Skip to content

Practical Magic

WHAT WENT WRONG

Hosted by Chris Winterbauer and Lizzie Bassett

1h 21m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode examines the turbulent production and lasting cultural legacy of the 1998 film Practical Magic. The hosts discuss how the movie became a beloved millennial classic despite its troubled genesis, structural narrative issues, and an infamous real-life encounter with a disgruntled witch consultant who threatened the set with a curse. They explore how director Griffin Dunn infused personal trauma and domestic violence themes into a story that studio executives ultimately forced into a lighter, more commercially palatable tone, leading to a disastrous theatrical box office run before finding its audience on home video.

  • Review your contracts and project alignment carefully when taking on multiple back-to-back studio blockbusters. 25:29
  • Reject stereotypical character tropes in favor of distinct, grounded casting choices that bring unexpected menace to a villain. 46:43
  • Establish a strong visual contrast between light and dark elements when attempting to ground a supernatural story. 56:38
  • Commit fully to physical realism in intense emotional sequences, even if it leads to physical exhaustion or injury. 1:06:02

Chapters

  1. 0:00
  2. 1:58
    Podcast Intro and Ad Read

    Hosts introduce the episode and read a brief ad before diving into the main topic.

  3. 2:42
    Setting the Stage: Practical Magic Overview

    Hosts explain why they chose to discuss the 1998 film Practical Magic and its cultural context.

  4. 6:51
    Adapting the Novel: Setting and Tone Changes

    Discussion of how the screenplay altered location, character ages, and themes from the book.

  5. 11:25
    Alice Hoffman's Background and Inspiration

    The hosts delve into the author’s upbringing, influences, and path to writing the novel.

  6. 39:03
    Production Challenges and Final Outcome

    Hosts wrap up by reflecting on the film’s production hurdles and its lasting legacy.

  7. 41:20
    Casting Choices and Star Power

    Analysis of why Sandra Bullock, Nicole Kidman, and other actors were selected for the film.

  8. 45:16
    Casting Choices and Character Rewrite

    The discussion opens with the decision to cast Aiden Quinn and the rewrite of Jimmy’s character to an ambiguous Eastern European figure.

  9. 50:18
    Hiring a Witch Consultant for Authenticity

    Griffin Dunn brings in a witch consultant to research white magic, hoping to ground the film’s supernatural elements.

  10. 51:49
    The Witch’s Demands and the Curse Threat

    The consultant demands a percentage of the film, threatens to curse the set, and the crew must navigate the ensuing conflict.

  11. 53:21
    Legal Fallout and Studio Response

    The witch files a lawsuit, Warner Bros. pays her off, and the incident haunts Dunn during production.

  12. 54:23
    Location Challenges and Set Construction

    The team struggles to find a suitable coastal town, ultimately building a set on San Juan Island under strict environmental constraints.

Highlights

  • 4:42

    Structural Flaws in the Classicinsight

    The hosts debate the structural messiness of Practical Magic, comparing its narrative pacing to an out-of-time musical note.

  • 11:00

    Budget and Box Office Numbersdata

    The film cost around $75 million to make and ultimately bombed in theaters, grossing only $68 million worldwide.

  • 18:10

    Revisiting the Novel's Settingsstrategy

    Screenwriter Robin Swickeard explains why moving the story from Boston suburbs to an isolated New England coastal town was essential for belief.

  • 27:13

    Directing Women in Hollywoodinsight

    Griffin Dunn discusses how Hollywood studios labeled him a woman's director in the 1990s simply because he had previously worked with female actors.

  • 47:42

    Casting an Unfamiliar Villainstrategy

    Goran Visnic was cast as Jimmy after the director sought an Eastern European presence, learning his entire script phonetically in broken English.

  • 51:34

    A Witch's Vengeful Phone Callstory

    A disgruntled witch consultant demands a massive payout and a percentage of the movie, leaving a terrifying voicemail threat after being rejected.

  • 1:07:26

    Composer Replaced After Screeningstory

    Michael Nyman's original arthouse score was completely scrapped after a disastrous test screening and replaced by Alan Silvestri.

Quotes

  • “I think the two of them are remarkably good in this, although I didn't realize, he doesn't show up until halfway through this movie, and he's in it for like 30 minutes.”
    Lizzie Bassett · 8:01
  • “It is at turns incredibly quickly paced, to the detriment, I think, of the characters, and then at others, seemingly glacially slow, as we slip into a weird, charming woman returns from, you know, big town life to small town life.”
    Chris Winterbauer · 4:51
  • “I love his performance. His performance in this is one of the highlights of this movie for me, and it's one of the most memorable in the whole thing.”
    Lizzie Bassett · 47:27
  • “She said, 'I'm sure the minute I left, they hired someone else to do it, right? But I made a real horse's ass of myself.'”
    Lizzie Bassett · 45:36
  • “The witch goes, 'You're not gonna buy me off with a hotel room. I want a percentage of the movie.'”
    Lizzie Bassett · 51:34
  • “I think in the movie, they are kind of trying to walk the line of suggesting that perhaps he is a vampire because there are so many lines about that.”
    Lizzie Bassett · 49:16
  • “I love that she's like, 'I am an idiot.'”
    Lizzie Bassett · 45:31
  • Drip Drop 20:26–21:29
  • TinCan 21:29–22:35
  • FreshBooks 22:44–23:42
  • Mars 42:53–43:57
  • Patreon 1:23:34–1:23:57

About this episode

Despite its all-star cast, when ‘Practical Magic’ landed in theaters in 1998 it was a critical and commercial failure. The blow was particularly devastating for director Griffin Dunne who had tried to exorcise some very personal demons via the film. This week, Chris and Lizzie discover how the Owens sisters went from box office poison to home video magic. Find out how Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman got involved, how the film fooled Barbra Streisand, who built those beautiful sets, and why an actual witch tried to burn the whole movie down. Come back on Friday for our subscriber-only review of ‘Practical Magic 2’! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

0:00
1:21:44

17,324 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Practical Magic
  • Warner Brothers
  • Coopville
  • Hulu
  • El Nino
  • Practical Magic 2
  • The Craft
  • San Juan Island
  • Goochville
  • Edward Scissorhands

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated