Skip to content

MURDERED: Stephanie Casberg

Crime Junkie

Hosted by Ashley Flowers

50m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In the summer of 1969, 17-year-old Stephanie Casberg left her waitressing shift at Mark's Big Boy in Milwaukee at 12:30 a.m. and was never seen alive again. Her dismembered remains were found along Root River in Racine County, wrapped in newspaper and scattered across multiple sites spanning nearly 25 miles. The pathologist noted precise, scalpel-like cuts at each joint, suggesting a killer with skill, patience, and time. Over five decades, the case cycled through suspects: cook Michael Bartelt, who claimed he saw Stephanie leave through the back door but whose time card showed he wasn't even working that night; Wilbert Mackey, who lived near the bridge and allegedly terrorized his children by claiming he was the killer; and a new lead that emerged from a Crime Junkie episode about Kristin David, a 1981 murder in Idaho with a nearly identical MO. DNA from pubic hairs produced two partial male profiles, and Michael Bartelt was ruled out after his death in 2024. Lieutenant Brian Van Sock continues to pursue the case, with a new suspect still under investigation.

  • The pathologist found precise, scalpel-like cuts at each joint and two puncture wounds beneath the chin, indicating the killer had anatomical knowledge and worked methodically after death. 6:45
  • Michael Bartelt's time card revealed he was not even working the night Stephanie disappeared, meaning he lied his way into being one of the last people to see her alive. 49:35
  • Two pubic hairs from a towel in the second disposal site produced two different partial male DNA profiles, neither of which matched any suspect tested so far. 38:51
  • A new suspect entered the case file after Lieutenant Van Sock heard a Crime Junkie episode about Kristin David, a 1981 Idaho murder with the same dismemberment pattern and missing leg. 53:27
  • The distance between Mark's Big Boy and the farthest disposal site spans nearly 25 miles, suggesting the killer knew the area well and moved with purpose. 27:22

Highlights

  • 4:18

    Boy Finds Dismembered Remainsstory

    A 10-year-old boy exploring the riverbank near a condemned bridge on Eight Mile Road discovers a foot, then the scattered remains of a teenage girl wrapped in newspaper and brown paper bags.

  • 6:45

    Pathologist Identifies Skilled Killerinsight

    The pathologist finds two puncture wounds beneath the chin, a large cut across the back of the neck, and precise scalpel-like cuts at each joint, concluding the dismemberment was deliberate and methodical.

  • 15:27

    Witness Describes Man at Bridgedata

    A man near another bridge on Root River spots a white man in his late 40s, about five foot eleven, with reddish hair and a bandage on his hand, putting or pulling something in the river hours before the body was found.

  • 25:29

    Second Disposal Site Foundstory

    A couple on a farm four and a half miles from the bridge finds bones their dog dragged home. Detectives locate a half-buried cardboard box containing a rib cage, spine, and a dirty towel with pubic hairs.

  • 32:31

    Sister Tips Police on Brotherstory

    In 1988, Pam calls detectives to say she believes her brother Michael Bartelt killed Stephanie, revealing he never went to Hawaii, that their mother lied to police, and that Michael sexually abused family members.

  • 40:30

    Wilbert Mackey Terrorized His Childrenstory

    Wilbert Mackey lived less than 10 minutes from the bridge and allegedly told his children he was the Root River Killer, making them read case files and correcting what the stories got wrong. His DNA did not match the hair evidence.

  • 49:24

    Time Card Exposes the Lieinsight

    Lieutenant Van Sock discovers that Michael Bartelt's time card shows he was not working the night Stephanie left the restaurant, contradicting his 1969 claim that he saw her leave through the back door.

  • 53:27

    Crime Junkie Episode Cracks New Leadstrategy

    Lieutenant Van Sock hears the Kristin David episode while mowing his lawn, drops his mower, and contacts the show to compare notes. The man in that case has major ties to the Midwest and possibly Wisconsin.

About this episode

In the summer of 1969, Stephanie Casberg walked out the front door of a Milwaukee restaurant after her waitressing shift — and was never seen alive again. Days later, her dismembered remains were found near a condemned bridge along the Root River, leaving investigators with a chilling conclusion: the work of someone methodical, skilled and patient.

Transcript

0:00
50:43

10,093 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Cold Case
  • Dismemberment
  • Wisconsin
  • 1969 Murder
  • DNA Evidence
  • Unsolved Homicide
  • Crime Investigation
  • Serial Killer

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated