Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode of American Scandal, hosted by Lindsay Graham, dramatizes the story of two NYPD officers, Louis Eppolito and Stephen Caracappa, who became hitmen and information brokers for the New York mafia in the 1980s. The narrative opens in 1959 with Burton Kaplan, a gambler who owes money to an ex-cop, driving a dead body through frozen Connecticut countryside. Kaplan later becomes the intermediary connecting the corrupt cops to the mob after meeting Eppolito's cousin Frank Santora in federal prison. The episode traces how Caracappa, despite a criminal record and a drug addiction, rose through the NYPD to the Major Case Squad, where he could access confidential homicide intelligence. The FBI's 1984 raid on Gambino crime family member Rosario Gambino's home uncovered 36 photocopied NYPD documents in his bedroom, with Eppolito's fingerprints on them. Yet Eppolito was cleared at his disciplinary hearing because the department's lawyers declined to present evidence. The episode culminates in Kaplan's decision to have Israel Greenwald killed after Greenwald agreed to cooperate with the FBI, and the subsequent murder and burial of Greenwald in a Brooklyn garage.
- The NYPD's culture of protecting its own meant complaints against Eppolito and Caracappa for theft and drug dealing were consistently dismissed as their word against civilians. 10:41
- Access to confidential police intelligence on active investigations was the most valuable commodity corrupt cops could sell to the mob, far exceeding the value of stolen drugs. 11:25
- The FBI's discovery of 36 photocopied NYPD documents in Rosario Gambino's bedroom provided the physical evidence that a police officer was leaking information to the mob. 17:03
- Eppolito was cleared at his disciplinary hearing because the department's lawyers declined to call witnesses or cross-examine him, leaving the Deputy Commissioner with no choice but to acquit. 22:11
- Kaplan negotiated the price of Greenwald's murder from $30,000 down to $25,000 over a payphone call, agreeing to pay in three installments. 27:26
Highlights
- 0:20
A Body in the Trunkstory
Burton Kaplan drives a dead body through rural Connecticut in 1959, coerced by an ex-cop he owes gambling debts to. The frozen ground prevents burial, so they plan to dump the body in Long Island Sound.
- 7:37
Caracappa's Background Checkstory
NYPD investigator Arthur Hearns interviews 26-year-old Stephen Caracappa at the police academy. Caracappa was arrested at 17 for a professional-looking warehouse burglary, and Hearns recommends dismissal, but the recommendation is overruled by a supervisor.
- 17:03
NYPD Files in a Mafia Boss's Bedroomdata
FBI agents raiding Rosario Gambino's home in Cherry Hill, New Jersey discover 36 photocopied NYPD documents including surveillance reports and suspect lists in his bedroom, proving someone inside the department was leaking intelligence to the mob.
- 22:11
Eppolito Cleared Despite Fingerprint Evidencedebate
At Eppolito's disciplinary hearing, the department's lawyers decline to call witnesses or cross-examine him. The Deputy Commissioner is forced to clear Eppolito based on the single fact of his fingerprints on the leaked files, which he argues does not prove he leaked them.
- 27:26
Negotiating a Murder by Phonestory
From a payphone, Burton Kaplan calls Frank Santora to arrange the killing of Israel Greenwald. He negotiates the price down from $30,000 to $25,000 in installments and provides Greenwald's address, car description, and workplace.
- 32:18
Greenwald Lured to the Garagestory
Israel Greenwald is pulled over on the New York State Thruway under the pretense of a hit-and-run identification lineup. He is driven to a row of garages in Brooklyn where Eppolito rents a shed, and pushed inside by Santora and another man.
- 35:07
Franzone Forced to Bury the Bodystory
Pete Franzone, who owns the garage lot, is forced by Santora to look inside the shed where Greenwald lies dead from bullet wounds. Santora threatens him with accessory-to-murder charges, and together they dig through the concrete floor to bury the body.
About this episode
In 1969, police cadet Stephen Caracappa meets fellow recruit Louis Eppolito. The two officers soon rack up allegations of misconduct—but nothing is proven, and before long, their dealings with the Mafia lead to murder. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
7,005 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Mafia Corruption
- NYPD Internal Affairs
- Organized Crime
- Police Misconduct
- FBI Investigation
- Hitmen
- New York Crime Families
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated