Skip to content

ENCORE: Challenger Disaster | Acceptable Risk | 2

American Scandal

Hosted by Lindsay Graham

36m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode of American Scandal dramatizes the months leading up to the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster, focusing on the O-ring problem at Morton Thiokol and the Teacher in Space Program. In November 1982, NASA project manager Larry Malloy visits Thiokol's Utah headquarters and is told by the booster manager that O-ring burn damage is merely an anomaly with a 1-in-10,000 chance of catastrophic failure. Malloy accepts this reassurance and does not escalate the issue to his superiors.

By 1985, engineer Roger Boisjoly presents NASA with soot-covered O-rings from the Discovery launch, arguing that cold temperatures caused the damage. Lab tests confirm the rubber hardens below 75 degrees and never fully expands below 50. Meanwhile, Bob Ebling writes a memo beginning with HELP in all caps, warning that corporate bureaucracy is blocking O-ring fixes, and later storms through Thiokol's hallways demanding production be shut down.

The episode closes on January 26, 1986, when quality inspector Johnny Corlou encounters a stripped bolt on the shuttle's hatch door, the launch is scrubbed for high winds, and commander Dick Scobie notes a cold front will push temperatures into the low twenties.

  • Boisjoly's lab tests showed O-rings harden below 75°F and never fully expand below 50°F, proving cold weather was the failure mechanism. 19:53
  • The Thiokol manager told NASA's Malloy the odds of two O-rings failing on the same joint were 'maybe 1 in 10,000,' which Malloy accepted without escalation. 3:05
  • Ebling's memo to Thiokol's senior managers began with the word HELP in all capital letters, detailing how bureaucracy was blocking O-ring fixes. 26:11
  • Krista McAuliffe was selected from a pool of more than 11,000 applicants for the Teacher in Space Program, announced by Vice President George Bush at the White House. 21:01
  • On the morning of the cancelled Challenger launch, the temperature had already dropped to 40 degrees, and Scobie warned it would fall into the low twenties. 36:27

Highlights

  • 3:05

    O-Ring Risk Dismissed as Astronomicalinsight

    The Thiokol manager tells Malloy that even if one O-ring fails, the backup will hold, and the odds of both failing on the same joint are 'maybe 1 in 10,000.' Malloy accepts this and moves on.

  • 15:26

    Boisjoly Presents Incinerated O-Rings to NASAdata

    Boisjoly holds up plastic bags containing O-rings from Discovery's boosters, showing the grease has turned black with soot and portions of two rings have been completely incinerated. Flames had reached through the seal to the outer casing.

  • 16:52

    Cold Temperatures Identified as O-Ring Killerinsight

    Boisjoly tells the room that the O-rings were damaged by low temperatures, citing a record cold front that dropped Florida to 18 degrees Fahrenheit two days before the Discovery launch. A NASA official responds: 'Nobody wanted to hear that.'

  • 26:11

    Ebling Writes Desperate HELP Memostory

    Bob Ebling, a 25-year Thiokol veteran who has witnessed rocket leaks on the test range, writes a memo to senior managers beginning with the word HELP in all caps, detailing how the O-ring task force is being hampered by corporate bureaucracy.

  • 27:39

    Ebling Storms Hallway Demanding Shutdownstory

    Overcome by the thought that he might be responsible for killing Krista McAuliffe, Ebling storms up and down Thiokol's corridors yelling that they must lock the gates and stop sending faulty rockets to NASA. A manager tells him to quit being dramatic.

  • 34:28

    Scobie Sings Farewell on the Beachstory

    On the last evening before the launch, Dick Scobie stops walking on the beach, turns to his wife June, and sings 'The Last Farewell,' a folk song whose chorus includes the line 'how bitter will be this last farewell.'

  • 36:27

    Temperature Drops to 40 Degreesdata

    Quality inspector Johnny Corlou is working in the White Room 195 feet up the launch tower when he notes the temperature has dropped to 40 degrees. He blows on his hands to keep them warm as he works through his checklist.

  • 37:40

    Stripped Bolt Delays Challenger Launchstory

    Corlou discovers a stripped bolt on the hatch door handle that won't come out. After a dead drill battery, a failed replacement, and a new drill, his crew saws through the bolt. The launch is then cancelled for high winds.

About this episode

As NASA struggles to keep its ambitious launch schedule on track, engineers at contractor Morton Thiokol raise concerns about a key component of the space shuttle’s rocket boosters: O-Rings, which are designed to prevent fuel leaks. Amid this tension, the Teacher in Space program captivates the nation after Christa McAuliffe is selected, raising public interest in the launch. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript

0:00
36:53

7,508 words · 7 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Space Shuttle Challenger
  • O-Ring Failure
  • Morton Thiokol
  • NASA Safety Culture
  • Teacher in Space Program
  • Engineering Ethics
  • Risk Management
  • Krista McAuliffe

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated