex: a woman named Wendy who drove 300 miles from Colorado to give Sierra $50 in graduation money on August 8, but now denies knowing the family. Flowers and her team traced the phone number Wendy gave Sierra to a John S. Smith connected to Caterpillar Inc., which holds Department of Defense contracts totaling over $180 million in 2025. Sierra confirmed the couple who accompanied Wendy was a different John A. Smith, not the one tied to the number. A 2011 Los Alamos National Laboratory presentation lists Caterpillar as a contributor, raising questions about whether Mark's theory that Melissa received help from a lab subcontractor has merit.

  • P.I. Thomas McNally is licensed in Arizona but not New Mexico, where Melissa went missing, and his aggressive public posts have made the Casillas family worry about their safety. 5:26
  • Rick Valerio admitted to Mata that he is intoxicated every time he's on a horse, but no connection to Melissa has been established. 6:36
  • The phone number Wendy gave Sierra is connected to a John S. Smith who works for Caterpillar Inc., which holds DoD contracts worth over $180 million in 2025. 13:49
  • Sierra confirmed the couple who came with Wendy was John A. Smith, a different person from John S. Smith who is actually connected to the phone number. 13:02
  • A 2011 Los Alamos National Laboratory presentation lists Caterpillar Inc. as a contributor, potentially supporting Mark's theory about a lab subcontractor connection. 15:47

Highlights

  • 3:38

    Moffett Crash Links to Huntsvilledata

    Fox News reported that aerospace engineer James Tony Moffett and his son Andrew died in a plane crash in South Carolina. Both were from Huntsville, Alabama, the same city Amy Eskridge called home before her 2022 death was ruled a suicide.

  • 5:26

    Unlicensed P.I. Aggressive Tacticsinsight

    Thomas McNally is licensed in Arizona but not New Mexico, where Melissa went missing. He has been making strongly worded public Facebook posts calling for Mark to be investigated as a person of interest, and the Casillas family says they are now worried for their safety.

  • 6:36

    Valerio Admits Horseback Intoxicationdata

    Mata confirmed that in a follow-up interview, Valerio admitted he is intoxicated every time he's on a horse. No connection between Valerio and Melissa has been established, and the blue truck was only visually inspected showing old rusty damage.

  • 8:44

    Wendy Visit Date Confirmed August 8strategy

    Sierra checked her phone notes and confirmed the encounter with Wendy happened on exactly August 8, not September or July as previously thought. Three people came: Wendy, her husband or fiancé, and another man and woman.

  • 9:54

    Wrong Wendy, One Letter Offinsight

    The team had been calling the wrong Wendy because Mark had the last name wrong by one letter. Mata confirmed he called the correct number Sierra received from the woman, so he spoke to the right Wendy who denied knowing the family.

  • 13:02

    Two Different John Smithsinsight

    The phone number is connected to John S. Smith, but Sierra confirmed 99% sure the couple who came with Wendy was John A. Smith—a completely different person. This discrepancy remains unexplained.

  • 14:37

    Caterpillar's DoD Contract Valuedata

    Caterpillar Inc. received an $83.4 million contract on April 29, 2025, and a contract that has paid out $97.1 million as of the episode date, both for earth-moving and excavating equipment from the Department of Defense.

  • 15:47

    Los Alamos and Caterpillar Linkinsight

    Flowers found a 2011 presentation from Los Alamos National Laboratory for its work with the National Nuclear Security Administration, with Caterpillar Inc. listed as a contributor. This predates Melissa's disappearance but may support Mark's subcontractor theory.

About this episode

The Melissa Casias case keeps unraveling, and the more we learn, the less anything makes sense. New details have emerged about the strange woman who showed up at Sierra's job to deliver $50 in graduation money, and the trail leads to a confusing tangle of mismatched names. Meanwhile, the family fracture has only widened, with a private investigator turning up the heat and the FBI now stepping in. Was Mark's theory about a subcontractor closer to the truth than anyone realized? Or is this just another dead end in a case that refuses to stay still?

Transcript

0:00
15:00

2,766 words · 3 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Missing Persons
  • Private Investigation
  • FBI Involvement
  • Caterpillar Inc.
  • Department of Defense
  • Los Alamos National Laboratory
  • Public Pressure
  • Cold Case

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated