Skip to content

MURDERED: Carmen Van Huss

Crime Junkie

Hosted by Ashley Flowers

49m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Carmen Van Huss, 19, was stabbed 60 times in her Indianapolis apartment on March 23, 1993. Neighbors heard her screaming for 30 minutes but no one called 911. Her father found her body the next morning. The case went cold after investigators cleared her boyfriend, exes, and friends, all of whom had alibis.

In 2013, Sergeant Bill Carter, a nuisance abatement officer with no homicide training, began working the case in his spare time. After a botched DNA test in 2015 misidentified the killer as a European female, Carter was removed from the case and suspended for crowdfunding the retest himself. Reinstated after a family petition, he continued collecting samples and eventually, through genetic genealogy work with Parabon Nano Labs and a 23andMe match, the investigation narrowed to Dana Shepherd, who lived in the same apartment complex. Shepherd was arrested in August 2024 and, in January 2026, pled guilty to murder, receiving a 45-year sentence.

Carmen's sister Pam Francis championed Carmen's Law, signed into Indiana law in March 2026, which creates a formal process for families to request advanced DNA testing in cold cases unsolved for five or more years.

  • Neighbors in a gated apartment complex heard a 19-year-old woman screaming for 30 minutes and no one called 911, illustrating how bystander inaction can have fatal consequences. 3:49
  • A nuisance abatement officer with zero homicide training solved a 31-year-old cold case through persistence and willingness to work outside his official role. 24:53
  • A $1,600 DNA test sent to the lab by the city returned a profile identifying the killer as a European female because the wrong sample was submitted, derailing the investigation for years. 34:33
  • Genetic genealogy via Parabon Nano Labs and a 23andMe upload by a distant relative was the breakthrough that identified the killer after decades of dead ends. 44:25
  • Carmen's Law, signed into Indiana law in March 2026, establishes a framework for private funding of advanced DNA testing in cold cases unsolved for five or more years. 56:27

Highlights

  • 3:49

    Neighbors Ignore 30 Minutes of Screamingstory

    A neighbor across the hall heard Carmen screaming and said, 'I just heard a scream in the middle of the night. I turned over and went back to bed.' No one called 911 for 30 minutes.

  • 24:53

    Unlikely Hero: Nuisance Abatement Officerinsight

    Bill Carter started as a state revenue agent, moved to domestic violence and nuisance abatement, and stumbled into cold cases by helping a detective monitor a Facebook memorial page. He had no homicide training at all.

  • 34:33

    Wrong DNA Sample Derails Investigationdata

    The city sent the wrong sample to the lab in 2015, and the results came back identifying the killer as a European female. Carter was then refused funding for a retest and removed from the case.

  • 36:14

    GoFundMe for DNA Test Backfiresstory

    Carter raised over $1,200 in seven hours via GoFundMe to pay for the retest. IMPD made him return all the money and suspended him for 10 days, his first discipline in his entire career.

  • 44:25

    Genealogy Match After Decade of Workdata

    On June 2, 2023, Parabon identified a great-niece-once-removed of the suspect who had uploaded her DNA to 23andMe. This was the 'magic hit' after nearly a decade of work.

  • 46:53

    Dana Shepherd's DNA Confirmeddata

    Four months after the warrant was served on Dana Shepherd at the University of Missouri campus, his DNA matched the evidence from Carmen's 1993 murder scene. He was arrested August 30, 2024.

  • 54:10

    Plea Deal Before Trial Beginsdata

    Less than a week before jury selection was set to begin in January 2026, Dana Shepherd pled guilty to one count of murder and was sentenced to 45 years. The rape charge was dropped.

  • 56:27

    Carmen's Law Signed Into Lawstrategy

    Pam Francis's bill passed unanimously by the Indiana State Senate and was signed by the governor in March 2026, creating an established framework for private funding of advanced DNA testing in cases unsolved for five or more years.

About this episode

On March 23, 1993, screams tore through the thin walls of a gated Indianapolis apartment complex as 19-year-old Carmen Van Huss fought for her life. Neighbors heard the attack, but no one called 911. Carmen was assaulted, mutilated, and killed. For decades, her murder remained unsolved – until a relentless investigator identified a suspect. And after more than 30 years, Carmen’s family finally saw justice.

Transcript

0:00
49:15

10,311 words · 5 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Cold Case Murder
  • DNA Genealogy
  • Bystander Effect
  • Criminal Justice Reform
  • Indiana Crime
  • Unsolved Homicide
  • Forensic Science
  • Advocacy

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated