Skip to content

SERIAL KILLER: David Meirhofer

Crime Junkie

Hosted by Ashley Flowers

50m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In June 1973, seven-year-old Suzie Jaeger was taken from her tent at Headwater State Park in Montana, her stuffed animals left beside a hole cut through the fabric. Ransom calls demanded $50,000 with a pickup at the Denver bus depot that never materialized. The case went cold until February 1974, when deputies searching for missing 19-year-old Sandy Dykman found her car and over a thousand bone fragments at an abandoned ranch—some belonging to a girl aged five to eight.

FBI agents attending a training session on the then-nascent technique of criminal profiling built a profile matching local carpenter and former Marine David Meirhofer: white, in his twenties, a loner with military experience who would insert himself into investigations. Despite passing two polygraphs, one with truth serum, Meirhofer was cornered when a rancher noticed a suspicious hour-long call on his phone bill and tire tracks matching his truck. A search revealed a to-do list of camp locations, a child's blouse, bloodstained sheets, and Disneyland tickets. The final blow: Sandy Dykman's severed hand in his freezer.

Meirhofer confessed on September 29, 1974, to killing Suzie, Sandy, Boy Scout Michael Rainey in 1968, and Bernie Pullman in 1967, then was found dead in his cell hours later. The hosts discuss what remains unresolved: the child's voice on the final call, possible additional victims, and why he never taunted other families.

  • This was one of the very first cases where the FBI applied criminal profiling to catch a serial killer, and the profile's predictions about future calls proved accurate. 2:55
  • The FBI profilers predicted the killer would call again on a significant date, and he did call on the exact one-year anniversary of Suzie's kidnapping. 33:01
  • David Meirhofer passed two polygraphs, including one administered with truth serum, which the FBI profilers explained was possible for a true psychopath. 40:13
  • Sandy Dykman's severed hand, wrapped in butcher paper labeled S M D S, was found in Meirhofer's freezer during a second search of his property. 50:05
  • David Meirhofer committed suicide in his jail cell just hours after confessing to four murders, leaving questions about additional victims unanswered. 56:05

Highlights

  • 3:43

    Suzie Vanishes From Her Tentstory

    Heidi Jaeger wakes to find a hole sliced through the back of the family tent and her seven-year-old sister Suzie gone, with only stuffed animals in the grass as evidence.

  • 10:29

    Ransom Call With Telling Detailinsight

    The kidnapper calls Deputy Ron Brown's wife at 11:16 PM, raises the ransom to $50,000, and proves he has Suzie by describing her slightly humped index fingernails—a detail the family had forgotten to report.

  • 26:08

    Bones Reveal a Second Victimdata

    Over a thousand bone fragments are collected from a burn pile at the abandoned ranch. Pathologists confirm some belong to Sandy Dykman, but others belong to a girl between five and eight years old.

  • 31:44

    FBI Builds First Killer Profilestrategy

    Agents at a Quantico training session on criminal profiling create a profile: white, twenties, loner, unmarried, modestly intelligent, military experience, physically fit, likely killed before, keeps souvenirs, inserts himself into investigations.

  • 34:27

    Marietta Negotiates for an Hourstory

    On the one-year anniversary, the kidnapper calls Marietta and she keeps him talking for a full hour, calling his bluff, demanding proof Suzie is alive, and learning he lurked at the campsite that night before taking her.

  • 39:07

    Tire Tracks Point to Meirhoferinsight

    A rancher disputes a suspicious hour-long call on his phone bill; the employee recognizes the Jaeger name. The rancher recalls tire tracks from his former ranch hand David Meirhofer's truck, and the phone line could be tapped with telecom skills from military service.

  • 41:08

    The To-Do List and Souvenirsdata

    Agents find a receipt matching the first ransom call, bloodstained sheets, a child's blouse, a necklace, lip stick, Disneyland tickets, and a stationery sheet titled 'Things to Do Today' listing camp access points with Camp Silver Cloud checked off.

  • 50:05

    Sandy's Hand in the Freezerstory

    During a second search, investigators find a package in butcher paper labeled S M D S containing Sandy Dykman's severed hand with nail polish, ending any possibility of Meirhofer talking his way out.

About this episode

In the summer of 1973, the Jaeger family wakes at a Montana campground to every parent's nightmare: their young daughter, Susie, is gone. Searches turn up nothing, until a man begins tormenting the family with chilling calls and letters. He has Susie, and he has no intention of giving her back. As investigators race to find her, more victims begin to surface. The case finally breaks when a determined mother joins forces with the FBI’s newly formed behavioral profiling unit. Together, they uncover the truth about what happened to Susie and bring long-awaited answers to three other grieving families.

Transcript

0:00
50:36

10,445 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Serial Killer
  • Criminal Profiling
  • FBI Investigation
  • Cold Case
  • Montana
  • Kidnapping
  • True Crime

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated