Casefile Extra: Tina Herrmann, Kody Maynard & Stephanie Sprang
- 1h 8m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
On November 10, 2010, Tina Herman, 32, failed to show up for her shift at a Dairy Queen in Mount Vernon, Ohio. Her manager Valerie Haythorne drove to her home in the Apple Valley community and, after a welfare check found nothing, returned the next day to discover the living room carpet covered in blood. Four people were missing: Tina, her 13-year-old daughter Sarah, her 11-year-old son Cody, and Tina's best friend Stephanie Sprang, 41, who had driven over that afternoon. The perpetrator was Matthew Hoffman, a 30-year-old who lived half a mile away and had a prior conviction for arson in Colorado.
The case was cracked through a Walmart receipt showing tarpaulins and garbage bags purchased at 12:09 a.m. on November 11, roughly 12 hours after the attack. Security footage identified a man in a camouflage shirt driving a silver Toyota Yaris with a dent on the rear passenger side. A critical detail emerged from a police interaction: when Deputy Phillips asked Hoffman about his girlfriend, Hoffman said her first name was Sarah. Investigators raided Hoffman's house with a no-knock entry and found Sarah duct-taped and bungee-corded in a basement hidden behind a cabinet, surrounded by piles of dead leaves.
The episode is worth listening for the specifics of Sarah's four-day captivity, Hoffman's bizarre leaf-filled home, and the theory raised by crime journalist Robert Scott that Sarah may have been Hoffman's intended target from the start. Hoffman was sentenced to life without parole in January 2011, less than two months after the crimes.
- The Walmart receipt timing—purchased 12 hours after the attack—proved the perpetrator returned to the scene to cover up evidence. 17:00
- A single detail in a police interaction—Hoffman naming his girlfriend 'Sarah'—became the critical link connecting him to the case. 28:53
- Hoffman's prior arson in Colorado, where he used ten gallons of gasoline to destroy evidence, foreshadowed his plan to burn the King Beach Drive house. 24:39
- The victims' remains were hidden in a hollow beech tree 30 to 40 feet off the ground, wrapped in garbage bags. 54:20
- Sarah was held for approximately four days in Hoffman's basement, where he sexually assaulted her on November 13. 40:56
Highlights
- 8:54
Valerie Discovers the Bloodstory
Valerie Haythorne climbs through a window into Tina's house and finds the living room carpet covered in blood, with drag marks leading to the bathroom.
- 17:00
The Walmart Receipt Clueinsight
A bag of tarpaulins and garbage bags purchased at 12:09 a.m. on November 11 proved the perpetrator returned to the scene roughly 12 hours after the attack.
- 28:53
The Name Sarahinsight
Deputy Phillips' notes revealed Hoffman said his girlfriend's first name was Sarah, the same name as Tina's 13-year-old daughter, making his location urgent.
- 33:45
Sarah Found in the Basementstory
An investigator descended hidden basement stairs and found 13-year-old Sarah duct-taped, bungee-corded, and lying on a pile of dead leaves under blankets.
- 54:20
Bodies in the Hollow Beech Treedata
Hoffman led investigators to a hollow beech tree where the dismembered remains of Tina, Cody, and Stephanie were found in garbage bags 30 to 40 feet up.
- 55:54
Hoffman's Confession of Motivestrategy
Hoffman claimed he broke in to steal, got trapped when Tina returned, panicked when Stephanie walked in, and killed all three victims in a daze.
- 1:05:02
Sarah as Intended Target Theorydebate
Crime journalist Robert Scott and Sarah's father suggested Hoffman may have targeted Sarah from the start, explaining why he lingered in the house after finding little to steal.
- 1:07:58
Sarah's Statement at Sentencingstory
Sarah read a statement recalling Cody as a left-handed pitcher who wanted to be a helicopter pilot, and her mother who loved dolphins and sunflowers.
About this episode
*** Content warnings: Sexual assault, child sexual assault, arson, animal cruelty *** When 32-year-old Tina Herrmann didn’t show up for work on Wednesday, November 10 2010, her manager immediately alerted the authorities. Soon they found that not only had Tina vanished, but so had her two children - 13-year-old Sarah Maynard and 11-year-old Kody Maynard - and her best friend, 41-year-old Stephanie Sprang. To make matters worse, there were bloodstains discovered throughout Tina’s home. Soon, clues would lead detectives to a disconcerting scene - a rundown house filled from top to bottom with leaves… Casefile Extra features bonus episodes exploring compelling cases, stories and topics beyond our regular weekly releases. --- Narration – Anonymous Host https://www.instagram.com/caseys.snaps/ Research & writing – Erin Munro Production & music – Mike Migas http://mikemigas.com/ Audio editing – Anthony Telfer Sign up for Casefile Premium: Apple Premium https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/casefile-true-crime/id998568017?ign-itscg=30200S&ign-itsct=casefile_podcastsSpotify Premium https://spotifyanchor-web.app.link/e/9gSwcv7USsbPatreon https://www.patreon.com/casefileFor all credits and sources, please visit https://casefilepodcast.com/casefile-archives-3-tina-herrmann-kody-maynard-stephanie-sprang Tina Herrmann, Kody Maynard & Stephanie Sprang case was originally released as a premium episode in September 2025. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript
10,096 words · 3 speakers
Topics
- True Crime
- Homicide Investigation
- Child Abduction
- Forensic Evidence
- Criminal Psychology
- Ohio
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated