Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode introduces the season three premiere of the investigative true crime podcast Bear Brook, titled A Private Matter, reported by Jason Moon. The story centers on a small town in New Hampshire called Epsom, population 5,000, and a well-known local couple: Patricia and John Hickey, known as Patty and Jay. Jay owned a historic Christmas tree farm and held various town government posts, while Patty served as the town's elected welfare officer for over thirty years. In his mid-70s, Jay developed dementia and began wandering off, prompting neighborhood concerns about whether Patty could handle caretaking duties alongside her demanding job.
The mystery unfolds when police announce in March 2024 that 76-year-old Jay has disappeared, and investigators discover he was last seen months earlier in October 2023. Patty never reported him missing, explaining during a police interrogation that she assumed he had gone to stay with his brothers out of state, despite leaving behind his phone, credit card, and care requirements. The host presents interviews with local residents, former employees, and recordings of Patty's calm, sometimes evasive police interview, exploring how a man could vanish from a small community for five months without anyone sounding the alarm.
- Ensure caregivers of dementia patients have adequate support networks, as wandering behaviors can escalate quickly and pose serious safety risks. 5:06
- Pay close attention to unusual timelines and unexplained absences in vulnerable populations, especially when official reports are significantly delayed. 5:26
- Recognize that extreme calm or seemingly normal behavior during a crisis can sometimes mask a deeply bizarre or concerning underlying reality. 6:56
Chapters
- 0:01Anthropic AI Message
A brief promotional segment from Anthropic about their Claude AI for businesses.
- 1:00Venmo Credit Card Promo
Venmo advertises its new credit card with cash‑back rewards.
- 2:06Bear Brook Overview
Hosts explain the premise of Bear Brook and the mystery of a missing Christmas tree farmer.
- 2:41Epsom Town & Tree Farm Setting
Narration describes the small town of Epsom and its iconic Christmas tree farm.
- 4:35Patty & Jay Hickey Background
Details about Patty and Jay’s long‑time civic roles and family life at the farm.
- 6:56Jay’s Dementia and Disappearance
Jay’s cognitive decline, caretaker role, and eventual disappearance are recounted.
- 10:03Community Reaction & Timeline Questions
Town members question the delayed police response and Patty’s behavior during the search.
- 17:47Investigation Deepens
Hosts discuss tips, recordings, and the growing suspicion that something more sinister may be involved.
- 19:05Police Interview with Patty
A recorded interrogation reveals Patty’s explanations and the mystery surrounding Jay’s last sighting.
- 29:14Conclusion & Call to Action
Hosts wrap up the episode, encourage listeners to follow Bear Brook, and provide final remarks.
Highlights
- 2:41
A Hallmark Settingstory
The episode opens by describing the idyllic setting of Epsom, New Hampshire, and the local Christmas tree farm owned by Patty and Jay Hickey.
- 4:59
Community Involvementinsight
Locals describe how Jay and Patty were deeply embedded in town life, holding government positions and running the family Christmas tree farm.
- 8:29
Dementia Wanderinginsight
The narrative explores the realities of dementia, noting how Jay began wandering off without shoes or proper clothing in the dead of winter.
- 10:31
A Strange Appearancestory
Despite her husband being missing, Patty attended the annual Meet the Candidates forum to campaign for reelection without mentioning Jay.
- 19:19
Police Interrogationstory
Audio from Patty's police interview reveals her surprisingly relaxed demeanor, including cracking a joke about being poisoned with almonds.
- 21:18
The Missing Timelinedebate
Patty tells investigators that she last saw Jay in October 2023, explaining she assumed he had gone to live with his brothers out of state.
Quotes
“The news report says the last time Jay was seen was in October 2023.”
Unnamed speaker · 10:07 “Most people with dementia will wander at least once. Many will do so repeatedly.”
Unnamed speaker · 8:29 “The farm was Jay's baby. He'd owned it since the early 1970s.”
Unnamed speaker · 5:44 “You set it up once, and they keep working in the background.”
Unnamed speaker · 14:07
Sponsored segments
- Anthropic 0:01–0:28
- Toyota 0:30–1:17
- Venmo Credit Card 1:02–1:23
- Quince 14:59–15:37
- Shopify 16:07–16:48
- Toyota 16:48–17:47
- Anthropic 30:01–30:48
- Lululemon 30:34–30:58
About this episode
Today, we're sharing the season three premiere of Bear Brook, the critically acclaimed true crime podcast from New Hampshire Public Radio's Pulitzer Prize-nominated Document team. Bear Brook returns with A Private Matter, hosted by award-winning journalist Jason Moon. This season, Jason investigates the disappearance of Jay Hickey, a beloved Christmas tree farmer with dementia who vanishes from his small New Hampshire town. His wife Patty never reports him missing. And it turns out, that's not necessarily a crime in New Hampshire. What follows is a story about family estrangement, the growing dementia crisis, and the legal gaps that leave vulnerable people behind. Listen to more of the new season, follow Bear Brook here: https://play.megaphone.fm/3gfaxmufro-bjytd5eobrg Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
4,644 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- NHPR
- Venmo Visa Credit Card
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated