Skip to content

MURDERED: Melanie Howell

Crime Junkie

Hosted by Ashley Flowers

23m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In 1976, 22-year-old Melanie Howell was found stabbed 47 times in her Los Angeles apartment, her wrists bound, a single bloody fingerprint on the doorknob the only physical evidence. The case went cold for nearly four decades until in 2014, cold case detective Martin Moharow reran the fingerprint with newer technology and got a match: Paul Bustamante. The twist that made the story unusual is that the case was officially closed but the killer's name was never shared—not with the family, not with the detective who had worked the case originally, not even in the case file.

Ashley Flowers and her co-host trace Bustamante's life through census records, military files, and marriage records, revealing he was an Army veteran who served in Germany from 1966 to 1968 and married a UC Davis sociology PhD student in 1972. More shockingly, they discover he had also killed 27-year-old Elizabeth Wolfe in Davis, California, in 1977—stabbed 14 times, no sexual assault, fingerprints on both sides of her door. Elizabeth's case had been wrongly attributed to serial killer Henry Lee Lucas in 1983 before being ruled out in 1990. Bustamante died in 2006, his body unclaimed for three years before cremation, meaning no DNA sample was ever collected. Detective Moharow believes he is a serial killer with more victims still unidentified.

  • A single bloody fingerprint on a doorknob, rerun in 2014 with post-2010 technology, solved a 1976 murder that had gone cold for nearly 40 years. 14:55
  • Paul Bustamante had also killed Elizabeth Wolfe in Davis, California in 1977, stabbing her 14 times with no sexual assault, a pattern nearly identical to Melanie's murder. 15:54
  • Elizabeth Wolfe's murder was attributed to Henry Lee Lucas based on his 1983 confession, but a Davis detective quietly ruled him out in 1990 without finding a replacement suspect. 18:27
  • Bustamante's unclaimed body was cremated after three years in 2006, destroying the only potential DNA source that could have linked him to additional cold cases. 20:46
  • Detective Moharow believes Bustamante is a serial killer and that the only reason he hasn't been connected to other cases is the absence of a DNA sample. 21:16

Highlights

  • 2:31

    A Solved Case With No Nameinsight

    The episode opens with the paradox of a cold case that was officially solved but whose killer's identity was never shared—not with the family, not with the original detective, not even in the case file.

  • 6:00

    The Neighbor's Account of the Attackstory

    A neighbor heard Melanie talking calmly with a man at her door, then minutes later heard a struggle, screams, and glass breaking. She saw a man leaving with a black attache case.

  • 14:55

    The 2014 Fingerprint Breakthroughdata

    Cold case detective Martin Moharow reran the single bloody fingerprint from the doorknob using post-2010 technology and got a match to Paul Bustamante, closing the case nearly 40 years after the murder.

  • 15:54

    The Second Victim: Elizabeth Wolfeinsight

    Melanie's sister revealed that Bustamante had also killed 27-year-old Elizabeth Wolfe, a teacher at a school for deaf children in Davis, California, more than a year after Melanie's murder.

  • 18:27

    The Henry Lee Lucas Misattributioninsight

    For years, Elizabeth Wolfe's murder was attributed to serial killer Henry Lee Lucas based on his 1983 confession. A Davis detective quietly ruled him out in 1990, but no replacement suspect was found until 2011.

  • 20:46

    The Cremated Body and Lost DNAdata

    Bustamante died in 2006, and after three years his unclaimed body was cremated. By the time investigators realized they needed a DNA sample to compare against cold cases, it was too late.

  • 26:26

    The Military Background and the Stalkerstory

    Records show Bustamante served in the Army in Germany from 1966 to 1968 as a rifleman and radio operator. Melanie's boyfriend noted this would explain how the stalker outran him.

  • 27:13

    The Wife's Research on Female Criminalityinsight

    Bustamante's wife, a UC Davis sociology PhD student, taught classes to inmates at a women's prison and authored a paper called 'The Nature of Female Criminality.' She did not respond to interview requests.

About this episode

In 1976, a 22-year-old nursing student was murdered in her Los Angeles apartment, leaving behind just one clue: a bloody fingerprint. Decades later, that print was matched—and the case was quietly marked solved. But no one ever publicly announced who did it. So we set out to find the answer… and to uncover what else he may have done.

Transcript

0:00
23:21

5,499 words · 3 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Cold Case
  • Serial Killer
  • Fingerprint Forensics
  • Unsolved Murders
  • LAPD
  • Henry Lee Lucas
  • True Crime Investigation
  • Victimology

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated